Question Locked

Reasons to not let users sign in as administrator

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Howdy,

I was hoping to find a top 10 on this subject - reasons to not let users sign in as administrator, at Tech Republic. Maybe it's here somewhere but I haven't been able to find it. So I request your expertise.

I go through this at work every once in awhile.I have a devil of a time convincing my managers that users should not be allowed to sign in as administrator just because they think they have a need. I have to periodically remind my managers of the dangers. They are semi-convinced for a period of time, but then they tend to forget.

The other thing is that my managers insist on having one administrator login for all computers. I really hate that. Although only "senior staff" are supposed to know the admin login, it doesn't take long before everyone knows it and are doing who knows what to the machines.

I am the 1 tech person for my department and I work closely with the 1 main tech person for the whole enterprise. He and I are in total agreement on these issues but neither of us carries much weight with the managers of my department. They are mavericks and do what they want to. Because they bring in so much money, the higher ups tend to let them do what they want to.

I am not strictly a tech person. That is, I have many other tasks to perform in my department, which is perhaps why I don't carry the credibility that I should have? I'm telling the truth to these people about the dangers of letting anyone sign in as administrator, but again, since there hasn't been a related incident for some time, the managers think that I am paranoid and overprotective of the computers.

So, I am hoping that reasons from you folks, who are fulltime techs, will carry more weight than I do. I am sure that many of the reasons you come up with are the same ones I stress, but coming from you it's valid. Coming from me it's not.

Actually, I like my job other than this vexing issue and would prefer not to quit.

Please, please help if you can. Thanks so much.

Stressed and Frustrated,
storch

11 replies

by dumphrey

a good virus infestation running as admin could either ignore or subvert any AV protection and then proceed to ruin all your data, or get you put on a spam black list....
A malicious user could modify data to their hearts content.
Its the computer equivalent of giving everyone a key to your house as opposed to just knowing how to get there...
Paranoia.... on the internet, THEY are out to get you. Look at SANS statistics for example.
Lists of financial loss due to preventable compromise are good weapons to wield.

Keep reminding them its not "if" its "when". It may never happen, but you have to think like it will, or it will.

by the altruist

VIRUSES
Any program you run intentionally or other wise has administrator rights to your system - including the non-friendly kind.

by the altruist

NOW FORMATTING DRIVE C
The road to Hell is paved with good intentions and bad judgment. Charlie Foxtrots can^H^H^H WILL occur when an uneducated user is given complete access. This includes device drivers, folder structure, and the fleeting whim that "I never use this System32 thing, it must not be important."

by the altruist

THE GIFT THAT KEEPS ON GIVING
Anyone who has your administrative access has admin access to anything you have admin access to. This is not limited to your user profile nor your computer.

by ---tk---

regedit... whats this? I dont think I need it. or what happens when I delete this value, or change a string? I'll give it a shot and see what it does.

by 1bn0

I thought that was listed in the job description under required skillset.

I had a department manager that insisted he wanted all of the user account password for the department server written down and stored in a safe place. So we gave them to him. Then we change ALL of the user account password. He started trying to edit a file, technical document be worked on by our document writer, that he was NOT supposed to be changing. Got pissed he could not get to it. Demanded the passwords AGAIN. Told him he could have them but our policy was that as soon as someone learns a users password the password is changed. NO EXCEPTIONS.

He finally got it through his thick head we were not going to give him access to the servers.

This is the same person who brought in a desktop from home, that he wanted to sell, with the keyboard mouse and monitor STILL CONNECTED because he was not sure he would be able to plug everything back in correctly.

Top 5 reason users should not have admin access.

1. Security
2. Stability
3. Security
4. Reliability
5. Security

by itnews

Hi Storch...

Maybe someone already told you this in a prior post... I'm not sure because I am a bit hurried today so I will get to the point.

First, many people in management are use to telling you how to do something versus what they "want" as an end result. Microsoft puts it best by saying, "Where do you want to go today?" They don't ask, "How would you like us to build Windows today?"

So first, find out the purpose of having all machines logging in as administrator. Usually they will say, "because I have to access John or MarySue's email quickly." or something else where they perceive their is a fire. Find a solution that everyone is happy with.

I finally made an agreement with management that I would make a master password list "for their area" and put it in a directory on the server that is secured. They loved the idea, and never asked me again because the perceived "need" to do that went away.

Other reason not to allow unlimited access:

1. Virus/Trojan's install very easily as an admin account. Company data could be at risk.

2. Identity theft. This could allow harmful communication to other employees, vendors, and competitors though a persons email that never sent that data. The innocent person gets fired while the person assuming their identity at the open machine walks away unscathed.

3. Too simple to install "warez" onto the system or file sharing software like Frostwire, etc. Company can be responsible for downloading of copyrighted materials.
Could result in viruses/trojans (see number 1 )

4. Most corporate hacks occur from inside.
You can google all types of articles on this.

by mamies

5. The unaware user may stumble across confidential data that should not be looked at by their eyes.

6. Users may edit other peoples data maliciously. (sounds hard to believe but IT HAPPENS).

7. People are dumb. They find something they dont know about they will experiment which doesnt always lead to good things.

And also with npascazi point about hacks and Hijacks (point 4.) You someone who wants to control your system administrator access. Everyone else can kiss their administrator privlidges goodbye, they just make them users or delete their account.

Companies can be crippled and even destroyed by people like this.

by storch

Thanks to all of you for your great replies. I'm armed with plenty of good ammunition now.
Oh, I appreciate your humor too. Gave me some good laughs in an otherwise super frustrating day. Charlie Foxtrot, indeed. That is what happens, isn't it?

Cheers!

This discussion is closed to new replies.