150 posts? That says it all, doesn't it? We used to have so much more than that. Redesigning the forum from top to bottom is a turn-off to the 1.6 million users that are used to coming here for technical information. When I'm looking for some information, the look of the site doesn't matter, its the usefulness. Less is more, sometimes.
Aside from the watercooler, I've used TR extensively when I need to get specific answers on network problems. When they took away the browse button, the ability to narrow the search enough was lost, so you get too many hits. If you try to sort by date (instead of relevance), most of the hits disappear except for the newest ones, on some searches. The dropdown menu for your search (Relevance, Date and Popularity) is hard to use. In many searches, I couldn't select date or popularity because its imposed over the URL for the first hit. Thats with 1280 x 1024 screen resolution. They need to fix that.
I'm no stranger to the truth about software upgrades, but they need to address problems like these and keep people up to date on when and if they will fix the problems. Otherwise, we might see the day you're talking about when "Justin is arguing gently with Jason, Erik and Jack...."
AV