Discussion Locked

size of the Universe

0 helpful
43 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Claudius Ptolemy, whose Almagest was the standard astronomy text from his days till the end of the Middle Ages, when Copernicus, Galileo and Newton brought in a lot of upsetting stuff, stated that in comparison with the distance to the stars the Earth must be considered a point. The stars, in other words, are inaccesibly far away. But nowadays we have exponential notation. The Earth is 1.35 x 10^7 m in diameter, not a point, the Sun is 1.5 x 10^11 m away, and the nearest "fixed" star is 6 x 10^16 m away. So our notation makes the Universe more accessible than it was.
Furthermore, in the Middle Ages it was thought that things beneath the Moon were made of 4 or 5 elements whereas the heavenly bodies were made of something quite different. But nowadays we think that the heavenly bodies are made of the same 100-odd elements we know on Earth, with the possible exception of dark matter. So the Universe is not only smaller, it is homelier.

43 replies

by seanferd

Comfortable, home-like, describing a domicile which would make a good home in the speaker's opinion. As opposed to applying it to a person, which I have always found odd. (Perhaps meaning one who is so "plain" that he or she would never leave their parent's home, or one who could be trusted to stay home by default, and not "run around".

Weird is language.

by seanferd

The stars not being plastered into a crystal sphere, all an equal distance* away, made conceptualizing the universe more difficult or less comfortable? I suppose it depends on one's mindset.

*Theorized to be at a much smaller distance than the closest real stars.

What blows my mind is that one cannot observe or guess at the size of the universe. The greatest distance to which we can see is the same distance EM radiation has been able to travel since recombination. We may be able to "see" 13.5-14 billion light years out, but that in no way is the "edge" of the universe.

Sci-Fi may give people the impression that the stars themselves are more accessible now, but they really are not. As to grasping the distances involved, I suppose people are more or less inclined to believe they can do this just because measurements have been taken, and represented by usable numbers.

I wonder how many people exposed only to ancient cosmologies would find the universe to seem either smaller or larger once introduced to modern cosmology. It would probably interests psychologists, sociologists, and anthropologists.

by ansugisalas

See, before it was taken for granted that God might move a person to the stars.
This is not now a universally held idea.

by john.a.wills

Ptolemy did not teach the doctrine of the crystal spheres; that was Aristotle (or someone earlier). Ptolemy thought the planets moved in cycles and epicycles.

by hal 9000

I'm not really sure maybe it's just that our concept of God is so wrong and who we incorrectly perceive as our God is just some Pimply faced Juvenile Delinquent doing a low Level Science Experiment under their bed at home.

Naturally enough this spoty faced kid is no more aware of what it is he has done than we are of understanding why he did it. ;)

Col

by hal 9000

0:-)

Actually I was starting to think we could restart

[b]The Evolution Lie[/b] but then the nightmare of it sunk in and I ran away screaming for mercy.

But then again after the Site Dedesign it may be worthwhile as you couldn't possibly follow it. ;)

Col

by ansugisalas

the universe is expanding into the big freeze because the pimply faced kid doesn't want gays serving in the military... :p ;)

by jck

White Stig? Original White, Sacked White, or New White Stig? :p

(yes, I watch UK Top Gear obsessively... ;) )

Edit: I forgot...there's also American, Big (lorry driving), African and German Stigs too :^0

I wonder if they'll let new Stig take the Koenigsegg Agera R around Ehra-Lessien :D

by santeewelding

Beyond the breath you breathe, and the thoughts you think, neverminding your arm.

Thou art the Universe.

by hal 9000

The base code of the universe is

[i][b][u]26 06 2010[/i][/b][/u]

And it's big incredibly big so big that it's incomprehensible and ridiculous.

OH and the answer to the Ultimate Question of Life the Universe and Everything is

[b][i][u]42.[/b][/i][/u]

You can Thank Douglas Adams and the follow up Script writers of Doctor Who for your answer. See Dr Who is the answer to every possible question that could ever be asked.

Understand now? ;)

Col

by charliespencer

it could never again achieve its legendary size or level of vitriol. The reduced level depth and 'Take Offlines' would gut it.

by hal 9000

That drives cars fast and sometimes bends them in a big way so that the UK Media can complain bitterly about the idiots at Top Gear and their ways of doing things in a Most Unprofessional Media Type way.

A Platypus is a strange animal native to Australia that most people refused to believe was real till they had a living one in their hot little hands and even then they refused to believe what their eyes showed them.

Some to this day still believe that a platypus is the results of some Mad Genetic Engineering gone horribly wrong that was hidden from the public by the Government who is somehow involved in the Genetic Engineering to the determent of their people.

Confused yet?

Col :^0

by slayer_

The Stig is a strange animal native to Europe that most people refused to believe was real till they had a living one in their hot little hands and even then they refused to believe what their eyes showed them.

Some to this day still believe that the Stig is the result of some Mad Genetic Engineering gone horribly wrong that was hidden from the public by the Government who is somehow involved in the Genetic Engineering to the determent of their people.

by nicknielsen

constitutes absolute proof that [God / The Creator / The All-Father / Mother Nature / The Earth Mother / Your deity of choice] has a sense of humor...

by jim's brain

If inflation is the force that created our universe from the Big Bang would it not stand to reason that we are still travelling in an outward motion and not at a constant coordinate in space? With this being said the universe is enlarging every second of every day, therefore there is no end to it. Ever expanding like the ripples in a pond when a stone is cast into it.

by john.a.wills

a new set of comments. I wonder what caused that. I also wonder why the actual water cooler is empty. Maybe there is a connection.

by nicknielsen

the mass exodus of TR peers after the rollout of the last site changes. (I refuse to call it an "upgrade".)

by delbertpgh

No more. It's grown dull, and the people who care enough to write something interesting don't come by any more. And it's not just because, like Santee, they're dead; this discussion forum has become a bore to use.

Actually, the primary reason I would visit this site was for the off-topic discussions. I think TR may have gotten in its head to discourage them. If so, their strategy was a success.

by mjd420nova

Whereever you go, there you are. I've got average size arms but others seem to have a larger universe, because of their arm length. Being that the time space boundary is impassable, we are stuck with what we can see. Understanding the universe and its rules are just as complex as understanding the atom and the rules that govern them. Stuck between a rock and an empty space.

by nicknielsen

made it almost impossible to track subscribed discussions or to know who had made the most recent post in a discussion from the Discussions page.

In less than a month, the regulars were pretty much gone and the WC essentially empty

This discussion is closed to new replies.