Question Locked

Questions hdd new or used

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I bought two 2.5" Seagate ST500LM030 HDDs. I got the serial number from CrystalDiskInfo and entered it on the Seagate website, but it says the warranty expired in 2020.

How can I find out if these HDDs are original, new, almost new, in good condition, or refurbished?

Is there any way to find out if these HDDs have had their SMART data reset?

When I buy a 2.5" HDD, is it possible to find out if the SMART and reset values ​​have been altered or reset? If the SMART value hasn't been modified or reset, is it necessary to perform a surface scan of several hours to determine the actual mechanical, electronic, and magnetic health?

5 replies

by rproffitt edited

You can test them with the app mentioned to see if they are still functional but my take is that I wouldn't trust them with the LAST COPY OF ANY FILE THAT YOU CAN'T LOSE.

Yes, they were well known to do bad without notice.

I have to be honest with you, these are not worth much here. Maybe a cup of coffee pricing.

by rproffitt edited

"Key Observations
Observed Failure Rate: A report from Q3 2025 by a data storage company, Backblaze, listed the ST500LM030 with an average AFR of 2.38%, derived from 15,345 drive days with zero failures during that specific quarter. The "mean" AFR was also 2.38% with a 95% limit of 7.12%, indicating a lack of sufficient data to pinpoint a precise, low AFR with high confidence.

Intended Use: This drive is a 2.5-inch model designed for laptops and all-in-one PCs, not the demanding 24/7 environment of a data center where the study was conducted. Using consumer-grade drives in enterprise settings can result in higher failure rates than in typical consumer use.

General Reputation: The ST500LM030 uses Shingled Magnetic Recording (SMR) technology, which can make it a poor choice for specific high-write-workload applications like archiving or NAS setups. Some user anecdotes on forums report high failure rates for their specific batches of 2.5-inch Seagate drives."

by kees_b

At Amazon here I can buy this 500 GB HDD for 50 euro and the Kingston 500 GB SSD for 60 euro. I would surely buy the SSD for speed and reliability. Why did you (as apparently a gamer) buy an HDD in stead of an SSD?

Only the seller can answer your first question.

by birdmantd edited

I agree that only the seller can answer the OP's questions. This all comes down to a matter of trust, and there is not likely there is any warranty available now. I don't feel that an HDD is a good choice today for the OP and agree that an SDD is a better choice. Ultimately the OP will have to make that determination no matter the advice offered.

by gamer87 edited

That's a good use for a HDD, even an old one if it passes all tests. But as proffitt says, have at least 2 copies, so you're protected when one fails.

This discussion is closed to new replies.