My main advice on this is "Nothing by Norton". In other words, avoid Symantec products at all cost.
They were the best in the early '90s when I tested them at that time. They barely work today, and they will kill the performance on your computer.
I've done less testing with McCaffey, but from what little I've seen and a lot I've read, they have the same performance issues as Symantec.
I've had good experiences with AdAware for spyware removal.
I've had better experiences with running under limited privileges when using the computer, and using an admin account for administering the computer.
I lock down my browser so it won't do ActiveX unless I tell it to. Won't run java unless I say go ahead. Etc.
I don't let software install unless I give it a password.
And I pay attention to where I'm browsing and why.
That way, my computer runs at a good speed (no A/V app eating up RAM and CPU), and when I do my monthly scan for malware, I've never had anything come up yet.