Discussion Locked

Power Supply or MoBo

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Situation: Computer starts (lights, fan, etc) but does not boot. No BIOS beeps, video or boot.

Actions taken: Tested power supply w/ multimeter, output on PowerGd was 1.2v, which I understand to be low (?), other voltages ok; Replaced PS, still won't boot. Stripped machine to MoBo, video card, memory and CPU, still won't boot.

Quirk: When I test each PS connected to computer, the PowerGd line tests at around 1.2v, when I disconnect the PS from computer and backprobe it with it connected to an ATX power tester, it tests good (via the ATX tester) and the PowerGD line tests at 2.1v w/multimeter.

Questions: Would I be correct in concluding this is a MoBo problem? Why does the PowerGd line of the power supply test differently when unplugged from the computer vs. connected to a different device (the ATX tester)?

8 replies

by hereinoz

My guess would be motherboard. The probable reason for the voltage drop when connected to the MOBO in question would be excessive current draw from a short or low resistance, which is drawing lots of current and dropping the voltage. (V=IR)

Have you perhaps got one of the motherboard supports shorting on to the board? Look perhaps for something like that. Can you remove the board from the chassis and then test it, so it is definitley insulated from the case? Might give you some clues.

alan

by zlitocook

Reseat all connections, cards, memory ect. If you get start up ie sounds and lights, there is a device that is not starting. Do the basics, remove every thing except the memory and the floppy to see what you get on boot up.

by thechas

It might be the motherboard.

It could be the CPU or a BIOS setting issue.

The Power Good line on the ATX test box is just pulled down low enough to keep the power supply running. The different voltage readings are simply from the different circuits on the power supply tester and motherboard.
The tester likely uses a voltage divider, the motherboard uses a logic gate or transistor switch.

If this is a Socket A system, it is VERY common for the system to not boot if the CPU speed settings are wrong.

I would first reset the CMOS and see if the system boots.

Next, swap in a known good CPU.

One last thought, I have seen more than 1 system problem from a cooling fan plugged into the motherboard. Seems that some fans emit electrical noise on the Tach output that can cause problems with some motherboards.

Chas

by ozi eagle

Also check the electrolytic capacitors around the cpu. If any have a bulging top or side they are faulty and the probable cause. Generally the mobo is history, unless you are very proficient with a soldering iron and lucky to boot.

by rindi1

I'd go with answer 3. Something else that often causesthe the behaviour of your system is the Graphic Card. Remove it and see what happens.

by koldfusion2187

Locate the jumper for resetting the bios. Reset the bios, and try booting. If no luck, turn it off, and then start removing devices one by one (remove a card, disconnect cd rom, etc etc) and try to boot after removing each device. If the computer boots after that, you know which component was your trouble part. If possible, physically test the PSU in another (known to be working) machine. If it boots, it is not the PSU. (There are all sorts of reasons for wierd voltage readings, but it is possible to be a short, or bad capacitor)

It is also a likely possibility that there is a short somewhere on the motherboard itself, which there is a good chance that the board also got fried as a result. Check all of the spacers under the board and make sure there is no way the board could have come in contact with the case.

Also, if possible, test the CPU/RAM in another known working system.

I would probably put my money on the power supply from what you have said. I recently had a buddy who's computer did something simular after getting stuck in standby. The computer would not turn on, but the board was getting power (Wake Lan light was lit, etc).

by sgt_shultz

somebody probably already said this but i believe the power supply tests like that because it is a switching power supply and needs a load to test properly. when i test, i unhook mbd and everything else except known good hd for load. don't do this if i can avoid it but seems to me you are looking for about 5v to make mboard happy to boot so if you are measuring right wire and getting 2.v when ps plugged in? maybe short on mbd? where you can't see it? see if ps will measure correctly with other load besides mbd. bet chas knows wire voltages by heart but not me.
i have a stack of boxes like with symptoms like yours and i think it is the motherboard but just my gut. you would need another motherbd to swap your components into to see if any are bad, seems to me. otherwise your best guess. open box in good light at comfortable working height. inspect for shorts, burned areas, damaged or loose components. both sides if you are really into it. you could initiate email correspondence with mbd mfg for whatever in depth t shooting advice they may have.

This discussion is closed to new replies.