Discussion Locked

People who call themselves "consultants" and ask stupid questions

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I'm just here ranting about what I'm seeing lately as stupid questions being asked by new members claiming they are "IT Consultants" or "IT Managers". Now I can understand if they're entry level and just starting out in the field, but I seriously take offense at someone claiming to be an "IT Consultant" or "IT Dept Manager" and asking stupid questions like how to promote a member server to a domain controller, or how to allow multiple PC's to share a single ISP connection. Maybe I am taking this all too personally, but I am insulted by those calling themselves "consultants" who don't know the basic things that should be known because it tarnishes the overall image of what consultants are. I pride myself in my knowledge, experience, and being able to call myself a consultant, but when I see stupid questions posted by so called "Consultants" such as "How do I promote a Windows server to a DC", it really insults my intelligence. I'm not looking to start a flaming thread, but this is starting to really irritate me as a professional. Any thoughts or comments?

23 replies

by cg it

just kidding.

I've had these exact same thoughts as well but figured this site is supposed to be for IT professionals, so if there are forum trolls who want to jerk peoples chains, I'm not gonna be one of them. I'll just ignor the post.

by maniacman

I don't know if these new members are falsely representing their titles or such, but it is insulting to see such questions asked by people who claim to be consultants or IT Dept Managers, assuming they are. And I'm told on interviews that I am not technical enough? Perhaps I'm being interviewed by the same nimrods who post these dumb questions here, claiming to be "IT Dept Managers" and my knowledge threatens their positions and authority.

by cg it

last I looked you had like 10... your moving fast....

but yeah I think that those who call themselves consultants or IT Dept Managers and ask basic knowledge questions are just forum trolls.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

from a supposed IT Consultant, I think Bah, humbug! I also think, I wonder who they think they are fooling...

Now, when I ask a goofy question it's a different matter! :)
Then again, all the typos I edit belies the notion that I'm a teacher...

by roger99a

There are none. Anybody that can print or buy a business card can be a consultant.

by bizzo

Although I do think that the new people here think that if they have their title as consultant or manager they think that their questions will be answered quicker. We all know that doesn't happen.

Also, some people think that a title is just a title and that it doesn't actually mean anything. You've worked hard, you've got your certifications, you know what you know and you've earned the title "IT Consultant", so obviously it means something to you, because you actually know what the title means.

Outside of work I tend to call myself an IT Consultant simply because our job titles here mean nothing outside of work, but everyone know that IT Consultant means "computers and stuff" (that annoys me, when I say I'm and IT Consultant, they reply with "Oh, you mean you're into computers and stuff?"), so maybe that works the other way around also, if you're "into computers and stuff" you can call yourself an IT Consultant! My official role is Technical Specialist, and people do look blankly at me when I tell them that.

Maybe on here we could change the job role based on the number of Thumbs Up you have?

0-5 thumbs: Noob!
5-20 thumbs: 1st Line Support
20-50 thumbs: Technical Specialist
...
100+: Consultant etc...

Or one based on the number of discussion posts you made this week.

0-5: Noob!
5-20: Helper
20-50: Not working much
...
100+: Active here, but needs to knuckle down at work!

:-)

I've not changed my job role here since I joined many years ago. Maybe I'm due for a promotion!!!

by hal 9000

Officially I call myself the [b]Alleged Boss & Official Scape Goat[/b] works out well on all Professional Sites that I'm involved with and confuses the hell out of most of the M$ workers who ring me up. :D

Though to be honest the Technical Types ask if they can use the same Job Description. :p

[b]Perhaps it's time that we all give Beth a Shout and get the titles changed. Now who wants to be the first to E-Mail Beth?[/b] :^0

Col

by joer

The term or title consultant could mean anything from A to Z. I've hired a consultant before who was an expert on certain software applications, and probably wasn't very well versed in networking, but most likely had at least some working knowledge of such things.

?By the way, Mr. Application Software Consultant,? one might ask, ?before you leave, can you help us upgrade one of our servers? Do you know anything about that??

?That's not exactly my cup of tea,? this consultant might answer, ?but let me see what I can find out on that great TechRepublic Web site, and perhaps we can figure out how to do it.?

The job titles in the TR profiles are limited, to say the least. At best, it?s no more than a category with any number of subsets. A car?s not a truck, and a truck?s not a car, but both are vehicles. And a consultant is kind of like an engineer. It might mean one thing to you, but it means another thing to somebody else. And consider how the IT industry hijacked the title architect - Frank Lloyd Wright and Bill Gates both architects.

As far as IT Department Manager, it might be the closest thing that TR has to [i]the computer guy everybody else relies on because he seems to be the most computer savvy, but he?s still just one of the users[/i]. Perhaps TR should include that job title in their list of possibilities. No, on second thought, that's too long.

by roger99a

You made me remember back to the mid 90's I ran across an AS400 guy trying to install a modem in a workstation. He looked like a monkey solving a math problem. I was kind enough to set the jumpers for him.

Managers on the other hand, I wouldn't expect most of them to know how to promote a DC. It's just not their job to know the nuts and bolts of it.

by neil higgins

that a cleaner,can call themselves a "floor manager".Cleaners are very important by the way.Without them,my office would resemble a tip.But I digress.Maybe if the profile options could include,I have not a clue,but I have just consulted a manual from 1999,we might get somewhere.However,there ARE a lot of very experianced posters here on TR,who are brilliant when giving answers.As always,it is only a few who write foolish things.

by the scummy one

You dont think for a moment that he actually got all of those through the proper channels do you???

nah, he hacked TR a few times and overnight gained 100 thumbs up's, every week he went back and did it again until they found out about the exploit being used. I think it was Daveo who turned him in after Daveo hacked Hals account. :^0 :^0

by hal 9000

:D :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0

He just continued posting silly questions like 1234 and when I answered 42 he gave me the Points Er Thumbs. :x

Actually I had to have one removed because I messed up and some one who shall remain nameless gave me another one for stating the obvious to someone who couldn't read.

Yes I forget to change the Account but that one incident taught me to [b]Take Notice[/b] of what I was posting where. :D

Now who wants a freezer full of Thumbs? :8}

The Evil Sod sent me real thumbs not anything else. :_|

Now back to asking silly questions like [b]How Do I turn it on.[/b] :p

Col ]:)

by dr dij

to prevent people from calling themselves anything that they are not. We'll have to hire political faves with degrees in such things as 'Training Thoroughbred Horses' to manage such an agency and supply it with billions to enforce mandates:
no one should be allowed to lie--
on the internet

(including sides such as Facebook, etc)
on TR the enforcers will verify claims that someone is from 'Botswana' when two days later they now say 'Rome, Italy'
I specifically will have to be investigated since my profile says 'LaLaLand, California' when in fact a MapQuest or USPS.com search returns no such city. And Max will have to be investigated as his profiles says 'Nowheresville'

Other duties should include checking:
on resumes (saying they were programmer when they were help desk for example)
to women at bars (such as telling them they are a pilot)

Proposed name could be:

Bureau of
Uncorrected
Legalities,
Consultancies
Rightly
Applied
Positions

Thanks for the inspiring post!!
Should we not want to do this in the US in a stupid attempt to save money and prevent the proliferation of big govt, then it will have to be implemented on the 'WorldGov' level with a new UN agency with enforcement powers.

This would be better as we all know how efficient and honest the UN is. There is no chance such an agency could get out of control as all that would be issued are rubber truncheons and access to all our data records.. Good luck!

by roger99a

Only if you take the gov't required courses, pass the gov't required tests and pay the proper fees. It's the only way we can ensure our idiots are idiotic enough to use that title.

by locolobo

Give the students a dollar every time they get it right and see how they do. Or better yet put it in a slot machine in a casino. Put in 1 dollar if you get it right you get back 2. I bet you the slot machine would be losing money in a day.

by sparks

I am new in the IT consulting world as I own a few other business in the financal services and medical billing industries. I will be happy to say that I am a far cry from being a professional "IT Consultant" as it takes many years to learns and master ones trade. I wouldn't like it if you started doing home or commercial loans and called your self a mortgage broker but the fact is all industries have these people that want to build themselves up internally and we just need to let them. So in turn if you see a post asking a "stupid" question please just lend a hand which will make me a better "IT Consoltant". I am just trying to fill a viod here in our area. On another note I don't feel right paying an "IT Consultant" money where I learned what he did in 1 hr took me only 30 minutes and he has been in the business for years. So there are many so called real IT Consultants who don't know a hell of a lot either. Just be thankful that you don't have me as a client. Sorry for being honest with my opinions. Take care.

by juan

well, I can feel the heat from that comment but I will have
to totally agree. I did not spend over $20,000 and five
years in school, built my own small library of technical
book and 12yrs in the field to be at the same level as
those with "Given" titles by HR......lol

Also, remember that just because they call themselves IT
manager or consultants does not mean they have the
education or experience in the field. We are trained
engineers and put our time as a grunt in the trenches.

Be well and at peace for the true engineers will fix the
world....not just take the credit for it....lol

by hal 9000

My staff before they got to know me well used to run screaming out of the building as I arrived. :D

When they got to know me better they kept a Lookout and left before I arrived. :^0

Then when I couldn't scare then SHIRTLESS I started terrifying the Management. That worked a treat as I was left free to do as I liked. Of course the word got out and my staff returned. :(

Col ]:)

by burntfinger1

You're never going to run out of stupid people or stupid questions. That's why Dilbert is so funny. Besides, to the person asking, it's never a stupid question.
I'd much rather have someone ask a "stupid" question than really mess up a client's system.

As for limiting who can call themselves a consultant, well, that's a slippery slope. The consultants I respect most are those who have 2 units of people skills for every one unit of tech skills and aren't afraid to ask a stupid question if they don't know something.

Having said all that, I do sympathize with you. I too get frustrated with people who take jobs way beyond their competence and then expect to be rescued - for free - by someone who does know what they're doing.

This discussion is closed to new replies.