Discussion Locked

Spam, i'm sick of it, but what can i do?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

For the past few weeks, I’ve been getting email from all sorts of people that are receiving unsolicited pornographic Spam mail. They want it stopped, and so do I. But what can I do?

Most of these are sent to legit addresses, some aren't, but there is a legit address somewhere in the header and it gets to destination anyways.

Now I may be off the ball here, but I’m really starting to hate those people who think they can send us any type of garbage they want.

Why can't we work of a more secure way of sending mail? A system that does not allow you to cheat. A system that does not allow you to pretend you are someone else. A system that does not allow you to send garbage anonymously.

If someone sends me an envelopeto my house, and it blows up my mailbox or my front door, I call the cops and they track down the guy who did it. Why should it be any different for an email loaded with a virus?

If I don't want to receive unsolicited mails in my mailbox, I callthe post office, and they stop. Why can't we do that with emails?

My discussion is this: What can we do to make these changes become reality? That type of "innovation" would make me by that type of mail server (wink wink MS!). What can we do to make this a reality? Can this become reality?

I fear that if we don't do something soon, no email, no matter where or from whom it came from will be trusted. When that happens, having email will be more hazardous than practical, and it will disappear.

6 replies

by sheilau

To impose much harsher penalties on spammers is going to be tough. Not that it's going to do a lot of good anyway, because most of it comes from people who know they're doing something wrong and couldn't care less. I have been fairly successful in avoiding spam in my home and work by creating "throw away" accounts (hotmail) that I use whenever I have to "enter my email address" to register. Whenever I sign up for newsletters, newswires, etc, that's the address I give. Everything going to that address is junk, so I just access it every few days and delete. My home and work accounts have been blissfully spam free. Don't know if that helps at all for your situation. I agree completely that there should be laws, but there should also be laws about virus attacks, hoax virus "threats", and all the other junk we see on a daily basis.

by prefbid ii

For personal protection, I can't agree more. I have a decoy address on hotmail too and I use it for all of my "email required" boxes on the web.

In addition, though, I have hotmail set up to strongly thin out the junk. First, turn on "high" junk mail filter and "immediate delete" on junk mail deletion. Then build up your own block list. I recommend you start with the entire domain of yahoo.com, juno.com, and usa.net (they seem to be spoofed a lot). As you get more trash that makes it through the filter -- always block the whole domain.

This system works wonders. My real email site is rarely touched and even my hotmail account only gets around 3 spams a week that make it through my controls. I have no problem getting any of my real messages (on line news letters and sign-ups for advertisements).

I can never seem to stop the "university degree" people -- they seem to spoof every domain in the book.

by marksonit

Eliminating SPAM must take several forms: common sense by end users, real-time blacklisting services, anti-spam rules, keyword and heuristic detection proxies/servers like (free CPAN) Mail::SpamAssassin, whitelisting [1], effective legislation [2], cultural disgust, and economic dis-incentives.

Users must be taught about spammer tactics and avoiding them; many sites like orbz, osirusoft and spamcop actively track spamming servers - use them!; antispam software tests varies aspects of spam email and grades each piece; laws merely give legal backing but rarely mean anything to people already practicing shady businesses; society must send negative msgs back to the spammers and most importantly DO NOT SUPPORT THEIR BUSINESSES and APPLY equalization taxes to their messages to take away the incentives. They care less about your angry clients because they just targeted 4,999,999 other customers for mere pennies.

[1] whitelist servers send back a confirmation the first time a new senderis seen. Idea is spammers won't reply to confirmation requests. After that, senders' email accepted automatically.

[2] Ha Ha. Just seeing if you were paying attention. Effective legislation is a mythical goal. Pray for something at least thought out and not a shoot-from-the-hips WAG at a law.

by marksonit

Firstly, I want to declare that I like "Spam," the meat product from Hormel(?), but I too and sick of UCEs (unsolicited commercial emails), which I call Spam out of personal sloppiness.

Our first approach was to use real-time blacklists to rejectemail from well-known spam servers. With our 200 clients, we started REJECTED 300-600 emails daily at the beginning of the year, growing to 500-1000 daily at the end of April. Our users often didn't notice much improvement, especially if its blatant porn sites (plus they remember what they get, they become oblivious to the 1000 rejected mails they'll never see - just turn off blocking for a day ;-)

This alone is also worth a headache... end-users want 100% accurate spam detection and elimination based on their very unique views of the problem. Outside customers complain vocally because that free ISP they use for their business makes its money hosting spammers, but their emails should somehow come through the RBL's squeeky clean. Don'texplain it clearly in an email reply either. I have yet to find a person who realizes their ISP is shady and the mailserver is blacklisted; they somehow manage to think that they, personally, have been blacklisted from the internet....

by marksonit

[next level of spam attact]
Next step was to add heuristics plus some blacklisting of major blocks of IPs (such as from some countries) and from known abusive domains.

Mail::SpamAssassin appealed the most in this area, integrated easily enough with our mailserver (CommuniGatePro): it doesn't reject any email (something I find ethically questionable, like throwing about neighbors adverts even if they are taking up too much space. Ths neighbor is and should be responsible for the (mis)handling of the emails addressed to them). It runs dozens of tests for common spam traits and scores each email. Emails above a certain grage are considered spam. It can also allow automatic whitelists and blacklists maintained by my clients and can be tougher or relaxed depending on the client.

If spam. the email subject has a [?] added original subject to let users know visually this is questionable email. The headers contain an X-SPAM-FLAG: YES (if spam) and headers for the score (always) and list of failed tests (if spam).

No other msg modifications are done (the SpamAssassin default is to put the score and test results in a big text box at the start of email warning the user. The MIME type is also changed to text/plain (neutralizing malicious html,java,code etc).

I was amazed how extremely reactive users were. If a message was marked as spam falsely, they compained more that the inocent people receiving VERY inappropriate content -- even though they still got their newletters (mainly from users subscribed to questionable lists like shady-investment-practices@not.really.a.spammer.com. The solitary [?] was the compromise, nothing else.

Accuracy was initially around 90% (both false + and -'s). After adjusting some test scores and lowering the grade (fence), accuracied went to around 95-98%. It tagged as spam another 250 emails daily OVER AND ABOVE the RBL solution.

by marksonit

[finally, to wrap it up]

In summary, we're just using a simple subject modification and the headers; but it's very powerful - now each user bears responsibility for their SPAM policy and it's very simple to show them how to setup rules: some users delete all spam, some send a reject letter to the sender, others redirect the email to another folder for review and/or automatic deletion after xx days, and some who just don't really care.

For me the best of all is the reduction in the spam complaints are do and I've discovered legitimate emails in my inbox once again! Yet I know this too shall evolve and once again Cyndi (with an 'i'), Brandi, Tonya or Mr ViagraMeetaVegAdmin will be calling at my email box.

Now if employers looking for Sr. Networking Architects would only spam me... :-) shortly after finishing this project, our company was acquired by another and my 15 years service is now my first month unemployed along with many other fine workers!

This discussion is closed to new replies.