Discussion Locked

One UP for the Climate change sceptics

0 helpful
166 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've always been on the warming side of the fence, but tried to listen more to both sides

- when I actually found out there WAS another side, of course.

Here is an interesting article, with another failry eminent scientiest posing some interesting points:

http://blogs.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/piersakerman/index.php/dailytelegraph/comments/climate_changes_as_alarmists_exposed/

166 replies

by the 'g-man.'

just gotta turn up the Air Con a bit before I get down to typing.

No fuss, the coffee stays hot all day around here!

OK, who turned the light in the basement off?

WOL - NO

by jackofalltech

I've had a subscription to Scientific American for more than 20 years, I ran the weather station at each of the schools I attended, I've looked at the data from both sides (at least what's available on the Internet) and it seems to me that the preponderance of the evidence is that not only MMGW is a hoax, but GW period is also.

by jaqui

we have had a heat wave here, and very little rain.
4 hours of rain in 2 months, in a rain forest climate.

at 6:44 am [ right now ] it is currently 30 C.
when that is a high for the day here most summers.

and close to 15% of the province is on fire, forest fires. Which doesn't sound bad, until you look at the square miles of the province being equal to Washington State, Oregon State and Northern California, combined.

by saurondor

Clearly there are changes in the weather. To deny that is to be out of touch with reality. Rain seasons are changing. Winters are sometimes colder. Etc.

If it isn't CO2 then what is it? The ozone layer? Sun burning hotter? A black rectangular object on the far side of the Moon?

Main issue I have with those who don't believe in global warming is that they generally don't provide an alternative explanation nor model. If it's not CO2 what is it? If it isn't permanent then how transitory is it?

by oz_media

That storm the other night was awesome! But breaking 60 year old records every day has been a bit much.

It's worse that mid August weather already! What about rain to start the PNE? It was a given for years but not lately, BRING BACK OUR RAAAAIIIIIN!!!!

Maybe I'll drop by Hastings & Main and see if I can get a rain dance going. :D
"Give ya $10 for a rock if you can bring rain!"

All the various types of corn, Peaches & Cream, Jubilee etc are all ready at the same time for the first time in recorded history. Guys out in Chilliwack are going nuts trying to reap 3 or 4 crops at the same time.

As has always been said, we should feel the effects long before the central US, which is where most of these absolute naysayers live, interestingly enough.

by dadspad

not climate. I,ll let the certified experts fight over climate. :)

I once saw a cartoon, I think it was a Herman one, that showed a car on a road somewhere in the midwest. All you could see was the car on a black top road and corn fields. On the radio the the talk was of overpopulation was killing the world.

I think of someone in Chicago, on the street, looking in a window at a TV talking about global warming heating up the world, with the temerature 60 degrees F.

Just stikes me as funny.

by gsg

We're also having one of the Coldest and wettest July's on record.

I agree that we're warming up, but we're also still coming off of the last ice age. Antarctica has been almost, if not completely ice free the last time we were off of an ice age, so the warming is normal.

Do I think we're warming a bit faster than we would if we humans weren't here? Yes. Do I think its a global catastrophe? No.

I think it's a case of politicians jumping on the latest fad and buzzword and running with it because if nothing bad happens, they'll take all the credit, and if something bad does happen, they can say, "I told you so, and I worked so hard to save the human race."

It also is a great way to throw a bright shiny object in our faces to hide their affairs, embezzlement, etc...

by notsochiguy

I actually used this technique last night on my oldest daughter.

I found a spelunking light, and put in new batteries. After dinner, when dessert was getting doled out, I put it on, and said "look what daddy found".

Shine goes the bright light into her eyes.

Sweet (yet healthy) goodness goes from her plate into my mouth!

:)

by maxwell edison

..... and is merely a political agenda in search of justification - as I've been saying for years.

I'm amazed at how foolish people are to believe such nonsense.

In the USA, they're on the verge of passing [i]Climate Legislation[/i] in Congress. Climate legislation? Climate legislation? They're legislating the climate? HELLO, PEOPLE!

Tax and control - that's what it's all about, and that's what it's always been about. And otherwise intelligent people are buying into the lie like a bunch of gullible dupes. People need to wake up and pull their heads out. But so many of them won't. Who wants to admit they've been duped? So they won't admit it. Who wants to defy and question their preferred political party? So they won't. And who wants to abandon their preferred agenda? So they continue the lie.

Future generations will look back and shake their heads in disbelief wondering how we could be so stupid - so utterly stupid - to believe such nonsense.

by Member 25348569

We've been here before. Organised religion gets the top spot every time.

Neil :)

"War Against Terror" is pushing for that second-place slot. There haven't been any wars over GW - yet.

by jardinier

I will agree with you about organized religion, but I do not think it is in the same category as MMGW.

Since time immemorial, people, noticing the inequalities in life, and being dependent for their survival on the vagaries of nature, have felt the need to believe that someone or something out there actually knows what is going on and may have some control over these things. And so they have invented gods.

Regarding the major religions with which we are familiar today, the more they have become organized, the more they are corrupted from the original source, and in time survival of the institution becomes an end in itself.

I am not at all aware that the average person would feel personally insecure on account of global warming, and hence would not need to create a god to pay homage to in order to hopefully control the phenomenon.

by Member 25348569

I'm just sitting on the sidelines tossing pebbles into the pool. I've debated this subject here too many times to expect anything other than entrenched positions.

:)

by Member 25348569

I think that there are those - definitely - who are jumping on the bandwagon for personal gain of power, money, whatever. They are those who seek power (such as Al Gore and you know what I think of him) or those who have vested interests in the status quo (GW Bush and his friends in the oil trade, perhaps).

I think your own position is pretty well marked down. The odd subtle hint gives me an idea of where you're at.

I think there are many, many more who really believe that "something is happening" (and I number myself in here) and that we "can do something about it" (there, I'm not so sure and I'm not even sure we should try).

If we can't agree how much of the change is anthropogenic and what the local effects of any change might be then how can we know how to stop it or slow it down or whether we should even try.

I do think that diversification of energy sources, renewable energy sources and conservation of the use of energy are such no-brainers that I'm willing to go along with doing what we can for the moment. Lots of it is easy and lots of it is obvious.

Cough!SUV!Cough!...

by Member 25348569

There are quite a few inaccuracies in the stuff that is attributed to Plimer.

He says atmospheric carbon dioxide is now at the lowest levels it has been for 500 million years. Not true.

Atmospheric carbon dioxide is only 0.001 per cent of the total amount of the chemical held in the oceans, surface rocks, soils and various life forms. Irrelevant, meaningless.

Carbon dioxide is not a pollutant, but a plant food. Plants eat carbon dioxide and excrete oxygen. Yes, and? We all know about the Carbon Cycle or, if we don't then we shouldn't be shooting our mouths off.

Human activity contributes only the tiniest fraction to even the atmospheric presence of carbon dioxide. Demonstrably untrue.

Ah, well...

by notsochiguy

....we're holding AquaNet parties. Entire blocks of people, spraying CFCs into the air in order for us to get a real summer!!

:p

On a more serious note, the weather in Chicago during the past few years has been increasingly more 'chaotic'. We've had some of the warmest Novembers, Decembers, Januarys and Februarys the last few years, but we've also had some of the coolest Junes, Julys (this one is about to become the first one ever where we don't even hit 88, let alone 90), Augusts and Septembers, too.

Overall, things skew back to average, I suppose. Just that the manner in which it happens is far different than when I was growing up here in the city. I'm not a climatologist or meteorologist, so I am not sure if that really means anything long term; but it is 'interesting' to me.

by jaqui

commenting that we are getting hit with odd weather, for here.

if the trend continues, the winter Olympics will be held on man-made snow, or else grass. :D

by jck

Have you any recollection in your lifetime having ever seen a high temperature on the national weather for Portland Oregon of over 100?

I saw that the other day, and that Seattle was like 97.

I've never seen that in the 35 years I can remember seeing weather reports on the national news.

Something is awry, and I genuinely don't think it's El Nin~o? (the page won't let me use the tilda-n I know how to do...sorry)

by jdclyde

[i]"Updated: Wednesday July 29, 2009 5:55 a.m.

An all-time high temperature is possible today in the Portland-Vancover area. The record is 107 (set last time... back in 1981). My forecast high is 107 today.. and a realistic range is between 105-108 for all areas in the inland valles. Tonight, overnight lows will not cool down much- into the low to mid 70s. The heatwave continues tomorrow with daytime highs near 101.

We'll hover around 90 at the start of the weekend. However, Sunday looks cooler with morning clouds and afternoon sun with highs around 88. This week will likely go down in Portland weather history as one of the worst heatwaves ever!

Rhonda"[/i]

http://www.katu.com/weather

by jck

I don't recall ever having seen Portland over 100...90s a lot, but never over 100.

btw...38?

Someone call Texas Instruments lol :^0

The National Weather Service had this information though for yesterday:

http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/oa/climate/research/records/index.php?ts=daily&elem=maxt&month=7&day=28&year=2009&submitted=Get+Records#recs

Just seems odd. Never seen the El Nino cause this kinda extended heat even in different places. It even got above 90 degrees for a duration in places that only get into the 80s during the summer in Washington state.

There's just something funny with this weather. Even the data from Alaska shows a large temperature flux.

I'm starting to think living in Idaho is sounding safe. lol

BTW, jd...i found you a woman...check the story out called "Kids OK, but woman faces neglect charges" down below the forecast. ;) :^0

by maxwell edison

I can't speak for the historic temperatures of Portland (Oregon or Maine), or Seattle, or most other places where I haven't spent a significant amount of time. I could, like you or anyone else, do Web searches for such things, but that's about the best I could do. For example:

[i]"(Portland) Meteorologist Miles Higa says the airport hit 103 degrees, beating the 1958 record of 102. Records have been kept there since 1941."[/i]

Therefore what, I might ask? The temperature creeped one degree higher than it did fifty years ago? Much ado about nothing, if you ask me - especially since records have been kept in Portland for less than 70 years.

I do remember, however, that while growing up in Missouri and Kansas I experienced absolutely scorching hot summer days, not so much different than today. Some summers, on the other hand, were much milder when I was a kid. Again, just like today. Was it hotter then or now? Who knows and who cares?

Records will be kept - highest this and lowest that, wettest this and driest that, longest, shortest, and so on - and records will be broken. But the amount of time for which any records are kept pales in comparison to the length of time weather patterns have been changing, and climate patterns have been changing, and temperatures have risen and fallen around the globe.

The Earth's eco-system always has been, still is, and always will be in a constant state of flux. Just because it's changing doesn't mean we're causing (or contributing to) it. Actually, in my opinion, to suggest that human activity is a significant factor in that change is the epitome of conceit and ignorance. If - and that's a HUGE if - we do make some insignificant contribution to such things, on balance and all things considered, it's not a bad thing - especially compared to the cures and fixes the politicos are suggesting, all of which are bad things.

Imagine what our lives would be like without the energy consumptions of the past 100 years. Let's just stop driving and shut down all coal fired power plants and live happily ever after. Yea, right. Without the way we've been using energy, how many people would have died? How much progress would have gone unrealized?

Sorry, but not only do I reject the political hijacking of what is, at best, a scientific theory (nothing proven), but I simply can't join people in demonizing the very things (energy) that have improved people's lives more than anything else in history. On balance, any MM-GW/CC theory is much ado about nothing, which is exactly what we should do about it - nothing.

by jck

But if we're doing nothing significant to affect the environment, then answer this:

If you deforest approximately 50% of the worlds largest rainforest basin (approx. 2M square miles in the Amazon alone or approximately 10% of the worlds total oxygen replenishing plantlife), and increase the CO2 emissions put out by cars, plants, etc. by some 68%...both over the same 30 year period worldwide.

A) Where is all the CO2 going if plants of all types are not as plentiful to turn that CO2 into O2?

And:

B) What does all that CO2 do when left in the atmosphere and its concentration increases over time?

Because from what I was taught in science:

If there are less plants to take care of increasing CO2 emissions and make them oxygen...

And CO2 stays in the atmosphere and traps heat as has been scientifically proven it does...

Then, the logical conclusion is increased CO2 levels would cause rises in temperatures across the globe.

Does that not make sense?

BTW, I don't endorse *all* means of being more power efficient.

However, there is nothing wrong with making changes that are not life changing or life threatening to people and still have a positive effect.

Oh, and I just have to comment on one point that you made:

It would be that weather over the past 120 years of industrialization would have killed fewer people...than the products of industrialization, i.e.- guns, bombs, planes, missles, etc.

So if the amount of death and lack of opportunity of lives to fulfill destiny is the factor in whether we should have advanced or not...

Then, I would think that your stance would have been that industrialization should have never happened and we should be still riding in wagons and shooting bows and arrows.

That only seems to make sense to me, according to your believing that implementing things that don't allow human capability to be realized are unnecessary.

Nonetheless, I do earnestly want to hear how you can disqualify my scientific predicates based on simple scientific facts about global warming, plus how you might endorse the progress of technology that forged industrialization and provided things like the bomb that was dropped on Hiroshima that killed 66,000 within seconds.

Thank you for your answer though. I do appreicate it.

by jardinier

I know the d*ckhead. He used to work on the same Sydney newspaper as myself (the now defunct Daily Mirror). That was a Rupert Murdoch paper as is the Daily Telegraph for which Akerman regularly writes absolute garbage, whatever the subject.

You don't want to believe ANYTHING he says. He is a complete ratbag.

by jardinier

which has absolutely no bearing whatsoever on the material Akerman writes, which I have learnt is not worth reading.

by maxwell edison

In your opinion, how should a person go about deciding who to believe and who to disbelieve? What if he (Akerman), for example, said the same thing about you - [i]that you're a d*ckhead and what you write is absolute garbage, whatever the subject?[/i]

Who would be right, you or him? Who would be wrong, you or him? And why should we [i]believe and trust[/i] you, and not him?

Couldn't absolutely everyone in the world be discredited by someone for some reason? I think the answer is yes. That's why the politics of personal destruction is always used as a strategy - and why it works so well. And that's why one should stick to debating the claim or idea and avoid dismissing it simply because of who makes it.

After all, an idea is not responsible for the person who might agree with it.

by jdclyde

a personal attack against the person instead of an honest debate about the validity of the data.

One of the big reasons the followers of man made global cooling/warming/shifts have no validity outside of their own circle. Pat themselves on the back about how grand and smart they all are for parroting each other while ignoring the data that counters their point.

by jardinier

Maxwell. Piers Akerman writes regularly for the Daily Telegraph. This newspaper is owned by the Murdoch group.

I use as my home page: news.com.au which takes stories from the various Murdoch newspapers published in Australia, as well as the usual new services at home and abroad.

What I particularly like about this website is that in many instances readers are invited to post comments on some particular article.

So it is not just me who thinks Piers Akerman is a loony, ultra-right-wing d*ckhead, but the majority of people who read his articles online and choose to post a comment.

These readers comments make for very interesting reading, as there is much material posted that is related to, but not included in the original article.

by drowningnotwaving

Hi Jardinier,

You're right in that Piers takes a twig and turns it into Bamboo under the fingernails, whenever he gets the chance. Especially agains the the sitting australian kind-of-left-leaning government.

The thing that made me pay more than the usual giggling attention to his stories was the reference to someone who DOES know what they are talking about.

Also that the person wasn't necessarily bagging the sh*t out of the pro-GW world, but moreso his opinion and evidence that true debate is being totally stifled.

Hence public policy, now very serious policy with the advent of the emissions trading scheme, will have a huge impact upon our entire way of living, is now being enacted without rigorous two-sided debate.

Personally I still err on the side of "benefit of the doubt" but I am hugely concerned about things such as ETS and their long term effect on nothing but our economy.

But I am swinging my opinion away from legislative solutions: that if each individual does what they can to reduce their energy use then this is just a great thing on its own, with no downside.

Just me, of course.

by notsochiguy

..only Pepe Le Pew could appreciate.

Maybe it is all the heat and humidity that damaged the hair???

:p

by amoeba1

The total average amount of carbon dioxide is still 0.0360%. There has been more sun activity in recent history (a know cause of planetary warming, also observed on all planets in our solar system).

My main question, who is to say 1980 was the optimum temp for the world or any point for that matter. We know there have been several ice ages in the past; and the way to get out of an ice age is class? Warming on a global scale. What caused the warming? Can't be mankind, we haven't been around for that long (geologically). Best theory (yes, THEORY) is caused by solar activity. After all, Greenland use to be green a couple 100's of years ago (per written records), so why is that period of time not the optimal global norm? ;)

by ic-it

Mostly it was still a great sheet of ice. Here is an excerpt from an interesting site and it has a sub-link to wikipedia;

Did Greenland used to be green?
The Greenland ice sheet is at least 400,000 to 800,000 years old. Certainly it was alive and well when the island was named around 1000 years ago. So where did the Green in Greenland come from? According to Wikipedia, legend has it was good marketing on the part of Erik the Red who figured it would attract more settlers (if he was more vain, it may have been called Redland). Or perhaps its a derivation of Engronelant or Gruntland. The main point is while the ice sheet has always been there, Greenland probably was somewhat warmer during the Medieval Period and part of Greenland was green. So once again, I refer you to the Climate's changed before argument.

Ref:
http://www.skepticalscience.com/greenland-used-to-be-green.htm

by jck

That Greenland is only currently 81% covered by the glacier and that the southern part of it is very very green during summer months.

As well, the MWP spoken of was a period of 300-400 years where Northern Hemisphere temperatures were above the millenial average.

So yes, it was probably greener and yes Erik The Red probably hyped it to get people to go there with him.

But, it's never been the oasis that Egypt once was.

by jck

in regards to sun activity.

The solar cycle occurs about every eleven years, when solar flare activity increases. That's a known fact. I know this, because I'm a science buff and because I'm an amateur radio operator and sunspot cycle activity increases increase an index which affects radio wave propagation atmospherically.

As for global warming, there are also misnomers about that.

Global warming does not mean there is less/no cold. It means there is an average increase of air and water temperatures on a global scale which does not fit within the scientific norm for traditional annual shifts taken over a period.

Global warming not only causes broad average temperature increases, but because of the increased energy in the atmosphere due to larger water vapor content then weather events become more extreme.

As for optimum temperature, that is an personal issue. However, scientists have shown via coring and sampling of materials that there are cycles in the climate. But when you chart the past 100 years during which industrialization has occured, you get an eerie diagram of exactly what sort of temperature variations are occuring.

For example, a temperature variation of < .05 degree Celsius in a century was considered within normal parameters. However, sea surface and air surface temperatures have deviated outside this trend showing data just within the past 30 years.

Oh btw...the biggest contributors known to extreme warming and cooling events on Earth:

1) Axis shifts
2) Extreme geological vulcanism
3) Climatogical engine shifting (sea conveyor, hemispheric flow pattern, etc)

For instance, in approximately 700AD the North Atlantic atmospheric flow pattern varied. Because of this shifting farther south than normal, areas as far away as Central and South America were adversely affected. Parts of Central America that were lush jungle and rain forest began to dry up and die off. When the pattern shifted back to normal, things resumed.

I could spout a lot more stuff. But if you want to see recorded data and analysis, check out places like NASA's Goddard Institute, The National Weather Service/NOAA, etc.

They have a lot of good information that is practical and definitive data, and analysis and charting visually showing you all the trends over month, year, decade, century, and millenia periods based on science and information...not hype and BS.

BTW, The Nile River Basin in Egypt used to be lush and green too. Axis shifts are hell. lol

by Member 25348569

is that no-one who researches into climate change hasn't thought of that! Hey fellas! Let's forget all about the Sun so that guys like amoeba can rubbish us on Net forum sites!

If you check Milankovitch cycles and also changes in the Earth's axial tilt and the combination of these, you'll see that palaeoclimatologists and geologists know all about them!

Here are the Milankovitch cycles from the Cretaceous Era etched into the chalk cliffs that run the length of England's southern coast. And you seem to think that NOBODY NOTICED.

http://i98.photobucket.com/albums/l243/neilb_uk/Picture019.jpg

:)

by jck

where is that? Cornwall? Devon?

Beautiful pics...amazing stratification.

by oz_media

Thispast week we have had a record heat wave through the northwest US to BC's coast, which is pretty much unheard of.

Th eother night was one of the coolest electrical storms I have ever experienced, golfball sized hail in teh Valley and lightning that was so often and so close that it literally knocked out a chunk of curn right outside my bedroom window, FLASH and a simultaneous BAAANG! power out 9thank god for notebooks with 4+ hour battery life, I watche dthe rest of my movie without interruption. I then took off to SFU ( a big hill close by witha university on it) around 11PM to see if I could capture some of it on film to seen in to TR, but they had streets closed with trees down etc.

But I oculdn' thelp but think, though I know it is not directly related to GW, wow, the end of the world, cooool! Extreme heat followed y extreme hail followed by extreme lightning storm! WAAAY COOL! B-)

But it sure as hell aint cooling down as some farther south seem to feel.

by drowningnotwaving

About 12 months ago one of the newspapers here showed a map of Sydney with a line showing what will happen when the oceans go up by 2 metres and 5 metres.

I think (hope) most thinking people realise that these speculations are completely unfounded, and that even the wildest (serious) scientific expectations are in the order of 15 - 45 cms.

{Not disputing that even that is serious to a number of folks worldwide}.

What was a little disturbing is that the maps that I mentioned were plastered on a first-year school wall (that's 5 - 6 year olds) and no doubt referred to by the teacher in a FUD kind of way.

Then I thought, heck, getting kids to pester their parents is how a lot of good changes have happened in the world, since the day dot, so it probably isn't as fearful as it may appear.

It's a laff.

by oz_media

What bothers me most is man's efects on the environment, I don't focus on the effects of GW because the same responsibility will help us live healthier anyway. People don't see it though. even drivign through BC, teh mountains are glorious from the highway ut as soon as you go over one, the amount of clear cutting and damage to the environment is seen. Loggers are becoming more responsible and trying to improve though.

It's not like I hump trees on my lunch break, it's more a reality in seeing we need to accept more personal responsibility.

I've seen salmon runs dwindle increasingly over the years due to over fishing, those run off streams are now getting weaker all the time due to smaller winter snowcaps on surrounding mountains, fewer salmon make it upstream as they are drying out (it's hell on a dirtbike, slippery buggers all over the road where washouts have dried up!), clear cuts in once protected forests where US companies have fought tooth and nail to justify it with replenishment plans, which are often neglected and ineffective.

As an auto tech., I am aware of the effects of Carbon MONoxide at street level, how we poison and can even kill ourselves with such simple emissions that don't just dissipate as many feel, I know that vehicles we buy today COULD be better but they are not because of age old trends, though there are many great moves in the better direction already. The US companies now preparing to build the small efficient cars that they already build in their European factories.

I see the effects we have on the planet, first hand. I live in a rainforest that is turning upside down right now due to poor resource management from the government to the consumer level. They started ot make better decisions but there is a lot of damage to be seen to before it can be deemed successful.

Funny enough, most of these common responsibilities we should assume ourselves are the same issues people are saying help increase the natural effects of GW.

SO when I hear people purposely abuse resources or see such uneccesary gluttony just to spite GW alarmists, it ticks me off to think people actually need a reason to care about the effects they have on our future on the planet.

All that crap people buy has to come from somewhere and a great deal of it comes from Canada because we are deemed resource rich and are out of sight and out of mind to people that rape resources without concern.

by jck

that you, a non-believer, sits here and belittles them by denegrating their stance without presenting your own proof they are wrong.

Where is the data that counters their point??

I ask you for your proof, since you are now the "parrot".

Thank you.

by jdclyde

is for he who wishes to impose their will upon others based upon their assertions.

If the chicken littles of the world just made their own lives as eco friendly and offered ideas for others how to do so, I wouldn't have a problem with them.

When these same people wish to use these same unproven ideas as a way to get political power and to gain (steal) revenue from those who have actually earned it, they have shown their true colors.

When these same people wish to legislate to others how they can live their lives, again, it is THEY that have to prove their case before they can take these forceful actions out upon anyone else.

I do not have to prove it isn't happening because I am not trying to force you or anyone else to change how they live.

Simple, huh?

And "just in case" is NOT proof or justification to force others to do or not do something.

If honesty would enter the debate, we would go back to talking about real issues like making sure we have clean air to breath, clean water to drink, and fight the real toxins that are poisoning the Earth.

Is the chance of 1 degree in 100 years more of a threat than mercury or lead poisoning now?

by jck

If you and millions of others live a life that indulges in activities that cause pollution which contributes to the warming of the planet, and that in turn causes people to have to purchase ACs for their homes, move because of coastal/island flooding, or even causes drought that allows wildfires where they lose their homes and lives...

Then, you have imposed your will upon others...by negligence of responsibility.

Now, for the proof thing you want.

Fact: 10 percent of the world's forest that recycle carbon dioxide into oxygen have been eliminated from the Amazon rainforest alone in the past 30 years.

Fact: other forests (such as in the Asian-Pacific and SE Asia) are also being eliminated now for "progress"

Fact: Carbon dioxide emissions in that same 30 years are up by almost 70%.

Fact: If plant life that does the recycling is down and emissions are up, then the concentration is going up in the atmosphere.

Fact: Carbon Dioxide is a gas which atmospherically traps heat radiation.

HENCE:

If we continue to live life irresponsibly toward the environment to indulge desires and wants by cutting down forests and not using cleaner fuel technologies, then we are going to heat the planet.

It is plain, scientific fact.

Don't believe me? Go look at any basic science textbook, and check out websites like the National Science Foundation.

They will give you more in depth research, formulas, and proofs that you want for exactingly showing you it is undenyable.

There is your honesty. Now, prove me wrong.

And as for CO2 not being a poison...go put a mask on and breath CO2 for me for an hour.

See if your body likes it.

You will bitch and complain about mercury and lead, but those poisons have already been banned from being dumped and used in concentrations which are toxic.

CO2 hasn't.

I guess when it gets hard for you and Thing One and Two to breathe, then you'll bitch about CO2.

Til then, live life up! Right? Let it go til it hurts you or someone you love, but who cares if it impacts someone in Holland or New Guinea because...you get to keep all your creature comforts...while their coasts slowly erode.

Yeah. If you wanna see what the rise in temps has done, check out these islands and how all these people have been effected because the modern world had to have all its conveniences.

http://www.commondreams.org/headlines/021600-01.htm

http://blogs.edf.org/climate411/2008/10/14/kiribati_evacuating/

And in the next 50 years as sea levels rise, Holland will lose hundreds of square miles of land.

So, how is indulging in using whatever you want so long as it doesn't hurt you...not imposing problems on others so that you can satiate your impulses and way of life you're accustomed to? When it costs others their homes? Their jobs? Their future? Their happiness?

That's honesty for you. The attitude that you and others carry is that I should get what I want until it is absolutely necessary to change.

My question is...how many people suffering makes it necessary? An island? A million? Your state? How many?

Really? Can you answer that?

by jck

I line out plain, basic, scientific facts that justify the fact that increased levels of CO2 will warm the planet.

I welcome any proof to the contrary you can provide.

But it is a fact that CO2 is a greenhouse gas that traps heat radiation.

And it is a fact that in the past 30 years that we've eliminated 10 percent of the worlds CO2 recycling plant life.

So if you increase the amount of CO2 put out...and decrease the amount of plants that turn it into oxygen?

Pretty basic premise to me. CO2 will go up, and therefore trap more heat in the atmosphere and your planet gets warmer.

Do you disagree?

by tonythetiger

"Approximately 65 percent of near earth-crossing objects of significant size have been discovered."

Most people don't see the logical problem with such a statement. It implies that the end result (in this case the "count") is known and thus the progress toward that result is also known, when neither is the case.

Now add in politicians who want to make policy decisions based on this crap....

by Member 25348569

That's the [b]point[/b] of a scientific theory - a single, coherent explanation for something. If you want alternatives then go and find them for yourself. There's enough out there willing to offer and then it's up to you to work out which you believe.

Allow me to assist...

If it's not CO2 then what is it? Well, it [b]is[/b] CO2!

If it isn't permanent then how transitory is it? Well, depends. There are three ways that remove CO2 from the air: vegetation, absorption by the ocean and reaction with calcium carbonate and with weathered igneous rocks such as granite. That makes it too complicated to describe a simple half-life model such as is used for radioactivity. As the two first methods, vegetation and oceans will give a short-term reduction of excess CO2, the sequestration of CO2 into ocean sediments and rock is a geological time process and will take thousands of years. So the answer to your question is "not long and a long time". OK?

:)

by jck

I am truly impressed by you.

And if I were female, I'd be turned on right now :^0

(Thank God I'm not, right? Big female I'd be :^0 )

by jck

I'd have you and your Mum over and take ya to the pub for meat pie and pints any day!

BTW, I've given up on Irish women (for now, that Corr girl burned me :^0 )...do you know Kiera Knightley? :^0

by jdclyde

Which was kind of my point in my Bmerica the beautiful discussion. It wasn't a flag waving post, but a look at the beautiful things around us. I had also intentionally opened it up for others to bring their homelands in.

Look around us, appreciate it, and take care of it, damnit.

by jck

If warming the planet causes drought that causes this kinda thing:

http://delivery.gettyimages.com/xd/sfw20720058.mov?c=NewsMaker&d=901E5C9F0DCF15B231FF8340BF13523E39717F241685D351&k=2&v=1
or
http://www.networlddirectory.com/blogs/geography-blog.html
(first article)

How is that taking care of the beauty we have around us?

Just a simple question. I think it should be kept like this:

http://img5.travelblog.org/Photos/13426/213550/t/1621562-Oregon-Forest-near-Mt-Bachelor-0.jpg

by jdclyde

burden of proof.

The earth has been changing from the day God made it, and will continue to do so.

Ancient cities in the middle east have been swallowed whole by the desert, was that caused by man made global warming as well?

Was the grand canon (erosion/iceburgs) caused by man made global warming?

That climates have changed has never been proven to be caused by mans use of fossil fuels, but acid rain has.

Do we mandate that no one is allowed to own an air conditioner in their home?

Do we allow the government to install controlls in our furnace that limits how warm we can heat our homes?

Cutting car emissions by half would have what impact on the environment?

by jck

She is lovely and elegant and...well...I'll stop with that...don't want to get sap all over TR :^0

by jck

And for the ocean flooding? I have a solution.

We'll have Tampax design super absorbant ocean water baffles then ship them to the ice caps to be squeezed dry and the water re-frozen and re-grow the polar ice!!!

We're so smart! :^0

by Member 25348569

The range of hills is called the Seven Sisters.

The Milankovitch cycles show up as the bands of greyer rock where the sea got shallower (or deeper, damned if I can remember) on a 23,000 year cycle and the composition of the sediment changed ).

:D

by jck

Just beautiful. I'll have to go there sometime when my holiday schedule allows.

As for boats, I was looking at a 105 ft/31m boat that was 3 or 4 decks formerly used as a casino cruise boat that was on the sale for cheap in the Bahamas. I figure that plus $40k of work on the interior, and I could lease it as a luxury cruiser for wealthy types at about $50k a week.

Think I'll wait for the economy to pick back up a bit tho...wealthy types seem to be rather tight pursed now.

by jdclyde

First off, financially attacking US companies will have what impact on deforestation?

Financially attacking us, the citizens, will have what impact?

Where is the formula that says X deforest times Y increase in CO2 gives you Z temp increase over T years?

[b]X*Y=Z over T period[/b]

If we cut ALL auto emissions in the US by half, what percent of the total world levels is that? (of ALL CO2, not automotive CO2)
What would be the effect?
How many degrees difference would that make, and over how long of a time frame?

The science is not there, the proof is not there, and isolated examples of things done with unsupported percentages do not equal man made global warming.

Sounds like we should be at war with the people along the Amazon basin over their attack on the globe with their deforestation? They are a greater threat than the terrorists, right?

And over 30 years. Is that how long global warming has been going on? Can you show spikes in the earth temps that match up with this increasing percent of deforestation?

by jck

[i][b] Goes back to my other reply to you
burden of proof.[/b][/i]

Alright, let me see if I can give you proof and show you the light. Here we go.

[i] The earth has been changing from the day God made it, and will continue to do so.[/i]

Very true. Can't argue that.

[i] Ancient cities in the middle east have been swallowed whole by the desert, was that caused by man made global warming as well?[/i]

Nope.

But, the axial tilt that pretty much is responsible for the Sahara Desert having become the amazing wasteland it is was unpreventable.

Global warming (man-made, not naturally occurring levels) is preventable/controllable.

[i] Was the grand canon (erosion/iceburgs) caused by man made global warming?[/i]

Nope. But, the on-set of the ice age that formed the icebergs and the subsequent end to it that melted them happened over hundreds of thousands of years. Not 20 or 30 or 40 year cycles.

Proof:

[b]that study ancient climates of the earth have identified three distinct periods of glaciation: 1.) a period of glaciation around 600 million years ago about which little is known, 2.) glaciation that effected areas of Africa, India and Australia approximately 275 million years ago, and 3.) the most recent period, which began about 1.5 million years ago and ended (or at least subsided) within the last 15,000 years.[/b]

http://www.uvm.edu/whale/GlaciersHowFrequent.html

[i] That climates have changed has never been proven to be caused by mans use of fossil fuels, but acid rain has.[/i]

Not true.

Ice core samples taken from the earth's polar regions and deepest glaciers have proven that the variance of CO2 and other atmospheric gases are attributable to man because they are rising at a rate not seen in the records for over 400,000 years.

How do they know that?

When the ice forms, those gases and contaminents in the atmosphere are trapped inside of small bubbles and trapped in the layers of ice being formed over time. So, it's basically like stacking yearbooks and being able to dig down them and see who was in school way back when.

[i] Do we mandate that no one is allowed to own an air conditioner in their home?[/i]

No, but their right to live in a climate where air conditioning was not a necessity 25 years ago are now having to purchase one.

Want proof? I have 3 friends in the UK who already have gone out and bought portables because the temperature has gone over 32C/90F there (which is according to them "bullocks" (spelling, Neil?) and "not like it was when they were kids"). And according to them, it's only started being regularly and lastingly hot in the past several.

They've never had to own AC in their life to live "normally".

But you'll say..."well prove man caused it".

Go to the NOAA/NWS website and look at the graphs from the research they did. The temperature has, since industrialization started rose steadily over time faster than before it. And, that slope has increased in rate since the 1960s.

The graphs are there from the scientific research. If scientific proof and research isn't enough for you, then no one can ever prove it to you.

[i] Do we allow the government to install controlls in our furnace that limits how warm we can heat our homes?[/i]

No, but government mandates that power generation companies who give you the power
for your AC operate at a certain level of efficiency...so...why should you be exempt?

BTW, coal or wood would heat you house as well, and various types of coal burn cleaner than oil and have been cheaper in recent years.

[i] Cutting car emissions by half would have what impact on the environment?[/i]

According to EarthSky Communications, Inc. a car in the U.S. on average puts out 7,700 Kg of Co2 (16,940lbs) a year.

According to sources at the U.S. Department of Transpotation Statistical Records Office there are approximately 68.4 million (62 million registered vehicles in the U.S. at the current time and appox. 6.4 million unregistered functioning vechicles.) which accounts for cars and transports total.

So...68.4M times 16940 lbs/year/veh. avg. equals....

1,158,696,000,000 pounds per year.

So cutting that in half would mean we'd reduce the total CO2 put into the atmosphere from cars alone by....

579,348,000,000 pounds per year.

How much will that improve things? Well, it would slow down the build-up of it in the atmosphere.

But the next step in getting the atmosphere normalized to the way it should be would be also to get the governments (mainly Brasil) who oversee the areas of the Amazon and other large rainforests they are allowing to be depleted...to make ranchers and foresters responsible to replenish the land with plant life so that the natural, normal, planetary cycle can keep existing in balance.

Willing to drive to drive something vastly more fuel efficient even tho it doesn't go VROOOM as loud or go 0 to 60 as fast now?

You too can cut 8,000 lbs a year of CO2 out by doubling the fuel efficiency of your automobile.

Then go plant a tree :^0

by jck

If I find it for you, will you change your position?

If I go do the work, and find the conclusive research for you from some master's or doctoral research that shows you the impact of vehicle fuel economy does impact directly to CO2 contamination and that reducing it helps to stave what's happening...what will you do?

I can almost guarantee you...that in the past 20 years, some student of environmental science, climatology, or earth science has done the research for a dissertation.

It's just a matter of looking and reading it.

by maxwell edison

Your explanation is nothing but an exercise in starting at a desired end-conclusion, and then working backwards, arranging good-sounding words together to justify and explain said desired end-conclusion.

My [i]proof to the contrary[/i] is to refer you to someone who is exponentially more qualified than you. (Even more qualified than Al Gore!)

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,269033,00.html

By the way, in 2008, he predicted a 10 year period of global cooling.

Another interesting article about Dr. Gray (and surprisingly found in an extremely left-leaning Denver tabloid):

http://www.westword.com/2006-06-29/news/the-skeptic/full

by jdclyde

I drive a saturn. on the highway I average 38 mpg.

And giving an amount of estimated co2 doesn't tell me the RESULTS of that change.

It also doesn't tell me what percent of ALL co2 it is.

30%? 10%? .00001%?

if you got that change TODAY, how close would we be towards the normalization you are stating?

by jaqui

a week of record high temps, averaging 14C above the norm. and no air conditioners installed here makes it even worse.

We don't need the air conditioners usually, it don't get that hot.

by jck

i think he doesn't believe me about my friends in the UK getting freak weather.

talked to 2 of them last night.
last month ungodly temps.
this month unseasonable large amounts of rain.

my friend Kevin said "you don't see this during summers. might for part of a day, but it don't normally go on like this."

maybe north americans are more credible...good luck

by jardinier

This does not compare in scale with what Oz mentions is happening in Canada, but in my little corner of the world it is a permanent and irreversible disaster, in which commercial gain (and quite likely under-the-counter lucre to the relevant local government body) has spoilt forever a small natural gem.

There is a branch of Sydney Harbour called Middle Harbour. It winds its way, still at sea level, deep into a natural reserve.

When I was young, the upper section of Middle Harbour had clear, white sand and being tidal for most of its journey, it was possible to get stuck there at low tide if you had rowed upstream.

Near to the point where it changed from salt water to freshwater creeks, there was a marvellous swimming hole. We could dive into deep, clear water from a flat rock shelf.

And then some genius recognised that this sand had commercial value, and dredging commenced. The dredging continued for many years until all the sand had been collected.

What was left was deep water which became muddy after rain. The area was now accessible to sharks. Rowing boats were replaced with power boats whose wake washed more mud into the river.

Gone forever was this formerly beautiful recreational area, situated right in the middle of a surburban area.

Multiply my sad story several millionfold, and perhaps you will see what Oz is getting at.

by jck

I referred to basic scientific facts, science books, and the National Science Foundation.

I never said I researched or proved any of it...just that I'd show it to him too.

Evidently, you didn't read it.

I started with cutting down the trees more and more, and contributing increasing CO2...the action.

I gave the basic, factual scientific principals of chemistry and thermodynamics involved, as well as a logical conclusion to be drawn in the cause and effect of that action...the effect of the action.

And, I give what the result (according to principles and proven science) is if those happen...the conclusion.

That's a pretty straight-forward, direct, logical process of thinking and a proper way to illustrate factual effects from proven process interactions.

Of course, I suppose you want .75% CO2 atmospheric concentration and the melting of ice caps on the mountains around you as proof before you'll want to change...right?

Honestly, Max. I would like an answer of yes or no to this.

Does everything have to be in front of your face on a silver platter for you to realize that it is a foregone conclusion to the situation, or can you derive fact from decades of scientific research that show rising CO2 levels in our atmosphere will trap more heat radiation at the Earth's surface and in its ocean waters?

Honestly? What is your answer? Yes or no?

by jck

JD, let's go back to 3rd grade.

If jck has a car and it gets 22mpg and it emits 63 lbs per year per gallon of fuel burned.

And, the magical MPG Fairy shows up and waves her magic wand and jck's car magically now gets 44mpg.

if 22mpg = 63lb/yr/gallon
then 44 = 22x2
therefore doubling efficiency of the cars means the inverse to the output used
or: 63lbs/yr/2x1gallon
or: 31.5lbs/yr/gallon

It is simple math, and a simple answer to your question.

Sorry, but I tried like hell not to talk like I was talking down to you or anything.

But, you drove me to doing a stepwise explanation of how fuel efficiency vs. expulsed products from its combustion.

If you make something 2x more efficient, its product from fuel use is 1/2x.

Mathematical proof...QED

by jdclyde

Cap and trade is a scam, from beginning to end.

Instead of blocking all new nuke plants to replace older dirty coal plants why doesn't government support moving our energy to something clean? No, they do not want a solution, they want a revenue stream.

I don't hear about the UN or Security council demanding that the deforestation along the amazon stop now or else. If this is the problem you claim, and that is one of the catalysts, then it would be a bigger threat than pretending an SUV is going to raise the temp of the world.

Where is the war against planes, and forcing people to stop flying for pleasure? Planes pollute much more than autos do.

There is not an honest approach to this, to reach a solution, so how can it be taken seriously by anyone that will honestly look around them?

Add in, even if all this were true, the US is not the leading contributor in the first place, look to China and India, and as you said, the bastards in Africa.

You still haven't told me what percent of all the CO2 going into the atmosphere is caused by cars in the US.

by jdclyde

What percent of the total co2 going into the atmosphere NOW is caused by auto emissions in the US?

Why do you ignore this question?

by jck

[i]Cap and trade is a scam, from beginning to end.[/i] hm...ok...

[i]Instead of blocking all new nuke plants to replace older dirty coal plants why doesn't government support moving our energy to something clean? No, they do not want a solution, they want a revenue stream.[/i]

You were just bitching about ground contamination and other pollutants.

Now you're advocating nuclear? Have you heard of nuclear waste?

When it contaminates water, you can't purify it.

Nice.

[i]I don't hear about the UN or Security council demanding that the deforestation along the amazon stop now or else. If this is the problem you claim, and that is one of the catalysts, then it would be a bigger threat than pretending an SUV is going to raise the temp of the world.[/i]

Um...
Combustion of fossil fuels puts it in the atmosphere.
Plants reduce it.
I honestly don't think the world populous can increase the amount of plants on earth enough to compensate within a decade or two.

You do realize just how much 2,000,000 square miles of plant life is...right?

[i]Where is the war against planes, and forcing people to stop flying for pleasure? [/i]

It's the same place the effort in trying to prove to people like you how basic, 3rd-grade science works.

It's going nowhere, evidently.

[i]Planes pollute much more than autos do.[/i]

Hm. I guess 1 plane does pollute more than 1 car. You're so right.

However, take a McDonnell-Douglas MD-8x series jet, determine the thousands of gallons of fuel it burns to move 120+ people from Miami to Atlanta.

Then compare that to 2 charter buses that move that same 120+ people.

I guess you could argue 120+ cars, but then it becomes more difficult with knowing all the MPG of all cars.

Plus, who in their right mind organizes a trip from Miami to Atlanta in 120+ cars?

[i]There is not an honest approach to this, to reach a solution, so how can it be taken seriously by anyone that will honestly look around them?[/i]

Seemed pretty simple to me.

Guess I am giving too much credit to scientists who studied the basics of math, law of averages, proportional inverses, and chemical properties of gaseous compounds.

You're right. I'm stupid to believe idiots like Isaac Newton, Blaise Pascal, etc.

You're so aestute.

[i]Add in, even if all this were true, the US is not the leading contributor in the first place, look to China and India, and as you said, the bastards in Africa.[/i]

Actually, America still is. We still have the largest "carbon footprint" in the world of any country. China will pass us soon though as they are still modernizing.

India will be next after China.

[i]You still haven't told me what percent of all the CO2 going into the atmosphere is caused by cars in the US.[/i]

I went and found you papers, presented you factual information, etc. And, you believed none of it.

So:

If international experts from independent bodies can't prove it to you.

If principles of basic science can't prove it to you.

I'm sure as hell not gonna try anymore.

I give up trying to present scientific matter to someone who won't listen to logic.

I even tried giving you step by step math in another case that even 3rd graders learn. That probably won't work either.

So, keep thinking to yourself that things will fix themselves or that it's just a natural event.

Have a nice day.

by jck

no matter what numbers i come up with, you'll call them bull$hit or say the source is wrong or unreliable.

i hope you have 103F temps during the summers and get lightning storms that set your state on fire like is happening in Oregon.

then you'll whine for Obama to give you money cause "it's the right thing to do".

like I said in the other post, i am done trying to present facts to you to meet your needs.

if you want an education on the greenhouse effect of CO2, total emissions of US cars vs the world total...you can get off your butt and do it yourself.

i'm done trying to educate those unwilling to learn or accept basic scientifically-proven facts, processes and effects.

by Member 25348569

Around one third of CO2 emissions, 2GT per annum or so for the US, can be attributed to "Transport" so that includes commercial road, private road, rail and air.

What is interesting is that over the last thirty years, the increase in CO2 output has EXACTLY tracked the increase in total miles travelled. This means that every increase in automobile and commercial vehicle efficiency that has been invented in that time has been swallowed up in larger engines.

In the US, that is.

:)

by jck

Read this:

http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/ieo/highlights.html

As of 2006, liquid fossil fuel sources are 36% of all fuel sources PERIOD.

If it's miniscule, then send me 36% of your paycheck every month.

I rest my case. If you don't believe this page, then go tell your government they're liars.

Now go read something beside leftist or right-wing blathering and educate yourself rather than believing the sensational hype you think is gospel.

by jck

People think I am lying here usually when I tell them of my friends in the UK having Volkswagens that get 45-54 miles per gallon.

Most think it's a load of bull.

Then I send them to my friend and former co-worker Bob, who worked in Herefordshire for about a decade.

by maxwell edison

It's not that anyone is suggesting the MM GW/CC zealots treat their cause as a replacement or alternative to organized religion, but rather they approach it in the same way.

They pay homage to their god, the environment.

They pray at the altar of environmentalism.

They have their prophets of doom and gloom in the likes of Al Gore, James Hansen, and their ilk.

They listen to their prophets.

They follow with blind faith, with no proof necessary.

They have their demons in oil and coal, and especially the [i]dastardly[/i] devils who maintain those industries (as well as others).

They have their commandments (ten or otherwise): Thou shalt not drive an SUV; thou shalt not use incandescent light bulbs; thou shalt take public transportation; thou shalt not...... (how many [i]commandments[/i] could be identified?)

They attempt to shame the guilty for committing their sins and breaking the commandments. (Some would even have them stoned to death!)

They have their hierarchy to create, publish, and enforce their doctrine in government and radical environmental laws.

They have their bibles: Earth in the Balance, An Inconvenient Truth, et al.

They view dissenters with disdain: the heathen non-believers - the [i]atheists[/i].

I could go on.......