Discussion Locked

Rant of The Week - OS as a religion? - 06/25/08

0 helpful
57 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Here we are once again, back for this week's rant of the week, where you all get to hear me rant, whine, stomp my little foot, and just basically give my feeble opinion (as little as that might be). :-)

This week's topic is something I see often, not just here at TechRepublic, but across several forum boards I either frequent, or moderate. I have no doubt you have seen the very same thing, or might have even found yourself engaged in such heated discussions. I am referring to ones personal choice of an operating system.

A discussion about ones operating system of choice can turn just as heated and ugly, as a discussion over politics and religion.

Like many things in life, whatever operating system one chooses to use is a personal preference. It in no way has any affect on another's personal preference, but some, seem to feel it does. If you happen to prefer Windows, and your neighbor prefers Linux, your choice and your neighbor's choice, does not affect one another's life in any sort of form what so ever. So I've always found it amazing how some feel it's their right to launch a personal attack on someone else simply because their personal preference of an operating system, does not match their own.

We each have our own preferences with our own likes and dislikes. We each have different needs, wants and desires on which operating system will best fulfill what we need, want and desire. No operating system is perfect; however, each operating system, depending on your own needs can be better or worse than another operating system. For example, if you are wanting something that you can just turn on, browse the web, maybe shoot off a few emails - Windows more likely will be your operating system of choice. If for example you want something you can tweak to your little hearts desire that isn't full of bloatware and don't mind a little learning curve - a Linux type will more likely be your operating system of choice. If you are wanting something that will handle large amounts of graphics for editing - a Mac might be your operating system of choice.

What ever the reason behind the "why" you chose the operating system you are currently using, that choice in no way infringes upon another's right to choose what they are using. So why do some feel they have the right to insult another's choice? Is it because it is a personal choice, and when it comes to ones own personal choice they feel if someone has an opposite view it is somehow an attack on their own choice?

In some ways when reading some of these "heated" discussions, it's like listening to two children in a school playground. "My daddy is better than your daddy", "My daddy can whip your daddy!", blah blah blah. The only difference is that these are not children but grown adults acting like children.

I personally prefer Windows, that is my choice. You don't have to agree with my choice or even like my choice. That is my "personal" choice. If your choice is a Mac, that is *your* personal choice and does not give me the right to push my own personal preferences upon you, nor does it give me the right to insult or attack you over your own personal preferences simply because it's not what I prefer.

And that folks is all I'm going to say about that, except - Please, lets respect another's right to choose what they prefer to use, instead of attacking them simply because your personal preference differs from your own.

-Tammy :-)

57 replies

by the scummy one

for Vista users, they all s**k. They keep insisting that it is
'easy' and 'better'. Oh and don't get me started on Office
07 and that POS ribbon cr@p........

Ok, I guess that falls in line with your rant too!

I agree with you on this. Too many people want to 'push'
their beliefs or favorite things onto others.
Personally, I believe that I can make mention of different
OS's and have at least a little knowledge on the subject,
however, the one using the system must be comfortable
with USING it, so why force something that they do not
want? If they are not a tech type, and use Win at work,
and dont want to learn something else, all that you will do
by pushing MAC or Linux onto them is cause lots of stress
(unneeded at that).

Currently I am on a (ughh, should I admit it?) Vista
system. Next to me is XP, and at my feet is PCLOS (KVM
with Vista). They are all used regularly. Sometimes it is
for the same or similar tasks, sometimes completely
different stuff.

P.S. -- No strip tease tonight??? Table Dance???
Anything???

by Tammy.Cavadias

..just for you...

Hope you didn't blink cause if you did, you missed it :D

I am with you about Vista, I personally do not care for it, so I use XP (and I plan to hold out as long as possible before having to upgrade). My son however loves Vista, so that is what he's using.

I do have a laptop that I don't use anymore (it still runs though), that has Windows 95 (c) on it. I loved that system. I skipped Win ME and went right to XP when I got a new desktop several years back.

-Tammy :-)

by seanferd

You've just coined yourself a phrase. Iiiiiii like it.

I liked Win 95c as well. It was much better than 95a, and I held off a long while before finally running 98se. XP hit SP2 before I used it myself.

I still occasionally feel the urge to fire up 95 on an old box. I don't know why...

by danlm

tasks.

Ie: I think windows is the worst choice for a server that any business can make.

But desk top... Only use windows.... Im too lazy to even attempt the migration. It's my fault, nobody else's.

I will say I go through more p.o.s. dialogs with myself with windows more then I do with any unix machine I have ever worked with... But... I still use it my primary desk top with no plans to move off it... So, that is all that counts with that discussion.

Dan

by jaqui

if it isn't available as source code, it's malware.
since malware is ONLY spread as executables. :p

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I don't care what people use, as long as they use it as safely as possible. For users of OS's less prone to virus and malware than Windows, unless I am grossly mistaken you can still pass the cr@p along by forwarding an infected email to the next id10t in line. So practice safe computing habits, no matter what OS you run!

Only barely on topic - my barely related pet peeve. Thanks for the opening! ;)

edit (to acquire daily quota using only feeble excuse that clarification seems called for)

This is not about software and OS, it is about good, general, safe computing habits.

by w2ktechman

you mean just because I am in Linux and dont get the virus, I will still spread it??? :0 :0
Oh Boxy, tell me it aint so! :0

LOL -- I actually wonder how many people would think that my statement is true ?:|

by boxfiddler Hot topic

are you telling me that I am grossly mistaken? If so, I need to edit that. Just as well, I probably don't my quota of edits for the day. :D

by jaqui

instead of complaining to us because the av software that runs on linux is useless, complain to the av software companies.

demand linux / *bsd / osx / *x workstation versions to help catch them nasty windows bugs from spreading.

tell them that until they have versions for every os, thy are guilty of promoting the spread of viruses.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

when have I ever complained that the a/v software that runs on Linux is useless?

by jaqui

I contacted Comodo, McAfee and Grisoft.
[ symantec has no way to contact them for non product specific / non customer comments, Trend Micro has no contact / support links at all on their site. ]

sent them:

A simple question:

Why don't your products run on any os other than MS' offerings? malware is SPREAD via any os even if it can't infest the host.

To truly stop virus / trojans / worms the anti malware software should be running on all systems, without regard for the os on the system.
[ it could be said that by not having versions for all operating systems the anti-malware software providers are actively promoting the spread of malware ]

Jaqui

by Tammy.Cavadias

I am all for "common sense" per se - keeping whatever system you happen to use updated for not only your own security but others as well, but also to NOT go around forwarding tons of emails, especially if you aren't running some type of virus scanner. I get these several times a month from friends - they forward me junk and they aren't running any type of virus scanner - drives me nuts. But the one thing that really irks me with forwarding messages is when they forward to tons of people and all our email addies are shown - use BCC thats what its for.

-Tammy :-)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

what is bcc: I've never looked closely enough at my window (and don't intend to start now!) to see anything like that. I only blindly point and click, I can't find my glasses, it's too much like work, why can't 'they' make it easier, it's all so confusing...

Where [b]are[/b] my meds? :D

by jaqui

mac's aren't as great as they say.

after all, if they were, trying to receive a call in skype on a mac with no microphone wouldn't crash skype on a mac. it doesn't on linux.

;)

just don't expect me to fix anything on your windows systems, I'm a *x person :p

by boxfiddler Hot topic

what you meant by 'think that' and what I read as 'think that'.

Must be a 'guy' thing! :D :D :D

edit the durn title

by boxfiddler Hot topic

but a complaint about thoughtless users (and stupid email habits).

Guess I better find a better way to put it. At least I'll get that edit quota! :D

by w2ktechman

I originally read it as intended. But Jaqui made me read it wrong (or right) from a different point of view

by jaqui

you didn't know that the few av apps for linux are only 38% effective so are not worth using?
[ I asked about clam, the one most distros include as a package, the clamwin was the only av running on linux tested and it was 38% effective in a study done last year.

all av apps only find malware for windows, doesn't matter what os they are on. :/

hmmm, mybe MS should look at that fact, since it points out that they really screwed up. :D in windows design.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

digging for a/v for Ubuntu is a bite. Almost irrelevant while a semester is up and running, I guess. XP is up most of the time since I teach MS Office classes.

Ain't got enough oomph at the moment to push XP and Office 07 at this pace in a virtual machine.

by jaqui

the makers of AVG do have thier commercial apps available for all operating systems.
[ avg 7.5 for linux/bsd, unix, osx are available. ]

haven't heard from comodo yet. ]:)

by charliespencer

is with people who unnecessarily inject useless 'recommendations' into a discussion of a problem specific to a single OS.

"Hey. My Windux 2004 system won't defibrilate the Gomkulator key any more."

"Your problem is your running Windux 2004 which is for n00bs and Id-10-t. You should run Constipated Cat X 12 instead."

or

"I wouldn't know, I don't use Windux 2004."

That's not helpful. If a person has a problem with a specific piece of software, a blanket recommendation of a completely different product is not helpful. Neither is an admission that you don't use it; if you don't, maintain silence.

by jaqui

if you read the tags for those discussions, the Original Poster tagged it with linux / osx /macos, thereby asking for those useless comments.

if it is only about windows, then it should NOT have a tag for any other OS on it.
[ that particular stupidity of people when tagging is what makes tagging useless. ]

example 1:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=101&threadID=267447&start=0

example 2:

removed since the report as spam had it removed already. Good response time on that.

by charliespencer

I've never noticed the tags before you mentioned them. I've added them when starting a discussion, but I never looked for them before. It took me a couple of minutes to even locate them; small blue text on white doesn't exactly leap out.

by w2ktechman

if it was done in 'fun' (with emoticons)???

I know, I have done it a few times. Usually with either additional info or another post following it.

So, have you tried Windux '04 or Constipated Cat X 12??? How do you know one is better than the other??? :^0

Hmmm, I dont think that Ill try Constipated Cat, it sounds soooo very messy :0

by charliespencer

I talking about the kind of post designed just to make fun of the original poster and to trumpet the subsequent poster's OS of choice.

by Tammy.Cavadias

>>Hmmm, I dont think that Ill try Constipated Cat, it sounds soooo very messy

Unless you install the "juicy" pants plug-in

-Tammy :-)

by jdclyde

it is fairly clear that they didn't work out as intended, so are being downplayed...

I still miss "categories".... I was MUCH more involved in the more technical side of TR when I could weed out the losers with the same windows password hack request and focus on issues I gave a rip about.

by jaqui

do what I started doing to.

call them stupid for abusing the tags.
screwing the finding of content that is relevant up by abusing the tags

then point out they only needed one or two tags, not all of them.

and don't actually give any answer to the question.

by jaqui

since I did report as spam when I read the post, I'm only surprised it was yanked as fast as it was.

by jaqui

decide to start poking them specifically for bad tagging habits.

it makes the browse discussions / questions useless when they abuse the tags.

TR can't lock windows and linux tags as exclusive to each other, since as you well know, networking the two operating systems together can be a pain in the butt, so they can be used together for a real question / discussion.

but an outlook problem?
nothing to do with linux

excel issue?
not linux related.

by Tammy.Cavadias

a *blind* carbon copy.. it should be easy to see for those who are *blind* :p

Sorry I took.. ummm.. borrowed your meds.... I needed some and was out of my own

-Tammy :-)

by gsg

I'm an equal opportunity person. I use mostly Windows because that's what the vendors have required and that's what our desktop standard is at work. However, that's changing.

We recently got a major system that's exclusively Linux, and I'm replacing 2 systems that are Unix and Windows with a single killer Unix set up. I'm even looking into getting a play workstation at work loaded with Linux. We're evaluating going to Linux for our desktops, and I want to start testing my apps to make sure they work properly.

At home, I run Windows because I narrowed my choice down to 2 laptops and the one that came loaded with XP was a better laptop and was cheaper. Because I buy through my employer, I avoid the bloatware, and can take advantage of our discounts. I also buy my Office products through our EA for $20, otherwise I'd be going with Open Office, or some other Open Source solution.

by hal 9000

If it ain't easy to do or takes more that 0 Clicks it just doesn't get done.

I once tried for 6 months to get in and renew his AV Package and he consistently just wasn't there/didn't turn up because he had more important things to do till he got a notice from a group that he is a member of informing him that he had a Infected Computer then it had to be [b]Fixed[/b] yesterday. I really felt like blowing the entire platform away and doing a clean new install of his product and then tell him [b]That's what Happens when you don't make the time to do it right.[/b] Instead I just suggested to him to get a surgical Glove cut off 1 finger and place it over the Ethernet Cable before plugging it into the NB.

[b]Safe Computing[/b] ever since and I saved him money for an ISP as well because he doesn't need this any more. :D

It's not just Home Users who don't know what they are doing most computer users don't realize just how dangerous it can be to have a Infected Computer. But then again this same person would ask how do you cure your Computer of M S when you send a E-Mail with the MS shorthand telling them that this months Updates are safe to install. :^0

Col ;\

by hal 9000

I know people who swear by ME though I personally think that they are crazy they like it.

Just goes to show people will accept anything if they have no idea that there are better things out there though. :0

When I first looked at it I could only stand 10 minutes of a Clean Install of ME before I threw the Install Disc into a corner and have never seen it again even after the move. :D

No loss there at all though.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

I have to test Vista and I even bought a Copy well 5 Volume Licenses before it became available to OEM sales.

I didn't think that it would be of any use and I was proved right given enough time. But it wasn't the nicest thing to play with back then but I had to see what would be required for it to run on and what Software would run on it. The finial answer has been Very Little so far that is Mission Critical for Business, though if you don't mind going bankrupt it looks Prerty. :D

OH BTW what have you done to Boxy she is making a lot of strange posts about a 31 KBS Internet connection?

Col ]:)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Tracking page loads at slow dialup speeds, in an effort to prove that graphics slow things down considerably for dialup users.

Took twice as long for pages with graphics to load, as it did for pages without. I did get one irritated email from an OP who chastised me for posting off topic. Life is rough now and then. :D

etu

by hal 9000

At the End of the Financial Year and is calling it a Holiday. Guess I'll have to Goggle [i]Holiday[/i] to find out what that is but I think I now understand somewhat.

Boxy has become part AU Aboriginal and doesn't see the need to work any more so life is good for her. :D

Now who broke TR?

Or is Sonja trying to get Swag for making me post an answer under the wrong user account? :0

Col

by seanferd

And here, I was thinking: A less-classy frequenter of strip-joints. Silly me!

If Polacks, why not Slovaks (Slow-Polacks, according to some of said ethnic background).

Slow-Pole Scum. :D

This discussion is closed to new replies.