I am 55 years old, and been into computers since 1984, so my experience is as follows:
I perfer a full size scanner, legal document size with a very good OCR(optical character recgonition) software. Zerox has a top quality OCR. The newest HP OCR was barely acceptable. Their legal size scanners are dependable though. Finding a full size scanner is a bit of a problem in the last couple of years. This is a mistake the manufacturers are forcing us consummers to accept. Used to be the other way around, when full size scanners were the norm.
My Brother MFC 420CN($125.00), a 4-in-one, (letter size), bought at Staples, does OK. The ScanSoft PaperPort 9.0 software, that comes with it, is a bummer. ScanSoft hijacks your photo rendering software,(such as Adobe)and makes photos that cannot be modified(nasty!).It is not user friendly, and is SLOW. It has not been a shining example for editable scans, to Word documents either.
Good thing, is that this model can "stand alone". It is an excellent stand alone copier, fax, and PhotoCapture Printing Center.
Inkjets have their place, but they suck ink with a passion. I perfer to have separate color and b&w printers. I and my daughters, do a lot of printing, mostly b&w. Using ink got expensive, so we now use two printers.
My older HP LaserJet 2100M, does most excellent black & white printing. I haven't had to do anything except feed paper to it in the last 3 years. I clean it out twice a year to get out any foriegn stuff that may get into it. It has been the best, dependable printer I have ever had.
Fax capability is good with the Brother unit, but I very seldom use it. I perfer to e-mail with an attachment, as a document(s) can be scanned and saved as a photo copy of the original document(legally better than a fax). Larger files are uploaded to a remote site for downloading. This is handy for those 5 meg to 100 meg files. I can send a high resolution fax, but if the receiving fax is a low resolution model (or set to low resolution) - I have wasted my time.
Lastly, The computer system I use is not an off-the-shelf unit. I hate machines that are proprietary. The computer system is not the speed problem with the Brother unit.
You will get what you pay for in the long run. My old HP 2100M printer was used for years in a business LAN before I got it. Still spits out the goods though. The Brother color aii-in-one units seem to give better resolution than the HP's I've tried, at equal price range. That is just my observation though.
I am NOT a fan of the ScanSoft OCR/Twain. HP's was much more user friendly and did not hijack your other programs. It also worked well with Windows Office programs. Roxio software was another hijacker I, and my brother(also an engineer), had problems with, when needing to render photos/graphics. ScanSoft and Roxio hijacked our Adobe programs and produced uneditable graphics/photos. It went through the hard drive and changed every photo and graphics work we had to an uneditable format. This was costly to us both, and we were MOST UNHAPPY!
If your all-in-one is going to be working with your personal computer, these are issues to concider BEFORE installing the OEM software.
Rex Berry