Discussion Locked

Remind me not to take a dinner invitation from you...

0 helpful
55 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
article root

55 replies

by papa_bill

Yes, It is perfectly legal in most US states to shoot anyone who is threatening you (nature of threat not presumed) NO MATTER WHERE YOU ARE.
Most home invasion victims do not survive partly because they don't generally carry their gun while at home and may die trying to access it.
Most home invasions do *not* occur during late night, since many homeowners keep a gun under their pillow.
And why should you fear being shot simply because I carry? Are you going to attack me?
Ansu I don't generally take an adversarial stance with you, I have usually agreed with you in the past especially as regards the sad state of education in this country. However, it seems you have taken what Americans will call a "fairyland" attitude toward our stance on private access to firearms.
Our experience (like it or not) with social inequality has placed us at a level of fear from attack seldom seen in other countries. at least from what I can see. Drug use and the general fear of drug users fuels that fear.
Furthermore, what we learned in the Revolution taught us that we cannot repel tyrants with a standing army, but must rely on our ability to draw on our on forceful resources has firmly instilled in us a reliance on firearms that few other nations can grasp. We are accused of invading other countries that we see as potential rather than actual enemies, but perhaps (speculation) this arises from the beginning of WWII. and the attack on 9/11.
Some say we all want to be John Wayne. That's backwards. John Wayne was imitating us.

by ansugisalas

but about a specific nutcase who will not acknowledge any need for a balanced response.
The kind of loonie which gives the responsible gun owners a bad name. I perfectly understand the need you feel to have means of self-protection. I am definitely not attacking that. If you're a sane, well-balanced person with due education on their use, you're probably safe with a gun. However, Rick there was saying some things that lead me to unavoidable conclusion that he is not perfectly sane, and is certainly not a well-balanced individual, and his other obnoxious behavior on that thread provides further evidence.

Now: Becabill, sadly I have quite a long trip ahead of me if you were to invite me over, so it might be difficult to make it. :( It would have nothing to do with your weapons, in fact I trust you on needing them, and that I'd probably be safer as your guest on account of them. Rick is another matter, he's apparently short a number of shingles - and crazies don't need firearms to be dangerous - often it is exactly their lack of reasonable responses which makes them dangerous.

by charliespencer

"Our experience (like it or not) with social inequality has placed us at a level of fear from attack seldom seen in other countries."

I don't think I've lived five minutes of my adult life in fear of physical attack. Maybe your experience has you living in fear, but that doesn't make it 'our' experience.

"Furthermore, what we learned in the Revolution taught us that we cannot repel tyrants with a standing army, but must rely on our ability to draw on our on forceful resources ..."

I don't see the possibility of repelling tyrants by armed force as still existing in the US in the 21st century, but that's just me.

by robo_dev

Where I live, in a suburb of a major US metropolitan area, there was a daylight home invasion robbery attempt in our subdivision.

Despite this one event, crime is very low where I Iive. The perception is that America is such a dangerous place to be is often misguided. The number of violent crimes in my city is a half-dozen per year, the murder-rate is zero, and the biggest crime is property theft.

In the robbery attempt, there were two kids at home when the bad guys broke in, so they hid and called 911. Two neighbors heard both glass breaking and also called 911. The first police unit was on the scene in under one minute, and in under three minutes, there were, quite literally, 15 police cars in my subdivision (sounded like WW III with all the sirens).

The K9 unit got one bad guy, and the officers got the other one in the house. No shots were fired, the bad guys were not armed, and nobody got hurt.

I got video footage of the perp vehicle on my home video surveillance system before they committed the crime, one neighbor had already got vehicle description and tag number.

One of my neighbors waved hello to one of the bad guys in their car (they do that here) and the bad guy made the mistake of trying to hide his face inside his hoodie...this prompted her to get the vehicle tag number.

Here the police are VERY very good. Well equipped, highly trained, even polite and courteous. They have a good relationship with the community, have some of the latest technology, and do their job very well. The simple fact that they have overlapping shift changes meant that twice the number of officers were on duty when the call came in. They have high-speed license plate scanners on their police cars and regularly recover lots of stolen cars.

Personally, I take security measures...video surveillance, alarm system, dog, common sense. We also have neighbors who watch out for others and, as I mentioned, a fantastic police force.

My tax dollars pay for these great police, and despite folks who bad-mouth 'the government' and 'the cops', that's not my feeling about it.

Do I really need to keep a keep a MP5 with a flash-suppressor under my pillow or mow the lawn with a .357 magnum tucked into my waistband? No.

I can just punch the code 911 into my iPhone, and I get three or four highly trained and well-armed police officers at my home within a minute or two. That's how it's supposed to work.

Last time I checked, there were no tyrants lurking in the City Hall of my town, nor am I all that worried that my neighbors have no standing army. I'd rather just walk the dog and not drink so much coffee.

by ansugisalas

Best way to start is make sure everybody has access to adequate schooling.
In Finland they have free school lunches, and even in a wealthy place like this the teachers report that some pupils eat like horses on mondays, specifically - they might not get enough to eat at home, making the school lunch extremely important. No such thing in Denmark, but I wonder if it wouldn't be a good idea there too.

Giving the children a break is a good place to start. I don't think that's going to lead to a mentality of entitlement, unlike some other kinds of initiative.

But that's an issue completely unrelated to handguns. I don't think it does any good to create a sense of opposition between gun ownership and social responsibility...

by ansugisalas

but that doesn't mean it pays off to do nothing :p
Start with the kids... there's no twickle down effect, but there certainly is a trickle up effect. Give them kids a proper education and that one square meal a day, perhaps even something worthwhile to do after school. Can't much hurt, can it?

by jp85257

are "that's how it's supposed to work".

It doesn't all the time. In locations with budget woes, police and firemen are stretched to the limit, so your minute or two to wait for police response turns into 15 to 20 minutes. That's how it REALLY works.

by ansugisalas

That's a choice.
Or if not, it's a question of taxation being spent too locally... if all the poor people are crammed into one part of the town, that part of town will have budget woes - and that's not really clever. To say nothing of fair.
Crime has a tendency to cross boundaries, you see.

by jp85257

we need a specific quota of poor people per square mile. But who's to to decide what that quota should be and how do we move poor people to other location to make it "fair"?

Of course, the big question is : Who's going to pay for it?

by robo_dev

I call 911 and the police are there, period.

I saw a suspicious person late at night a couple months ago and called them....within about three minutes come three crusiers up the street, lights off at around 65 mph. They did a perimeter search, verified the threat was a false alarm, thanked me and drove off.

by jp85257

you live in a great community and feel well protected. We get it. Now let's discuss all of those who are less fortunate than you.

by ansugisalas

I especially like that the police, in their efficiency, are also polite and friendly. Once police starts to act like they're under siege, it's a very very bad sign.
Police, I feel, should emphasize the second part of their motto, to serve.
Protection so easily becomes a racket, or jack-booted enforcement.

by apotheon

> Once police starts to act like they're under siege, it's a very very bad sign.

This is the inevitable result of making 98% or so of the job they do the enforcement of laws against nonviolent, victimless "crimes".

by charliespencer

You can't hardly improve on a dog. It doesn't even have to be a big dog. It's not the thought of getting bit that may deter burglars as much as the idea that the barking will draw too much attention.

by robo_dev

I'm thinking of rigging one of the channels of my home CCTV system to a wireless camera on the dog's collar, that could be a lot cheaper than investing in a pan-tilt-zoom camera. It could probably make at least a couple of good 'YouTube moments' as well.

by charliespencer

Make sure you keep the bedroom door closed. Also, cut the feed when it's puppy's 'personal grooming' time.

by robo_dev

The pessimist says you arm and defend yourself against the thugs and criminals who will kill you for a dollar.

The optimist says you fix the education system, the American family, and society as a whole so there are fewer thugs and criminals.

Everybody, I think is somewhere in those schools of thought. There are no magical answers or solutions.

At the end of the day it's all about the choices you make to make it to the end of the day.

by ansugisalas

Can't force people to move, and can't very well dump a trailer park in the middle of well-to-do neighborhoods... that's practically communistic!!!

But money moves admirably... the rich are well served by near-by poor-person living areas being well serviced. Just they don't realize it, and prefer gated communities. The increasing isolation of the rich from the surrounding nation isn't really a viable trend, is it?

by jp85257

Let's do the math:

A .357 and 25,000 rounds of ammo 1,847.50
An AK-47 spec'd out with 25,000 rounds of ammo 6,240.12

Fixing the school system - Start at a trillion dollars and prepare to continue spending into a bottomless pit.

I choose the guns. It's cheaper and you get immediate results.

by jamesrl

Many in the US (not all), believe that public education is the root of all evil and trains kids to be mindless Democratic supporting puppets.

I'm not saying public education there or anywhere is perfect. But flawed as it may be it is still one of the best ways of improving the economy of a country.

by apotheon

What do you do about the fact that public schooling creates an artificial market dominance so that public propaganda -- err, public schooling, I mean -- essentially prohibits the development of superior schooling options for any but the richest?

by santeewelding

We could be looking at our own version of a Black Death sweeping the world and scything livelihoods.

If so, you can live in mine. I'll send you out as emissary to the poor. Report back, if you come back, in your finery.

by ansugisalas

You think it will work to tell people where they can and cannot live?
Doesn't work with immigrants who are easily defined, then why would it work with people not so easily defined? Brand "POOR" across the foreheads? Put bells on their clothes? Or maybe require them to sew a "0$"-patch onto their clothes?

People want to organize themselves, and to live among people whose culture they recognize. It's up to the administrative entities to smooth out the demographic wrinkles... otherwise you'll see wealthy neighborhoods with 0% local taxes and expensive for-profit alternatives (so the those pesky poor can't afford to live there).
Not a good way to stave off the days of wrath.

Fineries, is it?

by charliespencer

If the parents don't consider education important (assuming there are two and not one), it doesn't matter what happens at school.

by apotheon

Given the miserable state of public schooling, the fact that some children prefer school to home is an indictment of the horrifying conditions of their homes -- not an endorsement of the quality of the school. There's a reason so many public schools look like prisons.

by jp85257

Wasn't developing superior schooling options the idea behind creating charter schools?

by robo_dev

I think that's what is called a Catch-22.

Here where I live, the State funds the public transportation system, which provides mediocre service since they are underfunded.

The State argues that the transportation system does not deserve more funding since they provide mediocre service.

Catch-22

Funding of education is not the sole recipe for success, but it's the same concept. If you cut budgets to the point where the quality of education suffers, then the wealthier and more successful parents will send their kids to charter and private schools, much to the detriment of the public schools.

The commitment and involvement of the successful two-parent families is part of what makes a school successful, as well as the support of the community and the overall culture and climate of setting expectations for academic success and achievement. (and you also need leadership, accountability, adequate funding, etc)

When those who attend the public school are those who live in poverty or are possibly from single-parent households, they are at a disadvantage. It does not help either that typically the legislators who fund the schools are wealthy individuals whose children also attend private school, so there is no connection there.

Those who believe in government conspiracies have too much faith in the competence of government.

by ansugisalas

Sorry about that, I know it must have been strange to watch, but I was carrying out an important mission of separating the immoderate from the well regulated. As you can I see I was not unsuccessful.

Not a split and deal though, simply cutting out tumors as I see them. Can't have them spoiling the viable ones, regulation of the mind being my thing - the winters too : doesn't have to be the weather bending to my will, if my will can bend to the weather.

by ansugisalas

This in response to Chad, above :
Someone has to provide the children of the poor with stepping stones to something better. Nonprofits aren't really tooled for running a school. So, what's the alternative for-profit schools for the poor? Doesn't really make sense, does it?

I the public system is well handled, it only means that there will be good schools (public) and more specialized schools (private). There shouldn't be a big enmity between the two, in fact they should cross-pollinate - the private schools can experiment more, and the public ones can follow more documented, research-based routes. The idea that the public and the private must be enemies is somewhat I don't really understand. I mean, there is no real opposition by state-maintained roads and privately financed toll roads. They complement each other.

With schools there are even synergies to be harvested.

by apotheon

> Nonprofits aren't really tooled for running a school. So, what's the alternative for-profit schools for the poor? Doesn't really make sense, does it?

Sure it does. Wherever there's a need, there's the potential for a business model. Remember, you don't have to bill a client directly to make money. TR's entire business model is built around this fact; note that you are not paying for access to the site.

> I the public system is well handled, it only means that there will be good schools (public) and more specialized schools (private).

. . . until the public school system goes through a couple of political generations of changing management, and becomes inevitably corrupted. The best one can hope for after that is temporary, localized resurgences of quality while most of the nation's public schooling continues merrily skipping down the path to Hell with all those students in its handbasket.

> There shouldn't be a big enmity between the two, in fact they should cross-pollinate

. . . and I should have been paid a lot more while I was in the Army, but I wasn't. These things do not tend to improve over time.

Y'know what cooperative development and "cross-pollination" brings to mind? Open source software development. Now, we do have an option for "public" schools that could be good, and this option is arising spontaneously in the world as we speak. It's more accurately "public" than what we know as public schooling today, but the term "public" has been so corrupted and twisted out of shape by propaganda (mostly delivered through the public school system, in fact) that we cannot reasonably use the term "public" to refer to this more-public system without unmanageable confusion. I refer to the "open source" (open content, open curriculum, et cetera) educational resources that are starting to develop online. Many of them are actually free access, too. If you want a "public" school system, that's a good model; what we call the "public school" system today, actually the government controlled indoctrination institutions that embed unwarranted assumptions in the inmates and do their best to crush a child's thirst for knowledge, is anything but a good alternative.

> the public ones can follow more documented, research-based routes.

The way it tends to work in practice is that public schools follow "documented" plans based on a combination of research that is fifty years out of date (at best) and politicial compromises that directly contradict actual educational research, with occasional injections of hypotheses that have not even been tested because they're faddishly popular for a little while (and, once again, politically appealing).

> The idea that the public and the private must be enemies is somewhat I don't really understand.

Given that public schooling as we know it is essentially a bureaucratic empire controlled by petty tyrants with swivel-chair spread and a burning desire for job security at all costs, it should be no wonder at all that the public school system will develop into a system for crushing all competition. As long as government controls the state of education in a given nation, mediocrity is the highest standard to which it can aspire in any systematic manner. This is why people have such touching and inspirational stories of great teachers: they're an absurd rarity, remarkable specifically because they are a fluke, an aberration in the otherwise stable system where true education is not the primary goal.

> I mean, there is no real opposition by state-maintained roads and privately financed toll roads. They complement each other.

Not so much. Political concerns tend to greatly restrict the nature and availability of privately maintained roads.

by ansugisalas

I haven't seen first hand the horrors of which you speak.
But a home with alcoholic violent parents can make pretty bad things look good.
I imagine harder recreational substances may make it look even better.

by ansugisalas

You must have it pretty bad over there.
I wonder why it's not so dismal over here... the Finnish school system is very scientific, not really open to political tampering.
Teachers have university degrees, and follow academic developments on account of their training. They are a bit like an army, they're loyal to the guiding principle, not to the specific politicians who administer things.

Now the Finnish schools are also geared for efficiency (not cost-efficiency, but coping efficiency), and some pupils have a hard time adapting. No such thing as a perfect system anywhere, I guess.

It sounds like too many politicians have tampered with the US public educational system... once a thing becomes politicized, its corruption and perversion is inevitable, like you describe.

by apotheon

> the Finnish school system is very scientific, not really open to political tampering.

I doubt that. Sure, scientific maybe -- but I doubt the curriculum is not open to political tampering, considering it's politicians who exercise ultimate control over the curriculum. Consider the lessons learned in history and economics, for instance. It may be more difficult to identify there -- but if so, it's probably because uniformity of propaganda tends to prevent deviation in thinking patterns from the official line.

by apotheon

My conversations with people who were coping with public schooling in Scandinavian countries suggests that the dysfunctions are different, but no less present. The mark of a good education is that it doesn't really teach the students; it just provides the tools to learn. Ultimately, there's no such thing as externally imposing real education on a person anyway. Either it's sought by the student, or it's replaced with indoctrination.

If things are worse in the States, it's only worse in some areas -- and in those cases, probably as a reaction from the people trying to maintain control against the tendency people (students included) have to question what they're told.

by ansugisalas

So it'd cause an outcry if politicians were to be seen to tamper with it.
That's a cultural safeguard, those can be worn down, but they're better than no safeguards.

Finland is an extremely consensus-driven society : for example it's an unwritten rule that a governing coalition must constitute a majority of the parliament (In the US, imagine if any president's cabinet had to always consist of a mix of representatives of the two parties according to number of seats in the House - not on account of the law, but on account of tradition), this extreme oddity probably has it's roots in the Finnish civil war/independence war. One of the first modern-time battles; the battle of Tampere happened only a century ago. So they are careful with demonizing each other.

by santeewelding

In this case, [i]polis[/i], politic, politics, political.

The consensus about Science is nothing if not political.

by ansugisalas

that's a difficult coin of phrase to dissect.
If you mean that the degree (extent x intensity) of dysfunction is equal, then I think your description of the US public education system suggests differently. I certainly can't recognize what you describe, or anything like it. Give me some examples of what you've heard (of both or either) and I'll have a looksee.
Basic schooling isn't well thought of as a service that can be purchased - it's not.
It's a mandatory task. Children are obliged to perform this task, at the whim of society, as filtered through the actions of the legislature.
Ideally, this task would provide the children with a set of communication tools (language of maths, language of negotiation, language of societal expectations), but mainly it's a chore.
Sort of what a meritocracy would have - you've reached age of majority when you've succeeded in this task.

Chores aren't purchased. People could conceivably pay to be allowed to perform their chore in a specific place, and they can with school, too. There are private schools, but the quality of education at these is not better. They may have different curricula, or different methods, or both. But Finland doesn't have the elite private schools that Denmark (or to a higher degree England) has.

On the other hand, schools in other Scandinavian countries is a bit more progressive, more focused on enabling pupils, and less focused on meeting specific learning goals (my daughter is three weeks into first grade, and they're solving math equations with variables. Ok, the variables are flowers and butterflies, but they are opaque/arbitrary marks [like x, y ...] that correspond to an initially unknown number).

Edit:amount > extent

by ansugisalas

then Hébert
now the Finnish

*Not really the first, you know? But that's not a secret, so I can't let it slip...

by jp85257

Spend my hard earned dollars on ways to protect myself or let the Government steal more money from me to throw into a broken educational system knowing that the money will never reach the people who need it or could do the most good with it.

by apotheon

You seem to have missed when I said "different".

> I certainly can't recognize what you describe, or anything like it.

Try looking for something unlike it -- like different political assumptions baked into every lesson, different misrepresentations of history to suit the current fad in politicization, different ways of training young minds to be pliable to authoritarian dictates, et cetera. I have heard stories of students punished for learning about a given subject beyond how it is taught, for instance, in an attempt to achieve a cult-like ideological isolation. Any nation where people grow up with the notion that "rights" are things granted by government (Who gives the governors the right to dictate rights?), that questioning the dominant historical or scientific model should be punishable by law, or that advocating locally unpopular ideas is not an activity that should be protected from governmental interference is obviously subject to a doctrinaire "consensus" that runs counter to the sort of actual free inquiry that is the mark of a truly educated mind.

Education is not something given to you. It is something claimed. What is given to you is merely rote indoctrination -- pablum meant to produce docile workers, breeders, and dependents. The sense that one needs protection from oneself by the benevolent hand of government is a malaise more insidious and ultimately damaging than any unfortunate effects of the irresponsible application of a free mind.

by ansugisalas

and accepting no given truth unturned.
Of course, mileage may vary.
When I was young, we had no problems seeing the hidden agendas (every teacher has them, they don't usually acknowledge them consciously though), and we had fun challenging them.
Iconoclasty is what our genes demand at that age, if no worse problems present. Like not getting enough to eat (a great way to indoctrinate people is to withhold food) or having to fear for one's life (that's another hook to sink into a person to bring them to heel)... we have an easy time in school over here. As a result we do not grow as hungry for entrepreneurship as you guys, that's a drawback, or tradeoff.
But indoctrination without starvation, sleep deprivation, bodily harm or other dehumanizing techniques just isn't effective.
Ask the CIA why they'd want to keep their prisoners off US soil, and not sign certain treaties.
And those methods are still no good.

by apotheon

I never said that willingly giving hard-earned cash to the government so it could be squandered on corruption and inefficiency was how I tried to work toward a better world.

by ansugisalas

Plenty of little problems, sure.
But nothing that amounts to what you describe.

There are no means for politicians to dictate the hidden curricula.
The hidden curriculum has more to do with the institution educating the teachers, and with how the teachers see their task.
And that goes for teachers at private schools, too.

They all indoctrinate, because that is what they think their job is.

And it's not a diabolically effective master plan... it's simple and easily detected by the pupils, who react against it instinctively, leading to a result rather opposite of intended (if subconsciously so intended).

Maybe I didn't understand your point?

by apotheon

> I just don't see the big problem.

Clearly.

> Plenty of little problems, sure.

They're all "little problems".

> There are no means for politicians to dictate the hidden curricula.

It's strange you think overt dictation of curricula from legislative chambers is the only way to hinder or corrupt the system.

> The hidden curriculum has more to do with the institution educating the teachers, and with how the teachers see their task.

. . . and you seem to understand my previous point, for brief flashes like this, but then it fades.

> They all indoctrinate, because that is what they think their job is.

Somehow, though, you don't see a problem.

> And it's not a diabolically effective master plan... it's simple and easily detected by the pupils, who react against it instinctively, leading to a result rather opposite of intended (if subconsciously so intended).

From what I've seen, there's crude rebellion among some and simplistic acceptance among others, both of which think they're thinking for themselves and the others are mindless idiots, with only the rarest few actually thinking for themselves.

> Maybe I didn't understand your point?

I'm really not sure. Maybe you're just in denial.

by ansugisalas

Yes, it is possible to corrupt the system, but it hasn't been corrupted over here. Nobody has an interest in making the public system fail, unlike what has been the case in the US.
The public system here works towards giving people a more equal starting point in life - yes, the children whose parents sit down to help their kids with their homework (and I am talking about the 7-15 year olds, here) will get better results than the ones whose parents don't give a fluck.
The point is that the ones with the no good parents are still going to have a chance at learning the rotes the allow access to real learning. That's all basic schooling is, laying down the foundations, learning the languages (maths, basic behavior expectations, some basic work routines), etc.

That's why I don't see a big problem with spending money on basic public schooling. It works ok, and it doesn't have to be perfect, because perfect isn't even possible.

It gives people from shitty homes a better chance of learning how to work at learning to learn (I meant that the way I wrote it), than anything else. There are more perfect learning systems, but those are never made available to the ones with the shitty parents. Unless we're talking about a level of government custodianship that nobody wants to deal with.
It's easy for people who want to spend energy on their children's education to create a home schooling experience to beat what the public system could offer, but that's never going to happen for the ones I was talking about earlier, the ones who really do need to have one square meal per day.

I am not talking about what's best for the lucky. I am talking about what's least crappy for the unlucky.

by apotheon

I can only assume by your naive statements about the successes of the system that it worked on you.

I really am not interested in this discussion any longer.

This discussion is closed to new replies.