Discussion Locked

Registry Cleaners

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have two Registry Cleaners installed in my workstation. One is from 3B Software and the other is Super Utilities Pro from Tech Net. I ran both programs, and oddly enough, Super Utilities indicated 497 registry errors while 3B?s Windows Registry Repair Pro reported 21 errors.

I want to know why registry cleaners report different results after scanning? It is like getting a second opinion from a doctor? Are there any trusted reliable software that actually yield correct results after scanning and removing invalid entries from the registry?

Clifford Salmon

24 replies

by tig2

Like and use CCleaner (www.ccleaner.com).

I think that what you may be seeing as discrepant between the two tools you use has something to do with recursion. In order for CCleaner to pick up everything, you have to run it recursively. That way, you are controlling how bits of programs get cleaned up- a first pass may get rid of a few things, the next pass will find new leftovers, and so on.

It sounds to me like Super Utilities has recursive check built in while 3B's is more like CCleaner.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

in no small part thanks to your recommendation. Love it - it's excellent. I have tried several others in the past, and not been happy with them at all due to the fact that they bung up the registry and cause problems after being run. I had given up on them until reading your many recommendations.

Thanks!

by tig2

I am really glad to know that you find it a good and helpful tool. I would hate to think I sent someone in a direction that totally screwed them up!

by craiglarry9

I use last free jv16 and easycleaner to cull out registry sludge. Both of them from time to time will want to delete good ones, so I keep another freebie installed to catch the mistakes they make. Spybot S&D will stop you and say this is a good and important reg entry, do you still want to delete it? So far it's worked well.

by peter r

CCleaner use for daily practice both as data- & registry-cleaner is near perfect, but for deep digging into serious problems you need a more powerful registry repair unit (maybe more than 1).

by craiglarry9

with jv16 last free and easycleaner, it certainly is not the most powerful. And with spybot S&D it is the meek who shall inherit the earth. Try to think, more conservative is better. Do you need to get rid of EVERY stinking problem? Or do you need to get rid of most and not worry about the small number of those left over.

by peter r

Some report only main key errors, others also subkeys. For rigorous repair you need 2 or more reg.cleaners. Once I tested ~ 30 of them against each other in different ways and found only 4 fairly capable. None fixes all detected errors, in combination maybe 80 - 90 %, depending on search algorhytms employed.

by peter r

It were RegVac,Registry Healer,Windows Registry Repair Pro(don't remember the expensive 4th). Advantage of the first 2 is: no further costs for upgrades. However, these tests are now 2 yrs old, so at present there may be other candidates.

by older mycroft

CCleaner does a good job, as far as it is able - for the remains left over I use Registry Mechanic.

Thay manage a good hit-rate between the two of them.

by helpdeskdude

I have been using Registry Mechanic for a long time and have been very happy. Just started using CCleaner. It seems to do a pretty good job. No complaints, at least not yet....

by danlm

And other then it did some weird crap with dell's preinstalled crapware that I needed to uninstall anyway. I like it.

there are some nice functions there.

Dan

by cdplayer

I use RegistrySmart, Registry First Aid and Registry Repair. They appear to do an adequate job.

by dumphrey

several over the years, what I used most was RegScrubXP, it was okay, and rarely gave a flase hit. Lately, I have been using CCleaner thanks to Tiggers recomendation and others follow up on that. So far so good. It does the trick well.
I also use Free Registry Defrag, which just compacts the reg database after a good cleaning. I have never had a problem from this program. That being said, I do back up my reg befor any cleaning/compacting.

by peter r

JV16 is the 'father'of the advanced powercleaners. Using them to solve some persistent 'hangs'& crashes, I found ~ 1200 additional reg.errors, mostly uninstall-remains but ~ 40 were crucial to solve the problems. From then on I agree about persistent left-overs. Maybe we'd better focus now on other XP (& other OS)lacks in optimization like registry disorder, pagefile fragmentation, RAM fragmentation and OS-database disorder. Try out e.g. NTRegOpt or Free Reg. Defrag,PageDefrag or Hare 1.5.1 and notice the results

by cdplayer

I've use PageDefrag and I found it to be quite useful when I had my old computer which had very little memory and a large pagefile.

I am interested in hearing what others have used and their impressions. Maybe starting a new thread titled OS optimization tools would kick this discussion off to a good start.

by peter r

I agree with proposal, but our editor first should open this new subject, I guess.
Furthermore I think that some preparation will favour the discussion's relevance.
Is it, in that context, possible/permitted to insert some website-links here ?

by cdplayer

I have used JV16 as well. I think it is a great tool in the hands of someone who knows what they are doing. JV16 can be a sleg hammer if you do delete/repair the wrong thing. BTW, I have not not use a current version of the software for quite sometime. So things may have changed.

by cdplayer

No, but from what I have read it sounds interesting. Have you tried it? If so what do you think of it?

by cybersecurity

yes I have and its very good, ya can download the full up version for free; 30 days, see for ya self. I bought into it yrs ago.

by tig2

Just enter the page URL from hhtp:// and the board will create a link. For long links, you can use Tiny URL (http://tinyurl.com) and convert the link.

I use a tabbed browser and will most commonly go to the place I want to refer you to, copy the address line, open another tab to Tiny URL, convert, and post.

Tech Republic in a non-moderated, self policing forum for the most part. The peers work together to keep discussions in check... for the most part.

Any questions you have about the site can likely be addressed in the FAQ.

by don.bouchard

There are no such things as registry cleaners that does anything to help a system. The truth is that the registry is like the pagefile and is in constant changes! Those so called Registry Cleaner programs displays all the files that "were removed" when installing the operating system. A person who knows his her way around the run: "regedit" can search a program that just got removed so to removing some of the folders emptied out and left there hanging for nothing; but, in case re-installing would quicken the process. Nothing else matters in there. Wasting time on something that cannot be helped that the system processes itself. Adding such software or only dampens the other software installed. Best clean up job possible is add remove program and find which one is slowing the system and then accomodate and configure it or remove it! Thats the ticket along with Auslogic diskdefrag is faster but not any better than system defrag already installed with the program. I love it and use several times a day. Quick and easy and keeps a system smooth running for months on! Do not fight the system, join it!

This discussion is closed to new replies.