Sam,
Whilst growth potential may be huge and everything seemingly looks rosy today, l'd say that since the dot.com bust that you're on eggshells if you push too hard, too soon.
Suggest you focus your efforts and attention moreso on aspects of "comparable worth" in relation to your peers' salaries who're doing similar duties in other non-startup (e-Comm)organisations.
Focus on comparable base with, say specific similar non-cash benefits like health insurance, grad school fees, etc..
Quality work and high value-add from your daily efforts will always pay-off in the longer term.. the times of instant payback even before company is cash-flow + are now long gone. RIP.
Good luck
David