Question Locked

SATA to IDE adapters any good?

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am in the middle of rebuilding a server and have a beautiful extra 200 GB IDE drive, yet the new mobo has only SATA.

Do the SATA to IDE adapters work well?

e.g. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16812186095

Do these work reliably? Do they work well, performance-wise?

Would it be better to buy a PCI card IDE adapter instead?

Or just punt and buy an external USB drive case?

11 replies

by ashish.sharma

I was almost in a similar situation couple months ago. I need IDE to SATA converter and I found it on Dell's site. It in an old Dell workstation now and working just fine.

by tobif

I followed the link you supplied. Some previous buyers have posted their comments there, and they point out that with this particular product, you may have to do some nasty hardware work, where there's risk to kill your harddrive.

Elsewise, I'd guess that this solution may work, but if you want this server to be alert and react quickly, then you're better off use your spare IDE drive somewhere else and get a SATA drive for the server.

by robo_dev

Other than 'possibly killing my hard drive' it works great :) :)

Like those drug commercials.... the product will cure your sore knee, but side affects may include brain explosion, uncontrollable bleeding from your eyes.... :)

by oh smeg

I would think twice about using one in a Server that is Mission Critical.

it's just another layer of complexity that can go wrong and with Servers this isn't a good thing.

While it may work flawlessly it may also cause the system to think that the HDD is failing when it's actually the interface card. :0

Personally instead of buying a PCI to IDE Card I would be using SATA Drives as they are just faster than a IDE and better for performance in a Server.

I would personally fit the IDE Drive to a USE/Firewire External Case and use it for Backing up. 200 GIG in a position like that is more than useful. :D

Col

by robo_dev

I have a bunch of the external cases laying around somewhere.

by who am i really

I use these:
http://www.vantecusa.com/en/product/search?sk=CB-IS100

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16812232004&Tpk=CB-IS100

they're completely encased so that the chips are not exposed

the only issue is they add about 2 extra inches to the end of the drive
so the space needs to be there or it doesn't work

also all of these are usually only SATA-I @ 1.5Gbps

but still waaaaay faster than USB

edit: add link

by robo_dev

It looks like I can buy a SATA 500GB drive for around $40 USD.

Since the adapter gizmo costs around $20, and my drive is more than two years old, I may just go the lazy route and buy a new drive.

Thanks everybody for the info and advice :)

by oldbaritone

It's probably less expensive to buy a true IDE controller than a converter or adapter, and you won't need to worry about issues with it.

I just went through something similar with my kid's computer: Sister-in-law bought the kid a video game; the game needed a better video card. Got the video card, plugged in the monitor (flat-screen VGA with DVI adapter) and it didn't work.

I talked to a reliable supplier, and asked about a converter to make the VGA screen work with DVI that didn't provide analog signals.

He told me, "Honestly, you can probably find a converter, but it will be almost as expensive as a new monitor, and you may have compatibility issues. You KNOW the new monitor will work."

In your situation, "Honestly, you can probably get a converter, but an IDE controller for your drive is only $20-30 or so, and you KNOW it will work. Why risk the hassles?"

(and I'm mad at my siter-in-law: she spent $35 for a game, and it cost me $250 for video board and monitor. Grrr....) ;-)

Good luck.

by tobif

My dear, I need a new car that would match my new shoes.

by oh smeg

That I restore a Gull Wing Merc by buying a Cylinder Head and building the car from that.

Seemed even too much for me so I didn't ask [b]SWMBO[/b] if she would like one of the few Gull Wing Mercedes that are around. She's seen one or two and made nice sounds about them but starting with just a Cylinder Head is even a bit too much for me. But then again if I really wanted one maybe...... :D

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.