Discussion Locked

Should you have to be legal to vote?

0 helpful
224 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Is there any country in the world that does not require you to be a registered voter, to vote in elections?

(dictatorships, need not respond)

Of these that require you to register, do you have to have valid Identification to cast your vote?

In places without required ID, is there a higher instance of voter fraud than places that DO require them? [i]( dead voting, felons, etc )[/i]

Can anyone possibly give me an explaination how it is discrimination in ANY way to require someone prove they are who they say they are when they go to vote? Their ballot is still confidential, so that is not a concern.

Ohio is dealing with that very issue now.
http://coshoctontribune.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20061030/NEWS01/61030002/1002

Does this mean people WANT dead people to continue to have a say in elections, both local and national?

224 replies

by jamesrl

There are municipal elections going on in my province, and in Toronto there is a movement to allow non citizens to vote. They point out that in many cities, all you need is established residency and you can vote for mayor.

There is a debate, and I am on the "citizenship becomes meaningless if it doesn't entitle you to some priveleges" camp. The other side points out that if you tax someone and don't give them some say in how those dollars are spent - its taxation without representation....

No one has yet suggested it at a national level. Once upon a time, I do remember that in Ontario, you could vote if you were resident in Ontario and were a British citizen, but that was subsequently eliminated.

James

by jdclyde

The only way that is valid is if the people WANT to become citizens, but are not allowed to.

No one is MAKING someone live somewhere and not become a citizen.

If you are NOT a citizen, then you should NOT have ANY say in the way the government is being run.

Illegal aliens and immigranst are NOT the reason for this in the US though. There are always thousands of dead people that find the time to vote, as well as convicted felons. Felons lose their right to vote when they make a choice to commit a felony in the US.

I still don't see how some people claim this is racist to require verification.

by protiusx

So that is why there is a death tax in Washington State! Queen Christine (our usurper governor) is attempting to legitimize her base by taxing them. Brilliant!

by maxwell edison

Just ask Neil, who paid who knows how much in sales tax, hospitality tax, and gasoline tax (but much less than in the UK, I might guess), without being represented. The same applies to any citizen of one country who goes into another country, legally or not.

by oldbag

I am against extending the municipal vote to non-citizens as well.

If you come to this country, please make a commitment. If you do not wish to commit, then you are not extended the priviledges of a citizen which includes the vote.

I could go on about non-citizens wanting all the same rights as citizens (either Canadian-born or those who take the oath) but I will leave that discussion for another day.

by mjd420nova

No one who is not a documented citizen should be allowed to vote. You are in America and you must be an American to vote. Along with that goes the requirement to read and speak english to be a citizen. This bi-lingual or multi-lingual ballots is crap. Just like allowing an interpreter to take a driving test with you. If you can't read or speak english, how do you know what the road signs say. More crap.

by jdclyde

That most represenatives will not say what you just said because deceitful and dishonst people will pull out the "race card" if they do.

"how dare you expect someone to do anything to fit in and become an addition to the country!"

by onbliss

In India, one has to be registered in an Electoral Roll. And The Election Commision requires a EPIC - Elector's Photo Identity Card - for the voter to vote.

But I think the EPIC has not been issued to all, and hence there is scope for election rigging and fraud. And in places where the Politician-Rowdies nexus is greater, the fraud is greater.

by oldbag

How could it be considered discrimation if everyone is obligated to present ID?

Personally, when I go to vote, I always either have my Elections canada card or my dirver's licence ready.

by protiusx

What the leftists are saying is that some people are so poor that they can not aford the cost associated with acquiring a photo ID. In some states it has become a race issue liken to the vote tax applied just after the civil war.

There are certain states that attempted to legislate this and then offered to waive the nominal cost associated with the photo ID.

To the average citizen (regardless of your political affiliation) some things are really a "no-brainer". Things like a person should be a living breathing American citizen who has a valid photo ID to vote or that there should not be anything like a professional politician (which means term limits) are "no-brainers".

by jamesrl

If you are poor, then I don't have an objection to having some kind of fee waiving or subsidy whatever to make photo ID accessable (this could pay off in other ways anyway). In Canada, you would have a health insurance card, which I believe would be paid for by welfare, if you couldn't afford the nominal fee.

But if you have no fixed address, even with valid ID, its hard to work out voting rights, because you need a fixed address to determine where to vote. You do not want people driving school buses through the streets and picking up people to let them vote in multiple places because they have no fixed address. Think it would never happen??? Don't bet on it.

James

by jamesrl

In Ontario, you are mailled a paper telling you that you are on the list and telling you where and when you can vote. You show up with your paper and some form of photo ID - government issued (health card/drivers license preferred). If you aren't on the list you can vote if you show some sort of ID proving citizenship - birth certificate, citizenship status card(only issued to people who become citizens, not those born here) and something that proves you are resident 30 days before the election - hydro bill etc.

The rules used to be stricter - if you were not on the voters list, then no vote, but in those days they did door to door enumeration. Now they use other information, including federal tax files (your option - tick box on the tax form) to create the list.

James

by oldbag

Except, if you have the Election card, you do not need to present photo ID. In theory, I could go and vote with my Elections Canada card then leave, pick up my daughter's card and go back and vote again with no one the wiser unless I was recognized. I think we should all present some sort of photo ID.

by tink!

I definitely think you should have to be a citizen to vote in America. Unfortunately we were too laid back for all these years and allowed thousands of illegals into the country which then multlipied into millions thereby making them a large part of the current population. We in turn are now customizing EVERYTHING to accommodate them. This I think is total B.S.! and mind you I am an extremely kind and sympathetic person..not a begrudging bone in my body, but this kind of thing really peeves me.

I cannot understand why people believe they should have all the rights of a true American citizen just because they live here. If they have [b]CHOSEN [/b] as America their permanent residence than they should make themselves a citizen of the country. If you don't want to be a citizen, than don't demand the rights of a citizen.

This country was built on the backs of immigrants. Those immigrants learned english well enough to communicate and do business with the rest of the country. Those immigrants worked their a**es off to build a good living and thereby build this country up. This is why it really gets to me to see illegals demanding rights and proclaiming discrimination.

If an American goes to another country, we are [b]EXPECTED [/b]to learn the native or official language...especially if we choose to live there permanently. They do not accommodate us save for the adjustments made for tourists. Why should America not treat others the same way? Why can't we make everyone learn our official language too?

We are just simply big push-overs. It's time to take a stand and show that we are a strong country...by standing up for ourselves. Screw racial discrimination... it's just an excuse to get things easy.

(I happen to be a non-natural born American citizen, but I was adopted as a young child by a true American family. I came over speaking Korean, but was taught English. It should be no different for anyone else. - and that's another thing that peeves me...an illegal can give birth to a child in this country, and that child is automatically an American citizen...more B.S. and it's causing a lot of problems because now they can claim we're separating their families if we force non-citizens out. Oh Boohoo! It was your *** choice)

Tink
(this is the most swearing you'll ever see out of me...I hate this issue)

[i](Edited for grammatical error !#@ something we've alrady discussed - I had "they're" instead of "their")[/i]

by jdclyde

"stupid" is a word that comes to mind.

My understanding though is that most of this has been put out as unfair to poor blacks that might not drive, and so never got a drivers license and never got a state ID. It usually falls back to the poor poor.

It is also faught because the people using discrimination as an excuse LIKE it that even the dead will rise up to vote for THEM every year.

How about where CA wanted to GIVE illegals valid drivers licenses?

by tink!

Illegals can get mortgages now without needing a social security number. This really got my goat because I had to [b] STRUGGLE[/b] to get my mortgage. Out of 12 years of marriage, my husband and I rented for 10, shelling out big bucks every month because even though at least one of us worked full-time and often both of us...we didn't have the doggone credit to get a mortgage. (In my case...I didn't have a credit score, and didn't want to risk having a credit card just to build up a score.)

It's too bad asians didn't raise big stinks about discrimination...I probably could have gotten my mortgage a lot quicker. LOL

Tink
(discrimination and racial issues bring out the worst in me)

by jgarcia102066

At the risk of over-generalizing I am going to put in my two cents. I get really peeved when I see illegal immigrants fighting for their rights when they have not paid their dues in the great U.S. I'm not talking about paying taxes, either. I'm talking about the blood that most American's can trace back in their familes as having been spilled in honor of our country.

One of my grandfathers was in WWII, my other grandfather was in the Korean War, my uncle was in Vietnam, I was in Desert Storm, and my nephew is now in Iraq. In my humble opinion, we have paid our dues and earned our citizenship for this country. Why shouldn't we expect that of all wanting to become citizens?

Here's a simple solution coming from my simple analytical mind.

1. Our armed forces have trouble reaching their recruitment quota's every year.

2. Illegal immigrants come to this country wanting to raise their families here.

1+2 = Why don't we require that at least one member of an illegal immigrant's family has to serve our country for some limited period of time (2 years, 4 years) and "pay their dues" to earn their right to be called a citizen and to receive all afforded rights, thereof?

I'm done.

by danlm

My opinion on illegal immigrants is derived from conversations with people that have become American citizens. They spent loads of time, money, and effort to become legal citizens of this nation. And their feelings are almost unanimous: What makes these illegal immigrants any better then them? Which is how I feel about it now.

But serving in the armed services would be a great idea. Un-fortionnally, I for see 1 problem.

* Sargent yells attack.
-- Illegal immigrant recruit looks in-comprehensively at his Sargent because he does not understand English.

Dan

by jdclyde

The Democrats have already been going on and on about how "it isn't fair" that only the poor poor fight the wars, dispite it being an all volunteer military.

They are also the same people that want to elimiate the border and give everyone free access to everything.

Clearly you would never see the democratic party support this.

The Republicans would be unlikely to either, because they are such whimps now, afraid that someone will call them a name.

Next thing we know, someone will step up and say it "isn't fair" to ask people to earn their keep.

by java_ho

I remember several fellow Marines who came in on green cards and were granted citizenship after completion of service. They were willing to pay their dues, and they are the kind of people who I'm honored to call fellow Americans. There is the legitimate civilian route to citizenship which I consider equally valid. Either way, like in all other facets of life, there's no free lunch. You have to pay to play.

Those not willing to become citizens and live by our country's laws bring their (invariably lower) standard of living to our shores and lower the average quality of life for everyone. It's not fair.

Just my 1/50th of a dollar's worth.

by drowningnotwaving

Someone who is totally opposed to war - I dunno, maybe someone who took the new testament to heart - are they able to be American citizens?

What about someone who actually is a red-blooded 50th generation American citizen but has some (well clearly in your opinion) misguided hippy left-wing homo women's-rights belief that usually war should actually be averted?

Oh my oh my oh my.

I'm guessing - just guessing here - that the anti-gun lobby should just be put on a boat and sent somewhere. F..kin' A bro. They're not really Americans.

Do you know just how much you really sound like any communist leader from the 60's?

by jamesrl

I know it is possible to join the US military if you are not a citizen, and if you serve honourably, gain your citizenship.

I don't recall all the details, but I have heard of people who have gone this route. One would assume that once they are a citizen they can sponsor their families to come over.

Not everyone is able to serve though. Nor would you want everyone coming in to serve.

One of the reasons that the draft was eliminated was that it was better to have a smaller force with motivated soldiers who want to be there, rather than spending time and $$ training people without the aptitude and motivation.

James

by delbertpgh

Your idea ('require that at least one member of an illegal immigrant's family has to serve our country for some limited period of time (2 years, 4 years) and "pay their dues" to earn their right to be called a citizen') makes the family, not the individual, the unit of citizenship. Mom gets to be a citizen because Junior joined the Army. There's just no room for that in the legal system.

Also, nice as some aspects of your idea are, it would only be fair if everybody had to do some kind of national service, including those lucky enough to be born here.

By the way, in the Vietnam era, legal immigrants were eligible to be drafted. I was in the Air Force with a guy who was still a Canadian who volunteered. It's probably still that way: you don't have to be a citizen to be in the military, and you don't have to be a citizen to be drafted.

by tink!

How else can you regulate an election to make sure there's only 1 vote per person and that person is a REAL registered voter?

by tig2

But yes, I DO think that you should be required to show proof of citizenship in order to vote. If it determined that a photo ID is sufficient to prove citizenship, fine.

I don't think that illegals should be permitted to vote. I think that if they want to be a part of that process, they should begin by becoming and remaining compliant to current law. They can also then take their place in the jury pool.

by jdclyde

Dems pick them up, giving smokes and booze in exchange for votes.

That is why there was a problem in the 2000 election with the butterfly ballot. Traditionally it goes R, D, and then the rest. With the butterfly, it made the text much larger for the aging population and had been used to get Clinton elected. When these people, most can't read, were dropped off and told to vote for the second candidate, they did. Buchanan got all kinds of votes that even HE agrees that he should not have gotten because of it.

And of course in Ohio the last time around where people were paid in crack to register voters.

You can guess for yourself which US political party was involved with each issue.

by drowningnotwaving

well . . .

let's see . . .

they put on white pokey hats, grabbed their guns and make damn sure that a reasonably high percentage of the American population - in some local cases the actual majority!! - didn't even get their chance to legally register their intent to vote. And god help them if they voted. If you want to know what terror is, imagine being at home and 10, 20, 100 or more screaming men come at your house with flames, guns and a rope. Now that was how some terrorists worked in the good old days.

And just check your history of the suffragettes - in the USA it was the GOP (and in every single operating democracy on the planet, the relevant conservative party) that fought hardest against them noisy bloody women getting the vote.

Wanna read about some of the domestic violence that a few of our upstanding, well-educated business leaders commited against their wives or daughters in that one? Just google suffragette and sit back for a while.

And the other way too . . .

Left-wing union leaders breaking the arms of anyone they found voting against their labor party (or Dem-equivalent) just to make sure everyone really got the message.

Lost votes, new votes, old machines, new machines.

Putting people on a bus gives them their right to vote VERSUS Putting people on a bus unfairly bribes minorities for the sake of (I'm sure it's true) a bit of crack. And I'd be pretty sure you learnt the bus trick off the English - they've been doing effectively the same thing for hundreds of years.

Both sides will find a million examples of sometimes funny sometimes shocking things done in the name of democracy.

But we all still beleive we should shove democracy down the throats of them pesky dark folk in the middle-east, at the end of a gun.

Well not really a democracy. Just a kind of controlled one where they vote with a limited kind of range. Because we wouldn't be happy if we gave them the vote and they elected Hammas, now would we? That wasn't the democracy we wanted. So we'll just let someone crush that one and make the population start again. Albeit without houses.

by jdclyde

we remember that it was a race issue, not a political issue. Stupid hate not based on what you believe, but what color your skin is, was not GOP.

If you look, known KKK members are in office now, but for the Democrats, not the Republicans. Any Republicans with ties to that were removed because of STANDARDS that they are held to. Democrats have no standards. Example in Michigan, a man is running uncontested, but because he was part of an armed robbery a few years back there is a move to not allow him to take his office. I can find the name if you really care, but I had never heard of him before, and yes, he is a democrat.

No sane Democratic nation will have anything to do with a Hammas government. The cowardly dogs hiding in with the citizens when they launch their attacks just so they can get the stupid to feel sorry for them because they got bombed back. Oh boo hoo.

by protiusx

Are you inferring that the KKK in the south was affiliated with the Republican Party? I don't know for sure so I'm going to have to research that. Sure would be strange as Lincoln was a Republican and it was the Southern Democrats who seceded from the Union in order to save the "Southern way of Life".
As far as your comments go regarding Iraq and their fledgling democracy:
Have you ever spoken face to face with an Iraqi who voted? Where you there during their elections? No? I was there for both elections last year and spoke to them. They went to the poles regardless of the threats and violence. Men, women and children dressed in their finest clothes in order to walk for several miles, stand in a queue for hours so that they could cast their vote and stain their fingers with purple blue ink so the whole world could see. I ate lunch with an Iraqi man who was bent and couldn't walk right because of the tortures he endured at the hands of Saddam's brutal and sadistic sons. He sat there in his best suit and smiled. So, you can think what you want about the terrible democracy we're "imposing" on Iraq but the reality is that Iraq is being besieged by foreign terrorists whose only goal is to destabilize the Iraqi government and foment a civil war in Iraq.

by onbliss

How does absentee voting work for Americans residing outside USA? Are there any restrictions? In the case of India, Non Resident Indians (NRIs) can not participate in Indian elections.

James: You can answer for Canada :-)

by jamesrl

Absentees for Students, military, people residing in Canada but away on temporary work visas are readily available. If you are a dual citizen living abroad, you have to meet the residency requirements, which if I recall correctly are living in Canada 3 months prior to the election being called.

We typically don't get many out of the country voters other than the military. In the height of the cold war we would have up to 8000 troops in Europe and they would vote heavily.

James

by tonythetiger

yes to being registered, no on the ID.

Requiring an ID would be akin to accusing someone of a crime and requiring them to prove they're innocent.

by protiusx

Requiring an ID is both logical and fair to everyone. It prevents people from voting twice, prevents illegal aliens from voting and it prevents dead people from voting which is what happened here in Washington State.

by maxwell edison

We live in an ID society. We need one to drive, to cash check, to buy an airline ticket, to buy a drink (well, they used to ask!), etc. Proving you are who you say you are is a fact of life. Why should voting be any different?

Using your logic, your bank is accusing you of theft if they ask you for an ID to cash a check. Personally speaking, I'd be more concerned if they didn't ask. Voting's the same way. If someone goes up to my bank or my polling place, I want the attendants to know it's me who's requesting my money or my vote. I don't want anyone to steal my money, nor do I want them to steal my vote. As such, asking for my ID isn't accusing me of anything, but rather it's protecting me. (I might also add that I always say, thanks for asking.)

by jdclyde

Why BOTHER with a registration if there is no verification?

What is the purpose of this registration? To determine eligability, correct? Now that you have gone to the step of determining someone is valid to vote in a region, why would you not make sure the person flipping the lever is really you?

Hope is protecting you accusing you of anything?

by tonythetiger

the signature on the registration form with the one on the poll should be good enough. Yes, there are good forgers, but again, it should be innocent until proven guilty.

Why don't police pull every car over to make sure every driver has a valid license?

by tig2

They would be wrong.

Voting in this country is a right (US Citizen over the age of majority) a privilege (Have not committed a crime that would disqualify me) and a civic duty (I join my voice in defense of my beliefs with my fellows).

Taking that away or passing it along to illegals is tantamount to saying to me that a set of standards applies to me and a different set to illegals. It validates breaking the law. How can that be perceived as sensible?

And what happens to the election process if such a thing is permitted? I don't know that I would bother to vote again. Why should I? I would have been told in no uncertain terms that my vote is useless.

by drowningnotwaving

Okay so major slabs of your economy collape.

That's an issue.

Lord you yanks are just straight-up funny.

With the resources of your local police, county police, state police, federal police, federal rangers, Texas rangers, secret service, the CIA, NSA, the army navy airforce marines, your national guard, local militia and Roger f--king Ramjet -

If your american Powers-that-be REALLY TRULY wanted to get rid of them do you think they couldn't?

If they are that incompetent, vote them out. See ya George W. You can't control the illegals. Your own people hate you.

by vidalr

The term ?Interface? is used differently by individuals, specialist , media professionals, interface managers, plus those in computing and cognitive science . We cannot forget in computer interface the
abstract people, the hackers the game makers, chat rooms retrieval id's.
For example interface scholars have shown their concern in computer interface or human to human communication. Many designers have develop useful definitions in specific fields to improve this phenomena call computer interface.
This definitions has the fortunate consequence of having different kind of processes carrying the C.I. phenomena.
A general definition of C.I. is that man and machine, or machine as a medium for man can communicate whiteout hindrance, if there are errors or misinformation it will cause to humans a problem which consequences are the lack of creativity and evolution.
Why Linux does not have the in the broad sense the human C.I.? I do have 9 different versions of Linux live dvd, my pay check has arrived so for sure I going to buy 2 more? yet one of the most basic and brainless feature wont be there the human C. I.?
I ask why? why? why!!!!!!
waiting for your speedy feed back
R
It has never been the point of on these discussions to talk about Voip itself but of the lack of computer human interface. Linux does not have it.
Computer human interface has as a counterpart: information, which must de consistent and clear knowing that in exact nature (substance. Energy or abstract concept) isn?t clear. Linux provide to home users a repeat Computer human interface in most of their OS is not informative. In C.H.I be ?true? a lie or false or counterfactual information is misinformation, not information itself.
.

This C.H.I. approach to information, like most human-centered approaches to information, leads one to emphasize the meaning and use of message, ``what the message is about?" and ``what is known already?" over the information carrying messenger and the message itself. When the C.H.I. is essentially random, or the message is of no value to the recipient, such as a repeated message previously received and understood, it is colloquially said that no information was received and no information was transmitted.
Some individuals equate information with meaning. Having a C.H.I. poor as Linux makes their statement not good enough to make an event an informative act; its meaning must be perceived to make the statement informative. Arguing against this approach, ``it is psychologically almost impossible not to make the shift from the one sense of C. H. I. to the other sense, information = what is expressed by the signal sequences?.
In an approach similar to defining C. H. I meaning, information is often understood in terms of knowledge that is transmitted to a sentient being ``that which occurs within the mind upon the absorption of a message"
The reasons of Linux and what implies not to have a Computer Human Interface is a?
R
Lets concluded the Linux computer interface, this topic is crucial to today?s human use of Linux as prewriting system , we are not talking about, how well the desktop is design, because we need to speak as well about the tools , the office, the consoles, the different ways of connectivity, the hundreds of applications that are in the lives dvd of Suse 10.1 or Knoppix 5.0 plus Ubuntu 6.06 or the releases of Knoppix hacks or hacking knoppix by O?really is in this systems of Linux were the Computer human interface is not found, were the input and output, speak volumes of were I?m getting into , the coherence of the theory of truth derived for and from Linux, were the belief in Linux OS has become justified . Statement may be understood as ``true" if it exactly represents what it is describing. This is referred to as the ``correspondence" theory of truth. This applies not only to statements but to the representation and belief. The coherence theory of truth, on the other hand, suggests that truth is essentially derived for and from Linux.
A statement is true when it is consistent with a system of accepted statements. Truth may also be viewed as a representation that is learned and that will not be altered, even given additional experiences. Defined truth as the vanishing point toward which we imagine that all our temporary truths will some day converge.
The justification of a belief is based on internal considerations concerning the qualities of the function producing the belief. A belief is ``justified" if and only if the input to the function is accurately represented in the output, stop the baby talk if the input of Linux is clear then the output must be clear. Consider a handheld calculator which accepts the keystrokes ``2" ``+" ``2" ``=" and then displays the digit ``4." We note that the digit displayed is not of the same form as the input, e.g., a keystroke. Instead, an accurate function takes keystrokes and produces a displayed number. If the calculator is broken and produces the digit ``3" given the above set of keystrokes, we clearly don't have knowledge that 2+2=4.Consider a different case where the calculator is broken but the above set of keystrokes produces, through erroneous sub processes, the digit ``4" in the display. While the output is correct or ``true" and may be interpreted as a belief, it is not justified--the function is not accurate in that it does not operate as the user intends or understands the calculator to operate.
Other models of knowledge have been proposed, such as the notion that knowledge is one's ``image," what one subjectively believes to be true [Bou56]. This is close to what we have referred to as a belief, and choosing to call it ``knowledge?. Yet, like the more conventional philosophical idea of knowledge, it can be understood as the values in the output of a process, actually, the hierarchical series of processes that range from low level atomic processes up to sophisticated intellectual processes.
Perception and observation can be understood as conveying information about the input to certain processes as Linux bug fixer?s, malware makers (for humans, sensory processes such as seeing, hearing, smelling, etc.) The output of such a process may be understood as a belief. Such a belief may constitute knowledge about the input when the process or set of processes producing the belief operate in a manner consistent with the understanding of the process. These definitions of knowledge and belief are broader than the common language notions of the terms and less human-centered, in the case of belief, making the concepts more objective and more easily studied. We note that knowledge is information that is both true and justified. These perceptual, observational, and processing functions take as input sensory data from the real world, as well as personal beliefs and cultural biases, when producing information bearing output. This conceptual framework for understanding information provides a mechanism for understanding both the cultural influence on information, as well as the minutest phenomena studied by physicists.

Errors, Misinformation, and Bad Data
When discussing knowledge, truth, and information, people often begin speaking of ``misinformation" or ``bad data." Scientists often speak of ``bad data," produced by faulty measurement or poor observations. Misinformation often refers to information that is ``false," that is, the information does not directly reflect the ``true" state of the world. Consider a ``lie" told by an individual or an organization. The person making the lie knows the truth and, instead of repeating it, chooses to produce a lie for some purpose. The lie is then information about the process that produced it. It is misinformation or ``false information" only in the sense that we may not know the nature of the full hierarchy of processes, that is, the characteristics of the function that did eventually produce the lie. The exact nature of misinformation, etc., is subject to a wide range of interpretations (and misinterpretations). ``no structure can carry the information that s is F unless, in fact, s is F. False information, misinformation, and disinformation are not varieties of information" or in Linux case their computer human interface.
Misinformation and related concepts may be defined consistent with the hierarchical model. When what is transmitted is not received as sent, i.e., $x \ne f^{-1}(f(x))$ for some xthat is input to an f(), an information loss has occurred in the process. This can occur when the function fcan be said to be a partially random or noisy process. When this happens, what is transmitted was not reproduced by the function; some of what was transmitted has been ``lost."
When information has been lost in producing a particular output characteristic, the value taken on by the characteristic is determined, in part, by a random or error component. When there exists a non-null error component in determining a characteristic or variable's value, the ``information" contained in the variable may be referred to as ``misinformation." The value of a variable is information about the input; when the information is only partial and is tainted by error, it is better understood as misinformation. Essentially, this is information that is partly or wholly false.
Economists and scholars interested in decision theory often refer to error free information as perfect information. Perfect information about a source domain Xexists when there is a one-to-one mapping in a noiseless environment for the source X onto the destination set Y [Los90]. Information may be said to be incomplete when the mapping from Xis into Y, not onto Y.
We may define another form of misinformation as information that isn't justified. If one believes something for the wrong reasons, one may be said to be ``misinformed." In these cases, there is a perception that something is wrong with the recipient of the information, and it is this faulty nature of the receiver that makes something ``misinformation.
R
http://video.google.ca/videoplay?docid=-4264625761212493345&q=HACKERS
http://video.google.ca/videoplaydocid?=
7707585592627775409&q=HACKERS

by jdclyde

that you hit reply to the wrong discussion.

Talk about needing a good interface! :D

by techexec2

This guy is posting this same ridiculous long message in multiple discussions here.

Weird...

by mjwx

It's mandatory, not optional.

I get fined for not voting, its not like I can charge the government for the hour of my time it takes to vote for people I don't particularly like.

I wont vote for Howard, (Slowly stripping workers rights) and I cant vote for Beasley (completely F'ing incopetent) and any vote for a minor party goes to Howard or Beasley anyway so I don't want to vote at all, but if I don't the bastards in Canberra will charge me AU$80 for the privilege of staying home. I think I'll have to donkey (vote) next year.

If they want my opinion on the government, that's one hours consulting at AU$80 an hour, its not like they ask me when they want a pay rise.

by maxwell edison

Cast a write-in vote for Maxwell Edison!

Actually, I don't agree with mandatory voting; and if it was ever put up to a vote, I would vote against it. (Now that's a ballot issue that could get confusing!)

If a person has a "right" to do something, it seems to me that, by definition, he/she also has a "right" not to do it. If something is forced upon you, it's not a right at all.

by drowningnotwaving

If voting wasn't compulsory, you'd complain that the minorities (issue-based) have a disproportionate representation - because it's a generalisation but reasonably true that minorities tend to be louder, more passionate and therefore more likely to get off their butts and vote.

But then of course in compulsory voting such a large percentage only ever vote the same way all their lives. So their vote is extremely predictable and therefore largely irrelevant in policy making.

So the minority issues get headway yet again.

But then, when the vote happens , and one hikster religious freak (or to be fair Max, one idiot gay greenie zealot - both of which really truly happened in Australia in the last few years) actually controls the senate, then the whole representational democracy breaks down because someone who represents actually less than 0.25 % of the population controls the entire parliament.

In NZ we just have 37 parties for 90 or so seats and nothing gets done. It's difficult to work out which minority is which a la Monty Python's popular peoples front.

And then you get America where the difference of a few thousand votes out of a population in excess of 280 million (NOT saying who was right or wrong!!!) gives absolute power "with a mandate to serve the people the way we see fit". Well there is clearly no such mandate whatsoever. that's like saying the presidential debate should be paper-scissor-rock. Maybe that's just what it is.

And in the UK, they have the blessed house of lords. Stripped of all their power except for enough to be a pain in the democratic ass now and then. Why do they pay them money?

In the words of Jello Biafra "so who thinks we live in a democracy?"

But yes people should have ID to vote. F... 'em.

by delbertpgh

Everybody in a democracy should vote. The system works better. It's the voice of the people, and the people have a moral obligation to speak up.

In the States, only about 55% of the voters bother turning out every four years, when they vote for the President, everybody in the House of Representatives, and one third of the members of the Senate. (Pres has four year term, representative has two years, senator has six.) That means that 45% of the country shrugs it off and trusts to the judgement of the ones who bother to show up. That makes it possible for demagogues to get a fraction of the country scared enough for a short time that they can tip the vote, simply because they outnumber the few who do their duty and cast ballots.

In the off years, it's even worse. We have Federal elections every two years, when again the whole House and a third of the Senate is elected, but because no President is up, most Americans ignore it. Only about 35% show up to vote. That leaves the militant tub-thumper extremist wings on the right and left with a huge voice, and sucks away at the power of the middle.

by maxwell edison

(You knew there had to be a "however", didn't you?)

The constitutional right is for my vote to be protected. If that's the basis (my right being protected), then all reasonable measures should be taken to ensure my vote is not stolen. Do you agree or disagree with that? If you agree with that, how would the government prevent that from happening without verifying the person casting the vote is really me? And what would you do (and what would you expect to happen) if you went to vote, but the people told you that you already did?

Moreover, I also have a constitutional right to vote in an election without fraud. Do you agree or disagree with that? If you agree, that might suggest the government should also ensure that all those voting are indeed eligible. How might the government do that without, again, verifying the vote being cast is an eligible vote.

It's a constitutional right to vote, but ONLY if that person is an eligible voter. An ineligible voter as no such constitutional right. It's also a constitutional right to run for president, but only if that person is a native-born citizen and is at least 35 years of age. Are you suggesting that if there's a question about a candidate's eligibility, that the burden of providing proof would not fall upon that person? What if Arnold Terminator, for example, claimed that he WAS born in the USA, and all those reports were wrong? Would he have to prove he was, or would others have to prove he wasn't?

I believe the constitutional right would only apply to eligible votes and eligible citizens, not ineligible ones. Therefore, the government actually has a duty to verify eligibility. Or are you suggesting that the government does not have a duty to verify eligibility? It has to be one or the other. Which do you believe it is?

by tonythetiger

[b]if there's a reasonable suspicion[/b] that someone is not eligible, then [b]that person[/b] can be challenged.

by maxwell edison

The polling place monitors are usually people from the neighborhoods, none of whom are elected officials, all of whom are really no more than appointed volunteers, and all of whom might have a political agenda of their own, not to mention a tendency to be over zealous, under zealous, or just plain stupid.

I can see the headlines now.

[b]Brower County Election Monitors Apply Unreasonable Suspicion: Gave The Election To Giuliani - Democrats To Challange In Court[/b]

Sorry, but everything's got to be cut-and-dry, applied equally across the board, with no room, or as little room as possible, for error or manipulation.

Proving who you are, and especially proving you're a legal citizen, is not expecting too much, nor is it violating anyone's constitutional right to vote.

by maxwell edison

Is it the job of the government to prevent non-citizens from doing some things? I think yes. (9-11 is all that needs to be said.)

And what if I wanted to enslave you? I'm certainly a citizen, so are you suggesting that it's not the role of government to prevent me from doing it? And by protecting you from being enslaved, by definition, they must also prevent others from doing it.

Assuming you agree with my suggestions, we can see that you over-simplified your comments, and that is it indeed the role of government to prevent some citizens from doing some things.

But again, the gist of the issue is concerning non-citizens.

by java_ho

All the more reason to take whatever steps necessary to make sure the process is administered fairly.

Implicit in the Constitutional provision of my right to vote is the protection of the legitimacy of my vote and the assurance that only legitimate votes like mine decide our elections.

I'd rather someone went to my bank and took my money than go to the poling place and tamper with my vote.

Ask yourself this: if someone is entitled to vote and really wants to do so, wouldn't they do what is fair and necessary to secure that right for themselves? And if they're unwilling to put forth that minimal effort, why is their vote worth anything to you when it obviously is worth nothing to them?

by maxwell edison

I think the similarities are closer than you may think. While you have 37 parties positioning themselves for power, they usually align themselves into fewer blocks after the get elected. In the US, we would have the same 37 "parties", but I might call them factions within a party, also positioning themselves for power, but it's done before they're elected.

We both have the same number of "parties", or I would call them interests or factions. You (and Canada, and the UK, etc.) make your alignments after the fact, we do it before. You could take either one of our two parties and divide them up into factions that might resemble any one one of your 37 parties.

by jamesrl

I am sure there are lots of mortgages in Florida from Canadians owning winter properties. They may live their up to six months of the year. I don't know how that works, do the credit agencies check their Canadian credit/assets? I know that some of the credit reporting agencies work on both sides of the border.

I didn't buy a house till early 30s for similar reasons to yours. Its been a great investment though.

James

by jamesrl

Is that if you are a legal immigrant it may take 5 years of residency/paying taxes before you can gain your citizenship and vote. Thats substantially different than being a tourist. So I understand where some of that comes from.

But in the end, I think the higher argument is that if you don't have some differentiation for being a citizen, like the right to vote, what does being a being a citizen mean? I don't want to do anything that doesn't encourgae people to become full citizens.

I also wonder about residency. We spent tens of millions of dollars rescuing "Canadians" out of Lebanon. The vast majority of them are dual citizens, who came to Canada when the civil war in Lebanon erupted in the 80s. When things became semi-peaceful, they moved back to Lebanon. When things errupted again they cried for help. Some of them were grateful, some of them were very unappreciative of the support the government gave. Maybe I am just bitter but should we allow people to use us as a country of convenience?

James

by jdclyde

if you place yourself in a dangerous situation, you have no one to blame but yourself.

The people that were upset because "the government" didn't save them fast enough are a disgrace to any country that is doing so much for them and unworthy.

And here I thought it was only the US that had people complaining about people not being extracted from the situation they had placed themselves in quickly enough. Can you believe some dregs of our society even started lawsuits over this?

You either have allegance to your country, or you don't. And you see a problem with treating your citizenship as an importable commodity. It devalues it, as these people have clearly shown.

by maxwell edison

Even if it does take 5 years to gain citizenship, that's not reason enough to allow a non-citizen to vote. It seems silly to even be debating that point. Non-citizens should not be allowed to vote.

Even on the taxes-representation issue, if they're not "represented", too bad. They're free to go back to their country of origin where they are "represented". Nobody's forcing them to either come or to stay. Moreover, they ARE enjoying the infrastructure of the country, which is paid for through sales taxes and such.

By the way, why does it seem that I'm always debating American politics and American domestic issues with Canadians? What's your dog in this hunt?

by jamesrl

Because I am on the same page with you. I was trying to show the argument, as its also been made recently during the municipal elections. I can try to explain the other side without supporting it, though I won't claim to be good at it.

As for taxation, landed immigrants in Canada, those who have formally applied and are going through the waiting period pay all taxes that a citizen does - Federal, provincial etc. Isn't that why the thirteen colonies had a revolution? But regardless, I think if we gave them the vote, fewer of them would become citizens, so I wouldn't support it.

Whats my dog in this hunt. We have the same issue in Canada. And you may be totally oblivious to what goes on in Canada, but there are times when US political ideas find their way across the border. Workfare in Ontario was modelled after the program in New Jersey.

And you know that US politics has a huge impact on Canadian lives - didn't you?

James

by onbliss

As you said, if we are enjoying the infrastructure then we better pay for it in some form.

by onbliss

My family never availed it after two visits to Canada. Am not sure how many countries have such programmes. But it looks like the programme is being eliminated from August 2007.

by jamesrl

The program had a worthy goal, to encourage more tourism by rebating a tax. But like many government programs, it cost more to administer than the moeny it actually put back in the hands of tourists.

The UK has a similar program I believe.

James

by jdclyde

that is should be PROTECTED.

No one is denying you your vote, so you lose nothing.

This keeps your vote from getting deluted because of the thousands of dead people that vote in NY every year. They estimate there are about 60,000 dead people registered to vote right now. do you really want some dishonest person putting those votes out against where your LEGAL vote is going?

Logically, I am sure you can see how this is PROTECTING you, and in no way hurts you.

Tony, give ONE valid reason NOT to show an ID.

by tonythetiger

prove the dead people are registered, and unregister them!

[i]Tony, give ONE valid reason NOT to show an ID.[/i]

I have already proven eligibility when I registered, I shouldn't have to prove I am innocent of a crime when I vote. My word is my bond, unless and until you [b]prove[/b] otherwise.

by jdclyde

and you will not get on an airplane without valid ID, even if you legally paid for your ticket.

You will NOT be allowed to cash a check or withdrawl money from your account based on your word, because your word means nothing outside of your own circle of people you have proven yourself to.

Someone registers. Now how do they know the person that shows up is the same person without ID?

Again, your word means nothing in the meat world. Try getting a loan from your bank without signing a contract. Are you some criminal that your word is not good enough? No, but they have no way of knowing who the criminals are and who aren't, so all must sign a contract.

You have yet to give ONE VALID reason.

by danlm

You sound British.

I don't tell you how to run your country or criticize your political process. Please have the same decency to keep your arrogant opinions to yourself. Which is exactly what it would be if I said the same type of diography statements about your political process.

Dan

by jgarcia102066

I was making a statement that all American's whose families have been in this country have made a sacrifice to some war or another. I don't condone war. If you actually read my statements, I said that any illegal immigrant should serve this country not fight a war for this country. Not everyone that serves our country for 2 or 4 years actually participates in a war. My take is you have to put your money where your mouth is.

Our men and women of the armed forces put their lives on the line for the rest of us. Unless you have served, you don't understand the brotherhood and sisterhood that exists between veterans. You don't feel the power of the song "Proud to be an American". Most veteran's that I know get teary eyed when they hear that song.

I also like the words that you are putting into my mouth. I never mentioned any kind of political affiliation yet you derived my opinions about "hippy left-wing homo women's rights". As much as you would like to get me all up in arms, it's not going to work.

It's people like me that have fought for this country to defend the rights for people like you to say these kinds of things about us. Despite all of the criticisms that our veterans with a strong sense of patriotism endure, my loyalty to my brothers and sisters in arms will never waiver.

I appreciate your thoughts and you're welcome on behalf of all veterans for having the right to say these things.

by danlm

To suit your own twisted view.

His statement was in reference to ILLIGIAL aliens. I'm assuming here, but if these individuals are not willing to go the route that all other immigrants who became citizens did. Then they should serve in the armed services and earn the right that way. And by the way twit, American citizens have served with those beliefs. What, you think the illegal immigrants should have more say then someone that is a citizen. Or, am I lowering myself to your level. And twisting what you said to what ever I want it to mean.

Again, your little bitty mind twisted that to suit your arrogant attitude.

Dan

by jgarcia102066

I agree with you. In my personal experience, serving this country in the armed forces has been prevalent. That is why my post has such a military focus.

There may be some civilian routes in which someone can serve this country to earn their citizenship. If that's the case then I would have no problem with illegal immigrants serving our country through that avenue.

My point is that like the rest of us, illegal immigrants need to pay their dues, become citizens and then be granted the rights they have earned.

by jgarcia102066

I don't have any false expectations that this solution could ever be made into law. Politicians are too busy protecting their political careers to make such a bold move.

I just see a problem in armed services recruiting and in illegal immigrants wanting to become citizens and so I put it together. That's just my analytical mind working. I realize that implementing this solution is much more complex than I stated but like I posted it was a "simple" solution, not an easy solution.

by jdclyde

I am not critisising the the idea, just the people that would be responsible for putting it into play.

by jgarcia102066

I don't think the language barrier would be a problem. I knew many sargents in the Air Force that could speak different languages. Also, even English speakers have to learn the proper command syntax to engage the enemy:

Commence Fire;
Fire; Fire; Fire;
Cease Fire;
Charge your weapons;
Disengage;
Stand Down;
etc.

Even if language is still a barrier after the training, when you see all of your brothers-in-arms firing at the enemy and you are being shot at, you would know what to do.

by jamesrl

Recruits in the legion don't always speak any French when they join, but they learn. The training sargeants become expert in non verbal communication. By the time the recruits finish training they have enough french to function.

James

by jamesrl

In both the US Civil war, and in the Vietnam war, Canadians joined the US army in the thousands (more in the Civil war than Vietnam though).

Some stayed and became naturalized US citizens, but most came back to Canada after their tours. Many Canadian natives - Mohawks particularly - still go south to join up even though they would be welcomed into the Canadian forces, because it has become tradition for them to serve in the Marines.

Of course Canada also received many US draft dodgers, many of whom became Canadians. If you want to blame Canada for being more left than the US, part of the blame has to go to those draft dodgers.

James

by onbliss

[i]No sane Democratic nation will have anything to do with a Hammas government. [/i]
It is in the best interest of the democratic nations and the world that Democratic nations constantly engage with Hammas government (and such). I do not mean succumbing to them and handing everything to them on a silver platter. As they say negotiations are conducted with our staunchest enemies.

As we see in Afghanistan and Iraq, stability of a country is paramount, and we only slowly wean them away to drop their arms.

ps: BTW, we shold look at the countries selling arms and convince them of their dangerous associations.

by jamesrl

As for Hamas, like the IRA, there is a time to just fight them, and a time to come to the table. Both sides need to want to work out issues, and there is no point in trying to work out those issues if the main body of Hamas is committed to violence as a method. The IRA had to committ to a ceasfire at least before meaningful talks could begin.

As for Democrats in the KKK, yes Bryd was a clan member, but he renounced it as the biggest mistake of his life.

David Duke on the other hand is unrepentant, is still in favour of segregation, and has run as both a Democrat and a Republican. He was elected as a Republican state representative.

I don't believe that racism is confined to either party or prevelant in either party.

James

by jdclyde

If a cop pulls you over, for anything from speeding, rolling stops, drunk driving, whatever, the first thing they do is identify you.

ANYtime you get on a plane, they identify you.

ANYtime you go to the bank, they identify you.

These identifications are to protect the citizens from abuse, and the vendor from being sued for allowing others to abuse your identity by not checking you out every time.

Write a check ANYWHERE and see if the store doesn't ask to see your drivers license.

You are being less than logical hear. Just trying to get people going?

by maxwell edison

And you make a great point on how we often model our various arguments on each other's system. According to some people, for example, the Canadian health care system is the best thing since sliced bread. (By the way, what was the best thing before sliced bread became common?)

On the taxation without representation mantra, I believe that was an issue, not necessarily because the taxes were being collected and applied, but rather because they were being collected and sent back to jolly old England for the King to use there, and not in the colonies. At least to some degree.

by jgarcia102066

I agree that it should be everyone's responsibility to earn their citizenship. When it comes to families this issue becomes very complex. I meant at least one in the immediate family. By immediate family, I mean spouse and children.

The military is not the only potential way to serve this country it's just the one where I see that we have a shortage that needs to be filled and immigrants could be used to fill that need.

Now about those that were lucky enough to be born here. I completely agree that they need to find some way to serve this country. Too many natural born American's take their freedoms for granted that someone else has paved the way for them to have...but that's another story.

by jdclyde

Then why is this a$$clowns account still active?

And after I had done that previous reply I saw you post a spam alert on him but was too late to edit my post.

I know what to do....... ]:)

by delbertpgh

I spent 20 minutes the other day trying to figure out how to send a spam alert to sys admin.

by tonythetiger

doesn't own the airlines, nor the banks. Private businesses do. If these businesses have requirements you don't like, you are, you are free to not use their service.

(BTW, I have performed ALL KINDS of business transactions (even bought a house!) without showing a picture ID. My employer requires me to drive on occasion, and they asked me if I had a valid drivers license, but they did not require that I show it! They accepted my word just fine.)

[i]You have yet to give ONE VALID reason.[/i]

How about I invoke my right against self incrimination :)

by jdclyde

your right to not incriminate yourself can be protected by you not participating in the activity that is reserved for only legal US citizens.

Next time you get pulled over for speeding, tell the cop you refuse to incriminate yourself, and your not giving him any information. See where it gets you.

When you want to write a check, tell them it is none of their business who you are.

And in many places, they require a photo copy of a valid drivers license AND proof of insurance before you can drive a company vehicle. It is the stupid sue happy world we live in, where leaches look for ways to get rich through litigation.

by tonythetiger

asks me for my birth date.

I 'll have to take your word on the plane, as my last plane ride was in 1976.

No, JD, I'm not trying to just get people going. I'm just trying to maintain my freedom. I am (or should be anyway) free to do anything I choose, however I choose to do it, as long as I don't infringe on the rights of someone else, and you should normally have to prove that I did infringe (not 'might infringe', not 'could possibly infringe') before restricting my rights.

As far as the cop pulling you over, you, by your actions, have given him reasonable cause to be suspicious, therefore asking for your ID is perfectly reasonable. On the other hand, you could intentionally mow down a pedestrian in the crosswalk at any time, so maybe you shouldn't be allowed to drive :)

by protiusx

It happened here. Our governor usurped the governor?s seat from the rightly elected Republican winner after two recounts where the good citizenry of Seattle "discovered" more votes that had mysteriously materialized after the first and second recounts. It was later proven that dead people voted. That was probably a stinky bus loaded with dead voters.

by tonythetiger

this is one time I'm clearly not! As long as I'm not breaking any laws or violating someone's rights (or you have a reason-based suspicion that I am (probable cause)), it's none of anybody's (including the government's) damned business who I am, where I am, or what I'm doing!

Obviously the merchant has something I want, and if I want him to give it to me, it would, naturally, behoove me to comply with the conditions he sets for the transaction. I must either [b]choose[/b] to do that, or do business elsewhere.

Also obviously, I signed a form saying I would obey all traffic laws when I got my license. One of those laws is that I am to carry my license on my person while I am driving, and to present it to authorized law enforcement personnel when asked. As I am a man of my word, I [b]wouldn't[/b] refuse to show it to a policeman who pulled me over.

As I said, driving, flying, and writing checks are not constitutionally protected rights... voting is!

How many OTHER constitutionally protected rights am I expected to give up if I don't have or don't want to produce a picture ID (which, by the way, can easily be counterfeited well enough to fool your average poll worker, would that be OK?)?

Maybe I'm not explaining it right, but I think you and Max are overlooking something pretty basic about liberty/freedom. It may not seem like a big deal now, but it paves the road for the next thing that will be a little bigger but by then won't seem like a big deal either. And that's just what those who would destroy this country (including some who are here legally) would like to see... [b]us[/b] destroying our own country... chipping away at our own freedoms... a little at a time... while they sit back and laugh their sick asses off!

Surely you see that the liberals are taking control of the republican party now... holding YOU responsible... making YOU bear the consequences of another's real or "imagined potential" wrongdoing. I had enough of that crap in the second grade, when Mrs. Bryant made us ALL stay in from recess because Billy Barnhart got caught chewing gum in class! What's going on now is a million times worse. Now I'm being punished for something someone else [b]might[/b] be doing.

by tonythetiger

and what have you done with the real Max?

[i]The polling place monitors are usually people from the neighborhoods, none of whom are elected officials, all of whom are really no more than appointed volunteers, and all of whom might have a political agenda of their own, not to mention a tendency to be over zealous, under zealous, or just plain stupid.[/i]

Think libertarian.

Challenges should require reasonable cause (as it [b]is[/b] a crime the challenger is accusing the voter of). If the challenger not being reasonable is the problem, the solution is to fix the challenger, not inconvenience millions of honest people who simply want to vote!

[i]Proving who you are, and especially proving you're a legal citizen, is not expecting too much, nor is it violating anyone's constitutional right to vote.[/i]

What exactly is the precedent that allows the government to demand identification from a person who is not suspected of any wrongdoing?

The closest thing I can think of is sobriety checkpoints, but even then they don't pull EVERYONE over. And in that case, the licensee agreed to submit to such as a condition of their licensing, so there's no constitutionally valid complaint.