Discussion Locked

Private Message - New 'pull down' list of members

0 helpful
36 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Would it be asking too much to put this list of members in alphabetical order, instead of the apparently random sequence they're in now? It makes it difficult for us old timers who have more than three or four contacts to find the one we want to reach. Some of us are so old that by the time we find the name we want, we've forgotten what we wanted to tell them.

Secondary and less likely, is there any chance of enabling multiple recipients?

36 replies

by seanferd

with the larger avatars, I would occasionally think I had lost a contact or something because the page freakin' rearranges itself.

You win my Idea-Man Award for today (which is actually worth nothing except in my mind).

Multiple recipients. Dude!

by charliespencer

I posted a notice a couple of weeks ago. I think it's still visible on the Water Cooler page. Let me know if you know anyone interested. I'll take new players right up until the green flag on Sunday.

by michael jay

when you are trying to send a peer message, yea that is silly, should be in order, but it is not.

by seanferd

I see what you did. Do I recall you mentioning that something went wrong with your old handle, or am I imagining that?

edit: Argh. I know at least one other person who has a different nym now. I must be slipping. Or more than usual, anyway.

by tigger_two

I used to be TiggerTwo and am now Tigger_Two. Couldn't log in as me and didn't feel like messing around too much so I just kept the underscore. Problem is that I lost all my contacts.

I think I recall someone else posting that they had lost all their contacts as well so I just assumed that this was a known bug with the relaunch and rebuilt my contacts. The problem is that I haven't been re-added to most folks contacts. I'm not being followed by many, in fact.

The only reason- in my opinion- to insure that I'm following people AND that they are following me is the fact that you can't PM anyone who isn't in your contact list and you in theirs. I can follow the thinking behind that but the execution didn't work as planned, I don't think. From my perspective, a notification would need to be generated when you add someone for that PM restriction to work as they were thinking.

by seanferd

As well as their favorites and other stuff.

I do still have Tig2 showing in my contacts, but indeed TiggerTwo had gone missing, and I was wondering what was up with that. Of all the logins that TR could have blackholed in transition...

edit: Doing a search, it seems like all the TiggerTwo posts were converted to Tig2 (Last seen in 2005!).

by nicknielsen

You, Beth, and Soni. Your comments there are also above Tig2. I think the user name is associated with an email address. I am unable to change the user name associated with my old ZDNet account because "That user name is already in use", even though I'm changing it FROM that user name.

Speaking of emails, I have two addresses listed for you. Is either one still good? I tried to ask you in a PM, but I get a return message of "You are attempting to contact a member that has elected not to be contacted."

by pos or pos?

This time, it let me change it. I can't associate my selected email address with it because a user account with that address already exists. This opens up all kinds of options...or not. I could attempt multiple personalities, but both would be me. Another option is to change the email address to a throwaway, then get the account banned. The most rational would be to ask the PTB to delete it...if they can.

by michael jay

POS is POS is you, Nick?

I see the post but that poster has not been seen in 6 years.

Not getting it.

by santeewelding

Maybe this explains why I'm seeing so many "handles" I don't ever recall seeing before. Where in hell are all these people coming from?

by michael jay

see this change as the best thing, and are posting like rabid squirrels.

I could be wrong, it has happened before.

by ansugisalas

the site change inadvertently overwrote a seal on a gateway to hell...

POS is POS... funny! Point of Sale is ... P. O. S. ?

by nicknielsen

Before the changeover, I couldn't change the username on the nicknielsen2 account, so I decided to try it again with a random user name. I didn't know there was a POS is POS user in the past, though. I know it wasn't me then. :D

Yes, Ansu, you got it. :^0

Maybe I'll go with Holgar on the other account... :|

by tigger_two

I have PM turned on.

A correct address would be the most common form of my name prior to marriage with appropriate punctuation and recalling that Comcast is a net.

According to TR, that address- which would be the one associated with Tig2- isn't. If it had been, I would have been able to relaunch that account. The one I was able to get them to acknowledge was created during some strangeness when several of us discovered the value of a second login.

Oddly, that is also the address that TR sends newsletters to. It should have worked and I should have been able to do a name reset. But then, a lot of things SHOULD work that don't.

*sigh*

I'm over the underscore but there is no reason that I can think of that it should tell you that I don't accept PMs.

by nicknielsen

That one is also the one I show as associated with your original account. The other would be the same name, with appropriate punctuation, but at an address provided by the host of the bug spreadsheet.

Strange about the PM. Think I'll add it to the bug sheet.

by tigger_two

Both Comcast and Google know me by the same name. I have a gmail account that knows my current name that I use primarily for business.

I finally broke down and signed on with Twitter. Amused to see a Tweet from David Slade raving about how easy the site is to use. It would be humorous if it wasn't so sad. All it tells me is that they simply refuse to listen to us and have chosen to tout this new revision as an improvement that it is not.

C/P from my Twitter feed... [i]@chezdave David Slade by @jasonhiner
The new TechRepublic.com site is so much easier to use! nice job team! So many great features in the pipeline too!! // @techrepublic[/i]

*sigh*

by av .

I had never set up contacts before and it wasn't an issue. I don't think the FAQs say thats how its supposed to work either, but I don't see any other way of doing it. Its nice to hear you get a list of contacts to PM in random order. I hope they will at least give you a way to sort them.

TR needs to do a better job of explaining how the new site works. Lately, I'm spending more time looking around than posting. Its frustrating, to say the least. Hunt and peck.

I just tried to reply to Tig's message "As it should be, Nick" and there was an option to Take Offline in place of the Reply option. I know it used to say "You have reached the maximum ...", but what does that mean?

If I go into "My Stuff", the posts only go up to Feb. 6. I can only find discussions after that time by searching.

What the heck happened to the browse button? I always used that. Can't find it. Maybe I'm just not looking hard enough.

AV

by tigger_two

Had you chosen that option, this discussion would have spawned an entirely new discussion... that would not have linked to the existing discussion so it would make absolutely NO sense whatsoever.

No browse button. They took away the stuff we actually liked, you see.

For me, I have found "My Stuff" to be a wasteful pain it the tail and I don't bother with it. I only go to my profile to recheck that I really HAVE put my settings as I actually want them. For anything else, the payout in frustration trumps any use it could conceivably be.

Finally, you CAN'T PM someone who isn't in YOUR contacts and you must also be in THEIRS. How social, right? And according to Nick, it would be a waste of time to PM me- regardless of how I have my settings, TR has decided that I am refusing PMs. Pretty ridiculous when you consider that in all the years I have used TR, I have NEVER turned off private messaging.

by av .

They must all be drinking the Koolaid there if they think this is an upgrade. Its a downgrade.

For a social networking site, they are making it damn near impossible to be social.

The worst thing is that they probably don't see any of these issues as a problem. Why would you want to go offline? It doesn't make any sense.

I don't like "My Stuff" either. All I want to see is a list of my posts. It isn't any good for that because it doesn't update.

The PM restrictions are just unnecessary. If I got a PM that I didn't want, I just wouldn't answer it.

I hope they're going to fix this debacle. Right now, the site is just a midden (thanks to Santee for that word!)

AV

by ansugisalas

The "community pulse" has revealed to me that the new TR gets only 150 posts a day... according to some statistics, that's seven of me!
How few would there be if the regulars give up the ghost? Non-spam?
15?
There'd be Justin arguing gently with Jason, Erik and Jack... and then 5 random passers through a day, each with one non-sequitur comment to a thread of random age, mostly zombies.

by nicknielsen

It was that little sidebar at the right of your Workspace titled "My Recent Discussions" or "My Recent Questions" or some such. The change appears to have been to strip all useful information from the old Workspace and substitute the information from there. I don't know why. I think I clicked on one of those links maybe once or twice a year.

Somebody apparently decided it was more important that we see what we have posted rather than how others responded to it.

by av .

150 posts? That says it all, doesn't it? We used to have so much more than that. Redesigning the forum from top to bottom is a turn-off to the 1.6 million users that are used to coming here for technical information. When I'm looking for some information, the look of the site doesn't matter, its the usefulness. Less is more, sometimes.

Aside from the watercooler, I've used TR extensively when I need to get specific answers on network problems. When they took away the browse button, the ability to narrow the search enough was lost, so you get too many hits. If you try to sort by date (instead of relevance), most of the hits disappear except for the newest ones, on some searches. The dropdown menu for your search (Relevance, Date and Popularity) is hard to use. In many searches, I couldn't select date or popularity because its imposed over the URL for the first hit. Thats with 1280 x 1024 screen resolution. They need to fix that.

I'm no stranger to the truth about software upgrades, but they need to address problems like these and keep people up to date on when and if they will fix the problems. Otherwise, we might see the day you're talking about when "Justin is arguing gently with Jason, Erik and Jack...."

AV

by av .

You can almost hear an echo. Only the few of us that are going for martyrdom are left. :^0

AV

by seanferd

The entire method of finding blogs, and the non-aligned categories they currently list (have you looked at the drop-down under Security?) is... Less Than Optimal.

by ansugisalas

It's like the China Daily; a personalized listing of the dirt the government has on each and everyone... with the option to pay, so to see the dirt on others, too...
Is it the old "crippled functionality" business model?

by nicknielsen

It's the "New and Improved" business model, and begs at least one question:

What's been improved?

by seanferd

at least it was CBS rather than Jana what took control of CNET. I'm still not sure that anyone has an idea on properly modernizing or monetizing the thing. I'm not enamoured of what has been done with any of the sites. Although ZDNet I gave up for lost, forum-wise, long ago, I would have given up when the forum itself changed. They made some good improvements, then killed it by changing the discussion format to a comment format - like the awful Q&A design here.

http://www.sparkplug9.com/wp-content/uploads/2006/01/business-model.jpg

And now I'll probably discuss this very little for a couple more weeks and see what shakes out. A little peep from the PTB would be nice now and then, though.

This discussion is closed to new replies.