Discussion Locked

Security Risk - Multiple networks on hub

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Is the following a security concern? why? why not?

If you have a router connecting your LAN to a network. The router is connect to a standard 10Mbps shared hub and your firewall is connected to the same hub. The router and the firewall use valid Internet IP addresses.

Now the possible security risk:
Someone adds 2 workstations to the hub (they are now outside of the company LAN and firewall) and gives the workstations internal ips (such as 10.10.10.1 and .2) and then enables file sharingon the two pcs.

Can someone on the Internet access, attack, scan, etc. these rogue workstations?

Any comments would be greatly appreciated,

Kevin K

9 replies

by rachel_s

Kevin -

If I understand this correctly - then yes there are at risk, depending on that router.
For example - if someone could VPN or 'break' the router, they are on your internal network. The firewall would do some type of packet inspection andblock malicious activity. Since these are not protected by the firewall, they can be attacked. Once again, it really depends on that router. Most routers do not actively detect malicious activity.

-Rachel

by turambar386

Hi Kevin.

There is a risk there, but not a great one. In order for someone to attack these machines, they have to know that they are there. As they would be using non-routable (10.x.x.x) IP addresses, there is really no way for someone to determine their existence from outside that subnet. In order to find them, a hacker would have to subvert either the router or the firewall, which is hopefully unlikely.

That said, I would strongly recommend that you get rid of the hub if you don't need it and just use a cross-over cable between your Internet router and firewall. That way, wayward users could not come along and plug in a workstation outside your firewall.

Hope that clears things up.

by mckaytech

I'm not entirely clear on your network topology but if I understand your setup, it looks something like this:

Internet->firewall->hub->router->LAN

If that is the case, these rogue workstations are in fact inside the firewall but outside the LAN. The security risk would be minimal, especially if the firewall/router connection was subnetted /30 and subject to an access list.

If your setup is:

Internet->router->hub->firewall->LAN

the rogue workstations would be outside the firewall and the risk would be somewhat greater but still rather small. In this scenario, you would want to use an access list on the router to keep the NetBIOS packets off the Internet and also use a subnetted connection between the router and firewall sothere are only two valid IP addresses and limit the access list to those two.

Theoretically, these rogue machines could be compromised from the Internet, but not easily. However, for the trivial cost of another hub to completely isolate them, I wouldn't take the chance.

paul

by madcateast

If the router is configured correctly it will not forward or accept non valid internet addresses ie: 10.x.x.x, 192.168.x.x, etc. So in this sense the workstations are somewhat safe as long as the router is set-up correctly and running. If the routeris compromised someone may be able to access them. It would be best to connect the router directly to the firewall and put all of the hosts inside. Another consideration is if the router is handling the NAT services. Then it will translate the IP?s and forward the packets to the 2 workstations if their names are somehow discovered. Ie: workstation1.yourcompany.com

This discussion is closed to new replies.