Discussion Locked

Private Sector vs Government Service

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Why is there such a wide gap between skill level and pay between private sector and government sector jobs? Especially when performing what is essentially the same job.

What are the benefits to workin in the Private Sector? The Government Sector? What are the drawbacks?

21 replies

by jamesrl

Government sector jobs typically provide more security/stability, better pensions and often more training than private companies. Private companies typically experience more $$ and often more opportunities for advancement.

James

by maxwell edison

.
In your experience, does the "wide gap" favor the private or government sector? And what is your source for your confirming your conclusion?

by netsec

In terms of Base pay, it favor is in the private sector. In terms of Job security, retirement the favor is with the government sector. But even in the government sector there is wide discrpancy in the pay rates for persons doing the same job.

by black panther

Currently in Government.

The main differences I have found ( apart from the beaurocratic red tape to get anything done in Government )

are:-

The Government has pre-defined pay levels for each Job. As a General Rule ( although I am lucky and got in without one ) you need an IT degree to get into the Government.

I have not found any difference in skill level though as you suggest - this always depends on the individual.

As for pay some private companies pay the minimum, some average and some well above average where as in the Government you are bound by the pay level and usually rely on CPI for the yearly payrise ( with no bonus system etc )

The benefits of working in the private sector are you don't have to deal with the "red tape".

The downside is they usually pay you for 38 to 40 hour week but "expect" you to work 50 or more hours without the extra pay.

In the Government you are required to work 36 - 38 hour week and if you work any extra hours they are accumulated and you can then take time off ie flexi-time or ATL.

I have found that the Government pays quite well compared to some of the "private" jobs where I was doing a similar role, also you have more job security ( as long as you are a permanent public servant ) not working on a contract for the Government.

If you are a "go-getter" type of person you may be more suited to a "private sector" position where there may be more room for promotion and there is more chance of changes being made more quickly in the organisation without barriers.

Not all people can relate to the Governments beaurocracy and it can take some time to get used to after a "private" role.

by netsec

I've worked in both sectors, but doing vastly different jobs - in the private sector I was an administrative assistant. For government I started as a computer Operator and have progressed to Network Administrator. In both, I have been at the low end of the pay scale. In the private sector it didn't bother me to much. But while working for the government it has been a constant source of irritation to see people who have less knowledge and experience than I do get put into positions which they have neither the knowledge nor skill sets to fulfill. The salaries they receive are ridiculous. I have had to struggle to get the pay I currently receive, which is still extremely low compared to some of my co-workers who do the same thing, but have fewer skills.

One of my Co-workers has a title that she does not have the credentials to have, but because she has the job title, she makes $30K/year more than I do. That is one of the things I find most frustrating about the government - around here it's not what you know and how well you know it, it's WHO you know and how well you know them.

by impulse

Agreed. I notice this alot around the office here too (gov't).
You would think it is almost counter-productive to higher on a senoirity basis (for new or open positions) then on revelant education / skill sets.
I'd have to say I am happy with my salarie, and am not looking for a raise, then I am more of a "fitting" position. I've spend alot of money training on Domain Controllers, security ect. Why am I here answering phones?

by willfromsf

I worked in a local government IT department for 17 years. Yes, it was secure and the benefits were very good, although training was sporadic and there were few perks. But there was virtually no chance of advancement. One reason is because the jobs don't turn over as much (a good sign, I suppose), but more it's just a very arbitrary system with zero incentive to do your best or even well. People who just show up may be treated as well or better than those who work their butts off. Things are very rigid. Example: when we went to Oracle systems (primarily a political decision), the bosses hired a lot of people with Oracle backgrounds, gave them pumped-up titles and paid them 20% more than myself and others at the same level who had worked there 10-20 years. I ended up leading, by default, all the projects that I worked on with the Oracle newbies, because I knew the needs, the systems, the functional requirements, and had the leadership and communication skills that the newbies didn't. So after some time of this inequity, I went to the boss and pointed out the situation and asked to be given the Oracleites' title and salary. The response? Stop leading, stop taking initiative, i.e. let the projects flounder. Unfortunately, that is how government tends to work... or not work.

by tonythetiger

I agree with your assessment (especially the last observation!), as I have numerous colleagues in both business and government and we talk of these things often.

I would add that Government seems to be a step or so behind private businesses most of the time (which makes some sense... let the private companies test all these new fangled gadgets before we sink a lot of someone else's money into it). They are also more resistant to change than private enterprise.

There are fewer kudos in government work too. Rarely is there an employer provided incentive to do "an extra special good job" (you're going to be paid the same as the barely adequate fellow in the same job class) so you must rely more on your personal work ethic.

Lastly, most Government IT personnel have as their main job putting out fires. So if you work smart and manage to prevent the fires from even starting, you might have time to catch up on the massive amount of documentation that you are required to do (it takes me 20 seconds to give someone a new toner from the cabinet, but 10 minutes to update the inventory and document the time I spent on the 'job' :)

by angry_white_male

Often in the public sector, budgets are tighter. But you get great benefits and better than average job security. For me - the only thing that comes out of my paycheck are withholding taxes. The agency I work for provides full health / dental / vision for my family, life insurance (3X base salary), and contributes 100% towards my pension (no 401k here). No union here in the admin ranks and no civil service requirements - so most new hires in our admin ranks come from political connections as was I - but at least I am actually qualified for my job unlike others I see here. But I have a nice office - walls, door and a full floor-to-ceiling wall-to-wall window... so it's not too bad here.

When I worked for Xerox I had a great salary that IMHO was probably on the high side... and even once they took out for benefits and 401k, I was still very happy on payday. Lived in a cube farm with the rest of the cube dwellers - little privacy. However I was laid off after 4 years when the company stock hit an all-time low and from what I hear the perks and fringe benefits over there are pretty much gone.

A public sector school district job I had in the late 90's was OK... pay was low... benefits were average and we had the additional joy of being in a union that sucked dues from us but gave very little in return. The IT dept was in a converted bus garage and my office was up in hot a dusty loft overlooking what used to be the main service bay. It was also civil service - had to take a test to get a job (or if hired provisionally take a test to keep your job). That's all good and fair - but you get a lot of people who got their job because they could pass a test but were otherwise complete wrecks.

by bseitsinger

My very first job out of college was a public sector job working for a city's IT department. Being brand new to the job market and rev'd up to use and develop my skills I was bored to death! All the existing staff wanted to do was sit around and talk most of the time, and occassionally do some real work (they had been there a while). It drove me crazy! I lasted about 1 year and have been in the private sector ever since.

For a long while working in the computer profession was a lot of fun - and still mostly is. However, after working in this field for 27+ years I'm tiring of the incessant need to learn new technologies quickly for each new project I work on. That is the blessing and the curse of this field - the need to keep technically relevant, and ramp up in ever shorter cycles.

Don't get me wrong, I enjoy learning new stuff as much as the next guy, but not when a deadline is fast approaching and it's critical that the work get done on time, and you've never used the technology before, and there isn't anybody on staff to ask about it. It can be very draining over the long haul.

At this point in my career I could do with a little less stress on the job (and a better benefits package), even if it means working with less-than cutting-edge technology.

So, where can one go to find out about technology jobs in the public sector? (suggestions can be sent to bseitsinger@sbcglobal.net)

In addition to my 27+ years experience, I have a Bachelors and Masters in Comp Sci.

by irishdadx4

Let's see - background first: 15 years working for widely known federal agency. Took buy out this year when I was in danger og veing affected by lay-off this year, or very very likely next year. Management couldn't say whether buyout would be offered again. So I took the money and ran. Anyways, I have 8 years of experience as Sys admin, security officer, etc. Mostly all self taught. Have 2 year degree in drafting and design. I'm in school going thorugh for my MSCE, hoping it would help with job replacement. Looking at available jobs, employers appear to be asking for applicants with a four year degree computer science, at least 5 years experience and certifications. And they seem to be only offering salary in the $35-45000 range. Im in theHampton Roads,Va market, not that small. lots of military and other gov't. So I dont have a four year degree, and 45,000 is almost 10K less then I made before, so not looking to good right now. And I can't get another gov't job or work on a contractor on a personal services contract for 5 years unless I pay back all the buyouy money I got, before I start the new job. So thatsmy two cents.

by the dalles dweller

I've worked both as well, and now currently work for a school district making less then I would in the private sector. However, as one of the other posts mentioned, I work 40 hours a week and usually no more. I have a family and I value my time with them. I do have better benefits then when I worked for a "dot-com". I ended up in education after I was layed off when we didn't get our 3rd round of venture capital funding. I made almost twice what I make now, but worked 60+ hours a week.

So as mentioned in an earlier post, if you want to move up quick and can work a lot hours, then go the private sector--especially if you are single and can take the risk of sudden layoffs. The public is slower, less $ but more stable and family-friendly.

Thanks

by rmiller

In my long career I have worked in the private, public, and non profit sectors. I have been an owner, manager, worker, day laborer, and contractor. If any of these situations could guarentee good management and job satisfaction, it would very soon replace all the others. There are a few good managers and the rest range from pathetic to evil. There are good, secure opportunities and poor in every sector. Our society lacks the vision of good employee management. Feedback mechanisms that can monitor employee abuse and correct it are very rare and weak. Most people still value the privileges of powerful over the necessities of the disenpowered. As long as that is the case, most workers will be frustrated. There are some great employers out there. Good luck finding one.

by jasmith

Oddly enough, there a similarites in both environments. In my 24 years in IT, it is about 50/50 now.

I started in Private with a small mom and pop. Pay was good, enough to live on but their operating budget was tight and you were salaried, so did what was necessary to keep your job. Usually benifits were very marginal, health only, but this may not always be the case. Have worked Fortune 100, a big company with many divisions and subsidaries. Good benifits, but if the books did not look good or meet the parent companies expectations, employess got wacked. The one I was at, pink slips went out Christmas week, but the budget was saved for that fiscal year. Four months later, they were hiring. In this type of environment, I agree that sometimes it is who you know and that is how you get promoted or hired, regardless of your knowledge or expertise. Depending on the company, the pay will vary. At Fortune 100, the pay it was well above the norm. It was more than mid grade in the pay band, but I had the knowledge and expertise they wanted. Buy the way, Private uses tests as well, somtimes detailed questions - verbal or written. My interview was 3.5 hours long and a follow up with the Division VP for 2 more hours. Sometimes those are the breaks. So like I said it varies, pay is good, benifits good, but the risk is out there that you can be out of a job, immediately.

Public will vary. Talking Federal, State, County (or its equivlant) or City. I have seen wide variences in all 4 of these. Those with rich budgets pay more. It also comes down to the entity within of each of these 4. A lot of the control is not in their hands as it is legislatively mandated. Also, depended upon the governmental entity, there may be unions or not. There also maybe vestion and bumping rights when the budget goes sour. There also maybe zero rights and when the budget goes sour, it will depend upon your evaluation to see who keeps their job and who gets the pink slip. The benifits are usually very good. Small employee contrib to health ins, maybe no or very trivial payment for life ins, zero contrib to a portable pension plan (401b by the way vs. 401k for private), employee deferred compensation, etc. Example, I pay $6 a month for parking in a major metropolitan city while friends of mine pay close to $200 per month. They make more than me but have higher expenses which off sets the salary. I will say that the same thing goes here. It is who you know and not necessarly what you know that can get you promoted or hired.

Enough for my soap box for now. There are risks and perks in both sectors. All factors need to be evaluated in determination overall compensation vs. final pay and I am not saying what your W2 says. There are some expenses that you can not deduct on your taxes but bite into your paycheck as costs of working at a particular company. The same goes the other way. There are benifits that the employer maybe paying at higher percentage of that when looked at in the BIG PICTURE of your compensation and will offset what looks like to be a reduced salary between environments. People, do the math. This is very important if you are considering changing jobs and localities.

May you all have a great day!

by digitaltheory

I currently work for a state govt. I started out in the agency in a non IT position 6years ago. This seems to happen a lot in our state govt.

They don't pay well enough to get highly qualified people. And since the budget crunch of the last few years, our benefits are terrible.

What happens is you have someone like me start doing the job, learning more and more, then eventually, they leave for a higher paying private sector job.

For instance, we had a secretary several years ago who was doing network admin work (still secretary pay). She continued to train and get certification, she was offered a job in the private sector making 4X her old pay (she took it).

But, from what I hear, it depends on the individual govt. agency you work for. Some pay good, some not. But they ALL have "red tape" and regulations. Pay raises are decided by the state legislature and the governor. Over the past 3 years, we have had ONE 2% raise.

by queenken

The "Get your foot in the door and explore the opportunities" verbiage was given to me during an interview. However, once you are in... then you begin to see the compensation hoops you have to go through and the up hill battle that ensues to obtain a raise and a promotion. In these economic times... having a job worth holding on to is a good thing. But it would be better if the pay were more comensurate with what you brought to the table.

by queenken

I have just begun working in govt sector. I'm finding there is a lot of shrinkage in the pay structure. benefits are more expensive, and exempt exempt employees made 2 take leave 4 partial days wkd? In private sector that is not the case.

by queenken

Also, there is a large populus of advance degreed personnel who's salary is not comparable to those with similar degrees in the private sector. I would really be interested in an apples-to-apples comparison.

This discussion is closed to new replies.