Discussion Locked

Self Taught is the best!!!!!!!!!!!!

0 helpful
106 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have had enough of all you so called self taught people. Why are you in your job?

You have no right to be there.

What gives you the right?

You never bothered to study the foundations of your profession. You make me sick.

Pray the day you entrust somthing to these wannabes!

106 replies

by mjd420nova

Don't subject an entire group to disdain just from your experiences with a few. They may do things different from the BOOK LEARNED people, but that's because they do have the experience to know how to approach problems from a more pragmatic direction. I see self taught individuals who couldn't find their butt holes in the dark with both hands and a flash light, but there are those who have a lot to teach about how to really solve a problem. I've seen them go right to a problem, skipping over steps that others would spend hours on eliminating step by step as they were taught.

by tony hopkinson

Fault finding does n't seem to be taught in academia, not in most IT courses anyway.

I learnt the technique off electricians, they do get taught how to do it.

For fault finding, you've got to think black box.
Then it's just binary a search.
Right here, wrong there must be somewhere in between, isolate the module, go into it's black boxes, re-iterate.

Sometimes having worked on a system for a while you get a feel for particular faults, but that's just intuition coupled with experience and a salting of luck.

The two cardinal rules are.

It's always in the last place you look. LOL

It's usually in the place you assumed it wasn't.

The real differences between self taught and academically taught.

A self taught person knows what they know much better. They only tend to know what they've had to teach themselves. So they do tend to haves tried and trusted solutions to problems, and until they cause a problem they won't be improved.

Unless some certified type (or a self taught person with different experience) comes along and says you can do that better like this.

Anyone of either stripe who thinks they've learnt all they need to know, just has a lot to learn.

A self taught person is much less likely to fall into this trap, as they've got nice people with bit's of paper to remind them they can't be all that clever, otherwise they'd have one too.

by half9

I started doing computer at home then went to school for 3 years ok. And a funny thing doing computer operation, they bought 3rd year students doing the 'Basis'[Batcherlor of applied science in information systems] guys down to our class and put a range of hardware on a desk. sound cards modems ect. The question asked was 'what are they' Boy this crowd was book smart but they had trouble with the components. most could not tell the diffrence from a sound card to a vidio card

by apotheon

Every few months, he pops up and calls self-taught, highly competent, experienced professionals wannabes and charlatans (or would, if he knew what "charlatan" meant). He's just bitter because, despite his years of expensive formal "education", he's still incompetent, inexperienced, and unemployable. Don't feed the troll, and maybe he'll die of starvation.

by tony hopkinson

You want to see if that bit of paper matches up?

I wouldn't say self taught was the best per se. There a lot of things I don't know, I know that because I've never stopped teaching myself when I bump into my own ignorance.

Are you having difficulties in your career by any chance.

Academia hasn't prepared you for the real world?

Perhaps, wanting to be makes you more useful than already are ?

Whining pratt.

by zlitocook

With out With out being in a classroom! We can learn on our own and have great jobs wiprove it.
Why do you put down people who have proven them selfs and are helping our great country? You do not need to go to a four or six year collage to get a great job. As a matter of fact it is has been provin that most collage grads, have a hard time finding a job in their profession.
Becase of no real life training which two year collages give and self training helps.
Going to a four year collage is great and can help you to a degree but if you are trying to get into the IT field you need real world experience and training. Which you can not get at school.
Look at the job heiring rate for grads. and the hiring rates for non grades with self training.

by nicknielsen

But you spoiled the curve by making the fourth line so long. Must be self-taught.

Who are you? Did you join TR just to make this post? What's wrong with being self-taught? How do you know what I know? Did you know that all generalizations have exceptions?

To quote you, "What gives you the right?"

If you want to spew, go to one of the kiddie forums. If you want to offer constructive criticism, then stick around and discuss it. Don't be a seagull poster.

by tig2

You must have missed the last time Spud boy graced the boards with his presence. Long irritating story and I won't bore you with detail.

He's been back a few times with this ca-ca. Must have found a public use terminal again. Either that or Mommy and Daddy haven't been monitoring his computer use lately.

Either way, he's a troll. Just another in a long line. *YAWN*

by nicknielsen

I think that was back when I was stil skulking and not paying too much attention. As Tony said below, "I must have missed it."

by ontheropes

but I was able to do a controlled turn just in time. That would've screwed up my weekend.

by puppybreath

Alvin? I've been looking everywhere for him. Simon and Theodore didn't know where he ran off to so I'd be interested to know where you saw him.

by txtopgun

Years of doing it the hard way and not claiming to know everything there is to know. Just for the record, I have learned from some of the best degreed people and managed to teach them a thing or two in the process. You see, nobody has told us what can't be done so we figure out a way to do it and make it work.

Lets see...the biggest mistake I can recall was the way I learned you can't plug in a sound card while a computer is running. That was in 1985 on a 286. Should I have known better? Yes. However, when the schooled folks told me about the same time that my hard drive had to be replaced because it couldn't write to the boot sector, I simply moved the boot sector. They told me it wouldn't work but I had already done it and the system was up and running.

by danlm

The only schooling I have is technical school, and that was in 1979. A lot of what I have learned in application development was from looking at other people's code and constant reading of various articles. Along with trying to understand the details of the business requirement.
I have shown college graduates how to do things, but they have also shown me various things. I do think a formally educated person is going to have an easier time in the consulting world because they have been exposed to a wider range of technology's then a self taught person. In my case, I worked for the same companies for a long period of time. I could run rings around most people their, but a lot of that had to do with knowing the business and it's requirements along with the technical side. Actually, I think that is a better argument. Who is better? A person that has a high degree of technical skills that feels that's all they need, or a person with technical skills that knows the business requirements and utilizes both sets of knowledge in the solving of problems. I guess this argument is only geared to application development, but you can see what I am trying to say I hope.

Dan

by ed woychowsky

I know someone that was a computer science major at a large college that had a issue with the department chairperson/professor. You see, the college?s computers were running DOS while the student had Windows 95. This meant that the college had one version of Turbo Pascal while the student had another. To get around the differences the student took advantage of the pre-processor in writing a homework assignment so that in DOS some statements would be compiled and in Windows other statements would be.

The issue was that the professor refused to compile and execute the students program because in her words, ?it won?t work.? The student taking the initiative herself compiled and executed the program herself in front of the professor. The professor was appalled that the student would not believe her and embarrass in front of others promptly marked down the student?s grade for lack of respect and cheating.

The professor?s logic for the student cheating was that the student read the manual for the compiler. The professor continued that, ?in the real world programmers need to make due without manuals.? In disgust the student left college.

Thinking about it now professors without real world experience are part of the problem.

by jdclyde

The only thing he is good for is to put on a hook and go fishing.

I am out of here.

by hal 9000

Is still smarting from being fired for Computer Misuse in it's last position and that was only a summer Fill in job without pay where it's piratically impossible to be fired from. After all who's going to fire a freebie? :) :^0

But little Spuddy M found out just how disposable it actually is I understand it's applying for Bill Gates Old Job [b]God Help Us All![/b] :p

It wants to do all the development on the next version of Vista. :D

Col ]:)

by jack-m

The way you come off Spuddy one would think you feel you wasted a lot of time and money going to school to learn what some of us have become expert at informally. And we are as well paid as anyone with a certification or degree.

by hal 9000

But just make sure that you're not caught this time for misusing the companies computers. :D

by suisunian

I am one of these so-called self-taught people. Who says someone who is self-taught isn't "schooled"? It's called the School of Hard Knocks, buddy. It's a tough Academy and people wash out every day. Academically trained individuals generally know a little about a lot of things. Experientially trained individuals generally know a lot about a few things. However, those few things are usually the really important ones. Which kind of person would you rather have working for you?

by maecuff

strange little man..and you have my pity.

.

Hey..Spuddy..wanna hear something that will REALLY piss you off? Not only am I self-taught, have NO degree and female, I also make a WHOLE lot of money. wooo hooo!!!!

by nicknielsen

You are SO mean. Go for it! B-)

Edit: Can't spell "go." And not a beer or martini in sight. :(

by maecuff

They nearly all have 4 year degrees. (All the developers have degrees) And they report to me. And not only that..I can STILL code circles around all of them.

And I'm hot.

by mjd420nova

Not a day goes by that I don't see this type of thing. Nor does a day go by that I don't encounter an individual with the same attitude. One of the first things I look at in TR forums and all the others I belong to is the Date they became a member. GREAT BIG CLUE as to the kind of person and type of post they make. WELL, Go flame on someplace else, we are all used to your approach to life and you must be a big failure. And like someone else posted, you probably spent a lot of money to find out that you really didn't learn a damned thing. Lets see some kind of response please, are we getting thru to you??

by jdclyde

After all his education and that is the best he can type? :D They USED to teach you how to write in college as part of your degree. Sad to think after all the writing classes I suffered through that they would do away with those?

(too bad they never required a SPELLING class though, huh? :^0 )

by richinnameonly

I am self-taught, because when I started in "I/T", you signed on with an employer and learned on the job -- that was the ONLY way, because colleges had no I/T curriculum!
Do I know everything an MCSE knows today? Emphatically, NO! I do NOT have the deep knowledge of every obscured command or technique that it takes to make a server dance.
Does a newly minted MCSE know what I know, about how to keep users happy, about sleepless nights before the books close, about the responsibility of having dumped the payroll source accidentally the night before a 240,000 person mill payroll has to go out? No, those are things that can never be learned in school -- responsibility, integrity, willingness to learn from one's mistakes, and willingness to help one's fellow man out of a sense of rightness or duty.
I proudly earned a living in I/T for over 30 years, and felt it was the greatest profession on earth. Now, however, it is populated by mindless robots for whom basic communication with co-workers is a "non-necessary" skill, and whose worth is established only by the number of "certificates" they have behind their name.
First, we need to learn the theory of the craft. THEN we need to learn the techniques of applying the craft to the theory. I am a trained biologiest, but time and time again, the knowledge of "controlled variables", "well-designed experiments", and "deductive reasoning", are what stood me in the greatest stead in my I/T career.
I can always learn new things if someone gives me a chance. I cannot learn new things if I am shut out from that chance by wannabes who can't speak English because they think they don't have to.

by apotheon

"[i]Do I know everything an MCSE knows today? Emphatically, NO! I do NOT have the deep knowledge of every obscured command or technique that it takes to make a server dance.[/i]"

News flash: a newly minted MCSE doesn't know that, either. In fact, he knows precious little.

I got my Microsoft certs in '99. I learned a couple things going through that process. One of the most imporant lessons I learned, by a combination of that and trial by fire in the real world, is that certifications are roughly useless as a measure of knowledge.

I learned more about making a Windows system get up on its hind legs and dance in six months of work than I did in two tech schools and a pile of certifications.

by maecuff

I'm smart enough to get where I am without it.

Of course, we're all different.

by tig2

It seems evident that you learned nothing from being banned the last time. Pity really. Attacking people here only give us a place to play- and potentially attack back.

Now go away or I shall replace you with a very small shell script.

by tig2

To ever pick up and run with the shell script comment. And I have used it several other times.

But in answer, yes- that was exactly what I was thinking.

You're good!

by tig2

Very nice Apotheon. You got me there.

I really must learn Perl...

by danlm

I have putzed with perl, use it mostly for cgi now though. All though, I have a couple applications at work that just cries out for perl. Just need to let them let me do it. Converting excel documents to .cvs so that the files can be read by pl/sql.
Has perl written all over it.
And hey, its cross platform. You can put the perl script on both a unix box and a windows box, and call him an idiot. lol, sorry.

Dan

by danlm

I do it for fun, no lie. lol

#!/bin/sh
# couldnt resist
IsStillIdiot="y"
while [ $IsStillIdiot = "y" ]
do
echo "spud, your still an idiot";
sleep 5
done

chuckle, sorry. That was kind of fun and I couldn't resist. I've been shampooing carpets all day so I am not of the right mind here.

Dan

by apotheon

I recommend getting the O'Reilly camelid trilogy of books, consisting of [i]Learning Perl[/i], [i]Intermediate Perl[/i], and [i]Programming Perl[/i] -- also known as The Llama Book, The Alpaca Book, and The Camel Book, respectively. Also, get an account at PerlMonks at http://www.perlmonks.org where you can read the tutorials (including two written by yours truly), follow the more elementary discussions, and ask questions. There as here, my user name is apotheon, in case you want to track me down.

Regular expressions are your friends. Also, read this TR article I wrote about things you should know about Perl:
http://articles.techrepublic.com.com/5100-3513-6077064.html

by tig2

I know what I will be doing for the rest of the night... and tomorrow... and tomorrow...

Thanks for the lead Apotheon! This is an area of my education sadly lacking!

by apotheon

Did you get far before being distracted by something else? How are things for you in Perl-land? I'm curious.

by apotheon

The above Perl script doesn't use strictures or warnings pragmas. That's bad programming practice in Perl.

It might benefit by adding the [b]-l[/b] option to the shebang line: this simulates Spuddy's tendency to take up space as well as time whilst saying nothing at all.

While the program runs fine with the strictures pragma, the warnings pragma causes it to spit out a noninitialized value error for every iteration of the while loop, thanks to the implicit use of an unassigned [b]$_[/b] variable for the print statement. Whether or not that's a "bug" depends on what you think proper parser behavior is when running spuddy.plx (the filename I've assigned to this short program). I actually rather like the warning-spewing behavior as an accurate representation of Spuddy in a Perl script.

My new and improved spuddy.plx:

[b]#!/usr/bin/perl
use strict;
use warnings;
print while 1;[/b]

Note, the program itself still consists of exactly one line of code, containing three discrete syntactic elements. The use statements are for using pragmas, which are compiler directives used to alter the default behavior of the script -- generally for debugging purposes.

Enjoy your new version of the TR member Spuddy.

by tig2

As they can do sh*t that makes you go... "Wish I'd thought of that!"

Apotheon is a REALLY bright people! So is Droolin.

by ontheropes

I've said it before too for some reason Apotheon just cracks me up.

He's the kind of man that could talk you out of writing him a ticket because when he got done explaining how it [b]really[/b] was you'd be convinced you were backing up and going the wrong way and didn't see [b]any[/b]thing that you thought you saw. :D Not that that's ever happened to me, more than once.

For whatever reason, I know literally 100's if not 1,000's of people by name and by face. Apotheon is one of just a very small percentage of the [b]many[/b] [i]really[/i] bright people I know whom I would and do trust.

by hal 9000

Both of the people that you mention are [b]Self Trained[/b] so by that definition they are stupid and shouldn't be allowed anywhere near their jobs as they are exactly the type of people that our good mate Spuddy M is complaining about. He is the type that has to come in and clean up after them. :D :^0 :D :^0

Well that's what it likes to think anyway actually it would be either of those two who would be cleaning up the mess after Spuddy. :D

Col

by tarnishedknight

In my experience it is often (not always) the self-taught guys who are the best. They don?t have some shiny certificate to hide behind it is there actions that must speak for them.

I have often seen guys get hired because they have the qualification but when it comes time to deliver they have no clue about how the real world works. They have tones of theoretical knowledge but just lack the practical skills needed to deliver.

by deanb

I have gotten the certs more to prove to me that I have some knowledge of the subject in question.

From an employer standpoint, I love the IT grunts(which I am). I also like to see people get off of their lazy buts and spend some time putting the effort in to testing for a cert.

I didnot need to , but I have tested on a variety of certs. Each time feel excellent I completed them. CCIE was the hardest, so the f****** people who complain about certs can go work and bitch about people who are more successful than they are. Or recognize anyone who has made an effort to improve there skill base and think they might learn something by them. Years back I heard someone say at Comdex that if you are in IT if you know how much your paycheck is, and are waiting for it. YOu are probably in the wrong field.

by tony hopkinson

You acquired the skills then you got certified.
This was the original idea. Certs were invented as a mechanism to prove a level of skill. To say to employers, this person is of a particular standard.

You don't get skill out of a book, you get it from practice !

Are they that now ?

An annoying generalistion, but the idea that someone who hasn't got certs is n't skilled or is lazy, could get up one or two peoples noses as well.

by jim_p

I think around 70% of my knowledge has come from self taught, a lot of my ways are much more productive then the text book ways. You can't have experience if you have never have been self taught, so if you think reading books is the only way to go then good luck to you building up .your experience.

Kind Regards,
Jim

by apotheon

The esteem of my peers here at TR makes me feel all warm an' fuzzy inside. I really appreciate your positive regard.

I'm also wearing a black t-shirt with a picture of the Moon on the front, with the words "The Moon" below it, and no picture at all on the back, where it says "The dark side of the Moon". I just thought I'd share.

by deanb

I have been in the IT field over 20 years, no degree, just a bunch of certs. I eat breathe and sleep the industry.

But you know I am enjoying watching the deer in my backyard. My beautiful wife and kids, and the 2 new Mercedes in the garage(just trying to make a point)

The cool part of this is that I get paid well for something that is like a hobby. So here's props to anyone that is "self tought" or has 35000000000 Phds in IT, as long as you love it.

by apotheon

If you have an aptitude for it, you love it, and you learn well, you'll be good. Degrees and certifications don't change that. In fact, degrees and certifications are almost irrelevant to measuring practical skill level. When someone with a degree is good, it's because he learns well, not because he was taught well. One can learn well in school or out of it.

Formal education isn't about learning, it's just another form of certification -- which is all about making money for the certifiers. The assumption is that they'd make more money as an educational institution by teaching effectively, within a free market -- but the market is not free, so schools end up becoming little more than self-perpetuating bureaucratic organizations optimized for maintaining the status quo.

You can learn a lot in school. You can also learn a lot outside of it. As a hiring manager, I wouldn't care where you learned -- the key would be that you learned.

by danlm

Were people still in college that qualified for internship where I worked. They were able to take their school knowledge as it was still fresh, and learn the hard knocks of what businesses want and don't want. Meaning, they learned how budget restraints, older equipment, standardization of various software did not necessarily tie exactly back to what they were taught. But how they could use what they were taught to work within the framework. Also, because these people really were good. They didn't look down on old farts like me, and actually seen where what I knew from banging my head off the desk more then they did could help them.
They took the knowledge that I had gotten while banging my head off the desk, with what they knew already, to become outstanding IT people. And I was able to learn off them at the same time which was great.
And your right, the reason they were good was because they liked what they was doing.

Dan

by nicknielsen

That always helps. I've worked with a few interns and almost all of them applied for the internship because they [b]wanted[/b] to learn how to apply the knowledge they got in school. It's the ones that won't apply for internships because they think they know it all after passing a couple of finals that you've got to watch out for.

by hal 9000

I meat my fair share of the [b]Know It All Brigade[/b] who are outright dangerous when let loose on a system without supervision.

Reminds me of a story that I heard from a Range Sargent who was in charge of a Firing Range with a bunch of Cadets there He tore into one for running around with a SAM 7 with all the safeties off and finger on the trigger. The Cadet Leader there at the time supervising the cadets tore into him as he was just a Sargent but he controlled the Range and there was noting allowed to happen there that he didn't allow and he wore the responsibility for any accidents. Unfortunately the Cadet didn't shoot the Supervisor with the SAM 7 because the poor old Sergent had stopped him from acting foolishly.

But it's the same in any industry there are those willing to learn and those who are only in it for the [b]Big Bucks[/b] I know which I prefer to have working for me and their Education Qualifications don't amount to much if they are unwilling to work within the existing frame work, they just don't last long and have a very short life with any company that I've ever worked with.

Col

by mraap

The worst part of all of this for Mister Spudds (like the dog from the comercials) is that his supervisor is probably reading this right now and of course is probably "self taught". The thing is paper only gets you so far, if you can't implement the application or the repair within the required time frame you fail. If you can get it done in half the time or less than the time allotted then great but you had better be somewhat self taught to do it other wise you still have a problem because the problem isn't in the book. The trouble shooting steps maybe but the problem didn't exist when the book was put together.

by shawn

So who the heck do you think TAUGHT you what you know? Think about it? I'm self taught, 36 years old with 24 years of hands on experience. (How many years are you now?)

I consult for people like you who try to do things the textbook way but quickly realize that self taught techies produce more in less time, use less company resources, and don't need to purchase 1/2 the tools you do because we know how to find what we need in the black screen ! Also, we don't just specialize in one area, we had to learn it all !

Anyway, You've obviously come across a bad self taught techie. DON'T PUT US ALL IN THE SAME CATAGORY....

by ed woychowsky

There is a difference between taking a class and actually doing something. A class is like a transplant, sometimes it just doesn't "take".

by sconsult

I have interviewed lots of college educated / Certified people for my clients. In many cases I find they have not actually done any development. They know the terms, and the theory, and look good on paper - but don't have a clue how to actually do the work.
I begin to find both are red flags to ask for specifics on how they would do something.

by tony hopkinson

The biggest problem I've found with the freshly theorised.

Is they don't write readable code.

It should be part of the course. Three versions of application, adding functionality.
They do one, swap with a classmate and do version two. Work on something completely different for some time, then swap with another classmate for version three.

They'd know what real world development was about then.

Change !

by apotheon

Having students work on each others' code like that is a great idea. It astounds me that schools don't seem to have stumbled upon that idea yet.

Then again, the instructors in college programming classes are often ivory tower academics who've never done production development themselves these days.

by ivy clark

Let's get real, everyone is self-taught one way or another these days, especially in the IT arena. There are stuff used today that were never taught in schools before anyway. And there'll be new technologies tomorrow that you dont learn about in school today.

If you're not self taught at all, you'll be left behind.

Sounds to me like you are the wannabe hiding behind a paper qualification because you lack the attitude and aptitude, lack the passion and drive to learn, and as a result you are not able to keep up.

by anne.baynes

My only problem with the self-taught zealots is that many of them (most that I've met through my experiences, at least) aren't willing to help any of us "schooled" in their learning, or guide them in the slightest.

Even though this post was just flamebait, many of you who are replying are showing the same attitude that the original post is complaining about. Maybe it wasn't such a flame after all?

Fact of the matter is that for those of us in the younger generation going to college is not an option, it's pretty much mandatory if you want to get anywhere in life. It's difficult to find job listings that don't require a 4-year degree of some sort. You try to spend your summers in internships to help you learn those practical application skills, but are met with people who won't give you any responsibility or respect because you're still a silly intern with no real-world skills. It's a pretty big deterrent when people are acting arrogant and disrespecting you when all you're trying to do with your summer is gain the knowledge and skills that they're hassling you for not having.

All I'm saying is that this "schooling" is pretty much mandatory now (even though I'll get replies that say, "As a hiring manager I don't care about schooling..." which I call out as being complete crap and out of touch with real HR)and that maybe you self-taught could help us learn the things that our ridiculously expensive college educations didn't teach us, don't just put us down.

This wasn't meant to be a rant. Just pointing out a few things. Thanks for reading.

by tony hopkinson

for exactly the same reason as those you wish to shoot down. He showed no respect and and made an imbecilic generalisation. I haven't noticed anyone one who's ripped him fall into that trap.

If there's one the thing the self taught know, it's that there are a lot of things they don't know.

On the don't pass on the knowledge front, I've seen that attitude from the qualified as well. Nothing to do with where they got their knowledge, much more to do with whether they'll have a job next week.

HR are out of touch with us, not us with them. Always and forever.

As for the need a degree to get a job now, unfortunately correct. I do mean unfortunate, given that the qualification isn't proof you are capable of the job and it is expensive, how many talents even as meagre as mine are being wasted ?

I'm not that brilliant or rare, just born to a relatively poor family at a time of high unemployment.

I've met people from more fortunate backgrounds with the qualifications, a shockingly high number of them weren't fit to sharpen my pencil.

by maecuff

All self-taught people aren't zealots, anymore than all people who have had formal education are zealots. People will either share their knowledge or they won't. Whether or not they went to school makes no difference.

And of COURSE people are responding the way they are. The original post said that people who are self taught are worthless. How is that ANYTHING but flamebait. There is no justification for that.

by hal 9000

But what makes it worse is this isn't the first time that [b]Good Old Spuddy M[/b] has done this now it's about the third time in the last 2 - 3 years that I've seen it from this clown. The last time he got replaced from his job for accessing the TR Site under an old account and abusing the [b]Computer Usage Rights[/b] of that company. Probably just its way of hurting the Self trained person responsible for its actions so it could feel justified for its beliefs.

But as far as your post goes unfortunately you are correct today that piece of paper is so important to get a job which isn't right but once you get accountants running a company you can not expect decent requirements from the companies concerned. My very first experience with someone like Spuddy was when I was writing Engine Management Programs for a company and we had all of 64K to play with. I gave the new guy who no one wanted to work with a simple job of rewriting a subroutine and he came back with a 128 K piece of code in the wrong format to use on the 64 K Storage EPROM that was available to us to use. His excuse was that he did it right and if it wouldn't fit it wasn't his fault it was a short coming of the hardware which needed redesigning. Needless to say I didn't put up with him for long particularly when he just wouldn't accept instructions and do things the way that I asked them to be done.

If I had of ever left the Punishment Detail that I was on he would have got a rude shock when he next ran into me but unfortunately for the company concerned I was doing something that I liked and what to most was Punishment was my Ideal Job. That was back in the days when you could only do Electronic Engineering as there where no Computer Courses of any kind available. So while I officially have the papers behind me I still consider myself [b]Self Trained[/b] and there is no way around that. The kid that I ran into was the product of one of the very first Computer Courses that the Uni's here ran which was several years after I had escaped the Local Uni.

[b]Uncle Albert[/b] said it best I think [b]No one should be allowed out of school without knowing just how little that they actually know.[/b] Spuddy on the other hand believes that it knows it all and there is nothing to learn but that others should be falling at its feet pleading with it to work for them. But in real life that never happens.

Also I don't know if you've noticed that this clown only starts something and then doesn't ever reply to any of the postings it plain & simple [b]Flame Bait[/b] nothing more & nothing less.

Col

by apotheon

I'm sorry you've had such bad experiences. I, for one, am always willing to help others learn, as long as A) they are genuinely interested in learning and B) have some aptitude for learning.

by anne.baynes

I'm really surprised that a lot of you are mentioning the "know-it-all" attitude of college grads. Seems like there more bad apples in the "schooled" category than I knew about. Perhaps I just never surrounded myself with those type of people. From my education, I took away the fact that you're never going to know EVERYTHING about a given subject, especially not at the time of your graduation. I took my education as a chance to not learn a subject fully, rather a chance to train myself to pick up a complicated topic in a relatively short period of time.

All this being said, sorry if I sounded like an ass in my post. I have nothing against the self-taught, I'm definitely envious of some of you for your opportunity to not have to waste a ridiculous amount of cash on school to get you where you are today. Also this first job of mine is seeming pretty stagnant already...

by tig2

When the job goes stagnant for you, your brain goes too. You stop even being open to new learning- you feel caught in a rut and dying there.

That is a bad place to be. How can we help you figure out how to not be there? I think that you are open to new views and new information.

What is your passion in IT? Your profile suggests that LAN is where you are- where do you want to be? If LAN Admin is it, what element of LAN Admin?

Many of us have been in the field since before the degree programs. That is true of both my partner (Applications Architect/ Programmer) and myself (Project/Programme Management). I have had to clean up the messes made by MBAs who "know computers". Many of them cost the company millions of dollars.

This is a good place to "un-stagnate". A great place for asking questions. And we're here to help. Won't say that there aren't idiots out there- there are. Sad fact. Most of us care about growing the next group. Some of us may want to retire someday and want to leave as a legacy what we have learned.

Edit typo

by tig2

When the hot-jock shows up in my world demanding that I teach him- and then "tries" to teach me, he will get none of my time.

When an intern shows up that really wants to learn, they have my undivided attention. I will send them websites, suggested reading, even buy them books. I am not alone in this.

Proof? I never learned Perl scripting. But earlier when I made the same statement, a peer directed me to some great resources. I have never met this peer but recognise that he is a valuable information source.

You may have had some bad experiences. You don't get through them or past them by being a troll.

The individual that started this post was banned from TR once already for identity theft and board misuse. We can learn nothing from such a person except to avoid him.

If you want real assistance, I will cheerfully point you to any resource I know in your arena.

If it helps any- I have to compete with people who have education but no clue how to do the job. As one who has spent 20+ years in the University of Life, that is annoying too.

Edit to add... I'm 43. IT is my first love, not my first job...

by tink!

It's all perspective and situation dependent. I'm sure there are many, many self-taught people who fall into the categorizations aforementioned. But I believe there are many more that are quietly doing their jobs without flaunting their lack of certificates or boasting of their experience over the schooled. Many of us do teach those who work under us because there is so much knowledge that is acquired through experience and it really helps others who are just learning to be forewarned of potential problems. Because the probablity and possibilities of problems is so infinite, they cannot possibly all be covered in schooling. Therefore experience plays a great part in teaching our techs what to focus on and what to learn more about.
As for how self-taught people are viewed by their peers, that will depend on the personality of that person as well as the personality of the peers.

Tink

(Go Mae! You are an inspiration to a female tech! - I currently don't have any minions though - :(

by maecuff

I think I'm pretty much older than you are..it takes a while to get 'minions'. :)

That, and being in the right place at the right time. I'm not minimizing my accomplishments, but there is something to be said for lucky timing.

by hal 9000

Is it [b]Good Luck or Bad Luck[/b] to be in a position where you have minions. While you can get them to run around after you, you also have to take responsibility for their actions as well. :D

My Minions used to insist that I was the worst person in the world to work for until I left and then they all wanted me back most kept following me around as well as I moved through the different companies. I never could manage to hold a job for any length of time as I couldn't fit in the systems without short circuiting them so that the customers got better service. :0

Actually in most cases after I had turned a place around and the Accountants where stepping in I was Head Hunted and left of my own accord to get into a position that suited my temperament better. :^0

Of course I'm also Narcissistic as well when I say that I've never actually applied for a single job I've always been approached to work for different companies so I must be doing something wrong. :)

Col

by tony hopkinson

Spend three months writing code with loops in them, and thirty seconds on what sort of loop you should use.

Question 1
Use a repeat loop to do ...
A constraint / clue like that solves three quarters of the problem straight off.

Course in real life, things aren't that simple. The guy who set the problem, would n't know a loop if you choked him out with it.

by nicknielsen

When I was taught Cobol waaaay back in the dark ages, our professor would fail projects that used loops and did not check for errors [b]inside[/b] the loop. Do they even teach error trapping today?

by maecuff

you are right. I DON'T like being responsible for the actions of 10 people. What I DO like, is the paycheck that goes along with it.

by tony hopkinson

The question thing is the main problem with an an exam for either academia or the cert merry go round.
Marking them is easy for factual content, for understanding that takes effort and therefore cost. These boys have got to maximise shareholder value as well you know. Besides if you make it too hard to pass, less people will pay to take it!

Simple economics really.

A good topic for a blog though (error handling !), I'll add it to my list.

by tink!

As they did take the time and effort to sit through all that educating. However, a reminder to them, to always keep an open mind once out of the classroom. You must always learn...everyday. This is something you'll see us self-taught people doing very naturally. The classroom gives you the foundation on which to build your learning platform. In IT you [b]NEVER STOP LEARNING![/b]
Tink

by tony hopkinson

competition between students. This would damage them emotionally, making some 'lose' and look like failures. It's a sort of child abuse really is n't it. It would damage them in later life.

Any reasonable person has got to agree with this view haven't they ?

Makes you f'kin boil doesn't it!

by tig2

Mostly because I manage IT projects. As far as the PMI is concerned, if you can manage construction projects you can manage IT projects. I believe that there is a difference.

To me, getting a certification that proves that I can reguritate the PMBOK is useless in my field. Frequently my job is more on the lines of facilitating communication between business and IT. I build happy motivated teams who want to successfully implement their work. And the work meets business requirements that I have had to work like a dog to pull out and clarify.

How do you certify that? You don't.

CompTIA has Project+. I will go for that one. PMP does not tell you anything about what I can do and no one is interested in my Microsoft certs- they don't tell you anything but that I was certified to support Microsoft Systems- rarely a requirement in my current employment.

CISSP is another matter entirely. That one I will finish off because I think there is a validity.

Incidentally, the fact that I was a licensed nurse rarely gets me noticed any more...

by tony hopkinson

that will get you noticed !
LOL
But otherwise you hit the nail on the head, how is some plonker from HR going to distinguish between someone who is certified and someone who has a certification. As soon as mills, boot camps, cheat sheets, answer downloads and books in how to pass them came on line, they got devalued.

Business wanted certs to have a standard, then they made a business out of handing said standard to anyone who could see lighting and hear thunder. Oh and pay up of course.

Serves them right.

by hal 9000

You both know the saying [b]Those That Can Do & Those That Can't Teach![/b]

You could never accuse many of these teachers as being overly bright and even worse you can never accept that they would willing be shown up by their students.

I can still remember the very first drawing that I did when I was doing Mech Engineering a assembly [b]Open & In Line[/b] which couldn't be assembled but the pictures looked so nice. :D

I got marked down for changing the drawing because you couldn't assemble it and was promptly told that it wasn't a [b]Design Problem but a Fitting Problem.[/b] :(

Col