What was mentioned in the previous note was true to some extent; when data is added to the drive, old data is overwritten. But, to overwrite it all old data would only occur if several factors were all in place at the same time and you were putting more data on the drive than it originally held... Unfortunately, though, you didn't just erase files, but reformatted the old drive and, from the sounds of it, the old drive was not NTFS to begin with, nor was the opsys WinXP Pro...recovery, even by the data recovery outfits, will be virtually (at best) nil. (The decision as to what "the proper virus scanner for the version of Windows" is a curiousity, but answering it would just spark useless arguing amongst neophytes and hobbyists, who appear to make up the larger sector of "members." )
Chalk this one up to experience, Doug, as well as how you are going to have to handle your customer's dissatisfaction. The blame rests entirely on your customer, not the slightest bit on you. Hindsight is always 20-20 and a 100% data restoration into a seperate partition should really be done to prevent any such future problems. And, yes, you need to have a standard disclaimer in writing that is given to a customer prior to beginning work, that you cannot be held responsible for any loss of data, but that you do your utmost to prevent any such possible loss. You may feel inclined (as I'm certain your customer may loudly expect) to offer some amount of reimbursement, but it's up to you...based upon what you've said (of course that's not real detailed! LOL), if I were you I wouldn't. Good luck in how things go...life will continue on.