Question Locked

Starlink - Accessing CCTV DVR

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Until recently I had a CCTV DVR which I could access over my home LAN and via the Internet using an Android app on my phone. I setup port forwarding on my Draytek 2862ac router, then all I had to do was supply the app with my fixed IP address, the port and password and I could connect.

I’ve recently had to take up a Starlink service as my landline speed is so bad. I’ve retained the Draytek router (because it’s setup with virtual LANs etc) and I now feed it from Starlink instead of my landline DSL.

However, as far as I can tell, there is now no way I can set things up such that I can contact the CCTV DVR thru the Starlink box from the Internet. After sniffing round the ‘net, this seems to be quite a common problem.

So, I have the generic question….is there an easy way this can be done?

Assuming not, I have a spare 4G modem and I’m wondering whether I can use this with a cheap data SIM for the sole purpose of being able to access my DVR over the ‘net utilising NoIP. So the DVR plugs straight in to the 4G LAN port.

However, I also continue to need local access to the DVR on my LAN.

Sooooo, is there a way to link these two LANs (the Draytek LAN and the 4G LAN), so they are completely independent but CCTV data can pass between them?

Or am I on completely the wrong track? You will, by now, have realised I’m not an expert. Just enough knowledge to be dangerous!

Thanks for any help in advance.

12 replies

by rproffitt

Starlink uses CGNAT (see the web about that) so you'll have to create other solutions when you use an Internet service that used CGNAT.

There are web articles about that but none are going to exclusively use your Starlink CGNAT connection.

by birdmantd

I suggest reaching out to Starlink customer support directly. They may have a solution or suggest a source of information for your question.

by tekrepublic576

I was pretty sure the Starlink path was a dead end. What I'm really interested in is the bit about linking two networks....

by rproffitt edited

Not enough detail to continue. But at least we know that CGNAT is in play here so that's 1 network and deeply discussed about access to servers on the other side of CGNAT. Short answer "He's dead Jim."

Can't guess what other network is in play here.

by tekrepublic576 edited

OK, I probably haven't explained it very well. Imagine I have a router with the DSL input connected to my ISP and the LAN output connecting to my home network. All very standard. Now imagine my next door neighbour has exactly the same setup. I want to connect my LAN directly to his LAN, so I can access his CCTV DVR (imagine I string a LAN cable between the houses!). In all other respects, I want to keep the networks completely separate and independent. Can this be done? I'm sure I can't be the first person who wants to communicate between two different networks?!

by rproffitt

Then all this has been done before. However, connecting to say the internet is in conflict with the "networks completely separate and independent."

The only way to hit that goal is to never connect the two networks together or to the web. Further refinement of that spec needed here.

Anyhow, CGNAT really throws a wrench into having servers of any sort accessible from the Internet. You no longer control the NAT so what you did before breaks into many tiny pieces.

-> "access his CCTV DVR" would be same as it other was if they on the bog standard ISP. Again, CGNAT sets up the bomb.

by tekrepublic576 edited

I have a diagram that might help, but I can't see how to post it on the forum?

by Wizard57M-TR

Is to utilize one of the various image/file hosting services, like MS OneDrive, Apple iCloud, Google Drive, Dropbox, etc. Upload the image to your service then choose to share, copy the link, and include the link with a description in your posting.

by rproffitt

Too many hurdles and too much hardware to add then configure.

I defer all CGNAT setups to others.

by tekrepublic576 edited

OK, let me simplify this even more. Imagine NO Internet connection to either router. Simply one router connected to a home network, acting as a DHCP server for that network (Network 1). The other router connected to a CCTV DVR, acting as a DHCP server for that DVR (Network 2). Two completely separate networks. How do I connect those two networks and configure the two routers so the home network (Network 1) can see the CCTV DVR (Network2), but in all other respects they remain separate networks?

by monalisa3661

Hey, yeah I’ve been in the same boat since switching to Starlink. Everything was smooth with port forwarding before, but now it’s like all the usual tricks just stop working. No public IP means stuff like DVR access from outside becomes a real pain.

I don’t have a perfect fix either, but I’ve been messing around with some side stuff (like on https://snaptroid.ws) and honestly started leaning toward using things like Tailscale or ZeroTier to kinda “fake” a LAN over the internet. Not ideal, but at least it keeps remote stuff connected without needing a public IP.

Your 4G modem idea doesn’t sound crazy at all though. If you can separate it just for DVR and use something like NoIP, it might actually work. You’d just need to figure out how to let your main LAN still talk to it. Routing between two networks can be annoying but not impossible.

Anyway, following this thread to see if someone has a cleaner solution. I’m still looking myself.

This discussion is closed to new replies.