Discussion Locked

Selecting a good bang 4 the buck router

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I was suddenly told, that I am changing WAN providers and will need to purchase and configure a router. Previously our router (Cisco 3600) was leased and provded, configured by our WAN vendor. We are a web host, and strictly provide web server hosting services. I am looking for the most inexpensive, yet secure, and quality router I can buy. Money IS an object, and I already have a finite budget of about $1,000.

Preferably I would like to have firewalling, and NAT. Since I have to select therouter by Friday Close of business, I am extremely interested in anyone opinions who has bought configured and used various routers in this budget constraint. I have zero router experience, but have single handedely manager 39 servers from install, secure, firewalling, NAT etc for two years with zero downtime or instrusions. I feel I have a strong grasp of TCP/IP NAT, and firewalling, and can if needed omit firewalling from the router and provide it at the server/bridge level as I am currently doing. DoS survivability would be nice at the router but I understand it may not be an option at this price range.

7 replies

by kelly_aitch

Sounds like you have much more experience than I in this stuff, but if your budget is tight, how about something with Linux? I have heard of neat things being done with it for firewall and routing.

Just an idle thought...

cheers

by gh1

Thanks Kelly, All but three of the servers we host are linux. I need something at the D-Marc. I have looked at cards that can handle this with Linux and if I had more time that 'purchase it today' I would strongly consider it. I must order it today, have it confirmed enroute Monday, and be installing when it gets here. Thanks for the comment though.
Bruce

by ebob

As you know, you're trying to implement a Rolls-Royce solution with a Kia budget. You should have a look on the relevant auction sites for 2nd hand Cisco 3600s (a great router) or similar boxes. You might also give your previous lease company a callto see what they've got in lease returns.

As an aside, if I found out that my Web Hosting Provider was trying to run their connections on such a cheap budget, I would pull my business so fast, they wouldn't know if they should go for a walk or wind their watch.

by gh1

I asked for help with a low buedget, high quality router solution. Not criticism or insinuations that our shop is anything less than top quality, just low cost. We keep out costs low, buy spending less and having much lower overhead. Thanks for the advice though.
As the next answer shows, ther ARE sub-$1000 solutions that are fast, secure, and don't require certifications to set up.

by fdisk

With that type of a buget Linux will be the best bet. If you have three servers runnig Linux you must have an admin who can setup an LRP box. Check out www.linuxrouter.org this is an easy way to build the router on an old 486 even. Hopefully the new provider has an external CSU/DSU option.
Good Luck

by gh1

Thanks. This is the way we are gloing. I have a LRP setup, and also discovered a company (www.routerrevolution.com) in a Linux Journal ad. It's also a linux based solution that uses IPTABLES or IPCHAINS for firewalling, uses what I am already anexpert in (Linux) has 24x7 FREE tech support including setting it up from scratch, and their sales person knew exactly what I was talking about each time I hit him with a difficult question. Seems like a tech doing the selling) In the mean time, while I try to gt the budget upped a bit to handle this, My LRP is kicking along (who knew, 1.685 MB on a floppy is simple stuff!) Fast as fast can be since it all runs from ramdisk, no HD, or CD, and unhackable (Read Only floppy) What a deal, and what great advice.

This discussion is closed to new replies.