Discussion Locked

Snowfalls are now just a thing of the past

0 helpful
148 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

[i]According to Dr David Viner, a senior research scientist at the climatic research unit (CRU) of the University of East Anglia, within a few years winter snowfall will become "a very rare and exciting event". [/i]

- Dr David Viner (March 2000)

http://www.independent.co.uk/environment/snowfalls-are-now-just-a-thing-of-the-past-724017.html

How many of you folks consider your blizzard conditions an [i]exciting event[/i]?

I've been calling the Man-Caused Global Warming and/or Climate Change claim a big lie for the past ten years or more. I've been on the cutting edge of calling out these liars and charlatans.

How many times do these people have to be proven wrong before they're totally discredited? Before the claim is discredited?

Question: How many people who hang out at the TR Water Cooler have actually changed their position, from being a MM-GW/CC believer to one who now knows it's a huge scam and big lie?

148 replies

by ansugisalas

about five...
The net movement may have been in the opposite direction though.

That's just a guesstimate, of course... you people are resistant to me mind-probe ; which is why I enjoy discussing with you all so much.

by dogknees

None of us. We all know your opinion is wrong and dangerous. Comparable to those who tell people that if they all stand on top of a hill on a certain day, the aliens will take you away to paradise.

by j-mart

Max has formed his opinion based more on his politics, I don't think he has looked deeply into the science and technical side of global warming. The increased volatility of the Australian weather fits the model many knowledgeable climate scientist have developed based on the higher mean earth temperature. The planet is definitely getting warmer. Of course the temperature of this planet has been hotter and colder in the past, but the natural factors that have been responsible in the past are not responsible this time around, this time it is human industrial pollution that is the cause. Max is good at pointing out how it is not fair on our children with our financial debt. I think we should not burden them with our environmental debt also.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I see no way NOT to burden our children with a multitude of 'debt'. Lack of foresight is our excruciating weakness.

by maxwell edison

I've called the MM-GW/CC question one that does not belong in politics. It should not be a political issue. How can it be my politics driving my opinion if I'm one who does not want it politicized?

by dogknees

I'm also interested in why he keeps calling us liars. It's a little impolite to say the least. He doesn't say we're wrong, he calls us liars which is quite a different thing.

by maxwell edison

The liars to whom I refer are the politicians (like Al Gore and his ilk) and scientists (like James Hansen, Dr David Viner and their ilk). I call you a believer of the liars.

by ansugisalas

with a steering wheel sticking out of his zipper.
Bartender tries pretending not to notice, but fails (O_o) , so he asks...
"Hey, Mr. Pirate, did you know you have a steering wheel sticking out of your crotch?"
And the Pirate answers:

"Arr, it be drivin' me nuts!"

From "My name is Earl" :D

by ansugisalas

is that being less wasteful makes economic sense, too.
Growth for the sake of growth is peeing the pants to stay warm in the frost... what happens when the flow stops?

by Member 25348569

East Anglia was a bloody long way away from the US East Coast..We do have rather different weather from continental US. The Doctor was talking about our climate, you know, but why let a good fact get in the way of anything. :)

Strangely enough, we had some serious snow in a few parts OF THE UK in December and it WAS an "exiting event". Most of the country skidded to a halt and the papers didn't cover anything else for days.

By the way, "serious snow" for us was about four to six inches and temperatures of -8C.

by dogknees

There's only one climate. It's not a local phenomenon, that's called weather. The climate is global and shared by us all. What I do affects you, and what you do affects me.

by Member 25348569

The definition of climate is the weather, averaged over a long period of time, in a particular location. The key differentiator between weather and climate is "time". Not location.

The point of my post - which you missed by quite a lot - was that Maxwell (as usual) was being deliberately contentious in linking the recent [b]weather[/b] in Eastern US with the [b]climate[/b] in the Eastern UK when there obviously can be no such link.

His wasn't a serious post. Just the rantings of a professional troublemaker. Mine certainly wasn't a serious post! However, you chose to admonish a pedant and then comitted the cardinal sin of getting your definition wrong.

Have a nice day. (That's "weather", by the way)

:)

Unlike Max, I don't dispute the influence of human beings on the Earths atmospheric systems, far from it, but I'm unsure of the the scope of our effect and absolutely what is being done by our politicians to "combat" it. And in that last one, I happen to totally agree with Max.

by maxwell edison

Friday 18 December 2009:

[i]Many parts of England are expected to wake this morning to a heavy blanket of snow that could lead to disruption on major roads and rail services..... By last night around four inches of snow fell in parts of East Anglia, making driving treacherous.[/i]

http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2009/dec/17/heavy-snow-predicted-south-east

February 12th, 2010:

[i]The worries about a UEA comeback were however overshadowed by the weather conditions. Only five minutes before kick-off, the heavens opened, coating the field in a layer of snow and completely obscuring the pitch markings, leaving the referee concerned and considering abandoning the match..... The weariness of two consecutive away games was not too much for the side who pulled together, almost unchanged to fend off impotent UEA attacks. The high line maintained by the defence pinned the UEA attack back, hampered as they were by the snow.[/i]

http://www.tcs.cam.ac.uk/issue/sport/football-blues-too-good-for-east-anglia-in-the-snow/

Snow in East Anglia Feb. 2, 2009:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQVJPh8Atb4

(Acknowledged that anyone could have posted said video from anywhere. I am the skeptic, here, you know. But it looks legitimate to me.)

17/12/2009:

[i]Met Office Issues Snow Warning

After predicting the change to much colder weather, the Met Office has now forecast heavy falls of snow in parts of East Anglia and south-east England.

Snow showers later on today and during Friday are likely to become heavy at times, bringing the potential of serious disruption in some areas tomorrow.

Up to 20cm of snow could fall in some parts of Kent, Sussex, Surrey, London and East Anglia, with gale-force winds causing drifts, forecasters say.[/i]

http://www.build.co.uk/national_news.asp?newsid=104410

28 May 2007:

[i]Now snow's on the way..... BRITAIN looks set to be hit by Bank Holiday SNOW today.
Heavy rain is forecast for almost everywhere, but areas as far apart as northern Scotland and East Anglia could turn white.[/i]

http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/article230584.ece

Wednesday 24 January 2007:

[i]There was light to moderate snow across much of East Midlands, East Anglia, central southern and SE England before dawn.....[/i]

http://www.richardjwild.co.uk/blog/2007/01/

Thursday 8 February 2007:

[i]Snow closes schools across UK..... Three hundred schools were shut in Herefordshire and Worcestershire, and across East Anglia schools were also disrupted because of the bad weather. [/i]

http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/2007/feb/08/schools.uk2

Okay, that's enough. (But I could go on.)

by Member 25348569

The climate is getting warmer and - because things are changing - the weather is getting less predictable. Yes, we had a few inches of pre-Christmas snow but we haven't had a flake, since. It's a nice 8C outside now and the sun is shining.

:)

You might like to know that around two inches of snow can cause total chaos as we get so little snow, we don't how to deal with it, so "Schools Closed All Over England" isn't really a headline worth quoting. Heath and Safety gone mad...

by maxwell edison

If the message gets up to a negative 5 (-5), it will be silenced! (Assuming people keep their default settings.)

The negative vote is not supposed to be used on messages just because you disagree with the message. But it???s a typical ploy - Silence those with whom you disagree!

P.S. I know what some of you are thinking. You're thinking that I want the MM-GW/CC advocates silenced. Not at all. I want them discredited!

by hal 9000

To have a thread Silenced after the redesign.

You could be up there with GoD in those stakes which is very rarified air. So you are in very good company.

Cheers

Col

Oh and it wasn't me but if you like I can help you out here. :^0

by maxwell edison

What would have happened if we had the negative vote back in the old days when things got REALLY heated? Discussions today are mild compared to then, don't you think?

Ah, the good ol' days........

by j-mart

James Hansen and Dr David Viner have serious experience and scientific training in the climatology field, so if they are liars give us your "science" that offers an alternate view not your personal blinkered viewpoint.

by maxwell edison

James Hansen, Dr David Viner and others, have [i]claimed[/i] not [i]proved[/i] that human activity is causing or contributing to changes in global temperature and/or climate patterns - things that have always happened anyway. None of their predicted claims made over the past twenty years have come true. None of them. As such, they've proven themselves wrong.

I've been skeptical for the past twenty years. I have nothing to prove.They do.

by maxwell edison

Since NONE of their predicted claims (made over the past twenty years) have come true, they're either liars or they've just been dead wrong. Since they haven't admitted they've been wrong, one can only assume the other.

by maxwell edison

I've always thought that the difference between a professional and an amateur was that the professional got paid while the amateur did not!

Hot damn! I finally made it to the pros! Where do I send my bill?

P.S. Thanks for that last comment! We do agree. The politicos are hijacking (have hijacked) the question to advance their own agenda and/or careers. (Get them out of it, and some things would probably be easier to sort out.)

by Member 25348569

"practised". Good at it. A Master Shitstirrer.

You aren't getting any money from ME - except, perhaps, the cost of a steak dinner, should our paths cross rather than our swords.

:D

by maxwell edison

And I knew what you meant. I'm always looking for an opportunity to have fun with a bit of sarcasm!

(What am I doing up this late, anyway? Or am I up way too early?)

by maxwell edison

AV sent me my astrological reading, or whatever it's called. It includes, among other things, the following:

[i]You express yourself in a very open, direct, and straightforward manner and are often blunt and tactless as well. Because you do not take yourself too seriously, you may not realize how deeply your candid statements can wound more sensitive souls. In fact, though you may not realize it, your insensitivity and lack of understanding regarding others' feelings is probably one of your worst faults.[/i]

Interesting.

Should I post the whole thing?

by j-mart

And pretend GW caused by increased CO2 and other contributing gasses by products of industrialisation is not happening. The only way to reduce this damage from continuing requires a world wide effort and Governments intervening to prevent this. You don't like the thought of any Government telling you how to live your life. As much as you don't like this approach I can't see individual responsibility solving this world wide problem. Your answer, call all the scientists and any politician a liar. Of course there will be from the politicians a bit of a vested interest and they will want the credit for saving the planet, but if nothing is done, it will not go away and we will leave our children and grandchildren with a much bigger problem.

If you don't want to believe in global warming Max, who really cares, as by yourself, your opinion is of no value in doing something to solve GW, as the more enlightened are beginning to see the truth and hopefully the politicians will get enough balls to make the tough decisions necessary.

So Max, are you as stupid as to ignore the sound science behind GW, or is it that you enjoy a bit of sh*t stirring for sport and entertainment.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"Max has formed his opinion based more on his politics."[/i]

I think I adequately addressed that false assertion. But instead of acknowledging your mistaken comment, you go on and on about how and why you are politicizing the question.

Round and round we go.

P.S. And after dogknees incorrectly claimed that I was calling my TR peers [i]liars[/i], I wonder if dogknees will call-out j-mart for calling me [i]stupid[/i]. For some reason, I doubt it.

by maxwell edison

[i]..... as the more enlightened are beginning to see the truth and hopefully the politicians will get enough balls to make the tough decisions necessary.[/i]

Ah yes, the [i]enlightened ones[/i]. They know best how to decide all things. We lowly and [i]stupid[/i] fools know nothing. We don't know what's best for us; but the [i]enlightened ones[/i] do.

By the way, where might one find the enlightened flavored kool-aid? You know, just in case I want to get a good dose of enlightenment.

by jackofalltech

That's such BS. You should try looking into the science more yourself from ALL perspectives rather than just ones you agree with. Did you know that green plants release CO2 at night? Have you ever seen this:

Your CO2 Footprint - Grab the Microscope - an Illustration
==========================================================
Carbon footprint. Carbon credits. Funny looking light bulbs. They say that
human-produced CO2 in the atmosphere is causing accelerated global warming and/
or climate change. Yea, right! If you buy into this ludicrous notion, it may be
time to give the claim a reality check.

If the Earth's atmosphere were to be represented on a 100 yard (91.44 meters)
football field (an American football field), the make-up would look like
something this:

From the goal line, go down 78 yards to the 22 yard line on the other end, and
you have nitrogen.

Go 21 yards further, to the 1 yard line, and you have oxygen (99 yards total so
far).

From the 1 yard line to the 3 inch line, you have argon.

From the 3 inch line to the 1 inch line, you have other gasses.

The last 1" would be representative of the CO2 in the atmosphere.

Let's switch our units from inch to millimeters. One inch equals 25.4mm

95 percent of that last inch (25.4mm) is CO2 that comes from water vapor - that
is, evaporation from oceans, lakes, rain water, and so on.

That leaves 1.27mm left on the field.

Out of that remainder, 0.678mm is CO2 from natural sources - volcanoes and
other stuff from the earth.

That leaves 0.591mm - just over one-half of one millimeter - which is CO2
produced by human (and other creature) activity.

Out of that 0.591mm, about half is from CO2 exhaled (and/or exhausted) from
living creatures, including us dastardly, planet-destroying, humans.

Which leaves 0.295mm - about one-fourth of one millimeter - of CO2 emissions
from automobiles, power plants, SUVs, and anyone driving a Toyota Prius. (I
wonder what the overall percentage difference would be between a Ford F250 pick-
up and a Toyota Prius? It probably couldn't even be measured as a percentage of
the whole.)

And they claim we're destroying the planet. Yea, right. The more you look into
the claim, the sillier it gets. And the more you consider the real motives .....
... the more it makes you wonder.

by Member 25348569

Even posts like the useless guff you've just dumped on us should be properly formatted.

OK, let's wipe out a whole bunch of your analogy:

"From the goal line, go down 78 yards to the 22 yard line on the other end, and you have nitrogen.

Go 21 yards further, to the 1 yard line, and you have oxygen (99 yards total so far).

From the 1 yard line to the 3 inch line, you have argon."

The problem is that none of these gases have any affect on infra-red radiation. They aren't greenhouse gases. YOU CAN'T COUNT THEM.

If you want to come back with some proper figures, I'll give those some consideration.

:)

by tigger_two

What I know is that here in the frozen tundra, we are experiencing the worst winter weather in some time. Between the 20 inch snowfall, the absolute lack of our yearly January thaw, and the days seemingly without end of hardly getting to zero, never mind a temp in the double digits, you would be hard pressed to convince me that global warming is an issue- man made or otherwise.

I find it interesting that adverse weather- cold or not- has been so prevalent this year world wide. Makes you wonder if there is anything to the whole 2012 thing.

by tink!

I am overwhelmed by the environmental debate just as I am with politics. I choose to not be an active protestor for any side. I do believe that environmental awareness is a good thing. I believe all the hype about Climate Change is not a good thing. Too much hype causes changes that are not necessarily the right ones.

Increasing envrionmental awareness has been an issue for ages now. My generation pushed it quite a bit throughout my school years. There have been a lot of changes worldwide that are helpful because of the spreading of the word. Today's hype however, is way out of control and is borderline mass hysteria. People are pushing for drastic changes before those things are even fully studied as to what adverse effects they may have. If something is going to end up being more harmful than good, we certainly don't want to implement it!

Quite frankly, I'm annoyed and sick of hearing about "going green" to the point that I wish they'd all shut up. Basically, the same way I feel about politicians.

by purpleskys

it's my belief that Climate Change was happening regardless being part of the Earth's natural process...but I also believe that if it weren't for humanity's intervention, it would not be occurring as fast has it has been. We warm up the Earth's atmosphere just by inhabiting this planet and industrial growth.

by purpleskys

you should be along the eastern seaboard then...we all just got a good dumping. We have at least two feet of snow here in NS. There hasn't been any shortage of it here this year :)

by tink!

have seen more snow than us I think! We got our dumping on Tuesday overnight.

Now if only that Snow/Ice Cameraphone challenge had waited til this week...!

by tigger_two

If we got no more snow this season. I haven't seen a blade of grass since 11/13 and I am about sick of it.

Would be nice if we could have a few days over 32 as well, but I've seen the extended forecast and I don't think I will get that wish.

*sigh*

by fregeus

....but I believe this scientist is in error. The temperature would need to increase by 4 or 5 degrees for his prediction to be possible, much less true (this is an educated guess, I'm no climatologist)

temperature is part of weather. Climate change is a change in CLIMATE, not WEATHER. I think calling the whole thing Global Warming was an error on the experts part. Most people associate that with the weather instead of climate. Weather is part of the Climate, but it has a lot more to it too.

TCB

by Member 25348569

else you'd know about the weather there. AND the climate.

In 2002, it didn't snow there at all. In 2003 through to 2008, there were no more than three snow days in any one year and most years only had one or two snow days. So it isn't going to take much of a change in temperature to make snow a REALLY rare event as the climate is already pretty snow free.

So, you didn't make an [b]educated[/b] guess, did you? Far from it.

:)

Eighteen snow days in 2010. Still, that's just weather. None in 2011, so far.

by j-mart

As it does not fit in with Max's "truth" he will not allow it to hold any validity as he does not believe human induced global climate change is real

by purpleskys

but that's one of the reasons i posted it...David is one of those in your face scientists that i've had faith in for over 20 yrs

by hal 9000

That's probably why I spend so much time in the Q & A Section. ;)

We can not get any really good Off Topic Discussions going now and things have only got worse for the past several years. :(

Col

by purpleskys

I've had my fill...but unfortunately, our weather forecast is saying more snow and/or rain Sunday and 15 cm of snow Tuesday...sigh...it's starting to test me to say the least :|

by av .

I think global warming/climate change is real and man has contributed to it. Look at our unbelievable weather lately, no matter where you live. Is it an anomaly or the new normal?

Dr. Viner is a little off-base, or maybe he is just talking about where he lives. This year in NJ, I have NEVER seen this amount of snow or the frequency of it in my entire life. We've had 8 major snow/ice storms in a month. I'm not counting the little ones.

I like this explanation by Professor Michio Kaku. http://www.nbc.com/news-sports/msnbc-video/whats-causing-winters-wicked-weather/

Something isn't right.

AV

by maxwell edison

(On a scale of 1-10, you're a 12!)

Re: [i]Global warming/climate change is real [/i]

Of course it is. Just like the wind is real.

But does human activity influence it?

AT BEST, on the same scale of 1-10, it's less than a 1. Much ado about nothing.

by ansugisalas

That final line takes you into the same territory you criticize those professors of going into...
You can point out the doubts - that's fine, but you've a bit of convincing to do before you can go defining how it "really" is.

by nicknielsen

We're part of the ecosystem, so of course we are contributing to changes.

Accelerated? Caused? As Dr. Kaku said, not proven.

by ansugisalas

we humans have a tendency of turning everything to shit, by touch alone... Not the Midas, but the Mudus touch.
So, I think we can take credit for at least making things worse for ourselves ;)

by nicknielsen

Ocean temperatures there are normal (based on historical readings). There's no El Niño or La Niña to cause monolithic changes in global weather, so we're getting the buggered weather we should normally get.

by Member 25348569

According to the Australian weather bureau, the Southern Oscillation Index now stands at 20.8. Any reading above 8 is associated with a La Nina weather pattern.

by nicknielsen

I was looking for it at the US National Weather Service. Lots of information on what El Niño or La Niña are, but nothing on current status.

Searching again, I just found this article on Yahoo! News.

by tigger_two

This is all my fault.

I seem to have p*ssed off the Almighty and this is what we get. Horrifically bad winter at a time when I really needed something- ANYTHING- to go reasonably well.

*sigh*

What I am saying is that it is possible to devise a theory (mine above) and even put a lot of intelligent thinking into it (ask me why it is all my fault- I have reasonable reasons!) and still come up with the [b]wrong[/b] answer.

I'm NO expert. There are a whole lot of things that I don't understand, regardless of how hard I try. What I think is that the whole issue is murky. I believe that there is more to be learned. I believe that asking questions and challenging accepted thinking is the best way to get to better answers.

by ansugisalas

that this is Mother Nature's great plan to toughen us up for things to come... breathe some awe into us... the whole of last year was a fireworks of weather, it was Archweather, and Archseasons of it.

by j-mart

James Hansen, Dr David Viner and other leading climate scientist, years of training and experience in this particular feild, JackOfAllTech, business consultant, it does not take much to figure out who might know how greenhouse gasses work in relation to the climate of this planet. You probably slept through your high school science classes so to avoid showing off your lack of real understanding of this topic you should spend some time with google to acquaint yourself with the basic principles regarding the gasses present in our atmosphere and their function in allowing this planet to support life as it exists for us.

by ansugisalas

If you had read the whole thing you'd have noticed that more than a little of all this is less than completely serious.
It's as if this discussion really has been going on, here, for twenty-plus years ;)

by j-mart

When the post has more in common with the product handled with Mr Crapper's wonderful invention than intelligent argument what else would you expect. The argument on human induced global warming is a scientific one. To put up an intelligent argument with any validity, one needs to find fault with the science not just dribble from the web. Find some science that supports your viewpoint. James Hansen, Dr David Viner climate science is what they do for a living, anyone who disagrees with them needs to look at the science and data the have used to form their point of view, and find fault with that.

With the amount of bollocks thrown around here, especially with the "water cooler" topics, anyone not up to giving and taking some flak is in the wrong place, or have you been voted chief of discussion police.

by puppybreath

this will just turn into another "my scientist is smarter than your scientist" debate. You aren't about to listen to anyone who disagrees with you any more than your opponents would listen to you.

But there are many distinguished "experts" who disagree with you and your "experts" and the number appears to be growing daily. It could just be that your posts are the ones containing fertilizer. We'll have to wait a few hundred years to see.

by Member 25348569

"Experts (...) the number appears to be growing daily". you can, of course, support that statement with anything other than a Maxfactopinguess?

Anyway, we don't have to wait at all. The average temperature of the Earth's atmosphere has risen 0.6C in the last thirty years so anyone who says it isn't happening is really not from this planet. Even Max has changed his tune from "it ain't happening".

The debate hinges on whether or not it's partly or wholly our fault. And, given that we have had accurate figures for the intensity of solar radiation since the Sputnik days, it can't be difficult to see if there is a correlation between the increase in atmospheric temperature and any change in the intensity of solar radiation cause by modifications to solar output or orbital or axial changes. Want a clue as to what the answer is?

:)

by puppybreath

"you can, of course, support that statement with anything other than a Maxfactopinguess?"

This article is from 2009 but you could find many more if you'd bother to look.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124597505076157449.html

I'm not saying who's right or who's wrong, I'm only saying that there are quite a few learned individuals who disagree with you and your "experts".

by ansugisalas

My scientist is SO smarter than your scientist:
After all, have you seen these tentacles I got?
And the "lead-makes-me-stronger" brand epidermis?
To say nothing of the pitchfork-repelling overalls... I mean, can you say "hands down"?

by tigger_two

Oy!

I want to draw your attention to a little seen tag...

"WARNING!!! Cape does not enable user to fly"

We can't all be Superman.

by puppybreath

but we have to check to see if your scientist is named in the "enlightened ones" list (j-mart has a copy). If he's not on the list, you're not allowed to present any of his accomplishments or findings. Only current "enlightened" members are allowed to have opinions. It makes it much easier to debate the issue if we control the allowable content.

If he is on the list, then and only then, will we try to determine if he's smarter than my scientist. ;-)

by j-mart

From the viewpoint that disagrees with human induced global warming.

I have read the basic premiss put up by the human induced global warming veiwpoint, and have a basic understanding of how the greenhouse gasses raise the mean temperature of the planet, can take in the concept that burning fossil fuels in ever greater quantities will raise the percentage of CO2 in atmosphere and as the virgin forests that have use the carbon from CO2 and lock up carbon to grow, are being steadily reduced, all elementary high school science stuff.

From those that don't believe human industrialization is the main contributor to increasing CO2 levels, or don't believe that the greenhouse gasses actually effect mean temperature of the planet PLEASE put up a decent bit of science to support your claim, or is that bollocks posted by JackOfAllTech or the dribble by Max the best that anyone can come up wit.h

by maxwell edison

We ask you to prove your assertions, and you reply with a demand that we prove a negative??????

Drink your kool-aide, dude.

by j-mart

All I am looking for is for some arguments that look into the actual science involved. All you put up is rot, no sign of a science based argument. As you have pointed out, politics will not give any real answers to this question, then why are most only looking at this from a more political direction than a scientific one. The real human or not induced global warming question will only be answered correctly by looking at the science, the rest is just BS, which is what most of this discussion is. Why does real thinking seem to be non existent, a well thought out science based argument for a problem like this, which is of a scientific nature, is being conducted only in terms of rubbish references to web pages that mostly are more about the politics than the science. I have yet to see a single post refuting human induced global warming in scientific terms.

You can encourage, insult, personally attack, but still few seem prepared to actually get the brain working and put up a well thought out argument based on the science, which regardless of ones stance on this issue is the only real part, the rest is just political garbage.

Going by the way it has gone so far, I don't hold out much hope as blindly reading through web pages not really understanding or analyzing much seems to have replaced real thought. I'm ever hopeful I may be surprised.

by j-mart

What an enlightened piece of reasoning to go to an article from the Wall St. Journal, as a supporting argument to your viewpoint. We all know that journalists, especially from a financial publication could only be printing the absolute truth when dealing with a science based problem. Would it not be a more reasoned argument to go to what any of the quoted scientists actually said and the reasoning behind their particular point of view.

Neil even gave us all a good clue to get information that would be of assistance in producing a top argument. Doesn't the web, though a great research tool, also encourage laziness not actually thinking things though and only looking to reinforce a preconceived view.

by tigger_two

[i]We all know that journalists, especially from a financial publication could only be printing the absolute truth when dealing with a science based problem. Would it not be a more reasoned argument to go to what any of the quoted scientists actually said and the reasoning behind their particular point of view.[/i]

As a used to was and theoretically still AM journalist, I can state that I have NEVER in my life written a piece for publication that I didn't TRY my *ss off to get factually correct. Does that mean that something I wrote is a definitive source? Of course not. I cannot be all things to all people. But does that mean that all my work should be dismissed as nothing? Based on your response, it does.

Global statements are rarely correct. Terms like "we all know" are a clue to a global- and therefore potentially incorrect- statement.

From my humble and unenlightened perspective, the issue re: man made global warming is not proven. Nor is it disproven. It is a question in search of an answer. It requires thoughtful discourse and rigorous science to arrive at that answer unambiguously.

Never attack people. Attack ideas.

by puppybreath

I was asked to support the statement that the number of skeptics APPEARED to be growing. I provided one article which said just that. There are hundreds, if not thousands more available, that provide the same conclusion. It just shows that quite a few people don't agree with you and neil. Nothing more, nothing less.

I didn't run out and buy parkas or cut more firewood when the "experts" told us about the coming ice age in the 80's and I'm not going to panic when the "experts" warn us about "global warming" now.

When it all gets boiled down, it really doesn't matter. You can force all of the regulations you deem necessary down our throats, but more than 1.5 billion Chinese, not to mention dozens of other countries, are going to ignore you and your dire warnings. Generations will be dead and buried before anything meaningful would even be attempted worldwide. And that is still assuming that your are right in your guess about the climate of the future.

by maxwell edison

I mentioned neither weather or climate. Your "scientist" buddy who claimed that snow was going to be rare was wrong - plain and simple.

I didn't mention weather. I didn't mention climate. Only snow. Your guy was wrong ten years ago. Or do you disagree? Why can't you admit he was wrong?

by maxwell edison

You assume incorrectly.

I've personally met and listened to Dr. William Gray. I've read the opinions of Roy Spencer, Richard Lindzen, John Coleman, and many others. (Look them up.)

But around these threads, all the MM-GW/CC advocates ignore their scientifically based arguments, and only find some silly reason to discredit them or question their qualifications - never addressing their arguments

The opposing arguments are there, but it's you and your ilk who refuse to consider them.

Perhaps this will help you understand:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rCrY0uRDEdY

It also shouldn't be surprising that you assert that it is I who insult and personally attack, when in fact, I've done no such thing. But so far you have specifically called me both stupid and slow. Who's attacking whom, here?

But what do I know. You are, after all, the self-proclaimed [i]enlightened one[/i].

P.S. This has been a pet peeve interest of mine for well over twenty years - longer, actually, as I've always considered myself a protector of the environment. I actually teach environmentally friendly practices. And I don't like the people - or more accurately, their motives - who hijacked the environmental movement. It started before he wrote the book, but Al Gore's [i]Earth in the Balance[/i] has done more harm to truth than you can imagine. It's on my bookshelf; I've read it a couple of times - as I have some other books of fiction.

by Member 25348569

Obviously, such an enlightened soul as yourself would have a balanced outlook on this and be weighing the evidence from both sides. Given the importance of the issue, surely you wouldn't just be listing sceptics. Would you?

Actually, I was with you for the first three and then you lost the plot. The three scientists heading your list actually have sufficient scientific clout to demand that their views be heard and discussed. As, indeed, they have been. However, all I can find out about Coleman is that he's a journalist and TV weatherman. He is the perfect antithesis to Al Gore. Bring the two of them together and there would be mutual annihilation and we - and the environment - would be better off.

:)

by maxwell edison

I never claim to be among the [i]enlightened ones[/i], as j-mart self-proclaimed and others apparently feel. I'm anything but.

He really did make such a self-proclamation:

https://www.techrepublic.com/forum/discussions/103-340977-3415538?tag=discussion-thread

You and I have discussed this issue enough to know where the other stands. I've named several of the [i]experts[/i] already. One to start the thread, Dr David Viner, who claimed 10 years ago that snow would be rare (he was wrong), James Hansen, and I could name more. But why?

And why in the world would I want to argue [i]the science[/i] with a bunch of people (around here) who who are not even 1/100th as qualified as the weatherman, John Coleman? There's a bunch of techies around here who think they're friggin' scientists! But they're simply following their own politics.

Actually, I don't give a rat's behind if they believe it or not. They could believe the sky is falling, for all I care (and some of them actually do). But I don't want it politicized. And anything short of free market solutions to this or any problem - real or perceived - will be met with resistance. Why are there never any free-market [i]solutions[/i] suggested and pursued?

If I could wave my magic wand, here's what would happen:

1. Politicians will be banned from uttering or writing any of the following: Global Warming, Climate Change, Climate Legislation, etc. (the list could get quite large). And it would be an impeachable offense to even suggest legislation regarding any of said listed words.

2. Funded by private donations - not government grants or government pay - scientists and experts, both advocates and skeptics alike being equally represented, would be encouraged to study to their heart's content until there's as close to a 100 percent consensus as possible. Anything under, say, 99 percent, and it's back to the books for them! AND, they will be absolutely forbidden to share any of their findings or opinions with any news outlet or government representative until said consensus is reached.

3. If it's unanimously agreed that human activity is causing a SIGNIFICANT and MEASURABLE adverse affect on the earth's temperature and/or climate patterns, then so be it.

4. Only free market solutions to any said problem would be acceptable.

5. And as a bonus for the scientists, they would have the first opportunity to invest in stock options in companies, either existing or start-up, that would develop and market whatever it takes to address said problem.

6. Al Gore is discredited and put into exile, giving up ALL THE MONEY he's made by driving the Global Warming Bandwagon.

Feel free to add to the list!

Related thoughts:

https://www.techrepublic.com/forum/discussions/103-340977-3416241?tag=discussion-thread

by Member 25348569

I don't think that you've have any reason to criticise him at all. As I've said in earlier answers, I don't think he was talking about anywhere outside Britain. And, until 2010, he was RIGHT!

by maxwell edison

[i].....the issue re: man made global warming is not proven. Nor is it disproven. It is a question in search of an answer....[/i]

That's the thing about their whole argument - it cannot be disproven. Not because it's true, but because they claim we are causing (or contributing to) a dynamic in nature that happens anyway! The global temperature has always been going up or down; climate patterns have always been changing; CO2 levels in the atmosphere have always been increasing or decreasing. Ocean levels have always either been on the rise or the fall. Arctic ice has always been in a cycle of freezing and thawing.

None of those things have been static - never. Where's the perfect level for all these things? Where's the benchmark? There is none. And the claim that human activity is adversely affecting those things simply cannot be proven - or, in the minds of many, even reasonably asserted. Moreover, there are myriad things that effect all of that (the sun, volcanic activity below the earth's surface, etc.), and human activity pales in comparison to the awesome power of those things. If you dump a bottle of salt into the ocean and someone were to tell you that you're destroying the ocean by making it more salty, would you consider them serious or laugh at them? (Or feel sorry for them if they actually believed it?)

And then when you consider the impact ALL of their, so-called, solutions will have on society, there's plenty of reason to dismiss them - and even be extremely leery of them! Don't you find it puzzling that ALL of their, so-called, solutions are socialistic in nature, while NONE of them are capitalistic in nature? Shouldn't that say something as to their true motives?

If something stinks, there's usually something rotten that's causing it. And they are really stinking up the joint!

by nicknielsen

Cap and trade. Carbon sequestration. Legislating light bulbs. How are these actions to "stop global warming" not political? How is the refusal to consider increased reliance on nuclear power as a carbon-neutral power source not political?

The geological record indicates the current global climate has been warming for at least 12,000 years, and probably much longer. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_glaciation That same record shows that global climate over the past 500-700 million years has been cyclical, with alternating warmer and cooler periods.

There is a direct correlation between the climatic warming of the past 12,000 years and the human population explosion over the same period. Now, did the warmer Earth allow the population explosion or did the population explosion cause the warmer Earth? Knowing some small amount about the Earth's geological past, and how environmental factors can affect species survival, I'm inclined to think that the former is the case.

I have yet to see a single piece of information concerning climate change that proves (or even substantially supports) the thesis that current increases in global temperature are directly caused by human activity. To my mind, the thesis (in the face of geological evidence of Earth's cyclical climate) that humans are directly responsible for the current warming reflects not so much the climatic record as the intellectual arrogance of those holding that thesis.

by santeewelding

Should you choose to accept, is to change the subject from "this sentence" to you; i.e., to read, "I am".

I'll await your answer to: How?

Seems to the welder that all this BS about climate without is secondary to the climate within -- "within" a shoddy substitute (it was near to hand; rounds out the sentence more better).

Without "how", the rest of all this is a wild-goose chase; or, as I said, BS, and fit only for amusement.

by ansugisalas

I need to do some recon...
"How is your leg?" - too narrow
"How does it work?" ... pending
"How was it?" ... pending
"How?" ... by what way or means - or through which state of affairs and train of events.
BREAK

Second foray:
"how is it that I am?" - I'm picking up contra-directional effects - unfolding
"how is it"///is it that I am?" Last item is not in scope of question, reforming:
"How?///it is that I am!"
> "It is so that I am - How?"
>By what state of affairs and trains of events, am I?

All am I
.
.
.
.
interesting...

by santeewelding

Means, manner, method.

That's what it was when I looked it up, so long, long ago. It's like, when, you finally come to a necessary halt and ask yourself, "What do I mean by, 'of'?"