Discussion Locked

RAID IDE?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Being a volunteer on a school network, My input isn't very pressing. There is someone on a committee that insists RAID IDE(???) should be implemented on the Servers rather than RAID5 SCSI. I, myself, have never heard id RAID5 IDE, plus, IDE is notmade for network servers from what I do know. Could anyone tell me if they've heard of it? And could someone fill me in as best and specifically as they possibly can on the differences between SCSI and IDE?

6 replies

by shanghai sam

SCSI is a hard drive. it runs at a faster speed and all that. But I have heard of IDE in a server but in the form of EIDE. It runs as fast as a scsi. little slower. You can have anything in a server. really. i mean anything. all you really need is the software and minimum requirements. RAID 5 IDE??? Raid = redundant array of independant disks.. raid 5= striped volumes with parity.. you can set it but... what ever..
if you have any questions... look at the MS server book... My e mail is Grondin_e@yahoo.com if you have any questions. please however identify yourself.

by shanghai sam

In the past, only SCSI drives were considered "server class" so most of the development work went into RAID controllers for SCSI. And even today, hardware RAID5 using SCSI drives is the gold standard for servers. This is primarily for performance reasons but also because you can hang many more drives on a SCSI array than on an IDE array.

However, Adaptec has now released a RAID controller for IDE drives. IDE drives will not offer the performance of equivalent SCSI drives but are considerably lower in cost. For a drive array that will never have more than 4 drives, it's an acceptable alternative for situations where the SCSI solution is not affordable. But in my opinion, it would never be preferable.

paul

by sysadmin

There are IDE RAID boxes out there that have the harddrives connected as IDE but the controller in the box is SCSI. They will support RAID 5. The drives should be 7200 rpm. This is as good as SCSI RAID's but cheaper. Why pay $300.00 per drive (3min for RAID 5) when you can get a IDE drive for $175.00.

by steviec

I think that one of the most important things to take into consideration when talking about the varying options for implementing RAID is availability.

It is not possible to hot-swap IDE drives, therefore the server would have to be taken down. Although being in an education environment this might not be as important as it would be in a business one.

by tci_cto

Check out the IDE raid controllers from Promise and High Point Technologies. In recent times MANY mobo mfg's have been incoporating the ide raid chipset controllers into the board itself. I have bnuilt quite a few small to medium size business classservers with up to 4 seperate drive array's (12 hard drives). Typically, the hard drives need to be the same size for the array to function properly. My current choice of Mobo has been the Epox d3va, a dual PIII socket 370 board that is a solid performer. If you have any questions Email me @ tci@relaypoint.net, Good Luck!

by jessie

I am running a WinNT network and have 2 NT servers running Raid arrays on IDE drives. I have one NT server running a RAID 5 stripe w/parrity with 3 80GB maxtor drives. in NT you can do this in the disk Administrator it is quick and cheap and very reliable. you can do anything from basic mirroring to full stripe. IDE drives are cheaper(usually much bigger) and the whole process of setting up the array takes about 1 min(+ sync time, which can be several hours on large drives).

This discussion is closed to new replies.