Discussion Locked

Should I spend $1,500 on my dog?

0 helpful
41 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I love dogs. They're beautiful animals. They can add so much fun and joy to a person's life that it's impossible to describe - unless you've ..... been there, done that.

They show unquestionable and unwavering love and affection. Our 11 year-old Golden Retriever is no exception. On second thought, maybe he IS the exception, because he's SO SMART, so obedient, so loving, and so well mannered. I absolutely love this dog. Not as much as the people in my family, mind you, and not at all in the same way, but if you're a dog owner - and a dog lover - I'm sure you understand.

The average life expectancy of a Golden Retriever is 12 years. Mine is 11.

I remember buying this dog (a puppy) from a breeder, surprising my son, who was 8 years old at the time, as a companion for an only child. My son is 18, almost 19, and will be going off to college in late August. Our dog has provided years of joy, loyalty, and companionship. He's gone on mountain hikes with us, swam in lakes and ponds, spent hours upon hours playing fetch, laid at our feet and licked our faces, and he's forgiven us with doggie-love whenever we've left him in the back yard during a storm.

He's obviously hurting, and there's nothing anyone can do about it. He struggles to get up, but he instinctively wants to follow us from room to room. He has some other ailments that I won't get into, but suffice it to say, his better days are behind him.

We could pay to treat those ailments, but it would only delay the inevitable - by how much, who knows? It might, however, improve the quality of life for a while - for our trusted companion.

He relies on us for everything. He's pretty helpless without us. For centuries we've domesticated dogs for our human pleasure and enjoyment. Do we own them anything in return?

Perhaps I should consider this: I can earn $1,500 in [i]X amount of hours[/i]. Is spending that amount of $$ worth the [i]more than X[/i] hours of enjoyment our dog will continue to provide?

As I think out-loud, it might be the best $1,500 I've ever spent. He's going to make it to 16, and I'll make it as comfortable as possible for him. What it might cost me pales in comparison to what he's given us.

41 replies

by hal 9000

I have spent considerably more than that on dogs over the years and I used to spend that much every time that one of my Bitches had a Litter.

My daughter has just spend well over 4.5K on a puppy that jumped out of a Ute in their driveway and got run over he had 5 days in Intensive Care and then several days in the Pet Hospital @ 1K per day for Intensive Care. She was advised to come in and say good by as they couldn't get him to eat, drink or even move more than the absolute minimum so when she got there he jumped into her and dragged over an O2 Bottle that he was attached to and wouldn't leave her side.

Apparently he was sulking because he wasn't with his owners and was fretting. Cost them 2K to find out that I might add. ;)

But back to your question this all depends on the dog itself and what is wrong. If there are serious issues I prefer not to let them suffer I watched a dog die of Distemper years ago and swore to myself that it would never happen again, where I allowed the vets to prolong the suffering. Then when Parvo hit this place I lost a entire litter and the Dam when a vet came in and brought the disease with him and contaminated the litter that he was there to immunize. We latter found out what had killed them but at the time no one knew what was going on. When it became obvious I had the litter put down and the Dam was sent into Intensive Care to try to save her the puppies didn't stand a chance and I wouldn't prolong the suffering after the first day where they all lost 50% of their body weight in under 24 hours.

The Bitch lasted 3 days more before I had her put down and neither of those decisions was easy till you looked at the dogs, they didn't need to suffer and I wouldn't allow them to any longer. At that time the Vets didn't agree with my decisions but I was latter proved to have been correct as when that initially hit this place the survival rate was less than 2% and the animals did suffer terribly.

But that is what I base my decisions when faced with these issues on how much will the dog suffer and I'm always beside them petting them when they get the needle and I stay with them till well after the end has occurred.

Col

by the scummy one

and I dont think that anyone should. This is a decision that you have to make yourself. Only you know your financials and feelings well enough to determine what may be done. However, it seems that you have made your decision and are looking for feedback on it.

You should go with what you can live with the best!

by deadly ernest

similar issue, to me the big questions are:

What will your companion's quality of life be like after the treatment?

You need to think about this, will there still be a lot of pain or a little pain. If little or no pain, then it's an easy call - spend the money. If a lot of pain and on a marginal improvement in life care - again and easy call, let them have peace.

The trouble comes with the scale in between. I know you want to spend more time with your companion, but think of them first. Think of what their life will be like for this time. If good, spend, if not ease their suffering.

Average is average, which means many will live well past that. So don't let the age be a deciding factor.

Back in late 1999 I inherited a kitten, not sure how, but it happened. As he neared his first birthday he got run over by a car. The vet suggested putting him down as the costs would be near A$2,000 - a couple of months income at that time, and the vet didn't think he'd last for more than another year or so. I paid up and he died in mid step while walking across the yard about six months back. Eight years past the vet's estimate.

Forget age and think about quality of life - and pain is a big thing there.

by mjd420nova

My heart goes out to you and don't think I could make the decision for you. My situation was similar, we had a loving cat for 18 years and were faced with $1,000. to attempt to cure a failing kidney. When the time came we decided to have him euthanized on a day when the whole family would have a chance to say their goodbyes. Early that same morning, I heard him crying. I found him cuddled on the bathroom floor. I picked him up, he looked at me, gave me a kind of grin, started purring, gave a big long streach, a big sigh and expired. He knew the end was coming and wanted to be held and comforted at the moment. I cried like a baby. It is a tough time and will not be easy. My sympathy is with you.

by jardinier

My cat Smokey was the best friend I ever had -- human or animal.

She would lie on top of the bedclothes at night, right up against me so that I could not move. I would boot her down to the end of the bed and that is where she would sleep.

We never knew her age as she was a hand-me-down from a deceased relative. But she was perhaps about 20 years of age when a red setter dog came into the yard and frightened her. Shortly after that we noticed she had developed what appeared to be a hernia.

The vet said she was too old to handle anesthetic so my mother and I took her home while we thought about what to do.

Then, she broke from her usual regimen of sleeping on top of the bed clothes, and wriggled in under the sheets so that she could sleep up against my body. She did this for two nights.

By this time my mother and I decided it was best to have her put down rather than suffer the discomfort of the hernia. I signed the form giving the vet permission for euthanasia, which was then performed.

So Smokey apparently knew, two days before we had made the decision, that she was going to die and wanted to be close to me for the last couple of days.

I was telling this story to a friend who responded with this true-life tale. There was a cat in a nursing home that was normally very aloof. But whenever one of the patients was approaching death, the cat would curl up on their bed and purr loudly.

Here is Smokey:

http://www.topsciencenews.com/images/Smokey_1_crop_34.jpg

by mjd420nova

Our cat was a stray that my son picked up on the streets. When he brought him home, we found a ring of oil and dirt around his neck. It was apparent to us that someone had tried to hang him. This was reinforced by his very strong resistance to wearing any kind of collar. I do believe that he knew when it was his time and his crying in the night was a plea to the one he knew would give him the comfort he needed to meet the end on his own terms. Cats are far more inteligent than we give them credit for.

by ontheropes

If it was me and I could afford it I'd spend the money and would never look back. It's just money. You'll make more.

by jamesrl

Our previous dog shwoed signs of cancer at 9, went through a remission after we spent many dollars, only to experience a rapid decline a year later. But you can't do the math on these things. All you should calculate is should you spend money when the outcome is uncertain, or more specifically, if the dog is not going to enjoy life.

If the animal has multiple problems and you can fix only some of them, is the animal still suffering or are they able to enjoy life. I would not be one to prolong an animals life because of my own selfishness. I'm not in any way suggesting you are doing that because I and everyone else here don't know enough details to make a decision.

It all comes down to quality of life. Humans can be invalids and be happy because they have a mental life. Dogs on the other hand, derive much of their pleasure from physical acts of walking, running and interacting. If there is a good chance that your dog will have a good quality of life for a while, then do it. If the quality is only slightly improved.....

James

by ic-it

There have been many thoughtful and kind words written in response already. My prose could only echo those same thoughts.
You sound as if you have decided, but if not, either choice will be the right one.

by bfilmfan

Last year, I had to spend a bit over $2500 on our family pet, as she had a huge bladder stone that just suddenly appeared. She's a small dog at 13 lbs and the stone weighed 19 ounces or about 5% of her total body weight.

After the surgery, which she recovered from 100%, the vet mentioned health insurance. I, live pretty simply, so the $50 a month for the doggie upkeep policy isn't a strain. Something you might want to look into with your vet.

I know that not every family can afford a large expense for a pet's health care crisis. I've had to make that hard decision myself in the past with 2 family pets and it was tough as hell. I still miss both of those animals to this day, a border collar anmed Sugar that lived for 20 years with us and a malmute\terrier mix named Fritzie that we somehow adopted that never learned to bark, but made all manner of noises to get your attention. When the collie was old, the new dog showed up and kept her interested in life for another 5 years.

We eventually had to put her down, because her hips got so bad that she couldn't stand anymore. We buried her in the back corner of the property and placed a snowball bush on her. Fritzi mopped around for months and adopted the bush as his favorite snare to lie in wait of the hated squirrels and chipmunks, which infested the yard with their evil rodent selves.

Years later, when Fritzi got to where he could no longer stand, we had to have him put down and buried him next to his companion under the snowball bushes.

Out current pet isn't really a yard dog, but her favorite place to lie in ambush of the great-great-great-great-grandchildren of those same evil squirrels, is the snowball bush...

by jardinier

sure beats talking about computers. I could add lots and lots of stories about our various pets, but I think all issues have already been covered in the various posts.

But I will mention the last dog my mother and I ever had -- Sweetie. About 12-13 years is the normal lifespan of an average sized dog.

Sweetie became progressively deaf and blind, but nothing would deter her from walking to the shops with me. I knew she was deaf because when I called or whistled her she could not tell the direction from which the sound was coming. Her blindness caused her to bump into walls and telegraph poles. There came a time when she had to be put down. I let my mother take Sweetie to the vet. I could not face being there when she was put down.

Here is Sweetie:

http://www.topsciencenews.com/images/Sweetie_30.jpg

by charliespencer

Five years ago our cocker / terrier mix was 14. She'd had a heart murmur all her life but it didn't bother her until the very end. She began having trouble breathing, and a couple of weeks after that the X-rays showed her heart had swollen to almost three times its normal size.

It wasn't a question of the money; I spent $150 just to get her an extra night. It was a question of a family member suffering with no possibility of long-term relief, and my being able to help end that suffering. In that light, my wife and I had no problem reaching a quick decision to end both the suffering and our pet's life. I do not regret that decision at all, and regard it as one of the best I've ever made.

Regardless of what you decide, I wish you and your dog the best. Now please excuse me while I blow my nose.

by maxwell edison

Colin, Scummy, Ernest, mjd42nova, Julian, Tony, Ropes, Boxy, James, bwilmot, BFilmFan, santeewelding, and Palmetto - great replies and some great insight. I've enjoyed reading everyone's opinion, and the stories you shared about your own experiences.

It's amazing how we get attached to our pets. They're animals, but they give us so much.

I'm spending the money. I have a feeling that he's still got at least three or four more good years in him, and I want them to be quality years for him.

Many thanks for taking the time to reply.

by nicknielsen

But you've already closed things out.

Good call. It feels like the right thing to do to me as well.

by maxwell edison

I simply wanted to acknowledge those who replied thus far, but I thought it would be rather redundant to say the same thing in each individual reply.

Please, feel free to keep the discussion going - and many thanks to you as well.

by ontheropes

I'm their Grumpa. (I didn't misspell that.) They're family and I'd miss either one of them terribly if something were to happen.
It pleases me to see your decision. Enjoy.

by nicknielsen

I need a pink ribbon on Sid and decided to do it with the GIMP. So far no good, but time's been tight lately; 10 minutes at a time every fourth or fifth day is no way to learn and retain. Heck, with this old laptop, half that time is spent waiting for the GIMP to load!

edit missing word

by charliespencer

Just making the decision, one way or the other, is the hard part. The longer you wait to reach a conclusion, the more both of you suffer. Best of luck.

by tonythetiger

Just about any bad quality a human can have... dogs don't.

They don't talk about you behind your back... They don't have ulterior motives... They don't cheat on you with another owner... etc.

by jamesrl

We adopted a stray once who took every opportunity to eat as many meals as possible all around the neighbourhood. Eventually I think someone fed her better and we lost a cat.

James

by hal 9000

Better than expected and that your Puppy comes bounding back.

Doesn't matter how old that they get they are always a Puppy at Heart. ;)

Col

by jardinier

My family always had both dogs and cats, and also chooks for quite a while.

When my Dad died in 1973, I moved back to live with my mother where -- except for a few years in the mid 1980s when I lived in Kings Cross -- I remained until she had to be transferred to a nursing home in 1994 suffering dementia. She passed on in 2006 at the age of 96 from the side effects of dementia.

The family home of 43 years was sold in 1995 and I purchased a unit (condo to you Americans). There was a strict rule forbidding pets. The thing I missed most was having a puss to say hello to me in the morning.

When I lived with my Mum we kept different hours. She went to bed early and arose at 7 am sharp, and I went to bed late and got about at around 10.30 am.

Her cat Shelley would wait in the kitchen until I emerged, to say hello to me before disappearing out into the yard for the day.

I hope you all don't mind me posting photos of my animals. I keep them on a special page of one of my websites for easy linking.

Here is my mother's cat Shelley:

http://www.topsciencenews.com/images/Shelley_crop_40.jpg

by deadly ernest

I ask as a couple of years back I made a couple of transparent background pink ribbons for addition to avatars, they're available from the download section of my web site. the direct link to the images are:

small
http://www.bywater.net.au/images/Pinktransparent2.gif

big
http://www.bywater.net.au/images/Pinktransparent1.gif

I put one on my avatar by copying the image and placing the ribbon on it, then flattening the image, and shrinking it to what's needed for the avatar. All done in Gimp at the time.

by nicknielsen

I'll look into it. I'm sure it won't look that good to start, but it will be a start.

I'm trying to find a larger image than the thumbnail I've got, but haven't had the time (or connection speed!) when I've been thinking about it.

edit: So what do you think? Should Sid get a pink bow tie?

by deadly ernest

Only one trouble with large old dogs is when they go to sleep on your feet, they can make it awkward getting out of the chair. But they never argue with you for long.

by av .

He's an old trusted friend that needs some help right now. Even if you can only give him a few months longer without pain, its worth the money. He was there for you for 11 years. You do owe it to him. Yes, he's a dog, but its the right thing to do.

AV

by captbilly1eye

... I would do whatever it took if I thought it meant it would improve my pet's quality of life. Unfortunately, I know me and it would be tough not to put too much weight on the hoping that I could just spend more time with them.

yea.. I cried when I read Marley & Me and again when I saw the movie.

whether it's a dog, a cat, a bird, or whatever, we all get attached & dependent on their companionship.

by jamesrl

I think it comes down to very similar issues.

If there is zero prognosis for recovery, and an illness that becomes very painful and debilitating, I am ok with the idea of assisted suicide. If the person involved is not able to make decisions on their own, I have more issues with that - unless they have a living will.

If the pain is manageable then I say stay as long as you can. Its a quality of life thing. Pain plus breathing tubes etc, there isn't much quality of life there, and if there is no hope, whats the point.

But I realize these are not everyone's choice. Thats why I like living wills.

James

by delbertpgh

He'll like a companion, and whatever life he has left to him (including what you buy for him) he'll enjoy better.

Then, after he's gone, the little guy can keep YOU company.

by charliespencer

Our cat and dog enjoyed each other's company, and the furball was a great comfort after the dog passed on. However, if you decide to do so I suggest you delay bringing in a new pet until after your dog has recovered from surgery.

by maxwell edison

After my current one is gone, however, I'd like to be without restraint as far as travelling and such. Dogs are great, but they add a whole new factor when going out of town; and in the future, I think I'll be doing more of it, not less.

by ksoniat

I had a dog with bone cancer in his leg only. We decided to amputate rather than put him down. He responded well - got along well on three legs for quite a while.

I don't think you will regret giving it a try. Good Luck!!!

by forum surfer

Would I? Depends. If it meant that much to my family, yes. If it were just me and the dog? I'd seriously consider euthanasia. But then again I'm not the one who spent so much time with the dog and looking in his sad eyes on a daily business.

Suppose I were putting my kid through college. $1500 is alot of money for a single parent putting a kid through college. We all saw how Old Yeller ended!

It's too tough to call from a totally objective point of view. I can't find any moral fault in either point of view.

by nerdherder

If spending this money will return the dog to a happy life, then spend it. If it will just prolong pain and misery, then it's time to say good-bye. This is not what is best for your budget or what is best for the family. The question is what is best for the dog. That's the hardest to answer. Discuss this with your vet.

This discussion is closed to new replies.