Discussion Locked

Requiring Spanish as a Job requirement

0 helpful
70 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

You know what grinds my gears?

If you browse job boards, and want ads in the paper. You will see numerous postings that one requirement that makes you move on to another posting is "Applicant must be able to read and speak Spanish" or "Must be able to Speak Spanish". Many people would be eligible for that position if that one sentence was removed. I understand the company may have dealing with a large number of Spanish speaking customers or even employee's (what? require the employee to speak English?). I still feel that it should be illegal and unfair to prospective applicants that do not meet those requirements that are otherwise qualified and want the job.

I would still apply and interview. Then when they say you are qualified, but sorry you don't speak Spanish. Sue them for unfair hiring practices especially if they have Spanish speaking employees.

you know what also grinds my gears?

Pinheads who drive around with their fog lights on all the time. Those are not "extra" lights. They are called fog lights for a reason.

http://www.misternicehands.com/

70 replies

by charliespencer

How about French? COBOL? .NET?

All of these are skills that can be acquired, and a company is well within it's rights to state them as job requirements. There's nothing unfair about rejecting people who don't have the necessary skills.

by xnavydk

I think the requirement of Spanish in relation to a job like Millwright, welder, factory worker of some sort, manufacturing, yes even payroll and accounting jobs. What would be the reason to require Spanish as a requirement? What do any of those positions have to do with understanding Spanish? I can see a customer service job, that makes sense if it is a direct relationship.

Understanding a language because it is directly related to your profession like .net and cobal is a given. Yes even a customer service job, that relates directly to a predominate Spanish speaking customer base.

What if ( dont you lve what if's) The job was a Web development job and they required a A+ cert.

The reason i posted just fyi , my son applied for a welder helper job, and they turned him down because some of his co-workers didn't understand English...

by charliespencer

"What do any of those positions have to do with understanding Spanish?"

That's not my call. I'm pointing out that it's an employer's right to determine job qualifications. As long as they're not discriminating on the basis of something a candidate has no control over (gender, race, etc.), they're within their legal rights. I'm disputing the value of taking legal action against them.

by jessie

I live in an area where there is a large Spanish speaking population. There are many Mexican-American owned businesses in my vicinity. As the owner of the company, they get to decide what skills are necessary for their employees to do their jobs, and one of those required skills is being able to understand the directions given to you by the boss.

And all ya arrogant bungholes that think they should learn English, just remember, if our ancestors had followed that same principle, we'd all be speaking some American-Indian language.

Times are changing. You can either change with them, or you can get left behind.

And no, I don't happen to know much Spanish, other than some profanity, but I'm certainly not opposed to any opportunity for learning.

EDITED for clarity

by oz_media

I am a tradesman, and you need to communicate intricate information, read detailed plans and instruction, communicate wih others in the shop or jobsite etc.

If you cannot speak the language you are useless.

by melissab

,,,to accomodate a work force that may not even be legally employed here? Why is it that we must bend to the breaking point to enforce radical political correctness when we were here first. We are first and foremost Americans and last time I checked, our national language WAS and IS ENGLISH!

by xnavydk

I'm still peeved though. It just doesn't sound like a reasonably logical requirement for the position.

He did pick up a job as a welders helper for a independent welder, who speaks redneck. I can just count my lucky stars that I don't have to pay his car payment I guess LOL :-)

by xnavydk

okay from a safety perspective I would think understanding those around you in the situation they are in, would require some good communication. Who would want to get hurt saying "What?!?"

by jdclyde

we would be speaking some "american-indian language" would have been if the indians would have been the dominate force.

As for learning languages. Anyone coming to this country that doesn't learn English is hurting their own chances of advancement.

If I were moving to another country, you bet your hinny I would get at least a working knowledge of the language. It is stupid not to.

As for business, money knows no language, and you would NOT want to turn a paying customer away for any reason. If you have a customer base that only speaks Spanish, then it would be prudent to have at least one person on-duty [i] (he said dooty, hee hee)[/i] at all times.

It is my same argument on why it is time for a standardized file format for documents, between all vendors. It is more important to be able to work with someone than that someone is using brand X.

by oz_media

No, its an American thing.

Melting pots require assimilation.

In Canada, you are allowed to retain your cultural diversity and language. Should they speak Chinese, there are plenty of places where Chinese (Mandarin) is the primary language spoken, not English. Same for Indians, Eastern Europeans etc.

Should someone not be able to find work with a company where their native language is the primary language then they will soon learn English as it is a REQUIREMENT in order to take a job with an English speaking position.

It works the same way for our immigrants if you want a job with an English speaking company, you must learn English; just as you would Spanish if the primary language was Spanish.

by jdclyde

To be able to communicate with the people you are serving is considered a good thing.

As for fog lights, an even bigger crime is the assclowns that drive around in the fog/rain/snow/dusk without ANY headlights on. They are not intelligent enough to realize the lights work as much to help others see YOU as for you to see others.

by jamesrl

If a private company wants people who speak a certain langauge they have every right to have that requirement, and their reasons are their own.

I can see though that the vast majority of government jobs not require a language other than english (in the US that is). Exceptions for people in the State Department, Intelligence agencies, Homeland security and Military because of special requirements.

We have ads in Toronto for Portugese speaking construction foremen, though Portguese is not an official language (French and English are) in Canada. Thats the employer's right - they have portugese speaking crews so they want someone who can speak the language.

As for fog lights, had them on my van, only used them in fog, fuse blew, haven't fixed it, I don't drive fast in fog anyway, and my low beams are fine without the fog lights.

James

James

by jamesrl

Cause thats just another layer of government bureacracy you don't wanna pay for, and believe in me they are paind in the butt.

Or how about if you are unhappy with the language skills of the employee serving you, you take your business elsewhere, complain to the manager or both.

James

by Member 19291532

A Native American dialect.

Yo tengo un idea sobre tus problema... apredaste la idioma lo que se desean y tu puedes tener el trabajo tu quieres! Pero tu eres peresozo y pienses es su "derecho" ser tienes este trabajo porque los estados unidos son su "pais natal"... Lo siento por me espanol es no muy bien, pero en las menos, yo entiendo mas sobre las culturas diferentes tan tu.

Your opinion is generated by fear, ignorance, uncertainty and arrogance. Mexican immigrants with very little formal education come to this country and learn English on their own so that they can have the most menial of jobs. You, I would assume have a complete formal education and have probably taken and skated through at least a couple of language courses, and yet you are limited to a single language, it would appear. Americans are one of the few people with such a high number of citizens that only speak their native language. It reflects on our mean national intelligence and is one of the reasons Europeans generally feel superior to us.

Fog lights are on very few cars anymore, and generally have yellow lenses. The lights you are seeing are white, I would bet, and they're called "driving lights". They're supplemental lights useful during high speed night driving, and they generally increase the field of illumination to the right and left of your vehicle.

Disclaimer (I am almost entirely of English heritage and can trace my roots back far in England's history. For what it is worth, from the English perspective, whatever it is we speak over here in the U.S. isn't *English*... it is, at best, "American", and often more difficult for English native speakers to understand than Austrialian, Indian, Irish or Scottish English dialects. Expand your world, dude, and stop being such a fanny).

by jdclyde

Europe, being much smaller, HAS to have much more interaction with the surrounding nations, while we have the same interaction with other states.

Doing something out of need and confusing it for superiority is one reason they are seen as mentally inferior.

The same goes for travel. To actually GO somewhere, they pretty much have to jump across a couple countries, while we have as much diversity in attractions (again) by just going to another state.

Sure, we can easily go to Canada or Mexico, but they aren't "real" countries anyways.... ;\

by oz_media

When you cross states, as I too have done countless times, you are met by the same culture, same government, same language, same food, same working conditions and laws (very close where there are slight variances) etc.

In Europe, you cross from one nation to another. It's not like an American visiting Canada, where its just more of the same but a bit different.

Europeans grow with more cultural awareness, acceptance, undertanding and become more worldly. As has been seen time and time again since the dawn of time, foreign affairs are key to survuval and progression as a nation. This is what I see as lacking in Americans, and Canadians too except we are lead to learn about and immerse ourselves in the multiple cultures we are surrounded with.

Other immigrants we have from Asia and the orient seem to have more cultural diversity and awareness too, not just Europeans. This would then mean you see them the same way, mentally inferior.

In this case, you are saying that you deem the majority of the world, or any others which have more cultural diversity/exposure than yourself, to be "mentally inferior" to yourself.

And you wonder why most in the rest of the world call Americans arrogant and uneducated?

always looking out and never looking in.

by xnavydk

You sir, make assumptions as well, my opinion is generated by fact and a real experience with a specific situation, not fear, hatred or ignorance, blah blah and soforth take a deep breath yak yak, now who thinks they are superior? And why do I care? But thanks for your opinion! :)

I know some spanish also:

Tengo un gato mis pantalones.

some tagalog: ( the language of the phillipens)

sa e nung tatay mo?

Fog lights are on a lot of cars, and they are normally brighter then the normal lights, usually affixed to a lower section or bumper of an automobile so they can fire under the fog. Whereas driving lights are dimmer and are on full time usually located on or near the headlights.

so tell me you have not been blinded on a dark road where some pinhead has them all on...

and if you would please? -->>http://www.misternicehands.com/

by jdclyde

are lower to the ground to shine UNDER the fog instead of INTO the fog like "normal" headlights do.

It is dipshits that drive with their BRIGHTS on that are the biggest pain in my region.

by oz_media

In Canada we have a lot of middle eastern immigrants, most that I have known speak at LEAST 5 languages, many speak 7 or even more.
Granted several are variations of an Arabic dialect but they still learn it and become diversified and worldly.

I only speak one, even after all these years living in Canada (where French is mandatory in school, which I managed to get out of taking for more than a couple of years) and living within sight of France when younger, I still don't speak French, nor has it hindered my opportunities yet.

But it took a while even to understand Canadians when I moved from the UK, Americans took a bit longer and Australians, well...bunch of Yobbo looneys that lot anyway. ;)

by jdclyde

Middle Easterners that plan on coming to Canada or the US, yes, they learn several languages.

How about the average Middle Easterner that has no intention of ever leaving?

The average woman in the Middle East, does she learn 5 or more languages?

by xnavydk

you have those cowboys with their huge 4 wheelers with the bright A$$ lights on right in your eyes (yea all 4 lights) ( I almost ditched my car this morning)

:-(

by charliespencer

They'll be gone in a second. It's the one behind me with the brights lighting up the entire cabin that frosts my shorts.

by oz_media

My truck has auto dimming rear view mirror. It senses the darkness and automatically moves the mirror back from the lens glass to dim lights, while another sensor turns on the headlights from daytime running lights, along with the dash, tail and marker lamps at dusk. NIIICE! I never forget to turn them on or off.

My rear window is tinted and high enough to help too. :p

As for fog lights, they are illegal in most places unless driving in fog. They are not usually brighter than normal headlights but are brighter than daytime running lights.

by jdclyde

suck ass for light placement to all of us that drive smaller cars. I drive a Saturn S1, and as soon as it gets dark, I have to flip the little switch on the rearview mirror.

At least many of the highways now have the barriers between the lanes, and they ACTUALLY got smart enough to add an extra foot at the top to block the lights from on-coming traffic. Makes driving at night so much more pleasant.

by oz_media

If Spanish is a requirement for the job, and you don't speak Spanish, you are not qualified for the job, simple as that.

As far aas law is concerned, they are not descriminating against anyone if Spanish is a requirement in order for the company to function in a normal fashion. If a lack of Spanish will hinder your ability to perform your daily duties, it is not descriminatory in any way at all.

For example, I am a licened mechanic with Alternate Fuel certification.

Many mechanics can find work without alternate fuels training, however if that shop is a certified Air Care shop, they must have certified air care mechanics in order to perform their advertised services.

Thus a mechanic does not qualify and one that also has Alternate Fuels certification is.

So simple.

My recommendation, if all the companies in our area require Spanish speaking employees, take this time that you are not working and start taking a Spanish class in the evenings.

Next best bet, forget job ads and just go get your own job by cold calling, qualifying and intruducing yourself and your skills.

by jdclyde

is someone that presumes they are superior to someone else based upon if they speak multiple languages or not. Clearly a flawed unit of measure that you and much of the world are incapable of shaking free of.

Knowing only ONE language doesn't make you either inferior or superior, just different.

Some of us are enlightened enough to recognize that. B-)

Or are you going to say that the French/Canadians are superior to you just because they can speak French and English?

[i](thought, if Americans speak American-English, and Canadians speech is closer to the US than it is to the UK, what do THEY speak? :D ) [/i]

As for culture in the US, there is plenty of rich cultural differences from one end of this country to another. We have different locations that were settled primarily from the same countries. While they do get "Americanized", there is still a lot that gets brought over with them.

It may not be as obvious as driving into an Asian section of Toronto, but it is still here.

by oz_media

YOu will argue part of the point but fail to recognize the full comment I offered.

My comments didn't say that knowing more languages makes you superior. I suppose you missed the whole foreign relations part and world exposure, in your race to disagree in any way that you could find, as you will again and again,

Now THAT's clever!

by jdclyde

but world exposure also does not make one great, but ignorance makes for the ungreat in the world. Ignorance was what I was talking about, and is the same for language as all parts. When you look down your nose at others you risk drowning when it rains....

by Member 19291532

"is someone that presumes they are superior to someone else based upon if they speak multiple languages or not."

Not speaking multiple languages is just one example that tends to reinforce the preconception of those OUTISDE the United States that we are self-absorbed, lazy, and that we embrace a culture of ignorance.

My experience with Europeans is that they're generally reserved in their opinion when first meeting an American, and that there are a number of things that indicate to a European "just what type" of American you are. I suppose this applies to anyone meeting someone else for the first time. As you learn more about that person, you fit that against previous experiences to determine where the person fits in your world view.

But the fact is, the typical American speaks one language, has limited world travel, isn't very well versed on international politics or situations, sees things strongly through the media bias of US media sources (and, btw, The New York Post or Fox Media, is all pretty much AMERICAN media from the perspective of most Europeans). Most Americans do not understand that the US Dollar has been weaker than the Pound for QUITE awhile now, has been weaker than the Euro since arrival, and has actually slid behind the Canadian dollar. They're still going on the assumption that the US dollar is the most desirable, most valuable currency on the planet.

The different "culture" of America is often of dubious cultural value. Experience the unique culture of West Virginia Appalachia, or of Montana, or of South Central LA, or of Suburban White Flight Gated MallRat Communities from Coast to Coast.

Listen, I'm pretty conservative and tend to take a pretty patriotic tone in defending our nation and our institutions as among the best in the world. But we're not perfect, and these battles over "language" are ridiculous. We're not alone, mind you. In Spain you get the Catalanians who are too proud to speak Spanish to you, let alone English - and you end up with the Canadian kind of thing where boxes have a Catalan side and a Spanish side (as opposed to a French side and an English side). In particular, though, the people in the US who make the most noise about not liking the influx of Spanish into our culture are pretty much the same kind of people who were upset about "the rising problem with Catholics/Chinese/Italians/Whatever" during past waves of immigration. They're the same people who always seem upset that "It is always some Muslam ([sic], and just as likely to be Indian) that drives a cab or works in the gas station.

There is an undercurrent of intolerance, racisim, protectionist isolationism, and a score of other unpalatable behaviors that lie at the root of issues like these. Xenophobic behavior - and generally futile behavior, as well.

So, to bring it back around...

If there is an influx of Spanish speaking citizens in the US, and therefore the need to provide services to them, what is WRONG with having signs in Spanish, having workers hired specifically for their language skills?

What is the HARM? What is the reason for concern? Elaborate on that, and maybe I'm wrong - maybe your reasons aren't based out of fear, insecurity, and arrogance.

But if the best you can come back with is, "English is the language of this country, and if they want to live here, they should got-dam have to learn to speak OUR language"... don't bother - you've lost me.

by santeewelding

You soapbox seems to be missing a side.

In the fourth paragraph, in order to exemplify how contained the typical American is, you employ the example of the dollar: "the most desirable, the most valuable currency on the planet" to the typical American.

How does one arrive at such a comparative value without comparative international thinking -- that which, in your argument, the typical American is without?

by jdclyde

if you do not learn the language of the area you are moving to.

If I were moving to Germany or some other part of the world, in order to be successful, I would HAVE to have a working knowledge of the language.

Should we really under go the time and expense of making everything bi-lingual? And where do we stop? Or is it just spanish?

It is not out of Nationalism, but out of giving people the ability to make THEMSELVES successful in life, they can't afford to put extra obsticals in their path.

Did I lose you?

by oz_media

No you weren't, you invaded North America with force over many years.

In case your history books fail you, as usual, the first Europeans to discover America were Italian, Spanish or even the Chinese.

"In 1497, the Italian explorer Amerigo Vespucci discovered a new country, and it was named America by the map maker, Martin Waldseemuller.

However, it was later realized that Amerigo’s friend, the Spanish explorer, Christopher Columbus, had been there a few years earlier in 1492. But it was too late to rename the country Columbia.

More recently evidence has appeared showing that in fact it was the Chinese Admiral Cheng Ho who discovered America in 1421."

And on top of all of that Native Indians were here first, not the Spanish, British or French settlers anyway.

by jdclyde

were a conquered race. That is why their language is not dominant here. Simple really.

As for the discovery, it is the people that settle the region that bring with it their language.

How much of the world speaks English because of being part of the British Empire?

by melissab

Thanks for the backup JD. The point I'm trying to make is this: Our National language is recognized worldwide as being english. We should not have to learn the language of every group immigrating here. In fact historically, it was the immigrant who was expected to learn OUR language and culture. What has changed and why?

by oz_media

So forcing it upon people is the answer in your mind.

As for British colonies, it is just the immigrants that introduce English, most natives retain their primary language.

What's typical is that you completely, flippantly, dismiss how Europeans invaded America as if it was their right to do so to any less powerful or developed nation. Certainly explains your views on the MIddle East.

by charliespencer

"...the first Europeans to discover America were Italian, Spanish or even the Chinese."

You forgot Scandinavians, earlier than even the Chinese.

by oz_media

I am sure the aliens that built the pyramids saw America from space long before we built wooden jalopies to float across the water!

So illegal alien just may be the true native tongue of America afterall. 'American' isn't even a language, it's a slang dialect of Spanglish, don't see what everyone's problem is.

by oz_media

How about the average Middle Easterner that has no intention of ever leaving?
Yes, they grow up learning several laguages from neighbouring courties, Arabic, Hindi, English, Urdu, and French.

The average woman in the Middle East, does she learn 5 or more languages?
As above.

I have dated several Indian women that all spoke several languages, and was surprised ot find out that one girl from Pakistan, who had been raised in Africa, spoke 8 languages, including French and German without ever visiting most of those nations.

It;s just how they are educated and what they choose to study on a personal level.

I have met more than my fair share of older Indian women who barely understand English but speak 5 or more other languages fluently.

Its actually quite common and probably more common than not.

by jdclyde

the language range stretches about as much as the US? It makes sense to learn the language of business partners, and don't many of the countries in that region actually have mixed populations from before many of the current mapped out country borders?

by oz_media

And that's kinda the point you've been missing that several have been trying to make.

You're talking in circles again JD, slow down and let it ride itself out.

by oz_media

You are complaining about having to learn the language of every group immigrating there. WHY? It's a non argument, you DON'T have too, you are free to speak whatever language you choose.

If you choose NOT to learn a language that is being used in a part of your society, for business, social advancement or whatever, that is YOUR choice to make, but you can't complain if others will not include you because of your personal choices.

by oz_media

Merely stops you from stepping on them as you pass them by. It is those that are on the bottom that would like you to think otherwise and come up with what they feel are pithy comments regarding drowning in the rain.

by xnavydk

like you LOL im gunna buy one of them big ol tall 4 wheel drive with a 6" lift.

and use my car as a skateboard.

by Member 19291532

I'm not sure which one, but he was a cop, I think.

This was before I learned Spanish.

What you have said, BTW, is...

I have a cat my pants.

I think you are missing an "en" in there between "gato" y "mis pantalones". Conjunctions are a pain in any language, but the conjugations in the subjunctive in Spanish are an absolute nightmare.

by xnavydk

You are almost correct Sir! It was martin Lawrence ( he was a crook playing a cop) when he was talking to the Federales at the border. He Kept yelling it! Awsome

the tagalog is " loosey " translated depending on the 120 or so dialects they have:

"whos your daddy"

by melissab

to mention my views on the middle east. I am the mother of a 22-year-old Marine who is serving his second tour in Iraq as we coorespond. The situation in the Mid East is far more complex and far too volitile for me to even begin to express my views. You don't know my views on the Mid East. So where you are ignorant I suggest you keep your mouth shut. P.S. Yo habla espanol en todo. Y tu?

by jdclyde

about HOW the behavior of Europeans got us to where we are now. A few hundred years later and the Indians that are left are laughing their way all the way to the bank.

There is no way to deny that they were taken advantage of, both here, Canada, and even in South America. The "New World" was set for plunder, and plunder it was.

I never said it was right, just that is how it happened. I had nothing to do with it, so feel no guilt for that, nor to how ANY slave was ever treated, for that matter.

As for force, no, I never said that was the key. Other than immigrations or foreign relations though, all GOVERNMENT dealings should be handled in English. Does the Canadian government yet require workers to know the Asian or Middle Eastern languages as well as French/English? Should it?

Does the UK government require the same?

by jdclyde

For decades, the US was a major source of income and goods for the rest of the world, and so that world learned English so they could benefit from that trade.

We are now suppose to believe that them learning OUR language for THEIR benefit makes them superior to us. Utter rubbish from people that want to pretend they are more significant in the world than they really are.

What has changed? The whole politically correct BS movement is what has changed. All liberals had to do is accuse someone of being racist if you didn't let them do whatever they wanted to do, regardless of it it was racist or not.

It is time for that crap to stop, as of now.

Tell your boy to keep his head down. B-) With any luck, he will be home soon.

by melissab

How many languages do speak, Oz? And how often do you look in? Last I knew, Canada spoke french and english depending on province. Where do you stand? Yo habla espanol, me amigo que tonto. Como este con personas real y no en aqui?

by oz_media

You don't have a clue yet, do you?

first of all, I did not say that I look down upon foreigners for not speaking English, that's the position YOU defend here.

I also commented on the world America, not my own, as I have experienced first hand myself from many angles, which all have the same focus.

Talking to you is like explaining everything slowly so atone person, in the back that always has a hand up, can keep up.

Anytime someone new comes on board it is always backtracking and dragging out old discussions again, gets pretty tiring and really boring. Keep up or give up.

by jdclyde

I do believe the US Dollar has passed the Canadian Dollar once again, hasn't it?

And from talking to Neil and other Brits, not everyone is pleased with the Euro over there either, and hasn't been ever since it was forced down their troughs.

by shellbot

generally seem to not have much interest in learning other languages..yes I am generalising..no offence against those who bother to learn others.
a lot of europeans speak multiple languages..thier own, and usually english, plus french or maybe spanish.
They seem to be taught in school, where as most native english speakers have the "option" to choose to learn a language for 2 or 3 years in high school.
Face it, if you don't need to learn a language, your not going to unless your highly interested in it, or you are motivated by travel or work prospects.
I took 3 years of French in school..can't speak a dang word of it other than "may i go to the bathroom"

I think if a language is required on a job spec, they obvisouly have a reason for it. Here some jobs require a eurpopean language, because you're going to be dealing with clients that speak those languages.

As the world migrates around, one has to expect this cropping up now and then. I was considering learning spanish because we holiday in spain..but i'm not that motivated..so willprobably never get round to it :)

by santeewelding

Same experience. Three years of Spanish. Never thought I'd use it, until I spent time in Spain and in Mexico years later. Came in handy. Hasn't since.

by shellbot

Was in paris a couple years back.. French Canadian is nothin like it!!
Thing is, I could read most of it decent enough, because in canada everything is written in french/english..so i was good for reading menus!!!
I did attempt to speak it and they generally spoke back to me in english as I'm sure i was offending thier ears :)

by oz_media

Another weak a$$ed peer that needs to rally the troops with third party speak in order to feel comfortable with her own words.

Old hat, Melissa, old hat, try something new that we haven't seen.

by oz_media

yes for those positions in which it is required. Having a huge multicultural citizenship, even many police positions (patrol and office)require that you speak various insian dialects or mandarin etc.

Or do you not deem that a government job?

by oz_media

don't start bring the sorry soldier story into things as if it gives you a right or any greater knowledge than anyone else. I'm not American, doesn't work.

Soldiers are not my issue, never have been and everyone here knows that I fully support troops and it has nothing to do with anything said here.

Your ignorace shines brightly enough for all to see. Many of your comments have already been discussed here and found to be complete horsh1t, so I'll leave it with you to feel clever, informed and righteous all by yourself.

by oz_media

You mean the Brits that don't use the Euro as a form of currency?

SOME people in England have dissed the adoption of ENGLAND adopting the euro as opposed to the pound which remains strong. It's like Canada expecting the US to adopt the Canadian dollar or Mexico saying yuo should all use Peso's. Yeah, we already know exactly what you'd say, no need.

by oz_media

Isn't limiting one's personal employment choices, entirely someone's choice?

You can go to Germany and find many jobs in English speaking positions, nobody is going to force you to speak German or think lesss of you if you choose not to.

However in the USA, if you don't speak English you must clean hotel rooms, drive taxi or run a shop in your own community to else you are not welcome. for thsi reason alone, more people feel forced to adopt your language in order to make a life for themselves.

This is not so in Europe or Canada. Certainly there are many jobs you have to learn a native language to work at efficiently, but again that's your choice, not an obligation of any sort.

by oz_media

French Canadian's don't get along with Parisienne speaking French and vice versa.

If you go to France speaking Canadian French, they hate it. They do have som eallowance fo rthose who have learned French in North America and are just trying to communicate though. I am not bad but definitely not fluent, I think I speak better German than French and better Latin than both French or German (can write it better anyway).

by thechas

I agree that it is a sad fact that for many jobs in the US, one must be able to effectively communicate in Spanish.

Even sadder, it is not the classic Spanish taught in school, but the local street Spanish and Spanglish.

Over 15 years ago, the electronics manufacture I worked for ended up with so many workers that could not communicate effectively English that any level of factory supervision had to be able to speak street Spanish.

A friend took a job several years ago at a small manufacturing company and had to learn 2 different dielects. 1 side of the plant had immigrants from Mexico, the other from Porto-Rico. And, don't ever attempt to cross or mix the 2.

In any other job where one has to work with the general public, it is becoming less and less of an option to not have all staff able to communicate with Spanish speaking clients.

The Spanish speaking population of the US is now large enough, and has enough economic clout that companies are not willing to risk loosing even 1 customer because they could not be understood.

The real place for the blame (if there is any) is the cross between what employers are willing to pay and what American workers are willing to work for.

As long as Mexican and South American immigrants are willing to work for much lower wages than American workers are willing to work for, there will be jobs waiting for every new immigrant.

I also am not sure that we can even consider putting the genie back in the bottle. I suspect that if we could somehow round up and deport all of the illegal immigrants overnight, that the result would be large numbers of companies going out of business, or at best moving operations across the Mexican border.

Chas

by oz_media

First of all, a way to get ahead with the ladies????

Wow, you mean tha if I am nice, all these TR women will come flying over the border to sleep with me, or just have a quick bang at the airport before heading home again?

I should have checked your link before!

This isn't a popularity contest or MATCH.COM.

I'm not here to pick up women or fill up an empty life with my online friends, this is just a forum, a debating board, a discussion.

I don't judge others by what they say here, everyone has their own personality at home and I am sure there are very few people here that are exactly the same at home, its the internet, not life, people here do exist but in other places and with other lives of their own.

I truly couldn't give a rats arse whether someone liked me or not though; I don't care what people think about me in real life so why would I care here, in Neverneverland?

I have friends, I have acquaintances, I have lovers and they are all people that exist in my life, not online.

I do have several 'acquaintances' I have made on TR, that are very nice people and I offer them due respect, but opinions still differ and I may not always agree with them.

I'm not in the practice of saying things just to make people happy, I say what I have to say. If it is not appreciated, so be it, that is not my issue to deal with though.

The way to a ladies heart?! Whatever next.

You need to walk away from the monitor slooowly, turn around and run for the door, slam it behind you and you will have done it, escaped, into the real world.

Now people in the real world actually use vocal chords for communication; until you get the hang of it, try nodding for yes and shaking your head from side to side to indicate NO.

In real life, 'LOL', is a more guttoral sound that eminates from the stomache by jostling the diaphram, eminating a joyful sound from the vocal chords.

When you reach a door to a PUBLIC building, you'll need to use your mousing hand to pull on the door handle, takes a bit of practice but you can't simply click it to open it.

You'll get the hang of it...and welcome, welcome to the real world.

P.S. That bright stuff that hurts your eyes is called sunlight, its good for you and elevates spirits; you can buy inexpensive tinted glasses, they will help keep the bright lights more in tune with the darkness of mom's basement for you until you can adjust.

Don't be scared, those noises you hear are people talking (can you say 'TALKING"? Knew ya could!) this is how REAL people communicate in the REAL world!

It is often best to actually consider what you are saying to people in the real world, these people are real and exist in your life, for the most part. You may need their help and support one day; if you are sure you will not, f-em, who cares.

This is where your comment has a shred of validity, but not online.

(Hey, you started it! :D)

by jandeporre

En espa??a no hablar ingl??s es excluyente para muchos empleos, por motivos evidentes.

Spanish is a language spoken by more than 800 million of people, the reasons for require may be obvious also. By the same reason, in spain it is necesary to speak english to apply to many jobs.

This discussion is closed to new replies.