Discussion Locked

Raid controlers what is the beter choice ?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Hello I have a question. What is the difference between Intel motherboards with integrated raid controllers and let's say for instance the raid controllers on the lowest class of servers by HP. Let's take for example HP ML110. The Intel motherboards are not specifically designed for servers and are desktop motherboards, let's take for example INTEL D915PBL. Does the raid controller on the Intel motherboards offer less reliability, considering that the HP ML110 has an integrated Adaptec raid controler. If the need arises is it a better choice to use an external raid controller on a simple Desktop motherboard.

3 replies

by charliespencer

If the controller is on the motherboard (and can't be disable in the BIOS), you'll have to replace the whole mobo if the controller fails. A separate RAID controller is much faster and easier to replace. In a production server, the time saved restoring a system often is more important that the replacement cost.

Onboard controllers aren't a bad option for a desktop, but I wouldn't use one in a server.

by jdclyde

A raid controller isn't that expensive to begin with.

On-board ANYTHING is going to be slower and potentially can cause more problems down the road.

As you said, if it is a card, you just drop in a new one.

If it is a server that is mission critical, I buy TWO cards, and have one sitting on the shelf. If it dies, I don't want my server to be down for two days while I wait for a new part. The down time costs MUCH more than the parts do. I also have at least ONE spare hard drive as well.

This discussion is closed to new replies.