Discussion Locked

Should I use Vlans?

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi Everyone,
I have a situation I need some input on, I?m sure someone here can help. I?ve been working now at a site as a Netadmin for several years. I built it from the ground up. Just about all the switches (19 in all) and layer3 switches (6 inall) are 3com. I use class C privet IP addressing schema (DHCP) with one subnet for Servers and another subnet for users and have one T1. Originally there was not much need for much more, however, over the past year the company has grown considerably to the point were IP addresses are low and the future forcast for company growth is very good. Here?s what I was thinking of doing:
1) Implement Class B addressing
2) Implement VLAN?s for all the departments. (7 total)

I have very little experience with Vlans and haven?t been able to find much info to the follwing questions:
1) Will Vlans even effect IP addressing and DNS, DHCP?
2) How will DHCP react to the Vlans?
3) How will DNS react to the Vlans?

This is just some Ideas, but any help would be greatly appreciated!

4 replies

by joseph moore

I am not a total VLAN expert, but here is what I do know.
Since you are not using VLANS now, then you have 2 broadcast domains, one for the servers and one for the users.
When you start to roll out VLANS, you will be making a separate broadcast domain for each VLAN, so you need to route between VLANS.
This means that you either have to a)have a router for each VLAN or b)have your switches do routing.
So, putting VLANS all over will make your LAN architecture more complex, with the routing. Make sure you are ready for this!
DHCP and VLANS (I think) is gonna be a problem, due to the whole broadcast domain thing. DHCP requests do not jump broadcast domains, so if you need DHCP in your 7 VLANS, you will either need a)1 DHCP server per VLAN or b)a DHCP server with multiple scopes plugged into a switch port that is a member of multiple VLANS. This might be interesting to set up.
Last, DNS and VLANS is easy. As long as the routing is set, then your clients in the VLANS can all hit your DNS server(s) in whatever VLAN they are in. VLANS won't hurt DNS.

Hope this helps

by joseph moore

Oh, I forgot to add:
Yes, you should use VLANS. They make things more complex, but once they are set up, you are gonna love the results.

by wireboy

Hey Joseph,
Thank you for the answer. After reading what you said I was able to find out that by using DHCP fowarding on the routers or the DHCP Relay agent I should be able to get through broadcast domain thing. Thanks for your help.

This discussion is closed to new replies.