Discussion Locked

Overtake former IT Boss' Job with a Proposal

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have been taking a graduate course in IT Management and it has broadened the way I view IT and the management of IT.

I have been working on a new "IT Management Proposal" that I want to submit to the Managing Director of the company I used to work for.

The content of the proposal includes:
Improve company efficiency
Improve project management procedure
Restructure of the IT department

My intention is to replace the former IT manager I used to work for.

My question are:
How to submit the proposal to the M.D.?
What other areas I should include in my proposal?
How should I conclude my proposal to maximize the chance of a personal interview with the M.D. ?

6 replies

by bfilmfan

If you think that your director will be receptive, then make the proposal. The worst they can say is thank you, but no.

by dc_guy

Communication skills are the most important talent of a manager, since most of his or her job duties involve communicating with other people.

I suggest that you expend a little effort learning more about proper business writing. Your posting is full of errors. Not bonehead errors in spelling, but errors nonetheless:

"really" -- why does this word need quotation marks?

broaden -- should be "broadened"

management of IT -- should be "the management of IT"

Restructuring of -- a breakdown in parallel construction. The previous two verbs are infinitives but this one is a gerund. Change it to "restructure."

replace/overtake -- colloquial composition. Find a word that means what you want instead of stuffing two words together that don't quite express your idea individually. Use your thesaurus more often.

How to approach... what other area -- breakdown in parallel construction again. One question is a sentence fragment but the other is a complete clause.

area -- this should be "areas."

Believe me, we managers notice this stuff. Not everyone looks for it consciously the way I do (I teach business writing so it comes naturally) but it slows us down when we read your writing. No manager wants to have to spend five minutes understanding a report that should only take two.

Something like this can easily make the difference between getting the interview you want and just getting a polite "thank you."

Good luck!

by billyboys

Thanks for correcting the grammar. I have corrected the grammar. How does it look now?

It is very true that business writing is very important in the workplace.

I will probably have to get somebody to proofread the proposal before I submit it.

Cheers.

by clindell

Don't let the managing director have your notes or give him a copy to follow with you as you read. The Managing Director could just as easily take the ideas and implement them through the current manager and there goes your hard work.

by billyboys

Well, I guess it is worth a try since I have nothing to lose other than time.

Any other ideas on how to make the proposal attractive? I know that M.D's like proposals that can generate more revenue or reduce cost.

I know full well that negativity should be avoided in the proposal. I am not going to bash the IT manager in the proposal.
I will focus on areas that can help the company gain bigger market share through the use of IT.

I can't help but to bash the IT manager a bit here.

The whole IT department consists of about 15 people. The department is divided into 3 sub-divisions.

The IT manager is the old fashion type that believes in arriving early and leaving late. I don't believe that is the way to manage professional IT staff. Staff performance should not be judged on the number of hours they put in but rather on the timeliness and quality of their work.

The manager does not know how to prioritize projects. He seems to take on all projects without evaluating the needs and ROI.

He has zero project management skill but likes to lead software development projects. He has no concept of defining measurable system requirements. The project he managed were always delivered late because he just never managed and documented the user expectation and requirement properly. At the end of the day, it is the software programmers that get the blame when projects were delivered late.

He is hiring very green staff and expect them to perform and meet deadline by putting in extra hours everyday. There are only 3 experienced staff in the department. So, the experienced ones have to act as mentors to help the juniors. But the problem is when the seniors spend time with the juniors, he would show his long face.

The manager does not encourage open communication. He does not allow the staff to discuss their work among peers.

The manager does not allow his staff to attend any training even those that would not cost the department or the company any money.

Instead of complimenting the staff after project completion (putting in 3 hours extra everyday for 3 months), he would critize the staff for the lack of committment.

Everybody in the department but himself is underpaid by 20% to 40% of the market rate. That's why 3 of the senior staff left the company recently. I bet all the staff will move on if the company does not start paying market rates.

His mood swing is so unpredictable that sometimes I suspect he is experiencing menopause.

by clindell

I would say you have reasonable thoughts but make sure you leave out any comparison to the current mgr, no negativity. Let the focus be on what and how you can better the department, it should be self explanatory in comparing your ideas to the standard process' and you need to be accountable for your plan, do you have milestones?

Do be aware that the big picture may not be so willing to increase payroll to increase retention if the current mgr gets things done, in the corporate world we are really all just pawns.

This discussion is closed to new replies.