Discussion Locked

Question for those who like Win 7 and Windows in general

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Before I get to my trick question, I want to say a couple of things.

From wikipedia, a definition which is very good:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operating_system

quote

An Operating System (OS) is an interface between hardware and user which is responsible for the management and coordination of activities and the sharing of the resources of the computer that acts as a host for computing applications run on the machine. As a host, one of the purposes of an operating system is to handle the details of the operation of the hardware. This relieves application programs from having to manage these details and makes it easier to write applications.

end quote

I've been away from TR for a few weeks, mostly to do with research etc for a fiction book I'm writing. I return to find a flurry of articles and posts all in favour of Win 7 and they mostly say "look how great this thing in Win 7 is." Now that's OK, except just about everything being mentioned does NOT come under the heading above, in fact the majority of them are applications that have been built into Win 7 by MS, and thus cutting into the profits of the third party companies that write and sell better versions of those applications, while bloating out the operating system footprint and affecting its performance capabilities. Wasn't the inclusion of certain applications as part of the operating system install what lead to huge fines against MS in the past, because it affected other people's profits unfairly? Oh, well, let's move on.

Now, because all these applications come on the same DVD as the operating system they are being regarded as a useful and important part of the operating system itself, and touted as such.

The big question is - -

Since MS can put applications on the install DVD and say how great the OS is, can I tell people how great my SimplyMepis Linux is because the install DVD I bought for about $30.00 comes with such useful features / capabilities as a full office suite, CD/DVD burning, extensive graphic manipulation, music playing and ripping and editing, video playing and ripping and editing, PDF viewer and creator, text to speech and speech to text, file and hard drive back up process, file archiving and opening (like winzip), web browser, mail client, IM client, firewall, file management, address book, news reader, system monitoring, anti-virus, web page design and creation, fancy 3D desktop display features, drivers for ALL my hardware, and a swag more that I can't remember?

.............

OK, I admit it, I got p'd off by all the posts saying how great the OS was simply because MS had stuffed another application inside it - so I'm saying what you get with Linux - for all those who don't really know - as a way of balancing it out.

I'd rather see a post that says something great about the operating system itself, like 'How it works well on older hardware' - yeah never happen, I know; or, how compatible it is with third party software written for earlier versions of Windows, whoops, another never happen. Sheet, what can they say? Oh play up the fancy pretties most people don't care about, which is what they're doing. Hmm, sad really, isn't it?

Oh, I feel so much better to get rid of all that angst.

16 replies

by .martin.

the amount of articles describing how fantastic this new feature on windows 7 is, and how it is going to change my life, (thinking about it, it reminds me of late night infomercials).

that's why I no longer read anything with windows 7 in the title... (apart from this one :D )

by deadly ernest

if you go and buy the proper hardware, they usually give you suitable software with it to make it work even better than Win 7 will.

However, none of these 'features' are parts of the OS or what should be in an OS. Adding most of these features is kind of like making a new family car with the engine from a huge Mack truck, placing a huge tray on the back and then saying 'Great, see how much extra carry room I now have.' Better to just get a trailer to hook up only as needed.

by dawgit

Did and still does touch screen, as does Linux. Both are in use as POS terminals.
Handwriting Recognition, yup, been around awhile, and yup also done on Linux.
DirectX ??? unnecessary if you don't use Windows.
So, your point is?
It's just another OS.

by charliespencer

"... can I tell people how great my SimplyMepis Linux is because the install DVD I bought for about $30.00 comes with such useful features / capabilities as ..."

I don't see why not. I'd mention that you paid for the DVD only for convenience, and that you could have downloaded the OS and most of the apps for free if you'd wanted.

by tink!

I totally hear what you're saying. I think people are coming to EXPECT all the extras with Windows as an integral part of Windows. The delusion continues to grow so that most users don't know that these features they find useful really are not a part of the OS.

Personally I could give a darn about hopping to the next version of Windows as soon as it is released. They seem to take away the things I use (or bury them) and add things on that I don't give a hoot about.

Things were nice when you knew exactly what applications did what and you didn't have to figure out what Windows could do for you.

by dawgit

That Windows is an integral part of a computer.
"It's a computer, of course it's windows, silly" told to me by a woman using a terminal with a big silly sweet penguin displayed on her screen. :)

by jamesrl

But until you match the ad budget of Microsoft you are XXXXXXing in the wind.

I ran a dual boot XP Vista system for a while. XP handled my old games better, Vista had too much overhead. But my wife and kids like the "useability" of Vista more than XP.

When the "new" version of the game I play a lot came out, I waited till a few others had some experience playing it on Win 7 64 bit. The game ran kinda slow on XP.

So I bought from a friend a newer computer, that had XP on it, and upgraded it to Windows 7 64 bit. I moved some devices from my old comp, like the video and sound cards, the inkjet printer etc.

It was clean, I needed to do no extra work, everything functioned fine without tweaking, with one exception. I now have a 64 bit version as well as 32 bit version of IE, and if I chose the 64 bit, it doesn't work with Adobe Flash, so no You tube. I can live with that, I just launch the 32 bit and go. NO problems at all with software written in the XP era. None, zip zilch. They run faster. Its all good.

I'm certainly no big MS fanboy, I used to prefer Macs, and I've played with Unix and Linux.

But don't take it personally that Windows remains the people's choice. We all know the people aren't always right....

James

by ansugisalas

Meaning, I hear that it folds up into a WinXP license if that's what you want.

Pricey though :p ]:)

by jaqui

bemynerd did.
he responded to YOUR post with the post titled smallprintfinders.

by charliespencer

And I don't get what his response has to do with my post. Clearly a lost and confused soul, wandering the wilds of the net unguided.

by bobp64

I have done a bit of research into Window 7 too - not a lot, but some. What I have found is that W7 seems to be far better received than Vista, but as far as I'm concerned that's like saying that the flu is more well received than smallpox. More to the point. Years ago, in the early Windows days, there were tons of other companies that did indeed write useful applications. One type of such applications was to backup your computer. Eventually, MS bought up several of these companies, incorporated backup as a standard part of the operating system and it has been that way for more than 10 years now.

Now, with W7, many of these useful utilities are once again LACKING in the OS. What this ultimately means is that the TRUE cost of bringing up and using a W7 machine is MUCH MUCH higher than simply purchasing the OS. I now have to go out and PURCHASE all those applications that were included with Windows NT 3.51, 4.0, 2000, and XP. I have yet to add up the amount that this will cost, however, I believe it will far overshadow the cost of the OS alone. In addition, we are most likely thrown back into the problem of having competing applications using many different (backup) format standards and who knows what backup devices they will support.

With the advent of cheap disks, I have taken to simply backup up my system onto portable Terabyte Hard Drives. I have a WD Mirrored portable drive - 2 - 1 TB drives mirrored in case one dies, I'm still covered, and I'm planning on getting an external raid device, something like a DROBO to handle my primary storage needs. I might even consider a RAID 6 device. But, before I do any of this, I need to consider what the backup software for W7 will require and how will I go about managing this.

There's no good reason for Microsoft to have done this. They are far more concerned with the GLITZY look of the GUI part of the OS rather than the basic guts that performs the functions that we all need.

To go even further on my rant, back in the late 90's I was doing some work on Solaris. I was very happy about it's multitasking capabilities. I could do some LARGE file copies, put them in the background, run a large compile in the background, and STILL get useful work done in the foreground (editing, reading email, etc). These days, Microsoft bogs down at the simples file copies. Sure, it is a "multitasking" operating system, however, MS has FORGOTTEN that the USER sitting in front of that screen should NEVER be made waiting while something is going on in the background. I have a quad core i7 920 CPU - that's right, FOUR PROCESSOR CORES, all of which have hyperthreading, so 8 threads can be run simultaneously, installed on an ASUS Rampage II Extreme MB with 6 GIGABYTES of ram, yet, this machine, when pushed, runs slower than my 386 running and old version of Linux, or the machine I used to use running solaris, or, heck, even slower than my 486 that I used to run Windows NT 3.51 and NT 4.0 on!!!

Why is this? Why has Microsoft so bloated the basic functionality that simple tasks required MULTI GIGAHERTZ processors???

All this adds up, not just to wasted CPU time, but to wasted energy, wasted money, and wasted productivity. Shame on you microsoft. You are a virtual monopoly and you are the PERFECT reason why monopolies should NOT be allowed.

Oh, btw, I uninstalled my trial version of W7 from my new machine and am happily running Linux with the FREE Open Office. No more MS for me ever again!!!

This discussion is closed to new replies.