Discussion Locked

Old enough to want to and fool enough to try

0 helpful
289 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

289 replies

by apotheon

Any RAD tool can be a crutch for a bad programmer. Programmers should not start out using RAD tools — if they're going to do RAD as an introduction to programming, they should start out using RAD languages and frameworks with almost bare-metal tools (think "ruby in vim", for instance). This allows for rapid application development without hiding the language from the developer. Nascent programmers need to be exposed to their own code constantly to be able to develop good programming habits.

Ultimately, I find that the most wizardly code hackers usually stick to the simplest tools, but combine simple tools in some surprising, and surprisingly efficient, ways. They'll use IDEs that provide RAD capability only very rarely, and always with very good reason. Like dealing with WYSIWYG web design tools (such as Dreamweaver), with drag-and-drop RAD tools you have to go back and hack the code to clean it up afterward anyway, if you want to turn out good code. While this might make for an interesting way to teach debugging and refactoring to a n00b, it's not a very efficient way to develop an application, and ends up udercutting the purpose of rapid application development anyway.

That's not to say that such tools are evil. There's a huge population of developers who work best with tools like Eclipse, and if that's what it takes to be productive, then that's what they should use. Just don't throw some clueless end-user into a huge IDE with drag-and-drop objects and tell them they're learning to program. There's a big difference between learning how to use an application like VS or Eclipse and learning to write C# or Java code.

by mdv3441

I like RAD tools and IDE's especially for Windows applications.  What I have found is with Visual Studio 200X (VS) the programming syntax has regressed somewhat.  I did quite a bit of Assembler programming and moved through several "Business Languages" and last using Classic Visual Basic.  Using VS has become almost as verbose as COBOL when satisfying the compiler.  Maybe I'm too impatient in my old age and WEB programming should far simpler.

Mike

by secureplay

Its interesting, the essential question that the article raised was about product quality (not code quality) and documentation and eveybody focuses on coding, coding, coding.

No tool is going to force programmers to document their work - training and business processes are.

I think this actually gets to the real question of why so many software projects fail. The focus is on "codiing it" rather than knowing what it is you are doing and providing - "describing it".

On the other hand, it would be nice if modern programmers knew a bit more about the machines they are using - it is depresssing to talk to college graduates in CS with no understanding of hardware, microproccessor design... heck, even operating systems.

 

Steve

blog: http://www.playnoevil.com/

by arg_51

The big problem with programmers is that they program to solve the question: How is it done? and not,  Why is it done?
RAD only solves the visual part of any project. Helps in solving the How to Do It but never the Why is it done? Only through knowing the process better than the users software can be really useful.

 

by snoopdoug

I disagree vehemently that the problem lies with the developer. The problem is sytemic, starting with clueless managers who squeeze schedules, dismiss "thinking" and demand "doing", won't let developers talk to customers, do not provide a nearby subject matter expert, and have never coded themselves.

RAD tools do not of themselves make a bad developer. They are a tool, not a methodology. If your team does not do any code reviews, it matters little which dev tools you use, you will get what you ask for--uncommented code and goofy algorithms. If you do not allow time in the schedule for proper testing, you will get what you ask for--buggy code.

We blather on and on about how critical it is to identify problems early in the dev cycle, yet how often do we hit a snag and management tells us to just "code around it and we'll fix it later". Or you pick up some other devs code and cannot fathom why there are so many "magic numbers" in there when the coding standard does not allow them. It's because management told everyone to skip the code reviews for a while and "just write code".

Developers are not stupid. If you do not provide feedback--positive or negative--there is no incentive to change.

doug in Seattle

by wayne m.

There appear to be several competing thoughts going on in this discussion.  I would like to address three issues, the meaning of Rapid Application Development, the meaning of Agile Development, and the IDE, Wizard, Framework issue.

Rapid Application Development was an approach based on the principal of plan to throw the first one away (reference: "The Mythical Man-Month" by Albert Brooks).  The concept was to quickly produce a prototype consisting of little more than the user interface, evaluate the prototype, and throw it away and start from scratch.  As a result of the last assumption, code quality was never a concern.  There was also a flaw inherent in the approach; anything can be done in a shell user interface, the penalties in doing it, however, only become apparent when the underlying details are also implemented.

Agile Development has been tarred due to bad experiences with Rapid Application Development.  Agile Development uses an extreme (pun intended) focus on code quality that other approaches fall well short of.  Agile Development focusses on getting a working system to the user rapidly, not just getting a user interface mock-up rapidly.

IDEs, Wizards, Frameworks tend to get used interchangeably.  I am a strong proponent of Integrated Development Environments: editors that organize and link together multiple files; links between editors, compilers, linkers, and error messages; links between editors and debuggers; links between editors and version control systems; etc.  I also like hiding of the make file; with built-in refactoring tools, my last complaint against hiding the make file has disappeared.  It is now possible to rename a file without having to manually update the make file.  Graphical editors for GUIs, however, still have a major capability missing; aligning elements on the screen (author admits he has been out of programming and GUI development for some time).  A simple snap-to capability to align items and provide common box sizes would be helpful and not force the developer to hand edit Microsoft resource files or manually build hidden HTML tables.

Frameworks, however, are another matter.  I find frameworks tend to be overly complex and this complexity leads to the development of most wizards.  I find that most frameworks do not transition well from academic thought into real implementations.  The rule sets and guidelines are not well understood, and rather than explain them, a "wizard" is written to do the work for the developer.  The problem, however, is that the wizard is rarely complete enough to maintain the framework in an ongoing environment, so the developer must sort through the resulting code to make sense of it.  Without a thorough understanding of the framework, code tends to be randomly placed where ever, leading to more complex and less maintainable code.

My over all score card: Rapid Application Development - Thumbs Down; Agile Development - Thumbs Up; IDEs - Thumbs Up; Wizards and Frameworks - Thumbs Down.

 

by m.jonathan.murphy

Earlier comments said it.

If you dont know what it is that you are building - then you will just haphazardly build something in an IDE rather that haphazardly build it in VI or whatever your flavor.

I for one dont actually find VS that "easy" - more like a jetplane cockpit with some useful project templates that get me around having to navigate the popups and sliding whatchamahoozits. Unless you are willing to sink even more $$$ into the Team Building options then it doesnt really help anybody probably :)

Most applications are more than the work of one guy with Visual Studio. The process and cooperation to understand the actual problem and then the discipline, organization, and skill to solve the problem mainly live outside an IDE - unless you can plug in an Windows Vista extension in your frontal lobes.

The intersting claim is that this helps build better code. So beyond well-crafted routines that execute and interface - what is so good about the code? Is it an asset? Did it get you further in the project? Or did you just get a work unit done without really understanding the impact (or detriment) that your VS wizard'ed output just contributed to the project under dev?

by dc guy

Steve is right, failure to document is not a new problem. We had just as bad a shortage of documentation back in the days of punched cards and 128K-memory mainframes as you kids have today. It's a management problem, one of several that would not be tolerated in any other engineering discipline and defines what we do as a medieval craft, not "software engineering."

Steve, projects may occasionally come in late and over budget because of bad coding practices or reluctance to document, but they rarely fail for those reasons. The most ruinous project failures are caused by defects in requirements. Failure to perform even quick, rudimentary requirements inspections is arguably the biggest problem in American software project management today. The other major contender is failure to perform risk analyses and kill off those hopeless projects before they get started.

Those are the other two glaring differences between us and real engineers.

by jaqui

Well since I don't have an mp3 with the tag in it, I can't check.
but if the header tag was given correctly in your posting, then this should work.
if the format of the tag is different, then the featured artist in the
listing below would need to be altered to fit the format of the tag.

naturally, the blog script is interpreting the table code for the output of the script.

the differences are:
line 4) added entire line :

$featured_artist = $id3->getTag('featured artist') : "n/a"; //Featured Artist, if tag format is correct
line 47) added entire line : < td >< b >Featured Artist< /b >< /td >
line 54) added entire line : < td >" . $d['featured artist'] . "< /td >

read($dir."/".$file);             $filename = $id3->getTag('file');   // file name           $artist = $id3->getTag('artists') ? $id3->getTag('artists') : "n/a"; // artist name           $featured_artist = $id3->getTag('featured artist') : "n/a"; //Featured Artist, if tag format is correct           $title = $id3->getTag('name') ? $id3->getTag('name') : "n/a"; // track title           $genre = $id3->getTag('genre') ? $id3->getTag('genre') : "n/a";   // genre           $year = $id3->getTag('year') ? $id3->getTag('year') : "n/a";  // year of release           $data[] = array('file' => $filename, 'artist' => $artist, 'featured artists' => $featured_artist, 'title' => $title, 'genre' => $genre, 'year' => $year);       }   }  } } // close handle closedir($dh);}// import MP3 classinclude("MP3/Id.php");// create new MP3_ID() class$id3 = &new MP3_Id();// define MP3 directory$dir = "/usr/local/share";// start scanning for MP3s// store extracted MP3 metadata in $datasearchMp3($dir);?>";    echo "";       echo "";       echo "";       echo "";...    echo "";       echo "";       echo "";}?>


File name
Title
Artist
Featured Artist
Genre
Year

" . $d['file'] . "
" . $d['title'] . "
" . $d['artist'] . "
" . $d['featured artist'] . "
" . $d['genre'] . "
" . $d['year'] . "						

by joeaaa22

There's another issue with IDE's and these mega-development
environments that I believe is counterproductive for developers. 
The tools are getting so big and sophisticated that you need to spend
more time and energy learning the tool than actually developing
anything with it.

Back a million years ago I was a mainframe COBOL programmer.  The product we used was a tool called ROSCO.  It was similar to ISPF,
for those who know that environment.  It was a basic editor from
which you could compile and run jobs and examine the output from
them. 

Code -> Compile -> Test -> Repeat until it works

Today we have tools like Eclipse and Sun Studio and the now in limbo
Borland C++ Builder.  You need a weeks worth of training classes
just to get started with these products.  And even then you'd
spend more time dealing with the tool than dealing with the code.

If I were to get back into programming I think I'd prefer using vi(m)
and the command line than any of the tools now available. 
Faster?  No.  Better?  Maybe.  Focus on code? 
Definitely.

by lovin_90

RAD tools are better.  You can NOT blame poor methodologies and practises on a tool.  If you don't make your writers add comments, then that is your fault and NOT the package's fault.

To say that you should work 10 years before using a RAD package is insane.  That is like me telling you that you must spend 10 years doing assembly and learning the intracacies of computers before you can use C.  Then spend another 10 before RAD.  If I haul dirt, I don't need to know how a dumptruck works, the internal workings of combustible engines, or the physics behind hydraulics.  I just need to know how to get to the site and how to dump the dirt.

The same is true of RAD.  It enables you to know less of the specifics, and do more work.  Yes, you need people that know assembly or C inside and out, but you also need to produce a product.  Computers are here to make our lives both easier and more productive.  To ignore that is silly.  You might as well not use email if you don't know TCP/IP, right?

Bad habits are not the fault of the software, but the person and organizations using it.

by jaqui

Well I'm not knocking ides as tools, I am knocking the concept that a programmer doesn't have to understand the underlying functionality of a computer [ which is what RAD has fostered ]

lovin 90 says that driving a dump truck you don't need to know how everything works, it's obvious that he's never looked at getting a license to drive a vehicle with air brakes and hydraulics, since part of the tests included FIXING hydraulics and air brake systems.

using RAD tools without understanding the underlying technology of a computer means you are generating code that doesn't function even at 10% effectiveness.

Bloated code from RAD caused by not knowing the underlying concepts is what causes a lot of bugs, security exploits and the constant need for more system resources. if RAD tools were able to optimise the code they generated then lovin 90 would be right, since they can't, no developer should be allowed to touch a rad tool until they have proven they understand how to code for minimal footprint... [ ie: entire application embedded on a 32 kb chip ]

by apotheon

While I'm nowhere near the hardass Jaqui is (I don't think everything needs to be able to run on an 8MB RAM machine, necessarily), he dances around a very important point. As such, I've got to disagree with lovin_90 on the applicability of his dumptruck analogy.

As understanding a dumptruck is to moving dirt, an IDE wizard is not to code. The code is the point when you're developing an application. You don't have to understand how the dumptruck works because the dirt is the point, not the dumptruck. To fit your dumptruck analogy, you'd have to be talking about the programmer understanding how the IDE wizard works under the skin.

You're right, lovin_90: I don't have to understand everything about the tool to be able to use it. You're wrong, lovin_90: I do have to know something about what I'm doing with the tool. Get the difference?

by staticonthewire

Rad/Agile/Framework tools, and IDEs like VS are wonderful. So are modern languages like C# which can (with clear limitations) be seen as partially self-documenting.

Of COURSE they hide and obfuscate some aspects of development - that's one of their strongest selling points. Of COURSE this results in a degree of slippage in some aspects of the craft. But this isn't anything new, is it. I clearly recall assembly programmers fulminating about the certain doom that was coming to us all because of the sloppiness inherent in C...

But good programmers will rise to their own level of perfection, and once you get a tool like VS into the hand of a good programmer, you have something special. Forcing top talent to use archaic antiques out of some unfounded belief that they'll be better is as likely to result in success as hitching greyhounds to a dogsled. It isn't what they were made for, you'll make them and yourself unhappy, and you won't get anywhere.

This discussion reminds me of the war on drugs, in the sense that certain axiomatic assumptions are being accepted and acted on without question, and the solutions based on those unspoken assumptions are disastrous - "force" n00bs to program for ten years before they can touch RAD tools - heh - just try it and see how long your interns stick around... my favorites are the complaints that the tool is "too deep" and takes a long time to learn, give me my notepad! Wow. I would have mugged for a copy of the current VS, even 5 years ago. In 1980? I would have killed.

"Documentation is good" is one of those unquestioned axioms I was talking about. But it SHOULD be questioned - documentation sucks. Documentation is an execrable response to the limitations of our tools and processes: since our tools are stupidly complex and incomprehensibly arcane, we will create tons of reference material that no one will ever, ever read... what we need isn't a return to the good old days when we carved binary in stone with our teeth, we need EVEN MORE sophistication, and even more layers of automation between the trigger and the finger - self documenting languages and frameworks and a merging of design tools with code generation.

Many people here are saying that the fault isn't with the tool, it's with the process - if people understanding something - well gosh darn it, then they'll understand it! Well duh... at that point, who needs documentation? Unless we're doing it for the children - won't somebody think of the children? We'll document our systems FOR POSTERITY. Good idea, hm? Especially since most sytems have the lifespan of a gnat.

Certainly, process is key. But there have always been scheming and ignorant managers, clueless n00bs, put-upon master craftsmen. Somehow we muddled through, and somehow we will in the future.

Insisting that people be prepared to finish a task before they start it isn't going to work either - unless all the problems you choose to solve have already been solved, you can't KNOW what you need to know, can you? So insisting of complete specifications and the like is as hopeless as that plan to force n00bs to sweep the building foyer for ten years before they're permitted to touch a keyboard.

I'm sick of alarmism, and I'm sick of "we wuz men, back in the good ol' days". As a general rule, the sophistication and completeness of the applications being created nowadays is orders of magnitude better than all the old assembler and COBOL and C code. Why is everyone surprised when they find that our cutting edge tools are on the cutting edge, that they are grappling with unsolved problems, that they are experimental and require tinkering on the part of their users? And who in hell would really want it to be any different?

Stop fighting the last war. Stop complaining that the kids are dumb bunnies. Of COURSE they are - they're kids. But give them enough rope to hang themselves, and believe it or not, only half of them will. The balance will go on to solve problems we old cats only dreamt of.

I recall my first acquisition of VS (which wasn't of course called VS back in the day). As a learning experience and a test platform I converted a newspaper linage system I had spent years writing by hand into a project under the new IDE. I discovered more errors - hung pointers, dereferenced variables, entire blocks of waste - in a five minute test compile than I had been able to winkle out with my eyes in five years.


You will never get my VS away from me - oh, maybe at gunpoint... but come on all you moaners - where's your perspective?

by Mark W. Kaelin

The concept
surrounding Microsoft's Office Live intrigues me. A complete set of
applications, designed to manage a business, complete with e-mail,
collaboration tools, contact management, sales management, lists of inventory,
and a Web site editor. It all seems like a wonderful utopia. Of course, using
this suite to actually run a business means storing your sensitive customer,
vendor, and sales information on someone else's server. A server you can only
access through the notorious insecurity of a Web browser over the just as
notoriously insecure Internet using infamously insecure Active X controls.

Being the
inquisitive editors we are, the TechRepublic content development team has
signed up for a beta account in Office Live. I'm going to poke around the
landscape and see what I can see and do what I can do to assess the viability
of this online management system experiment. I have to admit I approach the
whole concept with a bit of cynicism.

The idea of
storing sensitive information about my business on a server that I do not have
physical control over makes me very nervous. What kind of physical security do
they have for the Office Live servers? And even if they are physically secure,
how certain can we be that they are secure from hacking? How quickly will
Microsoft turn over our sensitive information to the government if they ask for
it? How will I know? What if Mt. Rainer erupts and wipes out Washington State,
is there an offsite backup?

Is anyone
actually going to do this? Do you trust Microsoft with this information? Do you
trust anyone with this information outside your company? Should you? It is one
thing for some squirrelly editors to put information on Office Live; it is completely
different when that information represents your entire business enterprise.

by apotheon

I'd like to see Google produce a competing web application suite that stores all data the local client machine. I won't trust my documents on Microsoft's servers (just as I won't trust my data on Google servers, and thus wouldn't use Google desktop searches and the like).

by staticonthewire

In addition to the possible threat to the security of your data, shouldn't you be concerned that you're placing your trust in a set of office productivity tools that don't belong even marginally to you, and that are not under your control? If Microsoft decides to raise their usage fees a thousand percent from one month to the next, is there a damned thing you could do about it, considering that you've allowed your business data and business tools to be walled away in a proprietary format and located on someone else's real estate?

If you want to create a local backup of all your data, does MOL allow you do so? Is the suite configurable so that a local copy could be made of every document you generate? That might be an answer to some of the problem. Does MOL allow you to manage your files on their servers? Can you create folders and sub-folders, move things aroung, zip them all up in a single archive and mail them to someone? Delete them? Does MOL have options to export your biz dox to open document formats if you want to? Can you open the documents you store on their servers with non-MS tools?

Ceding control of your mission critical data to a software company with its own business agenda that could conceivably be at odds with your own seems pretty hare-brained to me. Allowing your company to become dependent on a tool suite of which you have no local copy seems equally nutty. Why don't you just give MS the keys to the front door and let them install a row of CICS terminals for you next weekend, and take away those pesky PCs?

That way it'll be obvious to everyone who's in control - they got the programs, they got the data... now let's all bend over and take a deep, deep breath... that's it...

by yinbig

Plain and simple:

It's the choice of the Company if they want to use MOL.
Use it OR
Don't use it

We can go on about security this / backup that.  At the end of the day somebody
will use it.  I'm guessing the one man band business.

But I guess you all have your own set of utility plants in your homes /
offices, otherwise how do you get Power / Water / Gas???
Wait - do you trust this company?  What if they hike there prices
1000%?  What if the power grid blew up?

Utility Computing - get used to it.

by john.healey

It's true that we put our trust in the utility companies for power and communications, but they don't know anything about your business except what you have to tell them in order to do business with them. If you use utility computing to run your business then you have revealed everything....

by nickaaa19

It's plain and simple about economics. When it comes down to it, you have to trust someone - whether its your service provider or you computer hard drive. As we become more mobile, it makes sense to me to be able to have access to my information anytime, anyplace. I suspect that an organization like Microsoft or Google would have better luck protecting my data than I given their resources.

by blackfalconsoftware9

You have answered your own question.  Putting sensitive data on anyone else's server over the Internet is simply asking for trouble as no business is run efficiently enough to maintain such data under all circumstances including the unforseeable...

 

 

 

by stevecubberly9

for small businesses, it is impractical to own and manage application servers.

with the millions of small businesses out there, the US economy would be well-served by a solid, hosted application provider so that the businesses can go about their business instead of managing servers and apps.

i have been looking for hosted services and the only one that sounds mature and promising is foldera.com.

the price is right for small businesses and the functionality sounds complete.

any other suggestions?

by apotheon

What? Impractical to own/manage an application server? How do you figure? I've worked for a company of about twenty people with an application server, and I (living alone) have an application server all to myself at home. How can it possibly be "impractical" to own/manage an application server for a small company?

by sbrooks

There have been a few instances in recent years where government
security services have walked into businesses and walked out with their
entire servers due to one or two dodgy posts/blogs/news services (you
all know who I mean) regardless of the fact that everbody else who has
data stored on that server also loses access. While your data may not
be suspect, having it on the same server as suspect data may mean
losing access at any moment, at least until backups can be put in place.

Personally I would never trust anyone with my personal data except my
own business. We are a two person operation, we have a secure encrypted
VPN server of our own, it's not a big deal these days. If I could use
the MS Suite to access the data on my own server that might be
different, but I wouldn't use it to access my data on MS servers.

Steve

by mejpsimard

All of you are missing the problem by a longshot.  The problem is not in the software industry, but in the north american culture as a whole.  Everything out there is getting shocked into rapid this, rapid that.  It stardet with Ford mass producing it's cars, went on to Mc Donalds with it foods (if you call their products food), and now its up to software to slave down to mass production.  There is little of anything out there that is mass produced and remains of good quality, just look at your own furniture... will it last as long as the furniture of your forefathers.  But complain all you want, society requires it from the software industry by insisting on instant gratification will little cost.  What ever your line of work is in,  you'll never do it fast enough.  Live with it!

by Mark W. Kaelin

Looking
over my past blog entries I think you can safely make the assumption that I am
an accomplished skeptic. I am suspicious of all hype, especially when it comes
to marketing hype. I am a firm believer that the best ideas of the past have
come from grassroots innovations that grow into phenomena because real people
find real value in the idea. The Word Wide Web, Linux, Yahoo!, - the garage
innovation rules the world in my mind.

Right now I
am feeling particularly skeptical of the hype surrounding video
streaming
to small personal devices like cell phones and iPods. I was browsing through the local Best Buy, as I
often do on Sunday afternoons, and I saw a multitude of cell phones with video
capabilities, not to mention iPods with video. I love
the technology that makes video like this possible ? I love gadgets just like
any geek in good standing.

However, personally,
I have absolutely no desire to watch video on my cell phone. But I also don't
watch much television these days ? I've never seen Desperate Housewives or
Survivor for example ? and I can't think of any television program that I want
to see so bad that I would be willing to watch it on a postage-stamp-sized
screen. And I would never want to watch a movie that way ? I need big screens
and surround sound. There are already features on my cell phone I never use;
adding video would just be a waste.

But perhaps
that is just my feeling. Perhaps there is a market for personal device video. I
just remain skeptical. So I am asking for your perspective. Educate me. Do you
ride mass transit to the office and does video on your personal device sounds
like heaven to you? Or are you skeptical like me?

by jasonhiner

Mark -- I completely agree. I have no desire to watch TV shows or movies on a phone or iPod screen. I guess if I traveled by plane or public transit more often I might feel different (as you alluded to). However, I wouldn't mind being able to use these small screens for short home video clips that I could share with friends and family. That could be cool.

by dave

I agree with you 100%.  Do we just go ahead and 'do these things' because 'we can'??

Dave

by Mark W. Kaelin

Last week I
received a call from my niece asking for my help and advice on a computer
problem she and her fiance were having. Being the family computer geek, a
distinction I suspect many of the TechRepublic membership knows all too well, I
was happy to help.

However, as
they described the problem it became apparent that this was not going to be a
"go to the control panel" issue that could be resolved over the
phone. They had been hit with a malware bomb -- and a
pretty nasty one too. The hard drive is pretty much hosed. I have been trying
to avoid a complete wipe of the drive because it is a cut-rate HP computer that
did not come with a Windows CD. The Windows installation files are, of course,
on the hard drive which is completely useless at this point. Selling a PC
without a working CD with a clean copy of Windows should be outlawed. If I wipe
the drive, they won't have a copy of Windows, just a license number. I tried
the restore procedure but it failed because too much damage had already been
done to the files.

This is the
second family relative to have a major problem like this so I guess part of the
blame is mine since I apparently failed to emphasize the importance of keeping
virus software, firewall, and Windows up to date and patched. I forget that all
of that maintenance is second nature to me, but a foreign language to them.
With luck and some gentle prodding from her nice uncle, this incident should prevent
a future incident, at least with this member of the family. It is the rest of
the family that I worry about.

How many
catastrophic events have you had to clean up after for your family? Have you
tried to educate everyone about patches and updates? For me the problems really
hit the fan when broadband is introduced.

by arie.kaizer

Making an image (e.g. with the good old Drive Image of Ghost) at regular intervals in time must become part of maintaining my computer. Moreover computer shops include an initial image in a hidden partition.

Yes, the restore function is great, but cannot handle real damage. 

by van morris

Yes, you're right about keeping virus software, firewall, and Windows up to date and patched. However, I think the best protection is to prevent the malware infiltration in the first place.

Currently, I use (and recommend) a security tool called SafeSystem for that purpose. This program protects my system regardless the kind of (known or unknown) virus, spyware or malware is trying to get into it. In fact, it simply doesn't allow any program to be installed or copied to my system while I'm surfing the Web, reading my emails or working with my computer.

Sincerely, this gives me a lot of piece of mind because my system is always protected no matter if my anti-virus and anti-spyware are updated or not. Don't forget that perhaps they are updated but they just don't recognize the virus or spyware which is trying to get into my system.

I found SafeSystem at: http://www.gemiscorp.com/english/safesystem/info.html
Also, you can see a good PR about this program at: http://www.prweb.com/releases/2006/1/prweb339444.htm

IMPORTANT: I want to clarify that I don't have any direct or indirect relation with the company that owns the product I'm suggesting

by arie.kaizer

Standard maintenance must include making an image (e.g. with good old Drive Image or Ghost) at regular time intervals. Yes, the Windows restore is OK, but it cannot cope with very large problems.
Also PC suppliers often deliver the initial image on a hidden partition.

by Member 22007162

One tip that makes it much harder to contract malware is to run as a
normal user rather than an administrator. What stuff you do pickup will
be able to wipe out all your personal data, but not corrupt the OS
(barring taking advantage of a privilege elevation exploit).

You can either log in as a user and use RunAs to get admin authority
when needed (safest method), or else log on as an admin and use 'SAFER', a
WIndows XP API and policy feature that lets you reduce your
rights when running a specific application(s) - such as all
Internet-facing applications (media player, web browser, etc).

This article describes a tool that lets you drop your rights on a one-time basis:
http://msdn.microsoft.com/library/en-us/dncode/html/secure11152004.asp

This article describes how to configure your PC's software restriction
policy so that specific applications are always run with reduced rights:
http://msdn.microsoft.com/library/en-us/dncode/html/secure01182005.asp

There's lots of info about running as a non-administrator and still getting work done here:
http://nonadmin.editme.com/

by keithau001

I completely agree with the need for antivirus antispyware and firewalls,  I was maintaining a small office network recently and they had out of date antivirus software on their computer.  The manager asked if i found any viruses, all i was doing was removing spyware, and cleaning up the registry.. I could not do virus scans / cleanups with their program.  After their 3rd crash in as many months (fortunately i could use the restore but only by using the three finger salute) I decided to wash my hands of them until they decided to follow my advise and get a decent antivirus program.

I also cannot believe that a computer can be sold without the OS disk included, I guess a warning here would be to copy all the cabbed files to a CD and that may eliminate the problem.  Still It definately should be illegal to sell a computer with an OS on it but without a disk.

by haas

Being the geek of the family is not a fun position to be in. I get phone calls sometimes at 11 pm to help mother-in-law or sisten in law. But you can't win because you are not going to say no to a family member. So recently my mother-in-law got her high speed internet access. She had no clue about the dangers of having a connection that is available 24/7.

I think it should be the responsibility of Comacast (or any provider) to inform users/cutomers about what they (users) should do before getting on-line. Comcast actually offers free McAffee anti-virus, firewall, and malware (privacy manager) protection, but the installers never mention anything to the users and in my opininon they should install them while installing the cable modem.

Anyhow, a couple of months after my mother-in-law got her comcast service, she gave me a call telling me that her computer is awfully slow and it takes forever for any application to launch, hmmmmm anybody saying viruse(s) is having a party. When I got to look at her computer and after discovering she didn't have any protection at all, I knew I was in for a while. After installing all necessary tools, I run a complete scan (online scans as well) of her system, it was completely infested. All kind of trojans, viruses, and spyware in the world were infesting her system. I found over a 1000 of all bad stuff.

So to prevent this from happening again, I decided to get her a router and configured her system to get updates automatically, and installed McAffee package (offered my Comcast) and I didn't hear from her for awhile now.

Thanks
Haas

 

by Mark W. Kaelin

Thank you for the comments.


The idea of logging into your PC and not using the administrator account to do normal everyday activities is a good one, it is what I do myself. However, novice PC users don't know about this. They just turn their new PC on and begin to surf the Internet.


Education of the novice is something the geek community needs to participate in more vigorously.

by Mark W. Kaelin

This week,
the Chairman and CEO of CNET Networks, Shelby Bonnie, stopped by the office to
talk about the current state of media and what it means for our company. He
made a very compelling presentation explaining how media, in all its many forms,
has changed in recent years. The main point is that as a media company, CNET,
and any other media company for that matter, is not in
control of the distribution method anymore ??? the consumer is the controlling
factor. The consumer is deciding when they want content, how they will receive
it, and whether it is worthy of recommendation to the broader community.

Later that
day, Kudlow & Co. on CNBC did an entire hour on
the subject, which means Wall Street is thinking about this too. (Although, some of the so-called experts on Kudlow
were still living in the 1980s apparently.)

I haven't
joined the Tivo generation yet, but I do understand
its appeal. The idea that I can choose when to watch television and that I can
watch television I want to watch, is very appealing. (Say that three times
fast.) I have also become an advocate for digital music. In fact, I want my
next car stereo to have a USB port on it so I can plug in my iPod shuffle or other portable media player into it. The CD
has had its day -- it's time for a new delivery mechanism.

It is going
to be a very interesting future. The pace of change, something I have embraced
in youth, seems to accelerate every year. Even a geeky gadget-guy like me is
having trouble keeping up. I wonder if there will be a "back to
basics" backlash. Or will the pace of change continue to accelerate? What
do you think?

by Mark W. Kaelin

Last week,
I posted a gallery of before and after pictures of TechRepublic
staffer Paul Sisler who bravely sacrificed his precious locks of golden hair
for a good cause. St. Baldrick's Foundation raises
funds and awareness for childhood cancer research with events that feature the
shaving of volunteers' heads.

I can't see
myself getting my head shaved for any reason, even one as noble as finding a
cure for cancer, so I wanted to spread the word about Paul's fund raising
exploits. I encourage you to take a look at the gallery
and ask yourself if you would shave your head to raise money. If you are like
me, you might want to contribute some money in lieu of hair.

by bfilmfan

Encourage Paul to keep the bald look. It's a lot better look than with hair for him. All he needs is a lolipop and he can be Kojak.

by Mark W. Kaelin

As you may
or may not know, one of my major hobbies is playing computer games. I've had a
designated game computer of some kind or another (often more than one) in my
home since 1981. Wow, I just realized that's over 25 years.

Anyway, the
game I've been playing most often lately is World of Warcraft,
which is the one of the most popular MMORPGs right
now. That popularity probably means many of you are also playing WoW.

(Just
before I posted this entry, I noticed this discussion, which confirms my belief that I'm not alone in
my gaming experience. I wonder if we have enough to start a super-guild on one
of the new servers. We'd be so 1337)

I started
playing during the beta testing phase, so I've been running around in that
universe for quite a long time. In general, I still enjoy playing; I'm more of
a PVE guy, but I dabble in PVP from time to time.

The one
thing that irks me though is the continuing lack of stability the various
servers experience on an almost weekly basis. Maintaining the login servers,
the game servers, several databases, and whatever else is required to keep six
million players in the game happy and questing must be a real nightmare. I'm
willing to bet the administrators of those systems have some real pearls of wisdom
to share about how to handle that many simultaneous connections.

I'm going
to try to get an interview with a Blizzard representative to see if I can glean
some pertinent information that I can report to the TechRepublic membership.

Assuming I
can get them to talk to me, what do you think I should ask? I know a good
portion of TechRepublic is playing World of Warcraft
or some other MMORPG like EverQuest 2 or Star Wars
Galaxies. I mean there is a high geek quotient here. As an IT professional,
what would you like to know about how the game is served? How many servers? How
many CoLOs? What hardware? Give me some suggestions
in the comments to this blog and I'll try to get some
answers.

by jmgarvin

If you could get an idea of how they do their server clustering (hardware and software), that would be AWESOME!  I'm also curious how much bandwidth 6 million customers eat on a daily basis.  Can you also ask why they delete posts in the suggestion forum about a Linux client?  Can you also ask WHY they aren't considering a Linux client?  I mean, the game runs in Cedega and all, but they ported it to Mac...Mac's RUN OSX WHICH IS F'ING BSD...ok...I'm better now... ;-)

What server are you on?  I'm up for starting a TR guild ;-)  I've got a couple characters hanging out on:

Lothar (PvE fullish, but not bad), Cenarian Circle (PvE/RP and over populated), Frostwolf (PvP and over populated), and Thorium Brotherhood (PvE/RP medium-full).    

 

by Mark W. Kaelin

I'm on Killrogg right now, which is full up (one of the original servers).


If there is enough interest, I wouldn't mind starting up on a new server, especially if we have a large group of players that want to play together.


Anyone interested in starting a World of Warcraft TechRepublic guild on a new server? What would we call ourselves?

by jmgarvin

I'm up for that.  We can pick a new server and go from there.  I'm open!

I think we should call ourselves simply: TR

by Bill Detwiler

Like Mark, I'm a longtime and avid gamer--my wife can't
understand why I haven't grown up yet . But I'm late to the MMORPG genre.
Mark can attest to my previous claim of "I'll never pay for on online game
when free online games are available". WoW made me change me tune.

I had a few RL (real life) friends who just started playing
WoW and wanted me to join them. I figured I would give it a try and if I didn't
like the experience, I would quit after the first 30-days--WoW comes with a
free 30-day subscription. It's been 3 months and I'm still enjoying the game immensely.
I play a few hours each week.

I have an Alliance Warlock (currently lvl 45) and Paladin (currently
lvl 1--he's a new character serving as my SW auctioneer) on Stonemaul (PVP--full
but I have only had to wait once). I would love to start a TechRepublic Horde guild
on a new realm. PVP or PVE doesn't matter, although I'm not big on the
strict RP realms--I might want to ask an occasional out-of-character question.
I like the constant pressure of the PVP realms, but it can be annoying if you're
questing solo and get ganked by much-higher-level characters. Luckily, this
doesn't seem to be an issue on Stonemaul. I've been attacked a few times, but
often enemy characters will pass each other in a courteous yet cautious manner.

So, count me in!

by jmgarvin

l33t == elite.  It is what is called l33t speak.  The really "cool" h@><0r5 use it.

by Mark W. Kaelin

The 1337 or 133t was a tongue in cheek - I may have some geeky tendencies, but not enough to learn that gaming dialect.

by Mark W. Kaelin

Well, I asked the PR department at Blizzard for an interview with someone on their IT staff to ask what they have learned about handling a large cluster of servers and millions of simultaneous connections. Not too surprisingly, they turned me down, saying:

We want to thank you for considering us for this interview subject, but we have
to respectfully decline. We tend to keep the focus of our public communication
on the games themselves. Having worked regularly with our community team, we
understand that the public has a great interest in the perspective of our
technical teams, but this is just not the type of information that we?re able to
discuss freely, due to competitive and other concerns. I hope you understand,
and I want to say thank you again for considering us for this
opportunity.
Oh well, I still like playing the game. I wonder if some other game company would talk about their infrastructure?

by johnpall9

Insert comment text here The IT World can learn that WAR is Violence & should be Avoided at all costs.?

by Mark W. Kaelin

Last week I
attended two Microsoft presentations here in Louisville. The MSDN presentation
for developers in the afternoon was very interesting. William Steele, who works
the Midwest (many of you have probably seen him), showed a very interesting
demo.

He created
a simple real estate app in C# (would have worked in VB too) that showed the
address and pictures of properties, with the data coming from a SQL Server
Express database. While that may not be seem too fancy, the demo was showing off
the power of XAML, which stands for Extensible Application Markup Language.
With just a little bit of code, he was able to make what essentially became a
flash-like animation that flipped the images into a larger view upon each
mouseover.

Again, that
may not seem impressive, but he then converted that C# app into a Web-app that
a browser could display. At that point it became obvious to me and most of the
room that this was going to be positioned as a challenge to Macromedia and its
Flash products. I won't guess how successful it will be, but the demo did make
it clear that just about anybody could make a Flash-like animation with XAML
and some free tools Microsoft has available.

XAML is
what the Vista interface is based on, which also struck me as an indication of
Vistas versatility in terms of UI. I wonder, if someone was so inclined, you
could put a different interface on Vista then one that will come out of the
box? Could you shrink the interface down to a minimal set of buttons, essentially
hiding features you don't want users to interact with? Could you create a Vista
client on an Apple computer sporting Intel chips, only using a facsimile of the
Mac OS X? Not sure why you'd want to, but is it possible?

It might be
something to keep your eyes on as Vista eventually gets closer to reality.

by apotheon

re: the Vista interface questions

Is there any point in waiting, when you've been able to do the equivalent with Linux for about six years or so?

by Mark W. Kaelin

Well, as true as that may be, it hasn't been true for Windows - at least not in the manner I saw at this presentation. Microsoft may come late to each party but they make a splash when they get there.

by Mark W. Kaelin

We've gotten such a large response to what I thought was a rhetorical question that I'm a little surprised. I asked in passing if anyone was interested in starting a TR Guild on World of Warcraft and the number of players want to play continues to grow.

What I was really looking for was potential questions I should ask the Blizzard IT Staff if I were granted an interview. But, citing competitive concerns, I was politely turned away by the PR staff. It's too bad because I'm sure that group has some words of wisdom and insight to share when it comes to large server clusters and simultaneous connections.

I wonder if Earth and Beyond or Asheron's Call 2 (both closed now) would talk to me.

by jmgarvin

I'm very happy with the response!  I can't wait to see everyone online!

I'd love to see an interview (with my previously posted questions) with
either of those guys.  If you could swing Star Wars Galaxies that
would be nice too ;-)

Good luck!

by Mark W. Kaelin

Part of my
job as an editor on TechRepublic is to read what seems like a hundred
newsletter every week. (Like I have the time.) One of
the more interesting is from the SoftwareCEO. Here is
the link, but it may require you to log in to see it.

In a
nutshell, the original poster states:

Whenever we hire a new person I go
through a standard speech about how we are selling a tool, and we cannot make judgments
about the organization that we are talking to that either has purchased or is
considering purchase of our tool. Until recently that seemed to be adequate.

However we recently had a situation
where a contract employee refused to work on an assignment because they did not
agree with the political standing of the organization that they would be
working with. As a contractor they have that right...and I also have the right
to not pay them for that work.

But that raises a dilemma...it no
longer appears that my "little talk" is adequate. I really need some
type of statement that each employee and contractor is required to read and
agree to stating that an individual cannot refuse to work with an organization
simply because they do not agree with their moral, religious, philosophical or
political stand. I'm not even sure what to call this type of statement (as you
can tell from my title to this thread). This statement would also need to say
that non-compliance would be grounds for disciplinary action or termination.

I thought
this was an interesting question. Should the moral and philosophical beliefs of
your employees or contractors be taken into consideration when it comes to a
company's primary purpose of making money? Is a policy needed to address this?
Has this ever been an issue at your organization?

In an era
where regimes and organizations are marked as terrorist and where certain
religious organizations pursue stringent policies of intolerance, should management
be cognizant of potential conflicts.

In my
father's time such consideration would be laughable - if you wanted to keep
your job you did as you were told - but as he keeps reminding me, times have
changed.

What do you think?

by peter spande


Is it a cop out to say "it depends?"  

This is a free country.  If you don't agree with the work your company is doing, you have the right to leave the company.  As a contractor, you have more freedom to select the work you do. People have every right to make that ethical decision but they also must deal with the consequences of that decision.  An outcome of that decision may be lost work.  As a contractor, they may also be giving up future work assignments wouldn't present the same kind of issues for them.   

Similarly, there is a real need for people to be "whistle blowers" when the work a company is doing is illegal.  This goes beyond personal belief.  Towing the company line is not an adequate defense.  Enron, WorldCom, and others have made this clear.  Again, there are real consequences to these actions as well and it clearly isn't always clear what is illegal when you are in the middle of the issue.  

by jaqui

I have to agree with George on this one.

The employee / subcontractor has the choice of working for you or not, if your company engages in business practices they find objectionable, they can leave the company.

It boils down to a small forgotten fact by most people.. that when you apply for a position and go for an interview, you are also sizing up the company to see if they fit you well enough for you to work there. I know I've turned down good paying job offers, because the company making the offer rubbed me the wrong way, and I couldn't work in their environment.

by wayne m.

Concur With Peter

Actually, the question is not really "Should Moral Convictions Get in the Way ...", but rather, "What to do When Morale Convications Get in the Way ...".  One cannot anticipate all employee concerns about the work place, one can just fairly address the issues as they arise.

If the problem described above has only occurred once, I would advise against creating a new policy.  The current practice has been working, and there is no indication that it will not continue to work.  Address the issue with the particular individual (Publishing Gal has a recent blog on this issue).

Though I am not aware of moral issues causing staff to question assignments, other issues arise.  One of the more common is the length of commute to a client site.  There is no set response, but the determination is based on several factors, including length of employment and current work backlogs.  The decision is not always in the employees favor, but we try to do what we can based on the circumstances at the time.

If someone does not want to do something, you are unlikely to get a favorable result by mandating compliance.  The best you are likely to get is half-hearted compliance.  Remember even the US military makes allowances for conscientious objectors.  Don't try to create a one size fits all policy, but deal with each occurrence as it arises.

 

by btljooz

I'm going to answer a question WITH a question...or a couple of them: 

#1. Without sound morality how can business be 'sound'?

#2. As a consummer would YOU do business with a company with questionable morals, etc.? 

Yes, there IS a flip side to EVERY coin!  THINK about it ;)

by justin james

I had a really, REALLY long comment written. Then I dropped my conenction while posting, and because TR's comments don't return when I click "Back", they are gone. Sorry. :(

J.Ja

by staticonthewire

Business choices are always easier when we exclude ethics, aren't they? And nine times out of ten, it's fair and prudent to do so, because ETHICS AREN'T STATIC, they aren't laws of nature, they're matters of opinion. Often they're STRONGLY HELD matters of opinion, but still, they're nothing more than personal choices. To allow the whims of individuals to drive your business decisions is tantamount to a guarantee of failure.

On the other hand, you can't constrain employees to violate their own moral principles and expect good results. They'll drag their feet, they'll sabotage, they'll undermine. Perhaps expanding your questioning when interviewing prospective employees would help in the future - ASK THEM how they might respond. Chances are they'll tell you something close to the truth.

As for the current employee with the moral dilemma - if you can't reassign them, let them go. Unless they were hired specifically for the project they are now refusing to work on, give them the standard company severance and a handshake and part company. If they're deliberately sabotaging, give 'em the boot - have security escort them out and spread the word so this bonehead doesn't get the opportunity to poison any other wells.

Of course if we're talking about a socially enshrined ethical choice (one that has been enacted as law), then it's no longer a simple matter of opinion, is it. Your best business decision is to stick to the letter.

by dr. tarr

Being a fellow with rather strongly held personal convictions, as well as having an independent contractor?s shingle, I first read this post and thought Wow!  That looks suspiciously familiar.?  I don?t work in the software development business and so decided that the article probably wasn?t about me personally, but I feel compelled to respond.

If an employee feels so strongly about an organization that they are unwilling to work on their project, perhaps you should take a look at the project.  If the company management doesn?t find the client?s actions objectionable and wants to do business with them, you have a vehicle to resolve the issue:  the employment contract.  Among other things, contracts usually require that you do the work assigned, give the compensation for accomplishing the task, and detail the penalties for non compliance, to which both parties agree.  If there is an issue, read the contract and do what it says.  That is one of the reasons for having the contract in the first place.

There are people and entities that I will not do business with.  Some of these are for sound business reasons, but more are because of a core of strongly held personal beliefs.  After all, we are judged by the company we keep, and there are some whose company I do not wished to be associated with.  Your contract employee probably has a similar mindset.  As a contractor we have that flexibility, and that is why some of us work as contractors rather than as employees

If you can?t come up with a workable solution, then you and the contractor should part company.  That?s what I did, and I believe that it is the right ethical choice as well as a sound business decision.  I didn?t force an ugly confrontation, we parted on good terms, and in the end it actually helped me.

Immediately after leaving I was offered a couple of small projects by local small business whose owner?s share my convictions.  Don?t get me wrong, I didn?t try to get sympathy work, and I didn?t run around badmouthing anyone.  I spent twenty years of my life defending American?s right to be wrong, and people and organizations have the same right to feel the same way about me but the story did get around.  It turns out that the owner of the business I left spread the word that I wouldn?t work on projects because of the politics of a customer.  I don?t know if he meant it as a compliment , but what I was told was that he was so amazed that there were still people who have conviction?s that he enhanced my reputation as someone who was ethical and trustworthy.

I would be very careful about generating a policy document, to the point of getting a lawyer involved.  In our litigious society someone will find a way to use it against you, and force you to do something that is one hundred eighty degrees out of alignment with what you were trying to accomplish.  A boss once told me that regulations are created for people without common sense, and then forced on the rest of us so that those folks won?t feel singled out.  I understand that there is a need for rules and guidelines, but the fewer you can get away with the better off you are.

by mr l

I would never sign such an agreement, and there is no way I would work for an organization that expected me too...and that's the freedom we enjoy.  You of course have the right, if privately held, to insist on these terms of employment, but I think you'll be surprised at how many people refuse to work for you if you do.

by oresky

What business is this CEO in that he has to give a "this company is no place for morals" talk to every employee?  Spammer? Porn Website? Phishing? Mafia? Law firm?

Seriously, what type of business is based on "we force employees to work on projects they find morally wrong"?  Is that really a sustainable relationship model?

by gsquared

I would personally rather be unemployed than unethical.  Ethical violations ruin your whole future, make life not worth living, destroy relationships, etc.  If I found the company I work for was doing something I considered unethical, I'd start by challenging/question it, on the assumption that what I'm seeing isn't the whole story.  If, after I got the whole story, or I found that the "whole story" was being hidden from me, I would do what I could to correct the situation.  If that won't work, I'd leave.

I've only had one employer who was doing stuff I considered unethical.  It was legal, but it was deliberate deception of customers and employees.  No false advertising by legal definitions, just legal, deliberately misleading advertising.  I made it clear to management that I couldn't tolerate such, and, not being in a position to effect change, I left and got work elsewhere.

The company I currently work for, I know the owners personally and I am glad of the fact that they have high ethical standards and hold the company to them.

by paul.cook

Hmmm. If I was asked to do a job for a organization which I didn't agree with politically or morally, I would probably say no, because I don't want to help them forward their cause.

However, what about contractor who is a devout Christian pro-lifer and asked to work an assignment for Planned Parenthood. If s/he said no under religious grounds could s/he be legally reprimanded/let go/not offered more assignments?

Political, moral and philosphical bents are not protected. Religious bents are.

I'd be checking with Legal and HR before I did anything about a religious stance. The original poster said that the issue was a political one. Not protected. No more assignments for that contractor.

 

 

 

by .sjh.

Would you hire someone with no moral values?  I  think
that the Software CEO would want to hire people that had moral values against
stealing, cheating, sex in the work place,  etc. A person with high moral values makes a
good employee.  So what I read is. The software
CEO has different moral values in certain areas than the contractor has. 

Certain moral positions, i.e. abortion, homosexuality, pornography
 etc. have been politicized. This keeps the
person who has no problem with these things from having to face them as a moral
issue.  As for me, if I asked someone to
do something and they refused on moral 
grounds, I would  have to assess
my own position on the issue.  If the
employee or contractor in this case, had performed well in the past, I would
assign them duties that they did not object to. 

I would like to know who the contractor is. This is a person
that I can do business  with.

And if I knew who the software CEO was.  I would not want to do business with them.

After all, if I had a problem with their software, I just
might have a problem getting satisfaction. 
After all, business comes before morals.

by Mark W. Kaelin

I understand the comments about moral conviction and the right to make choices and the equal need to accept the consequences of those choices. But I read something different in the story told by the poster on SoftwareCEO.

The software his company created was designed to help non-profit organizations track donations and keep financial records. As a contractor for his company, you would be required to sell, with equal enthusiasm, to a non-profit group that worships Satan and/or one like Pat Robertson's 700 Club. You can pick your own extreme ? PETA and a non-profit group that likes to eat raw meat while wearing fur.

The question for the CEO, was should he have a policy that each contractor would have to acknowledge and accept that stated that they would be required to do this? The software itself does not discriminate the moral or political stance of its user; it just tracks donations and keeps financial records. Furthermore, the CEO has apparently decided that, in the name of revenue, his company will not make a distinction between or among customers based on those grounds.

Now, as a contractor you can choose not to work under those conditions, but wouldn't it be better for all concerned if those conditions were stated clearly at the start of the potential relationship?

by Mark W. Kaelin

I just wanted to reiterate that the World of Warcraft TechRepublic
guild, designated Technologia, has a Wiki page:

http://wiki.techrepublic.com/twiki/bin/view/TRWOWGuild/WebHome

This is a
public Wiki so we can do what we want with it. Besides the roster we can add
FAQs, Class Guides, links to other sites, etc. I mention this because I want to
emphasize that this is not part of the TechRepublic site so the only way it
will get content is through the efforts of Technologia.

by jmgarvin

I've added some links to guide on the wiki.

At some point, I'll add my own guides and such for Druids and Palis....

by Mark W. Kaelin

I have
recently had the pleasure (obligation) to help two family members' purchase and
setup new personal computers. Besides the usual clean up of all the extraneous
software that ships with a new PC these days (no thank you AOL, MSN, EarthLink,
etc.), I was asked if I can install Word, Excel, Outlook or a combination of
those.

My response
was what were you using before and where are the disks, we'll just install it
again. Both times the answer has been along the lines of, "I don't have them" or worse
yet, "I don't know what I was using - it was Word I think." Rather
than go through the hassle of explaining that Microsoft Office 2003 actually
costs a significant amount of money I decided to download and install Open
Office.

This is a
change for me, because I have been using MS Office in some form since there was
an Office 1995. I have avoided Open Office for my novice family members out of
the fear that change is more trouble then making them spend $200 or more for a
Microsoft version of an Office Suite. But the more I looked at it, the less wary I
became. For most every-day uses, Open Office works just as well as anything
else.

I am
beginning to think that I will not spend money on the next version of Microsoft
Office. There just doesn't seem to be a reason I should spend money on it. I
know many TechRepublic members have already come to that inclusion, but I
wonder how long before institutional buyers reach the same conclusion. Is that
the sound of a cash cow drying up?

by dawgit

Welcome to the club.!.  but watch out for George Ou comming at you with valuable un-reason.

by joaomfferreira

You must be joking.

The only time I needed the Open Office "Word" was to build 36 tables for an Photographic exposition, by creating a series of legends - for the author, theme, date, etc - because that sotware was installed in my friends machine.

Imagine my surprise when each page printed (with 3 tables per page) would show me the tables starting in different heights. The ideia is to cut 12 pages at once, suposing they are alike.

Needless to say, I went to my place - meanwhile I asked my friend to insert the data in Open Office "Excel" - got my portable with Office, did the files transfer (xls data and doc template), merged in Office and printed the same file without any difference (in heights) between the pages.

So if you write love letters, you can use Open Office. If you need something more professional, ask you neighboor if you can borrow his computer for a while.

by Mark W. Kaelin

No joke. The family members in question do not need most of the sophisticated features available in either suite. While the formatting problems you describe sound annoying, I'm sure they could have been overcome with some tweaking.

Anyone else have examples of compatibility problems? Were you able to correct them in Open Office or did you have to switch back to MS Office?

by don christner

At my office, one of the owners is Microsoft only. However, at home I can't afford MS Office and use OpenOffice. I have never come across a problem in Word or Excel when working at home with Open Office. Granted, there could be some wierd function or macro stuff that I haven't tried (or needed!). So, for me, Open Office is great. You can open Office files or even start a new file and save as if it were an Office file.

Now, if you want to talk database, I wouldn't try to use Open Office instead of Access. I would bet that for 90% of Office users, Open Office would be no problem.

Don

by bluecollargeek

I really don't care which one they use as I don't make anything on the sale of the software, I get paid for working on the system (install and maintain).

Whenever I get the MS Office question, I give the computer's owner a quick Pricegrabber search of the MS Office products (so they realize what it will cost) and offer to install OpenOffice.  I tell them if they don't like OpenOffice or feel OpenOffice is missing features they need, I will gladly come back at no additional charge and will uninstall OpenOffice and will install their purchased copy of MS Office.

Just this year alone, I have installed several hundred copies of OpenOffice and to date, only two users REALLY needed the MS products.  I gladly helped them find the best price on the MS products and installed them for them.  Everyone else has been perfectly satisfied with OpenOffice.

The computer owners appreciate saving a couple hundred dollars and call me again when they need help.  Repeat business - got to love it.



 

by Mark W. Kaelin

I was wary
of installing the beta version of Microsoft's Internet Explorer 7 on my
personal laptop, but with the release of Beta 2 I decided to take the plunge
and see if this new browser has more to offer then what is currently available.
I made an image gallery of my initial experience.

To my
surprise, the installation was relatively painless and to my amazement, I
haven't found a Web page yet that will not render. Granted it has only been a
day or so, but I have visited my list usual Web sites and I have no complaints.

In general,
I like the overall look and feel of IE7 and I can see myself adopting it as my
primary browser when it is released. I know that will upset some of you and I
can already hear the cries of security vulnerabilities and impending doom. But,
for the most part, I am not all that worried about my browser security. I don't
surf the Web indiscriminately so the chances for me to stumble across the
nefarious random Web site are rather limited.

Besides, I
don't really like Firefox. I'm not sure why, but Firefox just didn't seem to
match my eye. I would close windows when I meant to expand or minimize them;
things like that. That's not to say that Firefox has something wrong with it; I
just can't get comfortable using it. It is strictly a personal preference.

Anyway,
check out the image gallery and let me know what you think of IE7,
especially in comparison to Firefox and Opera. I know many of you are
passionate about your browser choice, so I expect to get some flak, but
remember I have absolutely no passion for my browser. If you want to sway me
toward your browser of choice, stick to the facts.

by drf1499

Insert comment text here

I've also installed IE 7 Beta 2 on my PC & have had no problems with any of my usual websites.  I tried Firefox but then I could not access any of the Games on the MSN Zone since the Zone would not recognize Firefox.  I've always liked IE - bugs & all!!

by j p charland

What about us "prehistoric" users who are still running on W2K?  Will IE7 be compatible when it goes into distribution or must I stick to Firefox (not that I really mind to be perfectly honest)

by jaysmith2

I started using the beta version when it was released, and I have to admit, I love it.  I have always had a love-hate relationship with IE, but this version is truly a an improvement over the previous releases. I have had no problems to date, and I get a lot of Japanese websites here in Japan...no problems with them either...now only if I could read Japanese...  JaySmith2@cox.net

 

by mmsatbgr

I installed IE7 beta 2 without a hitch and really loved the new browser.  That said, I lost html sending and receiving in Outlook 2003. I searched and searched, but couldn't find a security setting that would help or a workaround for it, so I uninstalled it.  If I find a way to fix that problem, I will definately reinstall IE7!

by murali bala

I have been using IE 7 for sometime now. It's been a great exp. I used to use firefox before i downloaded IE7...

Murali Bala

 

by Mark W. Kaelin

The Technologia Guild is going strong in the World of Warcraft and several of us have characters entering their 20s. That means we need new areas to explore and that it is time to consider instance dungeons.

For Horde, my favorite spots at 20 are Hilsbrad Foothills (Tauren Mill), Thousand Needles, and Ashevale.

I think we have enough people at the right level to give Wailing Caverns a try. It is an instance that takes about two hours to run through, maybe three the first time. We can try to set up a day and time for that, assuming there is interest.

by jmgarvin

I've already run WC, but I'll do it again.  Perhaps we should setup a guild "raid" time?  We should also post this in the guild....

As for the new area: Ashenvale is probably a good place to go as 1k Needles is a HUGE PITA.... ;-)

by Mark W. Kaelin

Some of you may have put two and two together, but it may have slipped right past some others; living in Louisville, KY means living with the thrill and anticipation of the most exciting two minutes in sports, almost year round. The Kentucky Derby is Saturday and there is much to prepare for.

I'm not all about technology all the time ? I dabble in other hobbies that are steeped in earthy traditions. Horse racing is one of my favorites. I'll be out of the office tomorrow so I can attend my 10th straight Oaks Day at Churchill Downs. For non-Louisville residents, Oaks Day refers to another horse race held on the first Friday in May every year ? the day before the Kentucky Derby. Louisvillians have adopted this day as their day at the races as opposed to Derby Day which is really for out-of-towners.

I have my tickets, my ballpoint pen, my program, my racing tips, my binoculars, my camera, a wad of money, and my hat with Pegasus pins from the last 25 Derby festivals ? I'm ready. Last year I won about $80, which is about as good as you can expect, but I hope to do even better. My pick for the Kentucky Oaks is Wait a While ? wish me luck.

For the Kentucky Derby, my pick is Point Determined.

by Mark W. Kaelin

Normally on a Sunday afternoon, I would be joining my friends in the World of Warcraft. But today I had to come to the office to prepare a newsletter for publication. I had started the weekly project late last week and only had about 30 minutes worth of work to do.

On a typical weekend I would have used the VPN, but Insightbb, my ISP, decided this weekend, Ky Derby weekend, would be a good time to deploy new hardware. Of course, the whole system crashed and I have been without an online connection from home since late Friday evening when they kicked me off without warning.

The whole process has been a real cluster-flop. The only response you can get from them, assuming you make it through and can wait the hour and a half on hold to actually talk to someone is "We're working on it. They are running some scripts to fix it ? it should work soon. Almost 72 hours later and no service ? those must be some big scripts.

I wonder how much DSL costs in my area?

by Mark W. Kaelin

I have been
without Internet access at home for the past four days and it has been
miserable. While I am more than mildly upset with Insightbb.com, my service
provider, for their inadequate and incompetent server migration, that is not
really why I am miserable. I have become dependent on my Internet connection.

Up until
this point, I had not realized how dependent I actually was. I use the Internet
to pay bills, keep in contact with friends and clients, manage my retirement
funds and stock portfolio, get bank statements in PDF form, keep up with
science and technology news, pick DVDs I want to rent, download music for my
iPod, VPN to the office, and play games. And this is just what I can think of
at the current moment.

I am
feeling vulnerable -- I don't like the feeling of not being in control. I
realize, intellectually, I am not really in control of much of anything, but I
usually feel like I am; a delusion from which I retain some small sliver of
sanity. But this continuing saga of ineptitude by the folks at Insightbb has
brought me back to the cold reality that I need Internet access and that I am
crippled, at least perceptively and metaphorically speaking, without it.

The current
situation will pass I'm sure -- despite their failings, the people at Insightbb
do want to provide me service -- but it has raised a question in my mind; a
question that I think many TechRepublic members have contemplated:

  • Should I have a backup system
    for my personal connection to the Internet?

I'm
thinking this could take the form of a Treo or other
handheld device that acts as a phone and Internet browsing appliance. That
would give me two ways to get to my bank's Web site wouldn't it? I did find one
solution to my lack of connection problem in the form of a laptop with wireless
and the free connection provided by Panera Bread restaurants. But I was
concerned about the security of such a setup.

So help me
out here -- do you have a backup service for your personal use? What is it? Is
it worth the extra cost? Or should I just start weaning myself from my Internet
dependence and join the Luddites?

by justin james

None of the things that you are missing out on seem terribly crucial to living a happy, fulfilling life. Frequently, I spend entire weekends "Internet-less" or even "computer-less" on purpose. There is more to life than ordering DVDs, checking my bank statement, looking at my portfolio, etc. Those things can wait. I have a life to be living. Yes, there are some friends and family that I use a computer as my primary means of contact with, but all of those people have telephones and mailboxes. I am not a Luddite by any means, but I do my best to not let my world revolve around the computer or the Internet. It is bad enough that I spend 8+ hours per day on the computer at work. By the time I get home, my body is rebelling against the thought of sitting in a chair staring at a monitor. I am sure all of the companies that you pay your bills online will let you call them and make a payment over the phone or send one in via mail. Bill payment is the only thing on that list that I see as time sensitive, and even that has non-computerized options. Remember, a large portion of US households have no Internet access; most of the people I spend time with do not even own computers. They are able to live happy, fulfilling lives. Spending time on the computer has never made me happy, it has simply provided me with a distraction from boredom. I now try to spend as much of my time talking with other people in person, walking, working around the house, playing with the cat, taking long drives, etc. I do not miss the "computer and Internet, 24x7" of years gone by, not one bit.

J.Ja

by Mark W. Kaelin

Justin - I think you are right about not needing the Internet for a happy life and that is what I always told myself. But I am thinking now that the Internet has become an integral part of my every day activity to a point where four days without has an impact.

I had not realized how big a role the Internet plays in my life; I have become accustomed, attuned, and in some ways dependent on it for everything from mudane surfing to the very real financial need to reach E-Trade to sell a tanking stock. All my bills come by e-mail, which means I really don't know what I may owe or when I need to pay the bill. I'm sure nothing pressing has come in four days, but I am uncomfortable with the idea that I can't click a few buttons with my mouse and find out for sure.

Am I the only one that feels this way?

by Mark W. Kaelin

I signed my
elderly father (83) up for one of the 43 separate Medicare Prescription drug
plans available in the Louisville area. That's right 43 --- how the heck is an
83-year old man, a man who cannot even switch between the TV and the VCR so he
can watch Laurel & Hardy movies, a man that would still have a rotary phone
if we hadn't bought him a touch tone phone --- how can this man decide which
plan is best for him.

For that
matter, how could I? The Medicare sight is a mess --- obviously created by a
bloated bureaucracy, the site is full of obscure references to more obscure
laws, most of which refer to indecipherable regulations. This is supposed to
help elderly people make a decision --- absolutely ridiculous.

During a
conversation with Bill Detwiler this morning, he correctly pointed out the
problem with the whole set up. Everything is designed to help the insurance
companies get enrollees --- all the gibberish is designed to cover their rear
ends from liability, not to help Medicare beneficiaries.

For the Web
site to be truly effective for the Medicare beneficiaries (as it claims to be),
it should ask only one question: Please
list your prescription drugs.
With that information, the Web site would
produce the least expensive plan for your prescriptions.

If this
were a customer-oriented site produced by a corporation or business that was
truly dependent on the satisfaction of its beneficiaries, it would be
completely different. The technology is available, but the bureaucratic will is
not. Medicare, the insurance companies, the federal government should be
ashamed of themselves and we, as a society with an increasingly older
population, should be embarrassed. We can and should do better.

by Michael Kassner

Amen! And not to mention that the prescription drug list would not be necessary were it not for pharamceutical companies pushing their "wares" on physicians who then push them on their elderly patients.

by wayne m.

Unfortunately, the correct question would have to be, "Please list your current and future prescription drugs."   Providing coverage for a uniform set of prescription drugs would simplify the application process as well as the administration process for insurance companies.

 

by Mark W. Kaelin

I like Jim
Cramer and I regularly watch his Mad Money television program. I also
occasionally listen to his much calmer radio show Real Money via a pod cast. In
general, I think he knows more about stocks then just about anyone and I have
made some money in the market following his advice over the past year or so.
However, he has take a recent stand that I'm not sure is correct.

He is down
on Microsoft, Dell and Intel on the assumption that the personal computer
market will continue to be sluggish for the next year or so. His take on Intel
may be correct because AMD has certainly achieved significant advances in
market share at the expense of the once untouchable giant. And Dell is getting
competition from discount Asian manufacturers, which forces their margins down
to painful levels, so he may be right to take a bearish stand there. However, I
am not sure about Microsoft.

Microsoft's
stock price took a nose dive after announcing the delay in Vista and following
that up with a poorly performing quarter, but I wonder if that is just a lull
before a corporate buying spree? In a recent article in PC Magazine they should
a graph and report by Jon Peddie Research that showed
the percentage of PCs in active use that are fully Vista compatible. Their
conclusion was that only 51% of PCs in active use will be able to run Vista.

So we get
the usual question: Will corporations buy new machines to run Vista or will
they sit tight and stick with Windows XP? It is the same question we asked eight
months before Windows XP and Windows 2000 and Windows 95. It is the perpetual
question. Each time the answer has been yes they will buy new PCs --- only it
won't really happen in the form of a spree. Corporations spread capital
expenditures out over the two years or so following the release of a new
Windows operating system.

The
difference this time, and the thing that worries Microsoft and the Wall Street
brokers, is whether that cycle will repeat itself this time. Windows Vista is
going to have to have a compelling story I think. So far, I have seen some nice
visual enhancements and some nice features that make Vista a viable operating
system. I don't think Vista will fall flat like Windows ME. However, from a
corporate purchase decision standpoint, I have yet to see what Vista brings to
the table beyond Windows XP that will make corporations buy it.

Perhaps I'm
missing something. Over the next year, TechRepublic will examine Vista sideways
and backwards to provide the membership with a comprehensive critique of Vista,
perhaps then I will see a reason to buy Vista. If reasons surface, I think
Microsoft will sell lots of Vista licenses, earn lots of money, and continue to
be the dominate player in software. If they don't, it could mark a turning
point in the history of the personal computer.

What do you
think? Have you found a compelling reason to buy Vista? Are you buying
Microsoft stock or looking to dump it. Personally, I sold my Microsoft stock in
January 2006.