My view is to monitor Task Manger Commit Charge. What you are looking for is to compare the Peak with Limit.
In my opinion if the Peak approaches the limit then increase the pagefile. If it never gets near then you could even consider reducing thepagefile. Another technique would be to create a log with Performance Monitor.
If you have multiple disks then performance improves if you have a pagefile on each.
The only disadvange in creating a 4GB pagefile would be the system overhead in maintaining it.
Pagefile = Ram +2mb means that if you do get a Blue screen of death stop message, you can decipher it with Dumpexam.