Discussion Locked

Security & Network Management

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi everyone,
I am looking for security and/or Network Manegement solution in and NT ethernet, cisco PIX 4.4 environment. My questions are:
1) Is it recommended to have security and network mangement (monitoring) done by one software/hardware?
2) Does it exist such a product? if yes can you tell me few name
3) if not advicable to have this done by one product can you give me few names of each product.
Thanks.

5 replies

by mckaytech

I tend to think of Network Management and Network Security as different types of products.

For Network Management, I think of SNMP reporting and management software such as HP OpenView, CA-Unicenter, etc.

For Network Security, I think about a basket of tools rather than a single program. This would include tools for intrusion detection (snort), network mapping (nmap), configuration changes (tripwire), log analysis, access auditing and so on.

I usually start with a list of problems to be solved or tasks to be automated and then look for the best of breed tools for each task, keeping in mind the platform, funds available and ease of use.

paul

paul

by dlw6

I'm not aware of a one-size-fits-all product. Then again, the more things something does, the worse it is at doing them usually. If such a thing does exist, I wouldn't recommend it anyway. Software is written by humans, which means it occasionally has bugs or security vulnerabilities. If something goes wrong with a combined NM/security program, you've lost both functions.

NM and security are different functions, and the optimal solutions are different for each. The optimal solution willvary based on how important each one is to you (and therefore how much you want to spend).

For security, ISS (www.iss.net) has a variety of proactive and real-time security tools that have worked great for me. I hear that Cybercop is good too. If you can't afford those, look for Intrusion Detection System shareware or some of the stuff the other answerer (sorry, I forgot your alias) suggested.

For network management, it depends on what you want it to do. Intel LANDesk lets you inventory hardware and software of all your PCs via the network, or even take remote control of others PCs for troubleshooting purposes. HP Openview does high-end network management stuff (i.e. getting status info from SNMP-capable nodes), and SNMPC is the lower-cost product that's optimized for smaller networks. If you just want to monitor whether servers X, Y, and Z are responding (and therefore verify the path to them), then WSWatch is the low-to-no-cost solution.

One last thing: SNMP isn't themost secure protocol in the world, so use caution.

Good fortune,
Don

This discussion is closed to new replies.