Discussion Locked

RE: Seriously...? and RE: This is an old argument

0 helpful
25 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
article root

25 replies

by Member 19291532

But I'd hope you noticed that by the time you posted this last response, I had abandoned this thread. It was hijacked and quickly became beyond salvation. You've understood the thread completely, including the head-line of the original post. If you would like a fuller explanation of my perspective of what went wrong here, I am very easy to get a hold of and would be glad to elaborate. I appreciate your contributions and insights in my thread - I am sorry that your experience in the forum was less than satisfactory.

by Member 19291532

I'm done with it. Turning over a new leaf for 2012...

Not really... but not going to play in the acid-bath with the other bad-kids of TR, at any rate - and that thread was full of all the juvenile delinquents your mother warned you never to play with.

I was really interested in discussing the implications of the bio-modified Bird flu more than getting caught up on Linux - too... but c'est la vie.

by hal 9000

To what is effectively Weaponise the Bird Fly Virus was a incredibly stupid thing to do.

I'm wondering why it was done and much more importantly who paid to have it done.

After all the Genetic Engineering Involved isn't something that could be done on Mum's Kitchen Table so it's complex, requires special equipment and knowledge and to me seemed a pointless exercise.

Unless of course it was something done to make a weapon and the crowd involved couldn't make a Cure so they are asking everyone and their dog to help them fix the mess that they have made.

The H1N1 Virus is nasty to begin with and changes all to quickly by itself so why would anyone want to help it?

Col

by ansugisalas

What's with the societal collapse?
Stephen King is the master of pulp fiction, not of prediction or description of actual events. Society doesn't collapse from a disease. They rebound.

Point to the mechanism that a contagion may cause societal collapse, I claim that they do not exist; beyond killing off all the bearers of the most vital skills, and no 50% is going to do that.

by charliespencer

For the record, I think this research should be kept unpublished. Unlike computer malware whit may be indirectly fatal, biological agents act directly on living organisms.

by ansugisalas

It hasn't been reported that it has been weaponized, that would take a lot more than this basic research.
This, I believe, was an experiment of simple threat assessment: After all; disease countermeasures are expensive on a societal level, scientists have to be able to tell heads of state that "Oh, yeah, this one is worth it".

So these guys poked the H1N1 with a stick, to see how angry it could get, and how quick.
It got real angry, real quick : so now they can have some attention when the next outbreak comes.

I don't think they actually need to keep live specimens of the various mutated strains; they just need to sequence their DNA so they can make a test-kit for finding out how close a natural outbreak is to "perfect storm".

This is all worth doing. Just like the people with honey pot labs, trying to catch new vectors and payload types.

by hal 9000

What's stopping the H1N1 Virus at the moment is the fact that it's not all that easily transmitted so there are yearly outbreaks particularly in Asia that are devastating but fairly limited in size and the local Caged Birds are all but exterminated when these outbreaks occur.

With the GE Strain of the Virus it's effectively a Weapon and that is what I find concerning. Even if all forms of that Mutation is destroyed it's still known that it can be made and as has already been said it's Impossible to Stuff the Genie back in the Bottle after it's let out so the danger now is far more present that it was before this was developed. ;)

Sure I agree it needs a Vaccine or some form of treatment developed but developing this particular strain was still a silly thing to do no matter the reasons behind it. :0

Currently with the known outbreaks of this Virus over the past years we know how devastating it is we don't need to improve it ourselves. The same as the Variation of TB currently circulating in Papua & New Guinea it's nasty and far more devastating that we have seen previously and with the Poor Treatment Regimes in P&G it's fast developing a resistance to the drugs we use to treat it.

Or the Hendra Virus currently in Queensland & Northern NSW. It's downright nasty, very fatal to most who catch it always bad news for Horses in the area and no known treatment yet though there is talk of a Vaccine this year maybe. You don't want to poke those things with a stick to see just how bad they can get even the Bureaucrats have to accept that they are really bad as they are we don't need to help them along.

Computer Modelling if they Mutate to certain Transmission Vectors are acceptable and even necessary but actually making the thing that way isn't. ;)

Col

by ansugisalas

Without a high-category lab, this is going to be like a font of nitroglycerin: no trigger, just inevitable spontaneous detonation.
To weaponize this, to create it in a form that can be released, or not released, at will... that's going to be extremely difficult.

by ansugisalas

Anyone can write code with just Notepad++...
Nobody can write DNA.
And no terrorist organization has ever had access to a category 3 lab, and even a cat3 lab might be insufficient for putting this knowledge to deliberate use.

by hal 9000

Prior to September 11 2001 no Terrorist had access to a Commercial Airliner and people to fly it but that certainly changed.

The same applies to Dirty Bombs or Chemical/Biological Weapons just because they haven't previously had access to the places where these things could be made doesn't mean things will always be that way.

Currently there are at least 2 countries with the capability to make Fuel Rods for a Uranium Reactor who are not part of the mainstream Global Community and if you want to count those countries that have this ability and are not signatories of the Non Proliferation Pact that number is far greater.

Besides the real possibility here is that a small amount of that Live Virus is acquired and then grown by people who are willing to use it for their ends. If that was to happen a Category 3 Lab isn't required and to be perfectly honest Mum's Kitchen Table would do the job quite nicely though that Kitchen Table would need to be in the middle of nowhere and you would have to be willing to accept those growing it dying. Unfortunately with the way that things are nowadays that???s quite possible.

Col

by ansugisalas

Of course, terrorism is more about the thought than the effect, I guess...

Weaponizing it is difficult... and if they did it suicide-bomber style, they'd need to have a lot of suiciders gathered in one place, with relay carriers standing by to take over "the flame".
A plot like that is harder to keep under wraps than a handful of pilot-trained whackos. Especially since everybody involved will know for sure that it's likely to eventually hit their own families, too.
Odds are, there will be leaks and telltales.

by charliespencer

While terrorists may not have access to the necessary tools, many governments have show their willingness to hire the capabilities to build nuclear weapons. The tools to tinker with DNA are cheaper to obtain, the knowledge can also be hired, and the payload delivery is easier and potentially more devastating.

by Member 19291532

Because the weapon will not discriminate between friendly and enemy targets once it is in the wild.

There are a few nations ruled by cults of personality or theocratic whack-jobs where this could conceivably be something they would welcome - but you would think that saner heads in their government and military organizations would prevail.

But that doesn't mean that there aren't organizations with access to significant resources who might not attempt this and succeed. I don't think the plot needs to be as complex as Ansu suggests in his post, "not very dangerous, really" - above. You don't have to have relays. You get 15 single men with no families and a deep ideological or religious driver to infect themselves and hop onto airplanes travelling through major world hubs with significant layovers - they walk around the airport mall, eat some Cinnabons, go to the rest room, coughing and sneezing... 4 or 5 layovers before they drop, each one potentially infecting thousands, tens of thousands at each leg of their journey, each of those infected likewise doing the same.

Let's change it up. Forget Stephen King. Watch the graphic at the end of the recent "Rise of the Planet of the Apes". But 15... 30... 300 original vectors for the disease instead of one guy from San Francisco.

Ansu has a lot of faith in the checkpoints, safeguards and competency of global society to put a leash on this. A LOT more than I do.

by ansugisalas

If you have to get a large amount of viable (very very hard to verifiably do), powder-form (very very very hard to do) viral agent, which doesn't leak out before the trigger is pulled (very very very hard to do)... then you need an extremely advanced facility.

by Member 19291532

As Hal pointed out...

It is effectively weaponized the minute it was engineered.

The delivery mechanism is easy. You engineer the mutated version, infect humans, and send them out with tickets hopping the globe. They're the delivery vector.

You're over-thinking this. I'm not talking about weaponization for traditional bio-chemical state-level warfare with time tables and attack strategies. I'm talking about a kid with a bag full of automatic weapons on a college campus spraying indiscriminately and with the idea that he isn't going to be walking away himself once he is done. Metaphorically speaking.

by Member 19291532

But you've answered my repeated question there - here.

You don't think 50% is the thresh-hold. I think it may very well be. I don't think we can get past that difference in opinion. We've never seen it happen before in the scenario as described here - so it is conjecture on both of our parts short of someone breaking out a computer model that supports one or the other of us.

by ansugisalas

You think so. Make an experiment: Find a list of titles for a company of 1000 employees. Then "kill off" at random fifty percent of them: Then look at the remainder; how much does it take to irrevocably destroy a company function? Not inconvenience for the period of remaining staff retraining new people, but to take it to "nobody knows"?
Disregard upper management; they hold their position due to authority, not skills. Whoever is appointed to replace them will get the authority in getting appointed. Finding out where the key to the executive liquor cabinet isn't a skill.

Then look at society: That's not a thousand people, is it? That's such a mind-boggling degree of redundancy that you can't even begin to evaluate it.
Fifty percent is NOT enough.
Fifty percent has been done: It causes a flowering of science and arts, and a jump in life expectancy.
Every time.

by Member 19291532

It doesn't help me out if you voice your vote/opinion in the off-topic, "water-cooler" discussion spawned from the original post.

But, maybe that was the intent? Not to get included in the very contentious main thread?

;)

by charliespencer

I read the initial article before there were more than three or four posts. I didn't have an opinion at that time, so I kept my two cents in my pocket. When you opened this 'Take Offline', I revisited the original. By then it had grown to the point where I couldn't figure out where to stick my two cents. (Yeah, I know; let's not go there.) I didn't expect my reply here to garner any responses; now my hoof is stuck in this particular tar pit.

by ansugisalas

You have no comprehension of what a weapon is and is not, Don.
A leaky water balloon is not a weapon.
A crumbling dam up the ravine may keep people from moving next door to you, but not from breaking into your home. It's not a weapon if it cannot be controlled.

Sure, it's dangerous... but it's not a weapon.

You're underthinking this: How do you obtain a viable H1N1 strain? How do you purify and control it while you induce the mutations? How do you keep your crew from dying to a non-airborne intermediary form? It's a mess. And remember, a non-airborn outbreak will tip off the world to danger, and medical staff from the WHO will be called in, who will raise the alarm when they find the stuff's been tampered with.

Once you have it, it's like lighting yourself on fire, then running across town to the fuel depot... it's not in your control at all whether you succeed or fail.

by jamesrl

Life does not stay static during an outbreak.

A) Health authorities clamped down. People with anything remotely similar to SARS were sent for testing, and positive results mean quarintine.

B) Airport screening wasn't totally effective, but it did slow the rate of infection and identify potential carriers.

C) When a city is marked as a plague city, as Toronto was, life changes, people minimize contact, tourists stay away etc. Again the rate slowed.

Most of the SARS deaths were in hospitals, when it killed people who already had serious medical issues. But it didn't take long for the public health system to figure out what was going wrong and respond to it.

by Member 19291532

Find a dead bird and build a culture. Remember - the virus itself is relatively difficult to transmit *prior* to mutation. This makes finding a viable version of the bug pretty easy to come by. The last (fatal) infection in China is thought to be caused by a jogger running through bird-poop. It is EASY to come by the virus and actually easy to MANAGE it once you have a sample of it. The difficult part is to get it to mutate - but it sounds like Dr. Fouchier is bent on taking care of THAT hurdle.

As for the World Health Organization - global governments still can't seem to come to grips with how to monitor Iran's nuclear ambitions and there are great areas of effective lawlessness throughout the globe. Your faith in the WHO being able to quickly identify and clamp down on any rogue organization working to start an Avian flu epidemic seems ambitious, to me. You paint it like there is a whole wing of NORAD with guys sitting around watching a global screens displaying the results of satellites sniffing for any kind of bio-checmical signatures. Once detected, a team of crack commandos is deployed to neutralize the threat. The BioSQUAD! Who has been reading too many pulp novels, now?!?

This discussion is closed to new replies.