.
All too many candidates try to play all sides of the issues, and when that becomes too much of an obvious contradiction they try to avoid the issue altogether. Candidates run the risk of being labeled as either anti-job or anti-trade, so they try to be both. Is a candidate in favor of globalization, or does he or she prefer to protect the American worker and be more of an isolationist? Is a candidate in favor of creating more American jobs, or would he or she prefer to help American business become more profitable? When a candidate takes a stand one way or the other, he or she runs the risk of polarizing a large segment of the voting public, something none of them wants to do. And it is rare indeed to find a candidate who can skillfully and honestly find an acceptable middle-ground or convince the constituency that their thinking is flawed. After all, how could a candidate possibly convince an out of work IT professional that IT offshoring is really a good thing in the long run? (Not that I'm suggesting it is or it isn't.) To make matters worse, most of the political banter we hear from many of them is no more than questionable rhetoric intended to mislead at best, or deceive at worst.
Standing up for one's principles, and just letting the chips fall where they may, is a virtue that is found in all too few politicians. That's not to say that ALL politicians fit this description, but those who are more principled in their stance are often labeled as extremists. That could include extremists on either the left or the right, by the way, although most extremist charges are, in my opinion, levied by those on the left targeting others on the right. Clarence Thomas, Ronald Reagan, Newt Gingrich, Tom DeLay, and other Republicans, for example, are among those who have been demonized simply because they take a principled stand. How many Democrats have been demonized in such a way? Was (and is) Ruth Bader Ginsburg demonized the way Clarence Thomas was (and is)? No, absolutely not. Both are extremely principled justices, but the difference is that one leans towards the left while the other leans towards the right. Are representatives Nancy Pelosi, Barney Frank, Major Owens, David Bonior, Maxine Waters or John Conyers demonized the way Tom DeLay is now or how Newt Gingrich was then? No, absolutely not, even though all are servants of their convictions, the only difference being the direction of those convictions.
I can't help but suggest that, in my humble (or not so humble) opinion, Republicans, in general, are more prone to such attacks for taking a principled stand and being labeled as an extremist, and Democrats are more prone to posturing themselves on both sides of an issue. I don't mean this as a slam, but rather I see it as almost a function of the way the Democrat party has progressed over the years. The Democrat party has had a history of pandering to particular groups, and oftentimes contradictions are inevitable. For example, the Democrats see themselves as "pro-choice", but the freedom to choose doesn't apply if a mother wants to choose a different school, by way of school vouchers, for the child she chooses to have. In the quest to attain and maintain their power, Democrats have created an umbrella so big and so diverse that contradictions are inevitable. But it doesn't have to be that way if a person (especially the voter) focuses on the bigger picture. For example, the Democrat party is considered, as a rule, the party of the worker and labor unions, but that is often seen as anti-business. And we all know that Democrats as well as Republicans want to see American business thrive, at least I hope we do. On the other side of the same coin, Republicans are considered, as a rule, the party of big business, and this is often seen as anti-worker. But we all know that Republicans as well as Democrats want to see the average worker thrive, at least I hope we do.
But I digress, even though it's all related. Back to the candidates and their stand on IT issues.
I think the biggest problem is the voter himself. I'm going to go out on a limb here, and suggest that many people in the IT industry want it both ways. (This is not just the IT industry, by the way, but this could apply to any industry.) On one hand, most IT professionals will admit that ours is a shrinking globe, especially with the advent of technology itself, and that free and open trade and globalization is inevitable, perhaps even preferable. But on the other hand, many are demanding that their American jobs be protected against such global change. Which way do we want it? Okay, the reality is that companies are forced to look for ways to become more profitable. Why is that, and therefore what? "Big-business" is just being greedy, one might argue. Oh really? Is it really just "big-business" being greedy, or do many of us have our own financial interest at stake here as well? Take a look at your company's retirement plan or your own 401(k) plan. Microsoft, Intel, and other technology "big-business" is a big part of that plan. If the company's profits decline, guess what happens to the value of your retirement plan? What happens to the country's overall financial stability, and what "domino effect" will result when those profits decline? Okay, the reality is that more IT jobs are going overseas. Why is that, and therefore what? Do we therefore cry foul and demand that our politicians protect us? Or do we therefore realize that we, as Americans, have to find ways to be better, we have to be more productive, we have to be more competitive, and we have to do it all at a lower cost?
Taxes and the Internet is another big issue. On one hand, no one wants their Internet access taxed. But on the other hand many people expect more and more government services to provide for their basic needs, services all funded by taxes. On one hand, no one wants taxes levied on their Internet transactions, but on the other hand we might all see a need to level the playing field so that the established brick and mortar businesses in out local communities can continue to thrive and employ our neighbors.
How about standing on the principle of your convictions, and just let the chips fall where they may. If the American voter wasn't so fickle, and if the American voter quit trying to sell his or her vote to the highest bidder, perhaps the candidates themselves wouldn't have to walk such a tight-rope. Put another way, who's going to be the first to stand up for the convictions of their principle, the candidate of the voter? The answer makes a strong argument for the underlying principle of self-reliance. And that just scares the heck out of too many people.