Discussion Locked

Servers visible accross multiple subnets

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

For security reasons, we would like it if users on one subnet cannot see servers on a second subnet when they browse network neighborhood.

We have a router between subnets A & B, however users on B can still see that there are servers on A(they can't access them, they just see them). Users on A need access to resources on B. Users on B need nothing on A.

Any ideas to block or filter those servers from being seen?

Thanks in advance.

gruta@ctsi-usa.com

6 replies

by lordinfidel

Questions:

Is this a NT4 domain or is this Active Directory?

If NT4 domains, the problem here is in the domain model. They are not really "seeing" the servers. They are getting a browse list returned to them from the master browser.

If you took those servers on A out of the domain and made them their own domain. Then set up a one way trust from B -> A (B trusts users from A). Then when users from B open up net neighborhood they will see the domain, but they can not open it. Thus hiding any servers on A.

A users will be able to browse the B domain/subnet because it is trusted to do so.

In AD, it is a little different because of the Global Catalog. Again you would create 2 domains seperating each of the subnets. But since 2K domains have transitive trusts, you will need to remove the access from users B to the A domain.

They will still see the domain in the Directory, but they will not be able to browse it.

Hope this helps, let me know if this does not make sense. I am sometimes bad at explaining things.

by lordinfidel

Just an FYI about access lists at the router.

While they will act as a firewall in basically blocking those address' from being accessed. They will not stop themselves from being seen in the domain.

The reason being is because every time a computer boots up, it looks for the master browser (after being authenticated). The master broswer for that domain then returns the browser list for the domain. If multiple domains are in a trust relationship. All trusted domains are returned.

Depending on your access rights will depend on whether or not you can open up/browse the domain.

Each domain contains it's own master browser.

In AD, regardless of where you are located on the network. If your computer is a member of the domain,it is registered into the global directory for that forest. Every DC that is a GC server knows about each system.

So again the only way to control "seeing" the systems is to seperate them into another domain and control access that way.

by singh

You mentioned you were using routers. he answer is simple just use access list in the roters config to block the addresses.
Cheers

This discussion is closed to new replies.