Discussion Locked

Scientists finally agree that humans contribute to global warming

0 helpful
359 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

359 replies

by seanferd

Once upon a time there was far more carbon in the atmosphere, which had over time been sequestered in the earth (coal, peat, oil, limestone) which is now being put back into the atmosphere faster than it can be geologically sequestered again.

Forget all the politics, forget even GW. Just explain how pumping trillions of tons of carbon into the atmosphere will have no effect, regardless as to what the effect may be.

by absolutely

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=244956&messageID=2387062

But why ever defend our liberty with statistical rigor less than that used to deprive us of it?

In other words, why f* up? Why not say [b]only[/b] what you know to be true, absolutely?

The truth is on your side; use it, and don't hamstring yourself with your enemies' methods. They are liars. Let them expose [b]themselves[/b] as such. It requires no effort on your part, but patience.

by seanferd

Old style Natural Philosophers, Philosophers of any stripe, Logicians or historical progenitors of the sciences with the Scientific Method.

Please reference the research founded on proper methodology which produced the replicable results to which you refer here. :)

Everyone knows that warts come from witches anyway.

by absolutely

seanferd: [i]Everyone knows that warts come from witches anyway.[/i]

Thank you for The Enlightenment!

by tonythetiger

AKA heretics :)

An oldie:

A guy walks into the E.R. with a toad on top of his head. The nurse said, "My God! What happened to you?"

The toad replied, "I don't know... it all started with a wart on my ass!"

by absolutely

[i]When you stop trying to convince people that it's a scientific issue and admit that it's a purely political one.[/i]

Prove that, if you can.

You cannot; instead, simply treat it as the political issue it is to you. There is no need to disprove the science. The curtailment of property rights is immoral, even if 'the sky [u]is[/u] falling.'

by deepsand

This just happens to be your turn.

I recently completed my shift elsewhere.

Hopefully, there are always a sufficient number involved so that one need not repeat with undue hardship.

by absolutely

"Hopefully ... one need not repeat with undue hardship."

From each according to his need, to each according to his ability, Amen.

by absolutely

they disproportionately do not have Internet access, thus cannot contribute to the flamewars!

by deepsand

which is far more effective than CO2 in its attenuation of IR, can be deduced.

Kidding aside, though, it should be noted that the shift from producing grass fed cattle to those corn fed, has indeed resulted in a measurable increase in methane generation.

Other not so nice side effects are that, as cows are not evolved as grain eaters, and do not easily digest corn, resulting in their being given to chronic low grade infections, which farmers counter with constant use of antibiotics, not only are more fuel, fertilizers and pesticides required for their feeding, but we end up consuming unneeded antibiotics which serve to foster a rising population of drug-resistant bacteria.

by absolutely

However, I think this is a topic for the AP students only, and not suited for the present remedial-level discourse.

I'd rather eat buffalo, but the cattle are ruining the streams so badly that here on the West Coast, Atlantic salmon are cheaper than the local ones. F* you for reminding me!!

by seanferd

Also note that antibiotics are also used in dairy farming to increase milk production. Last I heard, no one knows the mechanism behind this.

by seanferd

taking larger populations with higher growth rates, you are correct. I still think that the U.S., for example, is overpopulated.

See, this is a reason for universal broadband access. If certain populations could spend their time (especially way too late at night) conducting flame wars, they would be spending less time making babies. ;)

by deepsand

And, didn't we already discuss my "greenness," which is decades old, previously and elsewhere?

by absolutely

[edit: bloody, missed the 'n' key]

You say, science proves a problem.

Somebody concludes, 'tax the f* out of all carbon-based energy conversion.' It really doesn't matter who was first to that conclusion, that has become the context of the debate, but that context is f*-ing wrong.

Proof of climate change and what to do about it are separate topics [b]conceptually[/b].

To conflate them politically, socially, politically, economically, culturally, etc., is stupid & destructive, and I've already lost 7 of my favorite examples of modern architecture to this bullshi+, and thousands of people, and, I estimate, Trillions of collective Dollars, or hundreds of Billions, conservatively. This is ridiculous, and wasteful. Cut it out.

by seanferd

What do all the proponents of burning (the extracted contents of)geological formations suggest we do when there is no more coal, oil or gas left? No matter how much 'exploration' is done, the end of the supply is probably coming sooner than many of the older estimates might suggest. I guess it is always something that is our children's problem. I direct this comment particularly at those of us who like to have so many children. Of course we love our children, but sometimes we have an inconsiderately funny way of showing it.

edit: for clarity (thanks, Absolutely)

by deepsand

either that GW exists, or that mankind plays any conceivable role in it, [b]new oil[/b] is [b]constantly being produced[/b].

Why, to hear them, its a perpetual fountain of energy!

Of course, they're a little bit thin on the scientific details as to how this might be, so we'll just have to trust them.

by seanferd

Oops! Wrong floor.

It is actually not a very good term. Climate Change is a better one. It doesn't mean the weather is getting warmer every day. It means that the climate is being destabilized and becoming more chaotic.

The climate changes naturally, and the environment will change no matter what, but why go on poking a hornets nest with a stick?
How nice it will be when 50% of what is now land becomes covered with saltwater, followed by a 10,000 year glaciation. Why force that issue?

And why should those who are concerned (and all our children) be forced to live their lives according to your lifestyle, and the results thereof?

by deepsand

And, it's one that can be deduced by those inclined to set aside all passions except the thirst for knowledge and understanding, follow where logic will inexorably lead, and possessing of the courage to face his own greatest fears.

Only then can we begin to control our destiny.

by deepsand

"[i]The problem is the product of some technologies. Why should technology, and environmentalists' contributions to it, not be the solution?[/i]"

That some "environmentalists" may be neo-Luddites does not of necessity mean that all are such.

And, to assume that technology alone is capable of remediating all is to over-reach, for it is not technology which bears responsibility, but rather mankind's use of it.

by absolutely

seanferd: [i]And why should those who are concerned (and all our children) be forced to live their lives according to your lifestyle, and the results thereof?[/i]

Because you're new, I'll phrase this as information rather than reproach. At 'maximum message level,' it is very helpful to preface your replies with '[alias]: ' and merely ask you, to whom was that question addressed?

by deepsand

Seems obvious to me.

At least here in PA the hunting is still good; and, if one knows where to go, native brook, brown and rainbow trout can be had for the taking.

Not to mention the morrels!

by absolutely

seanferd: [i]What I want to know is
What do all the [b]proponents of[/b] burning geological formations suggest we do when there is no more coal, oil or gas left? No matter how much 'exploration' is done, the end of the supply is [b]probably[/b] coming sooner than many of the older estimates might suggest. I guess it is always something that is our children's problem. I direct this comment particularly at those of us who like to have so many children. Of course we love our children, but sometimes we have an inconsiderately funny way of showing it.[/i]

Those are disproportionately beyond Internet access, and will not have access to translation of your comments, anyway. Altavista's Babelfish is extremely convenient, but still limited, after all.

The problem is brought about by technology, and its use by the free market. The solution must be also. Discuss until you are blue in the face if you wish, but you will find that this is the bottom line, eventually.

by absolutely

I really honestly don't give a lamb whether those vessels have wings or rudders, just get those Beasts the hell out of my backyard. Their flavour is no better than bison, despite their higher cholesterol, and inferior to the flavous of lamb. The only plausible excuse for such waste of flesh to persist is superstitious taboo, admitted as such.

Hemp makes good rope and particle board. Why are you trying to confuse the issues, scoundrel?

by seanferd

I've been reading this on and off for a while, and only now have dared to post. Maybe I'll look for some broadband or telco threads next.

Easy to be a bit confused. I have to keep reminding myself to look at dates and decide whether or not to reply. Other times I am not quite sure as to who is replying to whom. It's just so bloody threaded.

by absolutely

"Give up all you liberties for a bit of security."

I've heard that one already. Tell me why the free market [b]cannot[/b] solve the problem it created. Surely, if there enough voters to solve the problem, there are a similar number of purchasers. No?

by absolutely

Now, please address the logical fallacy deepsand brought to your attention on its merits, not on loopholes.

by seanferd

Forget maximum message level, I didn't even post this in the right place! It belonged under Tony's post, to whom I was replying.

What a mess!

by absolutely

[i]That some "environmentalists" may be neo-Luddites does not of necessity mean that all are such. And, to [b]assume that technology alone is capable of remediating all[/b] is to over-reach, for it is not technology which bears responsibility, but rather mankind's use of it.[/i]

My position is not that technology [b]is[/b] capable of solving all problems, but that it might be, and therefore [b]should[/b] always be always attempted to its fullest potential, before resorting to force or the threat of it.

If the threat can be solved by technology, use technology, and profit by providing the solution [b]first[/b]; if the danger is beyond technology, why bother doing anything?

by seanferd

Global Warming is actually not a very good term. Climate Change is a better one. It doesn't mean the weather is getting warmer every day. It means that the climate is being destabilized and becoming more chaotic.

The climate changes naturally, and the environment will change no matter what, but why go on poking a hornets nest with a stick?
How nice it will be when 50% of what is now land becomes covered with saltwater, followed by a 10,000 year glaciation. Why force that issue?

And why should those who are concerned (and all our children) be forced to live their lives according to your lifestyle, and the results thereof?

by seanferd

I edited the post in question to read "...proponent of burning the extracted contents of geological formations...". No, I wasn't referring to Centralia, PA or the 45 other coal seam fires there, or the hundreds of similar fires throughout the world.

Most certainly, population growth in some parts of the world far outstrips that of "developed" countries, and that is the result of technologies... the agricultural revolution never ended, and many places support populations far beyond the carrying capacities of the lands within their respective economic spheres. No doubt that energy production and usage have problems that can be resolved by applying technology. However, even developed countries need to allow their populations to decrease.

by seanferd

the "evil weed" would be mentioned. Highly effective photosynthesizer, several growing seasons per year, nutritious seed (good oil also), strong and long lasting natural fiber (hemp for victory), great way to stop erosion, possible source of ethanol.

Oh yeah, and it is no good for illicit purposes if grown for a different purpose.

by seanferd

A free market might do just that, provided a truly free market and educated consumers. (Reasoning consumers who educate themselves assuming facts are available.)

Good for more than climate change, too!

by tonythetiger

"If I was not able to identify the Bird that I just saw, can I assume that it must have been any of the above named Birds? No, I cannot."

how do you know it's a bird?

by tonythetiger

[i]Just explain how pumping trillions of tons of carbon into the atmosphere will have no effect, regardless as to what the effect may be.[/i]

I'm not sure if anyone was claiming that it had "no effect".

by tonythetiger

[i]One need not know everything about everything that happened in the past[/i]

if these scientist types who are coring glaciers and examining tree rings and digging up old human settlements , etc. know that they are wasting their time? Maybe somebody ought to tell them.

by tonythetiger

[i]To fault Science for its past errors, to hold it to the impossible standard of Infallibility, is to condemn the very nature of humankind.[/i]

but I'm glad you said that.

by tonythetiger

"And why should those who are concerned (and all our children) be forced to live their lives according to your lifestyle, and the results thereof?"

that I am "anti-green". Nothing could be further from the truth. I am one of the greenest people I know, and I encourage those traits in others. I just don't buy into the Chicken Little viewpoint.

by jdclyde

Grant money to follow topics that match the intended goals of the granter.

Colleges that do research, that mirrors the political climate on many of the campuses today.

The poo-pooing of anyone from the science community that says something that doesn't conform to the "consensus". Instead of disproving their research, we hear they work for big oil or big business in a pathetic attempt to discredit the researchER instead of the research.

Also a lot of research being done by people that were never able to get a job outside of academia and live off of bigger government.

The only science that is not influenced and controlled by politics is independent studies that are free of government grants. Of course there is always a "possible" trade-off, of corporate influence instead. Why would one controlling group be better than the other?

by jdclyde

is now the preferd word because it is harder to be shown for the flawed cause that it is.

The climate has always changed and always will.

If I gave you a billion dollars and asked you to raise the temp of the Earth 5 degrees F without setting off a series of nukes, could you do it? how? Do you think we CAN control this? To what extent CAN we control or influence any of the changes?

by jdclyde

Selling "green" technology and charging an arm and a leg for it, seems to becoming the norm.

by absolutely

I'm reasonably confident that the free market I describe has no chance of coming into being, until sometime after the number of educated consumers increases dramatically.

by absolutely

[i]Oh yeah, and it is no good for illicit purposes if grown for a different purpose.[/i]

I just thought people who didn't already know, would not understand what you were saying.

Different varieties of [i]cannabis[/i] are better for productive use, and only negligibly intoxicating, so the primary [admitted] argument against its productive use is really moot. Nobody likes to hear that there is no [u]good[/u] reason not to use hemp a lot more than we do.

by tonythetiger

what my opinion was about UFOs. My reply:

They're unidentified. Until that changes, my opinion is that they're unidentified. :)

[i]It isn't a plane, and it isn't Superman, so what else could it be?[/i]

A feathered bat?

by tonythetiger

[i]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=244956&messageID=2387412[/i]

Deepsand's a Vulcan :)

by absolutely

...of thinking, they refer to the "logical consequence" of facts presently available; logic not only permits, it demands acknowledgment of the possibility that more facts will later become available, in all cases that completeness of present knowledge is [u]not proven[/u]. For all intents and purposes, and more so for all subjects we are likely to debate, such proof is [u]never[/u] possible.

*Some simplistic facts such as the definition of numbers and arithmetic properties are not subject to "discovery" of new, contrary knowledge, but in empirical science, where the subject is never purely abstract, we cannot expect to ever "conclude" in the sense Tony erroneously attributes to scientific thinking. However, we can frequently know, with a very high probability, that a current hypothesis is very, very close, and that subsequent revisions will be minor. You can reach such a point in development of a computer program, Tony, and if you practice the profession that you say you do, you know that "conclude" does not mean what you implied it means, in the context you said it, at all.

Also, the technique in which Tony and others use anecdotes about difficulty predicting the local weather, or short-term specifics such as the number of storms in a single season, as counterargument to the ability to predict climate change, has been annihilated.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=244956&messageID=2387316

by tonythetiger

I'm beginning to wonder if your continued misrepresentations of my statements are other than unintentional.

[i]*Some simplistic facts such as the definition of numbers and arithmetic properties are not subject to "discovery" of new, contrary knowledge, but in empirical science, where the subject is never purely abstract, we cannot expect to ever "conclude" in the sense Tony erroneously attributes to scientific thinking.[/i]

I did not attribute "concluding" to scientific thinking. In fact, exactly the opposite! ...

[i]To "conclude" is to stop thinking, and anyone who claims that (genuine) scientists have "concluded" anything is probably not someone I'd place a lot of faith in.[/i]

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=244956&messageID=2387054

by absolutely

Your counterarguments are about as credible as the typical abduction story.

There are good reasons to oppose government regulations advertised to us as remedies to global warming, but suspicion of the credibility of the basic conclusion that the earth is warming and because of human emissions of CO2, are not among those good reasons. The last thing that the environment needs is for the government to take a [u]larger[/u] role in it, as it has in health care and education. But free people, simple diligence, and knowledge gained from scientific research have cleaned up the Chernobyl area pretty well compared to what it was just after the worst-ever disaster in the history of nuclear energy. Keep reading, I'm about to make the topics connect.

[i]Almost 6,000 people worked at the plant every day, and their radiation dose has been within internationally accepted limits. A small team of scientists works within the wrecked reactor building itself, inside the shelter.[/i]

Harnessing a phenomenon which has the power to obliterate an entire city, and controlling that energy so carefully that it powers light switches instead, is not a trivial accomplishment. That something went wrong, once, does not imply that nuclear power is fundamentally unsafe, nor that people are fundamentally incapable of safe use of it. In fact, the fact that the worst nuclear power accident ever to occur killed 56 people, in a less than optimal design, maintained badly, implies that the work done before the Soviet engineers screwed it all up was done so well, that those malicious Soviet incompetents were only able to kill 56 people using nuclear power, and even that took them decades after the reactor was built. That same [b]potential[/b] for technical expertise which developed the underlying theory so well that hundreds of incompetents misusing [b]nuclear energy[/b] killed only 56 people, is also the best reason to [b]conclude[/b] that free people are capable of effectively addressing global warming without command-style government measures.

[i]28 people died within four months from radiation or thermal burns, 19 have subsequently died, and there have been around nine deaths from thyroid cancer apparently due to the accident: total 56 fatalities as of 2004...The April 1986 disaster at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant in the Ukraine was the product of a flawed Soviet reactor design coupled with serious mistakes made by the plant operators in the context of a system where training was minimal. It was a direct consequence of Cold War isolation and the resulting lack of any safety culture.[/i]

It's in that context that global warming is not the bogeyman that some chicken-hearts make out to be; not in the context that it isn't happening, but that it isn't beyond our capability to do something about it.

The same study found that what is much more unhealthy to the people around Chernobyl is the attitude, perhaps realistic given the nature of their particular form of government, of helplessness.

[i]The 600-page report says that people in the area have suffered a paralysing fatalism due to [b]myths and misperceptions[/b] about the threat of radiation, which has contributed to [b]a culture of chronic dependency[/b]. Some "took on the role of invalids." Mental health coupled with smoking and alcohol abuse is a very much greater problem than radiation, but worst of all at the time was the underlying level of health and nutrition. Apart from the initial 116,000, relocations of people were very traumatic and did little to reduce radiation exposure, which was low anyway. Psycho-social effects among those affected by the accident are similar to those arising from other major disasters such as earthquakes, floods and fires.[/i]

http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/chernobyl/inf07.html

by absolutely

[i]To "conclude" is to stop thinking,[/i]

No, it is not, and what you [b]conclude[/b] from your falsehood is also false.

[i]... and anyone who claims that (genuine) scientists have "concluded" anything is probably not someone I'd place a lot of faith in.[/i]

It's who is failing to support your contention. It is therefore your contention, not your opponents', which must be taken on faith, or denied. I choose the latter, because unlike you, I have not stopped thinking for myself.

I've tried to tell you the same thing politely, but you cling to your lies like a pit bull. You deserve these insults.

by tonythetiger

[i]The last thing that the environment needs is for the government to take a larger role in it, as it has in health care and education.[/i]

I have said similar in reference to other "proposals", but the connection seemed to have eluded me this time.

[i]... The same study found that what is much more unhealthy to the people around Chernobyl is the attitude, perhaps realistic given the nature of their particular form of government, of helplessness.[/i]

Point taken. The scary thing is, that is exactly what it appears that some entities are trying to do with the climate issue (I referred to it as "frightening the natives" in another post.)

I've got some thinking to do... you may have inadvertently helped me understand how to tackle a problem I've been fighting on two fronts for quite some time (it's been mentioned before but not in this thread). I'll let you know :)

by absolutely

... your inclusion of the phrase "of course."

I look forward to follow-up, on whatever two related subjects you're contemplating.

by tonythetiger

The situation you gave me pause on is an ongoing struggle between a mother who continues to abuse and neglect her children, my wife and I, and a government agency who on their best day isn't doing a good job of addressing the issues, and at worst is standing in the way of and sometimes actually working actively against the efforts of others who are trying to help.

What I connected with what you said was that I have been going after solving this problem from multiple directions, none of them very effectively, but all emotionally draining. You got me to thinking that maybe I should pick one issue that I think I have a good chance of resolving and putting all of my effort there. Then once one is taken care of, I can focus on something else. Kind of divide and conquer.

It may seem odd to you that one thing connects to the other... but sometimes my brain just works like that :)

by absolutely

And, I see nothing strange in any of that. If our thoughts did not have such similarities, why would anybody bother communicating, at all? The connections made in communication are usually more immediate and exact and less abstract, but still, "rare" and "strange" are distinct concepts, with a [i]spurious[/i] statistical correlation.

by deepsand

the species of which you were uncertain, belongs in a Genus, Family, Order, Class, Phylum or Kingdom that is indeterminable?

And, likewise for every other life form whose species you cannot identify?

Would you have us believe that you are so unknowledgeable as to not be able to make such differentiations? To be unable to distinguish between fish and fowl for lack of a proper taxonomic name?

This I shall not believe, but view simply as mis-direction, in hopes of escaping the consequences of the logical defects in your position.

by deepsand

It is clear that neither of you, Tony or JD, understand the Science here involved, or have any inclination toward even attempting to do so.

Both of you have failed to offer any "natural" cause for global warming other than the vague "same as in the past" or the now discredited conjecture re. increased solar radiation.

I once again challenge either of you to offer Scientific evidence to support your cause.

Persistent chatter re. policies, etal. will not suffice.

In short, guys, put up or shut up.

by deepsand

talking about.

Kindly refrain from even attempting to put words into my mouth.

You implication is egregiously offense.

by deepsand

unable to think [u]logically[/u]?

Your persistent and sophomoric attempts at evasion by way of mis-direction and mis-respresentation have worn most thin.

Again I say, it's time to start using your left brain rather than the right.

Bring us some Science, or nothing at all.

by deepsand

JD's "factual" reproach of man's role in climate change seems to have been a one-trick-pony, the claim that "it's the Sun." With that pony now brought to ground, he's nothing more to say re. matters of Science.

With no way to defend his position other than to proclaim that he's correct, he's reduced to the old "that's my story and I'm sticking to it" routine.

His mind is calcified, closed tighter than a witch's c*nt.

Tony, on the other hand, is still pliable. In fact, in an earlier discussion, he had shown what seemed to be genuine interest in the information that I pointed him to re. radiative forcing, etal..

However, given his penchant for wandering off the path, into the bushes full of the subjective, such as physic experiences and UFOs, he will cling to the hope that he is right for so long a possible.

Now, you may then ask, given the small likelihood of opening the eyes of either, whether or not there is good reason for continuing this matter with them.

I am of the mind that, in matters of public import, it is necessary that the purveyors of wrong thinking must be openly rebutted, lest thay entice or otherwise induce the ill-informed to blindly follow the Pied Piper of Ignorance, to the detriment of all.

by absolutely

because I would classify "GW happening & man-made=yes" as the event(s) in question.

I don't believe in witches, but the rest of your message is the basic reason why I wanted a discussion of the science, the whole science, and nothing but the science. People who have the time & inclination, however, generally defend their work before thesis committees, not troll squads like this one.

by tonythetiger

Deal with it. But deal with it in a way that does not infringe on my liberty without proving that I am doing something wrong.

by absolutely

And why do [u]you[/u] keep mentioning it in reply to questions about the scientific issue of global warming, when that is being discussed strictly as a scientific issue?

by deepsand

And, why must you attempt to change all debate re. Science into one of Politics, or some other [b]subjective[/b] matter?

Again I say, put aside your right brain and begin using the left.

by deepsand

If you cannot or will not assess the risks, you are incapable of making an informed decision.

Have some balls, answer the question.

by deepsand

Are you saying that the risk of your being wrong is the lesser one, and that we should simply take your word on that?

by jdclyde

because I have always had the position of keeping a clean environment and air quality for the sake of the people, animal, and plant life in our world. I don't need a made-up catastrophe that "might" happen in a thousand years to get me to be energy aware.

On the other hand, I will not listen to snake-oil salesmen that are selling a very expensive cure to this "might", for their own personal gain.

Carbon taxes? Carbon credits? all a bunch of BS.

The same people that cry about GW are also the same people that hinder us from moving to alternative solutions, [b] and it is moronic for us to be burning our FOOD for fuel.

by absolutely

Why all the smokescreen about whether or not global warming research is valid? You're so far from having any valid points on that score, you should stick to what you just said, and admit you don't know meteorology from thermodynamics, and you don't know either of those from the back of your pyjamas.

by absolutely

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=244956&messageID=2389199

Every time you comment on the "risk" of making the wrong "assumption,"
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=244956&messageID=2389205
you imply advocacy for [u]some[/u] course of action, or of actions. That becomes more apparent when you speak of who is capable or "incapable of making an informed decision. Have some balls, answer the question."
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5206-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=244956&start=0

JD and Tony are certainly evasive of the questions you put to them most directly, questions of empirical science and logical deductions from available data on climate change. But there's something you're not directly addressing, either.

Why not?

by deepsand

That a given situation warrants a response does not in and of itself direct any specific response(s).

On the one hand, it must be noted that the matter at hand is one of such complex diversity that the Law of Intended Consequences lurks at every fork in the path, behind every bush along the path; doing "anything" so as to to avoid doing "nothing" would therefore itself be shear folly.

On the other hand, it is equally important to understand that the present situation was not quick in the making, and will likewise not be quick in the solving. The more time that passes until steps are taken toward that solving, the more difficult and more lengthy such will be.

Therefore, it is necessary that all understand that the time for unified action is upon us, and that those who chose to not be part of the solution are themselves part of the problem.

So, yes, I do call for action; but, I presently endorse nothing more than general courses of action only, not specific steps for our following such. I.e., I make the distinction between the [i]strategic[i] and the [i]tactical[/i].

by deepsand

Merely saying that the risk is "low" will not suffice to either make it or prove it to be so.

As you've yet to offer any Scientific facts to explain the current climate change, and therefore cannot make any empirical estimate of the potential consequences of its continued trend, you likewise lack any factual basis for your claim that the risks from such are "low."

Once again, you're merely parroting an answer that suits your personal desires.

by deepsand

Tony's and JD's "Politics" are obviously divorced from the relevant facts, and are therefore naught but subjective.

by absolutely

[i]On the one hand, it must be noted that the matter at hand is one of such complex diversity that the Law of Intended Consequences lurks at every fork in the path, behind every bush along the path; [b]doing "anything" so as to to avoid doing "nothing" would therefore itself be sheer folly[/b].[/i]

That's a good point. No one person, or even one profession, is qualified to give a single verdict on "global warming" or "climate change caused by man" [i][b]and[/b][/i] to decide "therefore, what?" for anybody but themselves. Anybody who feels strongly enough about their progeny, or the Environment, or what-have-you, [b]also[/b] feels strongly enough to devote [b]their own[/b] efforts to affordable & clean technology, not try to legislate what everybody "ought" to do.

[i]On the other hand, it is equally important to understand that the present situation was not quick in the making, and will likewise not be quick in the solving. The more time that passes until steps are taken toward that solving, the more difficult and more lengthy such will be.[/i]

Obviously, as is the case with all cumulative damage or defacement, the more that accumulates, the more difficult will be the undoing.

[i]Therefore, it is necessary that all understand that the time for unified action is upon us, and that those who chose to not be part of the solution are themselves part of the problem.[/i]

Therefore, it is necessary that all that believe as you do put your own efforts into the most efficient action available to you, with whoever else is [b]willing[/b] to help you undertake such "unified action."

[i]So, yes, I do call for action; but, I presently endorse nothing more than general courses of action only, not specific steps for our following such. I.e., I make the distinction between the strategic and the tactical.[/i]

My computer is about to enter "hibernation" mode. Be satisfied with that degree of "effort" toward conservation on my part, for now.

by deepsand

are aware of.

Much has been made, for example, of China's fast growing contribution to atmospheric CO2, etal.. However, how many are aware of the fact that that owes to the West having effectively exported most of its "smoke stack" industries to China? In fact, it is in many case the very factories themselves, all of their equipment, that have been dismantled, transported to, and re-assembled in China.

Those relocated factories are now producing goods which are [b]re-imported[/b] to the West, so that all that has happened is that the source at which pollutants and greenhouse gases are being produced has been moved elsewhere.

Were the U.S. to repatriate those industries which it relies on for their goods, it is estimated its CO2 emmissions would be approx. 30% higher than they are at present.

Clearly, practicing conservation and energy efficiency on ones home soil alone will not suffice. And, therefore, neither will insisting that others take a first step before taking ones own.

To quote John Hancock, President of the Second Continental Congress, "[i]There must be no pulling different ways; we must all hang together.[/i]"

To which Ben Franklin added, "[i]"We must indeed all hang together, or most assuredly we will all hang separately.[/i]"

by jdclyde

It is not my burden to prove that GW is or isn't man made. I am not the one makings demands or taking away from anyone else via legislation. If you wish to impose upon the rights of others, it is YOU that has to prove your case, which you have not done.

The attitude that "there is a consensus, the conversation is over" is BS and you know it.

It would be a good thing if places like Mexico, China and India would get SOME environmental standards, because it is good for everyone to have clean air to breath and water to drink. They are left out of the "conversation" most of the time, even though they are by far bigger contributors, based on politics.

by tonythetiger

If nothing is done, many humans "might die" because of our inaction. (this is the ONLY thing you're looking at/touting)

If something IS done which involves imposing the will of one person or group onto another person or group, many humans "might die" because of our action.

In addition, there is the chance that whatever the imposing group is imposing will not work, meaning that many MORE humans "might die" because of our action.

Therefore according to my assessment, there is less risk in doing nothing than in doing something that imposes one's will on another.

by tonythetiger

No argument can be won against such fanatics who insist on putting everything in terms of their god. They are on a crusade mandated by their god, don't you know, and that gives them the right, no, the [b]obligation[/b] to impose their will on any and everyone who does not comply (except, of course, for their high priest, Allah Gore). After all, they know better what's good for us than we know ourselves. Sound familiar?