Discussion Locked

Plagiarism - What it is and what it isn't

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

On occasion, I've used the words or ideas of other people in one of my blogs here at TechRepublic, and as such I've dutifully cited the appropriate names and sources.

Hillary Clinton recently charged Barack Obama with plagiarism because he borrowed an idea from another person in one of his speeches, only slightly altering the exact words themselves.

Perhaps Mrs. Clinton thinks Mr. Obama should have either paused or added footnotes to his speech, giving credit to Massachusetts Governor Deval Patrick for the use of those particular thoughts. (And perhaps both men should have properly cited the source of the inspirational phrases they both used, although the sources are generally well known?)

I'm certainly no fan of Barack Obama, but I believe Mrs. Clinton's charge of plagiarism is a bit of a stretch. I'm not a fan of Mrs. Clinton either, and I'd also suggest that the counter-charge of plagiarism against her because she used John Edwards' Blockbuster Video analogy is also a stretch. (It might mean she's something else, but not a plagiarizer.)

I might also suggest that it's much easier to incorporate proper citation in the written form that it would be in an impassioned speech (regardless of the true substance of said speech). I certainly acknowledge the reality here, which is not much more than politics as usual, but I believe that particular charge not only made Mrs. Clinton look rather silly, but it doesn't even fit the true definition of plagiarism.

Since there's a lot of writing, citing, and borrowing going on around here, I thought it would be interesting to see the TechRepublic community's take on what must be every writer's fear, being charged with that dreaded P-Word - Plagiarism.

15 replies

by dadspad

When the news reported on Hilary's complaint on Obama using Gov Patrick's words in a speech, then played video on her using Edward's speech parts, it relegated it all to politics as usual.

I hope both parties realize that people can be turned off by negative politics and stick more to on the 'changes' they are promising.

by jdclyde

does not change anything.

Did you hear the Obama speed back to back with Governor Patrick's? It was almost a regurgitation, and clearly not what we have come to expect from the great "oratator" Barack Obama.

The fact that Radham-Clinton did the same thing only makes her look as bad as Barack, it does not excuse it.

I am so tired of the part of politics where people refuse to justify their own actions and simple point a finger and say someone else did the same or worse, as if that actually changes anything. The sad thing is, most people are actually stupid enough to fall for it.

by digitalfrog

that either of writes their own speeches, or spends much time vetting the sources of the ones they are given. If there is a problem with plagarism, I say take a look at the speech writers.

by tig2

Let's face it- it may be impossible to say anything that
someone else hasn't already said. It matters little if I have
ever seen the source.

I personally know a large number of people who
shamelessly took my resume format and replaced my
information with theirs. I certainly don't expect that they
will cite me as the originator of the format.

When I write for the News, I am taking information that I
have been able to gather independently and presenting
that information to the TR audience. I link my sources
and I make an effort to not present my opinion.

In the Desktop blog, I present opinion, based on my
experience. I don't read other sources to glean that
content. I don't cite anything, believing that my
information comes from my own brain. But that doesn't
mean that no one ever, at any time, didn't express the
same concepts.

I personally think that Clinton's assertion of plagiarism
against Obama was just an attack made by the desperate.
I think Obama's counter attack was just that- a counter
attack. I don't think that either of them were guilty of
plagiarism. I think they are both guilty of politics as usual.

by jamesrl

Plagarism has two aspects, one is copying without attribution, the other is copying without permission. Its not clear in Obama's case that he didn't have permission - Patrick is a staunch supporter and may have well suggested using the theme - in any case, we will never know.

In most cases of plagarism its both. And that is certainly more serious than failure to properly attribute - in a speech. The standard in journalism is higher, and highest of all in academic papers.

James

James

by jamesrl

There were lots of places that would sell you essays.

Now the universities take your essay and compare it to an online database and see if substantial portions match. If they do, many universities expel you.

That would be much harder to do with code, simple apps in university have fewer possible variations - how many ways can you code the "make change with as few coins as possible) app.

Yes I would consider stealing code without permission theft.

James

by oz_media

as ytjis is a public forum and there is explicit set o frules and alloowances. While the TR content and partner content is clearly protected your own content is not and ocne posted is the property of TR and also the users here. By posting here you grant rights to others for public use.

"You are solely responsible for all materials, whether publicly posted or privately transmitted, that you upload, post, e-mail, transmit, or otherwise make available on our sites ("Your Content"). You certify that you own all intellectual property rights in Your Content. You hereby grant us, our affiliates, and our partners a worldwide, irrevocable, royalty-free, nonexclusive, sublicensable license to use, reproduce, create derivative works of, distribute, publicly perform, publicly display, transfer, transmit, distribute, and publish Your Content and subsequent versions of Your Content for the purposes of (i) displaying Your Content on our sites, (ii) distributing Your Content, either electronically or via other media, to users seeking to download or otherwise acquire it, and/or (iii) storing Your Content in a remote database accessible by end users, for a charge. This license shall apply to the distribution and the storage of Your Content in any form, medium, or technology now known or later developed."

In the case of Clinton and Obama, they are boring and have no worthwhile agenda or any real hard core conspiracy going on, they are left to resort to these paqathetic charges against one another to try and raise some interest and keep them in the pubilc eye.

As an example, Bush and Kerry had some good conspiracy going on, even if it was BS it still kept the media excited.

by jdclyde

it could be "the media" is hoping to keep fluff like this in the fore-front so joe-voter will not take the time to figure out that Obama doesn't have a platform, and Rodham-Clinton is still an old bitter bitch.

by tonythetiger

witch, since her voice sounds jut like the old hag on "The Wizard of Oz". (and I hear she's contracted with O Cedar to provide transportation to and from events :) )

by oz_media

I think they both have no character, no magnetism, no charisma, they are just flat, doped-up looking, boring people.

Based on that, either one is aperfect candidate for president. Sure as hell better than Yosemite Sam who thinks he's "rootin' tootin' savin' the whole darn world from unChristian evils".

by jdclyde

if everyone is handed the same problem, and all follow the same process that is taught in that class, the only thing that should be different in the code is the choice of variable labels.

in most of my programming classes we were allowed and encouraged to work in groups, and then turn in a single paper.

by ed woychowsky

You're not remembering the folks that were only in school because; "Mom said get a job or go to school, I figger'd school was easier." It's easy to see how you'd forget them, since they usually didn't make it past the first semester.

by jdclyde

is his complete lack of voting record.

He has missed or voted "present" for over 85% of all of the votes.

That is EXACTLY what we need, someone that is willing to leave well enough alone and realizes more laws are not the solution to every problem.

If only he would handle the White House with the same 85% no-show attitude.

by tonythetiger

"He's not Clinton"

On the other hand, he's kind of leaning toward a Clinton-esque Health care, and that troubles me. It will destroy what little personal responsibility is left to control costs.

I had an idea. One of the objections to socialist health care is that it makes everybody liable for any one person's lifestyle choices (Why, for example, should I have to pay for Joe Blow's skiing accident?).

I had an idea that we come up with lifestyle-based insurance for risky activities, and make it mandatory in order to participate in that activity (like you have to have liability insurance to drive!). That way only those who participate in that activity will be shouldering the risk, and lower costs for people who choose not to.

This discussion is closed to new replies.