As to the appropriateness of the Captain's message, I'd refer to the the section of the UCMJ that covers political activity by active duty military personnel:
________ DOD (Department of Defense) Directive 1344.10, February 19, 2008 ________
4. POLICY
It is DoD policy to encourage members of the Armed Forces (hereafter referred to as ?members?) (including members on active duty, members of the Reserve Components not on active duty, members of the National Guard even when in a non-Federal status, and retired members) to carry out the obligations of citizenship. In keeping with the traditional concept that members on active duty should not engage in partisan political activity, and that members not on active duty should avoid inferences that their political activities imply or appear to imply official sponsorship, approval, or endorsement, the following policy shall apply:
4.1. General
[b]4.1.1. A member of the Armed Forces on active duty may: [/b]
4.1.1.1. Register, vote, and express a personal opinion on political candidates and issues, but not as a representative of the Armed Forces.
4.1.1.2. Promote and encourage others to exercise their voting franchise, if such promotion does not constitute use of their official authority or influence to interfere with the outcome of any election.
4.1.1.3. Join a partisan or nonpartisan political club and attend its meetings when not in uniform, subject to the restrictions of subparagraph 4.1.2.4. (See DoD Instruction 1334.1 (Reference (c).)
4.1.1.4. Serve as an election official, if such service is not as a representative of a partisan political party, does not interfere with the performance of military duties, is performed when not in uniform, and the Secretary concerned has given prior approval. The Secretary concerned may NOT delegate the authority to grant or deny such permission.
4.1.1.5. Sign a petition for a specific legislative action or a petition to place a candidate?s name on an official election ballot, if the signing does not obligate the member to engage in partisan political activity and is done as a private citizen and not as a representative of the Armed Forces.
4.1.1.6. Write a letter to the editor of a newspaper expressing the member?s personal views on public issues or political candidates, if such action is not part of an organized letter-writing campaign or a solicitation of votes for or against a political party or partisan political cause or candidate. If the letter identifies the member as on active duty (or if the member is otherwise reasonably identifiable as a member of the Armed Forces), the letter should clearly
2 DoDD 1344.10, February 19, 2008
state that the views expressed are those of the individual only and not those of the Department of Defense (or Department of Homeland Security for members of the Coast Guard).
4.1.1.7. Make monetary contributions to a political organization, party, or committee favoring a particular candidate or slate of candidates, subject to the limitations under section 441a of title 2, United States Code (U.S.C.) (Reference (d)); section 607 of title 18, U.S.C. (Reference (e)); and other applicable law.
4.1.1.8. Display a political bumper sticker on the member?s private vehicle.
4.1.1.9. Attend partisan and nonpartisan political fundraising activities, meetings, rallies, debates, conventions, or activities as a spectator when not in uniform and when no inference or appearance of official sponsorship, approval, or endorsement can reasonably be drawn.
4.1.1.10. Participate fully in the Federal Voting Assistance Program.
[b]4.1.2. A member of the Armed Forces on active duty shall not: [/b]
4.1.2.1. Participate in partisan political fundraising activities (except as permitted in subparagraph 4.1.1.7.), rallies, conventions (including making speeches in the course thereof), management of campaigns, or debates, either on one?s own behalf or on that of another, without respect to uniform or inference or appearance of official sponsorship, approval, or endorsement. Participation includes more than mere attendance as a spectator. (See subparagraph 4.1.1.9.)
4.1.2.2. Use official authority or influence to interfere with an election, affect the course or outcome of an election, solicit votes for a particular candidate or issue, or require or solicit political contributions from others.
4.1.2.3. Allow or cause to be published partisan political articles, letters, or endorsements signed or written by the member that solicits votes for or against a partisan political party, candidate, or cause. This is distinguished from a letter to the editor as permitted under the conditions noted in subparagraph 4.1.1.6.
4.1.2.4. Serve in any official capacity with or be listed as a sponsor of a partisan political club.
4.1.2.5. Speak before a partisan political gathering, including any gathering that promotes a partisan political party, candidate, or cause.
4.1.2.6. Participate in any radio, television, or other program or group discussion as an advocate for or against a partisan political party, candidate, or cause.
4.1.2.7. Conduct a political opinion survey under the auspices of a partisan political club or group or distribute partisan political literature.
4.1.2.8. Perform clerical or other duties for a partisan political committee or candidate during a campaign, on an election day, or after an election day during the process of closing out a campaign.
4.1.2.9. Solicit or otherwise engage in fundraising activities in Federal offices or facilities, including military reservations, for any political cause or candidate.
4.1.2.10. March or ride in a partisan political parade.
4.1.2.11. Display a large political sign, banner, or poster (as distinguished from a bumper sticker) on a private vehicle.
4.1.2.12. Display a partisan political sign, poster, banner, or similar device visible to the public at one?s residence on a military installation, even if that residence is part of a privatized housing development.
4.1.2.13. Participate in any organized effort to provide voters with transportation to the polls if the effort is organized by or associated with a partisan political party, cause, or candidate.
4.1.2.14. Sell tickets for or otherwise actively promote partisan political dinners and similar fundraising events.
4.1.2.15. Attend partisan political events as an official representative of the Armed Forces, except as a member of a joint Armed Forces color guard at the opening ceremonies of the national conventions of the Republican, Democratic, or other political parties recognized by the Federal Elections Committee or as otherwise authorized by the Secretary concerned.
4.1.2.16. Make a campaign contribution to, or receive or solicit (on one?s own behalf) a campaign contribution from, any other member of the Armed Forces on active duty. Any contributions not prohibited by this subparagraph remain subject to the gift provisions of sections 2635.301-2635.304 of title 5, Code of Federal Regulations (Reference (f)). See subparagraph 4.1.2.1. for general prohibitions on partisan fundraising activity.
4.1.3. Commissioned officers shall not use contemptuous words as prohibited by section 888 of Reference (b) or participate in activities proscribed by DoD Directives 5200.2 and 1325.6 (References (g) and (h), respectively).
4.1.4. Subject to any other restrictions in law, a member of the Armed Forces not on active duty may take the actions or participate in the activities permitted in subparagraph 4.1.1., and may take the actions and participate in the activities prohibited in subparagraph 4.1.2, provided the member is not in uniform and does not otherwise act in a manner that could reasonably give rise to the inference or appearance of official sponsorship, approval, or endorsement.
4.1.5. Activities not expressly prohibited may be contrary to the spirit and intent of this Directive. Any activity that may be reasonably viewed as directly or indirectly associating the Department of Defense or the Department of Homeland Security (in the case of the Coast Guard) or any component of these Departments with a partisan political activity or is otherwise contrary to the spirit and intention of this Directive shall be avoided.
________________________________________________________________________________________________
source: http://www.dtic.mil/whs/directives/corres/pdf/134410p.pdf
________________________________________________________________________________________________
The way I read this (and was trained when I was in the military), the letter was entirely appropriate, albeit factually inaccurate. Heck, there are political office holders (of both parties) currently serving with their Reserve units! To suggest a GI can't have a political opinion is ludicrous.
The Army Captain said he sent the e-mail to his wife and family members; I believe that. However, it was those people who took the liberty to forward it to everyone in their address books, many of whom also took the liberty to forward it to everyone in their address books, many of whom also took the liberty....., and presto, an out-of-control Internet urban legend is born. The Captain, I would guess, did not sign the letter to his own wife and family as a father of six. I believe she already knew that. It was probably added somewhere along the Internet Super Highway by some idiot who though it added something to the false claim, along with the "American Soldier" stuff. I'd also guess (emphasis on guess) that the Captain didn't sign by using his formal name, rank, and unit, this also being added sometime after the original (again, just a guess) by an overly zealous family member.
I think the lesson of the letter shows how two people can view the same event and take something different from it. Sure, there's an obvious political bias dripping from it, but what else is new? I think I can honestly say that I've seldom seen a story or an opinion on something like this that wasn't skewed with some political or personal bias. To those soldiers who sang Obama's praises, but felt compelled to add [i]"..... while McCain was playing golf in the US with Bush Sr....."[/i], their bias is also showing. Your political bias, Oz, is also dripping from your message. My political bias is transparent, although I readily admit it and define what it is and why I have it. We ALL have political bias, whether we admit it or not. It's not possible to be objective. We ALL see the world through the prism of our own experiences and our preferred world-view.
The way I see it, Barrack Obama probably had a great trip over there. He surely scored some political points with soldiers, foreign leaders, etc. To think he would shun soldiers is showing the epitome of ignorance. He went there to win them over, not to shun them. He went there to educate himself on the situations, not to make enemies. Security was tight, as it should have been. That's probably what the Captain was seeing. But other soldiers were on the opposite side of that security, and they saw something different.
I recall John McCain stories criticizing him for being security conscious when he went to the middle-east. John McCain is anything but a coward, and he - as well as Obama - were both prudent to be security conscious. Only a total idiot wouldn't be.
The bottom line is something I've been saying for years - don't believe Internet chain letters. We've seen them for years. We've seen them about GWB, J. Kerry, J. Edwards, John McCain, H. Clinton, Dick Cheney, etc. And just like people who don't read past the headline or hear past the one-liner jokes on late night television, people will believe whatever they want to believe.
[i]"How does a guy get a fair shake in such a media controlled marketplace?"[/i], you ask? That's a damn good question, but my answer is, he won't. And you're spot-on, Oz. It IS a media controlled marketplace - a point of total agreement between us. (By the way, on the same token, how does GWB get a fair shake in such a media controlled marketplace? The answer is, he doesn't.)
[i]How do YOU find or validate your sources"[/i], you go on to ask? I work at it; it takes time; it takes diligence; I go to the source; I verify; and so on. And I'll tell you this, it's frustrating as all get-out to discuss events and issues with those who don't. You'll notice I pretty much gave up trying - at least in these threads.