Discussion Locked

Online Discount Stock Brokers

0 helpful
30 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

First I'd like to say I hope everyone has had a safe holiday so far and Happy New Year to everyone!

It's been an interesting and stressful last few days especially Christmas (nothing like finding out your brother is in jail on Christmas eve night).. any way that isn't the point of this discussion :-)

Over the last couple of months I've done some research on Online Discount Stock Brokers (Zecco, Sharebuilder, Scottrade, Firsttrade, TradeKing, etc...) - as I thought I might dabble a tad outside hubby's 401k and my solo 401k. TR doesn't have an investment club I don't know about does it? If not might be interesting to start one :-)

Anyway, does anyone use an online stock broker? If so which one? What do you like about it? not like about it? What ones have you tried and didn't like? Why didn't you like it?

I'm basically trying to get a better grasp of what might be best for my little dabbling.

-Tammy :-)

30 replies

by santeewelding

Even the derivatives, and billion-dollar credit default swaps, but I don't have a pot to piss in. Sorry.

by Tammy.Cavadias

put things in the bucket..and when I look - its gone - it's not only old and rusty with a hole but it must be a magicians bucket since the darn thing empties quicker than I can blink!

-Tammy :-)

Edited to fix blick?? what is a blick??

by rob miners

help you out with the online brokers. I haven't had any dealings online but I do check my stock online. Just to see how much they have dropped. ;)

by rob miners

I did follow her instructions.

There's a hole in the bucket,
Dear Liza, dear Liza
There's a hole in the bucket,
Dear Liza, there's a hole.

Then fix it, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, dear Jacky
Then fix it, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, fix it.

With what shall I fix it,
Dear Liza, dear Liza?
With what shall I fix it,
Dear Liza, with what?

With a straw, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, dear Jacky
With a straw, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, with a straw.

But the straw is too long,
Dear Liza, dear Liza
But the straw is too long,
Dear Liza, too long

Then cut it, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, dear Jacky
Then cut it, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, cut it.

With what shall I cut it,
Dear Liza, dear Liza?
With what shall I cut it,
Dear Liza, with what?

With an axe, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, dear Jacky
With an axe, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, an axe.

The axe is too dull,
Dear Liza, dear Liza
The axe is too dull,
Dear Liza, too dull

Then sharpen it, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, dear Jacky
Then sharpen it, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, sharpen it.

With what shall I sharpen it,
Dear Liza, dear Liza?
With what shall I sharpen it,
Dear Liza, with what?

With a stone, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, dear Jacky
With a stone, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, a stone.

The stone is too dry,
Dear Liza, dear Liza
The stone is too dry,
Dear Liza, too dry

Then wet it, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, dear Jacky
Then wet it, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, wet it.

With what shall I wet it,
Dear Liza, dear Liza?
With what shall I wet it,
Dear Liza, with what?

With water, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, dear Jacky
With water, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, with water.

How shall I get it,
Dear Liza, dear Liza,
How shall I get it,
Dear Liza, how shall I?

In the bucket, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, dear Jacky
In the bucket, dear Jacky,
Dear Jacky, in the bucket.

There's a hole in the bucket.

by Tammy.Cavadias

Really there is no text in this message, it fell out of the hole in the bucket and the spammer ran away with it ;)

-Tammy :-)

by jaqui

after the whole market fell earlier this year, you STILL think it's a good idea to risk your money there? ~blink~

Actually, I have never even looked at investing on the market. I just don't like the idea of rumours destroying the value of a company that easily.

by hal 9000

Tammy is a Blondie. What more could you expect? :^0

The reality however is that very few realize just how dangerous the Stock Market actually is and how easy to manipulate the market for the Big Boys advantage. Or more importantly just how often it actually happens. :0

Col

by jaqui

you mean something like chatting about how MS is literally bleeding financially near a bunch of brokers one evening? ]:)

that type of manipulation?

stuff that would drive a company into bankruptcy within weeks?

by hal 9000

The most important one is that when you purchase On Line the Broker doesn't have to supply any information about the stock. There is no Due Diligence or warnings about some potential problems that may arise latter.

One example here recently was a Company who sold stock from their Prospectus in 3 Parts over a 3 year period. I will not mention their name but they where selling their Shares for $3.00 with a first payment of a $1.00 and in 12 months time another payment of a $1.00 and then on the second year at the 24 Month Time Frame the Finial $1.00 payment had to be made.

These stocks dropped to the 5 cent mark with a lot of Small Investors snapped them up but without the knowledge that there was a remaining 2/3 of the Face Value to pay. The upshot was that after investing 5K for these shares they had to find in excess of a Million $ by January to meat the Second Payment with the same amount of money being required 12 Months latter. Of course if they Default the Company has the right to revoke their Shares but also has the right to take em to the cleaners in the process. So they are effectively Bankrupt as they are unable to sell their Shares. Once they went mad and cried tot he Media there where no takers for these shares till after the next Payment to the company which they are now part of.

If they had of purchased these shares through a Normal Broker and paid the fees the Broker would have been responsible to tell them the Real Facts of these shares but as they purchased these On Line they have no one to blame but themselves.

Basically if you deal through a On Line Broker you do it at your Own Risk and you need to be really careful as there are many traps for the unwary and no Due Diligence to protect you from for want of a better term your own stupidity.

To be quite honest it's better going tot he local Casino and blowing your money there as you can only spend what you have or can get credit for. Not even the Worst Casino will run you to Bankruptcy and beyond as they want to get their money within a short time. The Stock Market doesn't have these Scruples manly because those who sell things are not the owners of the company and once they have their money they run like hell never to be seen again and leave the unwary investor where they really belong Broke and penniless and Bankrupt with no hope of recovery within the next decade.

Just something to keep in mind as the Stock Market is the Ultimate Gambling Institution that very rarely pays off. The Local Mafia Owned Casino offers better Odds and is really more helpful. :)

Col

by alisak20009

The ones I mentioned above though have all been recommended from popular resources that I do trust (Klinger, Forbes, Money, Smart Money, etc...) - A couple actual have local offices in my area (Scottrade for example)

So little money and so little time :D

-Tammy :-)

by hal 9000

All of these places put out a list of Under-performing Shares and it is the Mom & Pop Investors who predominately read these and act upon them. Unfortunately because they are buying On Line from say a Bank the Bank is not responsible for what they fail to put into their Listings so while the shares may currently be Under-performing there is a reason for this which may not be quite so easy to find out about.

Like try getting information out of a company about their shares when you don't own any. Of course a Broker would tell you what is involved because if they didn't it's their Financial Ass on the Line. When you buy On Line in AU there are no safeguards just as in the USA. Doesn't matter how solid a Brokerage Firm may be if they stand a chance of making bucket loads of moo la out of a deal without any comeback you had better believe that they will do everything possible to make as much as they possibly can. They are not the slightest bit concerned about any damage that they may do as long as they get paid their Commissions and Bonuses they are happy and they see the small Mom & Pop Investors as more [b]Grist for the Mill[/b] and they will never run out of the Gullible People to Fleece. While they may bankrupt this lot there will be others to take money from. :)

Oh also about only dealing with Reputable firms would you like me to make a list of the Reputable Firms that have been convicted of helping to defraud people on the Stock Market. Most are still trading and are considered as Reputable still. :D

Even if you get a Reputable Adviser who has your best interests at heart and not what goes into their pockets what is [b]Good Advice[/b] can still Bankrupt you quite easily. For instance those Shares that only have been paid for at 1/3 of their Value are a Good Investment and an even better investment for those who bought them at 1/3 their Face Value sold them for very little till after the remaining 2/3 gets paid and then most will buy them back under the $3.00 Face Value with a total outlay of under $2.00 per share which a year latter will have a Value of $3.00 per share. Doesn't matter how you look at things they are a Good Buy provided you are not the one paying those $2.00 per share over a 2 year period.

When eventually the Government Contract starts those shares will be worth a lot more than their Face Value but for those first 5 years they are just easy money for the Day Traders in the mean time. :D

Unfortunately that is how the Stock market works.

OH I should add using Reputable ad Stock Broker i the same sentence isn't only an Oxymoron it's plain stupidity. To be a successful Stock Broker you have to be a [b]Greedy Self Serving Bastard[/b] if you are not then you never get anywhere to begin with. As with all things the Golden Rule must be Followed but here it's not Do Unto Others as you would have them do unto you it is [b]Don't get Caught with your pants down.[/b]

Col

by charliespencer

It would be useful to know how your existing 401k's are invested. Do you manage them yourselves or does a third-party handle it for you?

Tespectfully, it would be helpful to know how long until you hope to retire.

Let us know how diversified your 401k's are. Do both of you invest in the same single stock? Is each account spread between a variety of individual stocks, mutual funds, and bonds?

Are either of your 401k's a Roth program?

The reason I ask all these questions is you may not be taking advantage of the opportunities in your existing 401K programs. If your primary goal is funding your retirement, investing in those offers tax advantages over other forms.

Google for investing clubs in the area.

by ontheropes

Kiplingers.com for another. There's probably an "Investing for Dummys" book out there too.

If you don't KNOW what you're doing you stand to lose all of your money, everything you intend to dabble with.

I've got a chunk of change I could invest but I'd much rather keep it in my savings account than risk it on something I don't know everything about. At the end of the day I still have my money.

by sleepin'dawg

an investment, any investment, stay the hell away from it. That's one of the main reasons the markets are in turmoil at the moment. [i][b]Not enough people understood or understand about derivatives and too many ignorant people invested in them. The schit is still flying and will keep flying for a while, just because of that.[/i][/b]

There are Dummies books on Investing and they're pretty good for anyone starting out with not enough information on how to get started.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

investments and investing.

If you are going to invest on line, there are a few caveats to be aware of.

The super discounts that these guys offer is only meant for their clientelle that maintains large balances with them.

Most of them charge fees for keeping 401Ks, Roths, etc.; make sure you have their fee structure before you entrust them with [i][b][u]anything[/i][/b][/u] or you could be in for a bit of a shock. Read the fine print, carefully.

Another thing to be aware of; not all brokers have a seat on the exchange(s). This isn't too serious unless you are dealing in time sensitive areas and a broker that has to deal through another broker may not be able to fill your order, either a sell or a buy, within the appropriate time frame. Make sure the broker you choose has a seat on the board.

Online brokers will offer some advice for free but like anything else, you have to ask, if their advice is any good why are they brokers and not using the information to get rich themselves.

Always demand confirmation of orders received imediately or within an hour of sending and filled orders as soon as they are filled.

Do not trust [i][b][u]any[/i][/b][/u] broker to maintain trailing stop loss orders.

Invest in companies with long term value that have DRIPs (Dividend ReInvestment Plans). these are ideal investment vehicles for retirement accounts.

There's a lot more but thats enough for you to get started thinking about.

Good Luck.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by shellbot

Are you thinking that stocks are so low right now that that extra couple of hundred you've got can be used to play around with it? Or are you looking at serious money?
If serious money, buy books and look online and learn all you can.

If yer looking to mess around with a few bucks, then what the h?ll. I'm thinking of doing it myself. Not trying to say I've lots of money I can lose like, but a couple hundred...and see what happens. I can afford to lose a couple hundred and not starve.

I looked into it a bit last year, but never went anywhere with it..a couple points i did pick up on though:

1. Most charge a transaction fee per buy/sell. Its a minimum fee or certain percentage. For example, the one place it was min 20 fee per trans, or 5% (whichever was the higher). So if ye were to buy a bacth of super cheap shares, you'd be getting hit with 20 bucks for the pleasure.
now this charge is charged when you buy and sell..so have to factor that in to the price of the shares. so buy 10 shares for oh 50, sell for 70..you've lost 20 bucks!!!!!!

2. They seem to have a min transaction amount..like can't go in and say buy 20 shares..have to be done in units of some certain amount.

If your looking at doing this with a spare few bucks, go ahead..and have fun, but treat it as gambling..never use money you can't afford to lose.
If yer looking at it as a way to make money, research for a few months...

I'm maybe gonna look at dabbling this year..with some stock so low..the temptation is too much to resist

by hal 9000

It's way too good a deal to pass up.

The bottom line it really is not good at all. But you are the one paying those others to loose money. Have you ever noticed any Bankrupt Brokers?

As I said above the Stock Market is nothing more than the Most Advanced Form of Gambling ever conceived. The only way I want to be involved is to be the one being paid to do the things that others want done.

But I'm way to Honest to be either a Stock Broker or a Politician so looks like I'll continue to dip out on the [b]Big Bucks.[/b] :(

Col

by shellbot

Its not such the big bad monster you thinnk it is, if approached with care.

Now, just to clarify "brokers"..I'm not talking about brokers as in people one rings up and yells "buy buy buy"... online stuff..for example, my bank has online share dealing. You administer everything, you decide what to buy/sell..they charge a fee for doing the transaction. Same way as they charge for a normal bank account. Way I see it, saves me the trip to the stock exchange to make my small share purchase..a fair enough trade off.

Now..most people think of using online trading for day trading..that is pure gambling..and dangerous..
What I'm talking about it looking at some shares..checking thier performance and taking a chance that if I buy them now at $1.20 a share, in 5-10 years they might be worth $15.00 a share..probably not, but you know what I mean. And if they don't ..well..someone like me would have only spent about 200 on them anyways..so over 5 years..whats 200 bucks..i spend more on a friday night out in dublin..so what the heck.

I'm the furthest thing from a gambler one could be. I buy the odd lotto ticket just in case and if Cheltenham falls on St Patricks day, i bet on the horses.. :)
So, I have no worries that I'd get sucked into day trading..

by Tammy.Cavadias

not sure how my name got swapped... but I was looking at 500.. but after reading what everyone has to say - I went with a CD - though I still may dabble some time in the future

-Tammy :-)

by hal 9000

The Big Bank here who shall remain Nameless but is sometimes called something about a Commonwealth is the main offender in the listed transactions above where some Mum & Pop Traders bought 5K worth of Shares that where severely undervalued and now find out that they have a $1,000,000.00 Bill due the end of this month and the same again next year. The Idiot thing is that eventually money will be made from those shares but those who brought them at a cent on the $ of their face Value will be Long Bankrupt.

Because the On Line Traders are not required to offer any Due Diligence they are not responsible for the Notices that they provide for anyone silly enough to believe the Banks Recommended Stocks.

As you quite rightly say they get paid on the Transaction so they don't give a RAT's about what happens after the event they have got their money and as they say in the Brokerage Firms [b]There's a Sucker Born every Second.[/b] There they are not talking about the big Institutional Investors but the Mum & Pop Investors who are out to make some money on a [b]Sure Thing[/b] as if it actually existed.

When you see places like Bearings go belly up because of 1 Share Trader who only had limited money to play with one just has to sit back and take notice of the Professionals going down in such a big way. :p

If you treat is as a Gambling Debt that may be worth something in a few years time that's OK but unfortunately many do not they constantly scan the share prices to see how much they have made or lost this 30 minute period/Day or whatever.

Do you really think that the current Stock Market Condition is the Result of the Big Investors getting jittery? If you look at the start of any crash it is the Small Mum & Pop Investors throwing in the towel that has started the crash.

You are however correct it's only your fault when things go wrong but so many complain that they didn't know any better when they get caught with their pants down around their ankles. I have yet to hear anyone say It's My Fault they always find someone else to blame. :D

Could be because they don't accept that they are Idiots for playing the Stock Market to begin with. We have all heard of Problem Gamblers but we are yet to hear of Problem Stock Traders not because they don't exist but because there is way too much money involved to admit that they exist and many more important people & Governments as well. I had to wait at a broken down car a few years ago and while I was there one of the places I was parked outside of I could hear the Radio on with the Stock Reports and a Violent Argument about some Shares that had been bought that week/month or whatever going down in price. She was screaming her head off about how much money they had lost that hour let alone that week or whatever. It was educational if nothing else. :D

One of my brothers is currently complaining that he is now broke as he has lost 50% of his money in 2008 and he considerer's that as the worst year of his life. I will not make any mention of how much I have lost on the Stock Market but I do have some lovely Wall Paper 750,000 worthless shares in a oil company that is still trading sitting on masses of Oil Reserves and that was long before 2008 happened. :0

Some silly Traders can not understand why I [b]Will Not[/b] spend any more money on Stocks not to make mention of Futures which are the really dangerous things and are always the reason why there are Booms & Busts. Stocks are mealy Dangerous Futures are Completely Dangerous and responsible for everything to goes wrong on the Markets.
That Oil Company was one of the Blue Chip ones as well something like Big Blue so they where never a risk supposedly. If I was to sell now the Brokers Fees would cost more than what I got for the complete sale at the Peek of the recent Oil Boom. :^0

Now who wants to buy a Bridge it's had little use only used by a little old lady to go to church on Sunday Honest. She wasn't allowed to come back over that bridge because it wore it the wrong way and it's in a Convenient Location that all the Local Governments are attempting to buy so that they can use the bridge for nothing. :^0

Yep I still buy Stocks but not for anything like Investments to me they are nothing more than a [b]Tax Deduction.[/b] Treated that way they are OK but forget about getting any return on the money wasted. I'm just keeping the Tax Mans hand lightly in my pocket instead of buried in all the way. :)

Perhaps you would like a Tip on the Winner of the Grand National? It's a [b]Sure Thing[/b] Honest. :D

Col

by Tammy.Cavadias

I'm not even gonna try to explain as I'm clueless

After all that I decided to go with a CD with a 5% interest rate (at least I'll know exactly what my return will be)

-Tammy :-)

by Tammy.Cavadias

It's with USAA

I noticed a lot of banks/credit unions have started to increase their long term CD rates, must be their way of raising money

-Tammy :-)

This discussion is closed to new replies.