Discussion Locked

supposed IT job shortage; can't find job

0 helpful
142 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

142 replies

by dayody

Well IT world is what is growing continously everyday.In my own case, I don't see it throwing the trainee out there. But that is the only way to learn

by eltoncole

I don't mean to be overtly negative, but all this MCSE stuff is a joke.

I began certifying on NT V3.51. Back then, no one knew the certifications existed. Now, some employers require it. No middle ground.

The existence of 6 week MCSE boot camps has really hurt the image of good MS technologists. I've seen dolts come out of such training, walk in my data center and step on a patch cable...

I have changed SE tracks twice-both times being only 2 tests away from the cert.

Hopefully, themore difficult W2K SE tests will restore some credibility to this.

by eltoncole

I don't mean this personally, and it isn't a general age issue, as I am 38. But...

I've worked in many environments. In my career, the overwhelming majority of IT staff with over 9 years of experience simply have not kept up.

I can't begin totell you how many times I've had to explain the most basic underlying concepts of C/S or n-tiered architectures to "old guard" types who, once having mastered CICS and sitting in front of their 3270/5250 screen, behaved as if the IT world was never going to change.

My comments aren't directed at age-I'm not saying the older one gets, the less energy or intellect. I am simply relating an unpleasant, undeniable (in my experience) fact of IT life...

by eltoncole

You are focusing too much on your title.

I hope you don't use that email on your resume. It looks, IMHO, very bad to tout your title like that.

Also, you need to have some impressive accomplishments in your decades. Simply having been there, then getting an SE doesn't mean much...

The Internet job boards are a joke. I made the mistake of posting my resume. I have various bullets such as:

* ...integrated with Unix and midrange systems

* ...connectivity with Oracle, SQL Server...
Now, my resume is ran through some OCR crap and I get calls asking if I am a Unix admin or DBA when, if my resume is actually read (by a human with a brain in their head), it is clear I connect NT to these other systems.

The vast majority of jobs are for developers, not networking/systems people...

by eltoncole

This is one issue that points to the problem.

How can someone with little or no experience be REALLY capable?

I don't think candidates should be eligible for MCSE until they've been in the industry for at least a year in a network/support position.

I don't care how smart someone is. And I do know that the MS training is pretty good. You HAVE to have considerable real world, firefighting experience to be an SE.

Without this experience, the SE is simply, like an IT degree, a piece of paper.

by eltoncole

What are you talking about?

Unions are for factories.

Unions promote based on length on the job, not actual expertise.

I've risen like a rocket in IT. I went from fixing PCs to managing projects in two years. If I were in a union shop, I would have been held back behind the slower staff who had been there longer.

Promotions should be based on merit, accomplishment, not tenure...

by marclipshitz

Yep, I have to agree, any system in IT that values length of service over expertise will be damaging. I had been messing around with programmming since I was 9 but I had no formal experience in IT, so my first job hired me as a juniour developer. A week later I was promoted to Analyst programmer on the strength of my programming skills, my degree in IS and the desire of my manager to to mentor me, six months later I was a project manager when I had the guts to say no to a difficult client, and get hiom to accept it. After the fact I was sent on some Project management courses. As a result I was put in charge of small programs where I ended being project manager, analyst and designer!

With a union system this probably could not have happened as way too many toes would have been stepped on. The friends of mine that told me about the company and organised for me to get interviewed all ended up juniour to me within eight months of me starting, luckily this didn't cause any friction, but a seniourty based on time served would have caused big friction.

by eltoncole

I wasn't able to respond to it (computer glitch) but someone earlier asked about campus experience.

Campus experience is invaluable. There ARE ways for the novice to get real world experience. If it involves volunteering, well, that is the reality.

by ailouro

I heard somewhere that the average time to get a job after graduation is a week for every $2000 annual salary. That's about how it worked for me. I got frustrated, saw complete idiots get jobs immediatly upon graduation, heard the success stories, etc. I even had to take a job as a video store clerk to pay the bills. But, it eventually happened.
I recommend starting small and taking what you can get. It's a lot easier to get promoted than it is to find a job. And you won't have to starve either.

by lbmyoung

Trying to find that fine line and balance is driving many to dispair.
Many professionals-in other vocations-have had to learn on the job IT skills, to stay with and at times ahead of their staff to assist the company remain attractive to users.
Unfortunately, straight from uni grad's, still require the -live,in the field-experience required to make informed choices about the IT needs of a company. Too often, this has been an expensive exercise for Upper Management who have had no check list for IT applications & software relating to their particular business.
As 'Upper Management' catch up, new IT personnel, MUST gain work experience within the industry they wish to work in to be enployable.
Approaching a business within the Industry you wish to work in, will be how IT personnel are hired in the future.

by eltoncole

This is my personal/professional opinion.

TEKSystems is a "body shop" of the lowest order. Their recruiters make many claims, but they rarely deliver.

Continuing, I have dealt with three of their offices in the Midwest. I interacted with very poor, unprofessional communicators.

In general, consulting firm recruiters are IT pimps who care nothing about you. They will be hot n heavy with email and telephone contact at first. But if they don't make any money from your talent and experience (meaning actually find you a spot) they will forget about you in a matter of days.

Good luck. It really is a numbers game-just keep at it...

by motiuttam

Can't we single click to open the complete discussion instead of opening one piece at a time.

Haven't heard of Internship in IT?
Any charges to get these discussions emailed to me. Thanks.

by kilroy

Well I have seen a lot of good advice and encouragement here. My two cents worth is this, welcome to reality. By far my largest disappointment with college was the lack of an intense curriculum throughly immersed in the study of a profession, mine being computer science. Also, you by far get much more book work, instead of a knowledge transfer form your professors, some have a great deal to offer and that is a shame.

I went to both a 2 year computer institute and a 4 year university. Although the university had in some cases a more professional environment, the 2 year college blew it out of the water when it comes to learning about computers. A typical 4 year school will only permit 2-3 computer classes for the Computer science core and 1-2 free electives for the computer science degree. You only have 3-5 computer classes, that just doesn't account for much. That is what you are selling to perspective employers, not much at all. Intro to psyc, anthro, economics et cetera just doesn't sell. Remember everyone who has a ((BS)the degree)) also has the same basic classes. Yes they give you calc algebra/boolean/linear physics et cetera however, there are painfully few computer jobs that require those skills and they usually hire someone with that back ground and train them with computer skills.

by kilroy

You will find that with a Novell CNE, Microsoft MCSE, Comptia A+, Inet+, Network+ you will go much further and be infinitely more in demand by employers then having a (BS) degree. It's a shame that after paying $30-50k and studying for four years you then must lay out an additional $5-10k to get some certification. That is reality. If I were18 again ( god forbid ) I would probably hose it up once again, however if I had my current level of common sense and was 18 again today, then I would blow off college altogether and get all of the above mentioned certifications that would be less expensive and I would be far better off in doing so. Unfortunately a (BS) degree in most cases doesn't make good toilet paper. It certainly has little impact in landing that first big job to start your career.

One last note, I recall having several different professors telling the class that we would be nuts if any one us in taking our first job would accept less then $50k. Well it took me 20 years toget offer. Flush that silly advise down the toilet were it belongs. What are they telling students today $100k for the first job? Well you have zero experience, how much do you think that is worth?

by buzz70_98

How about the fact that I have a BS in Civil Engineering, A+, MCP+I, MCSE, CCNA, 3 years of experience as LAN, Network, and WAN engineer in an environment where we had multi-platforms, switches, routers, and even some junior DBA using SQL 7.0. Now you tell me, is $50k to much to ask for.

It is not the money, the fact is that a lot of us got laid off from the dot com companies, and employers have a big choice. It is impossible to figure out what employers want now. In my opinion, as I haveseen, besides having your certifications and degrees, you better be able to make some real good coffee, expreso, or cuban coffee, or actually all of them, because that is what it is going to take to get a job today.

by makepono

I agree, all I had was an A+ and a Network+ along with one year worth of part time bottom of the barrel tech monkey work experience. I beat out MCSEs for my job because I knew my ass from a hole in the ground and didn't pretend to be someone or something I wasn't. This, in the heart of Microsoft land. My references came thru because the people I had worked with knew I had both the aptitude to work with technology AND people.

by max_clan

There are recruiters out there that focus on recent graduates. I am not sure what you expect for $$$ but that should be your last consideration at this point in your career. You need to get EXPERIENCE.

Also, don't expect your 4 year degree to carry you far. A lot of employers are looking at skill set or specific manufacturers certifications. A good starting point is A+, Microsoft (MCP/MCSE) or Cisco (CCNA/CCDA) (go to www.brainbuzz.cramsession for info).

I have been in the business for almost 20 years. Keeping up with the technologies is key to your success. You will be spending a great deal of time self-studying to keep the other folks from taking your job.

I hope this helps. Good luck to you.

Nick

by zzcatch22

The only shortage in IT is enough 25 year
olds with a Master Degree, 6 Certifications,
and 15 years of experience who will work all
day " Like a rented Mule" for $25,000.

< < Z Z > >

by kilroy

Well I'm sorry to hear about your current situation. I think we all go through it. My career hit a pot hole from 92-95 and from 95 to present the wheel turned and life is worth living once again. It depends on were you live at any given time. Somewhere things are going up and somewhere things are going down it's only relevant to the individuals affected at the time. Keeping tongue in check, I don't want to pick at you however, the original post was from someone who was a recent grad with no experience or certifications outside of the BS degree. The problem that was sited was that this person couldn't get an IT job. Not much else was given. That person could be in a affected area were times are tough right now. To that post, I posted my twopart reply.

by kilroy

In your case, you are completely different story from the original poster. You site that you have a degree and four different certifications and at least three years of wide ranging experience. I dare say that is a far cry from a newbie grad with out certifications and no experience. A sheep skin makes a good looking plaque on the wall in your den however, that alone doesn't bare much marketability. As to your reference to the 50k being to much to ask. Well I refer once again to the difference between you and the original poster. More over, the 50k has more to do with your location then other factors, of which are many. Making 50k where I live is a lot to ask for, work 50 miles southwest and 50k isn't much at all. Where I currently both live and work the median family income is 34k and in the other location it's 58k. The college professors which I referenced made no distinction other then to the 50k. For your first IT job I strongly believe that cart blanch demanding 50k to start is very unrealistic. Certainly there may be some rare and unusual circumstances which would permit someone to prevail. I would not put my eggs in that basket, although I certainly would have welcomed it 15 years ago. I hope this answers your question.

by kilroy

In my experience most problems that IT folks have both in looking for a job and on the job is that we still are treated as the new kid on the block. A lot of companies have a situation were non IT folks determine corporate IT needs and define the goals for the IT department. They are very apprehensive about giving control to a profession that they are clueless about and which has or can have a dramatic impact on both the company and their job. They don't understand the dynamics of their own department's IT needs and that is just the beginning. They want to bend IT around their perceived needs and desires and not adapt to the way the hardware and software works. That is when you are smugly told, you said that you were qualified, or you arenot god so just do what your told and best of all, so you are saying we got the wrong person. They just don't understand the profession or the products and have great difficulty in both hiring IT folks and working with them instead of trying to control them. They need to get with the program and accept IT as just one more pea in the pod. How can folks who don't understand how the products work be so determined to make the decisions? I will never understand how that persists when they so often shoot themselves in the foot.

by kilroy

They simply have a great lack of understanding the dynamics of IT as a whole and worse yet they just don't seem to care to find out. I have worked both for companies in side and outside the IT industry. The companies outside the industry have an enormous difficulty dealing with the volatility of the IT industry in every aspect. They assume that there is a problem with a job candidate if you have worked for 3 companies in five years or switched your IT focus, say from programming to network administration. Or if those companies you worked for downsized, sold or went out of business. That just isn't what they are used to. A dot com starts out in a garage and in 18 months goes from there to wall street and back to the garage, to them it's frightening and just beyond their grasp. All that and much more is just another day in the IT industry and it stands as a defining wall of division between IT and the other business professions.

by kilroy

I found myself getting up and walking out of many interviews leaving those clueless wonders shocked and stunned. I just want to spit nails at them when they boldly trot of course, get it wrong and I find myself correcting them. Of course you know were that often leads. I'm determined to be in control or a part of and IT department which is and I don't want a job that is any other way. We must work closely with the other departments and guide them in determining their IT needs however, we must make the final decision. Unless economics factor into the situation, I wont work for a company that is any other way. I have found that experience just to painful and when either IT or myself is in control, it's just to much fun to consider any other way. I know they think we have an attitude however, their view is whole heartedly reciprocated. I have found so many cases were non IT folks commandeered cooperate IT plans and got the wrong tools for the job and the wrong skills for the position andyou guessed it, they blamed IT. The infamous words, just fix it, shall forever echo in my mind.

by mike.woodruff

Please e-mail me a resume. I am in the recruiting business, and I will get back to you shortly.

Michael Woodruff

by findlayr

....as if we didn't hear that one before.
The best advice I can give you is: scrub the dust off that old french book, or see if you can remember some of the old irregular german verbs you used to hate at school. Central europe is buzzing with jobsfor IT specialists, and since companies are desperately trying to gain international market shares, you'll be recruited not only for your IT knowledge, but also for the simple fact that you're a native english speaker. Best of luck,
Richard

by barmaley

I agree with you that when they (interviewer) say something good about you - it make boost for the confidence.
But sometimes they say things because it is in their job description.
Last job I applied (internally, and was fully quilified) I didn't get even an interview. When interviewer gave me a feedback (thay have to) it was lame-nice feedback, just to make me feel better.

by dcavanaugh

Experience is to IT what "location" is to real estate -- everything. I have 15 years experience, no degree. Hiring managers (like me) are often willing to ignore the degree requirement, but not experience. HR has the opposite view, but in most companies, they don't actually hire anyone. Too much IT career advice comes from people who never worked in IT.

My suggestion is to manufacture your own experience. Build a software product that does something. You don't have to actually sell it, just use current technology and demonstrate how you can handle all the phases of the development cycle, write documentation. It needs to look like a commercial product, not a school project. Make a website, offer the product for download. The entire website should be a showcase of your abilities. Thanks to cheap hardware, free software, and the Internet, it has never been this easy to demonstrate IT competence without actually working for an IT shop where the expensive infrastructure was provided for you.

A key problem is that all recent grads look alike to the hiring manager. We have all seen people who graduated somehow lacked the skills to be successful. You won't have a job in IT until you can demonstrate your ability to apply what you learned.

by dcavanaugh

I'm an IT manager, and I'm not all that impressed with either a degree or certifcation. I want candidates to tell me what they , how they their skills, and how they are problems that are not multiple choice questions on a certification exam.

Having said that, it sounds like you want out of the help desk, but you're a little light (1 yr.) on sys. admin. Strange how employers are only willing to give you the job you already had, not the one you actually want!

I suggest you seek out employers whose salaries are too low for their requirements. State government and Higher Education are well-known for this. The competition for these jobs is watered down by the lack of salary; this creates certain opportunities thatcan be exploited. Better yet, government and education are known for spending big bucks on infrastructure. Capital money flows freely; operational money is tight.

You don't have to keep the low salary forever, just long enough to convince another employer to give you the same job with a competitive salary. Then again, you might get promoted. Low salaries create turnover and a "vacuum" effect -- the position above yours will almost certainly become vacant. It's not all that hard to move up the ladder.

Get the job you want, then go looking for the appropriate salary.

by barmaley

It seems to me that IT industry is in war with IT people.
People with experience cannot get jobs because of not having certificates.
People with certificates cannot get jobs because of not having experience.

There is always something is not enough for employers.

by dcavanaugh

If I have an open position that requires 10 years of experience, I would try to promote an internal candidate if it's a reasonable fit. Only if I can't do that would I be looking for outside people for senior positions.

Once in a while, I encounter people who have more experience than is required for a job. I don't usually have enough flexibility on salary to make it worthwhile to pursue such a candidate. My fear is that even if I land the experienced candidate, I won't have them for long. Turnover is really wasteful.

If you apply for a job where your 10 years of experience is truly relevant and necessary, you can rest assured the organization has NO ONE ready to move up.

If I'm lucky, I have people who can be promoted and my new hires will be entry-level. If I accidently hire a deadbeat, it's not as much of a risk.

It's possible to have a situation where the organization is looking for a person with 10 years of experience, but management really doesn't want itto work that way.

A few years ago, I started working as a manager for an organization that had to build IT capability from ground zero. These are the employers who will occasionally pay a premium to hire an experienced person.

by twhaight

My fist IT job was as an operator in a shop the used IBM mainframes. Sometimes I was on the main console, launching jobs, or else I was in the I/O section, running the printers and distributing products.

Later I got a position on a helpdesk. It gets tiresome after a while, but side projects you get when you aren't running calls break the monotony, and can help you figure out what you want to do. I started doing web development part of the time around 1994 when the internet exploded, and thats what I really enjoyed doing.

Today I do development using Cold Fusion, MS Access, and SQL Server.

by twhaight

Many companies don't want to pay for a permanent employee, and have to pay for benefits. They would rather bring on a temp employee because its much cheaper. When the job is done, then they go back to their agency, suposedly, unless the client is Microsoft, where they keep extending out the contract out a few months at a time, and then you'd have "temporary" employees that have been there for years.

by dvice

The fleecing of America. Higher learning Institutions are the ones projecting the need for 750,000 new IT position. The people that have the IT jobs are holding their positions as software becomes business freindlier. Non related IT businesses want to see a shift in the supply and demand of IT workers. Wage decreases. A job in IT will in the not to distant future be and average paying job. The amount of big paying is dwindeling.

by coppage

I work for the State and all a person has to do is fill out a questionaire about what training and experience they have and you get offers. Also there are recruiters calling asking if I am looking for a job. Call Teksystems they always have openings.

by lightnin_700

I'm 62, dye my hair (female)and just had my
first interview from my second app. This is my 3rd career I entered 6 years ago. Put myself thru college while raising the kids in '85. Thru networking got job splitting the 1st and 3rd shifts (4am to 12:30 pm)in great IBM shop, swiched to Tape Librarian and on my way up until laid-off in less than a year. Took job with state administering Public Assistance hoping to switch to IT -- found location too far to commute raising children. Relo with spouse '91, get AS from community college, work closely with Placement. Unpaid ops work for city, 3 hr commute COBOL job for 3 mos for $300. stipend, help desk at $5. per hr when I was getting a min of $7. in '80 for clerical. One yr. paid internship with a bank, then last job with gov't contractor starting same salary as bank. Only 2 yrs ago did I top my '91 salary of $30K. All the advice has been good. Older should concentrate on Public Sector or Gov't contractors to stave off age discrimination. Having the right skill set (COBOL HAS LOST GROUND) helps. All it takes is starting from the bottom, perserverence and LUCK! Skill helps too!

by dcavanaugh

There is no shortage of pure coders. I could hire a dozen interchangeable HB-1 javaheads in a few hours. If I need someone who can work from an incomplete spec., do some analysis, or improvise a little, it gets much tougher. If I add language skills to the mix, I'm in fantasy land.

If I look for people with experience, I'll probably find a bunch of Y2K leftovers, carrying stacks of 132-column coding pads. Just what the doctor ordered!

A pure coder is not particularly useful. It's amazing how many people know the answers to the certification exams without having a clue about the world of IT outside their certification. Just try to buy something online -- see the clunky software in action. Who is this 404 person, and why is he so upset about a malformed SELECT statement?

Thanks to higher salaries and the HB-1s, we are increasing the quantity of IT people. Too bad we're doing nothing to improve the quality.

by dcavanaugh

There is no shortage of pure coders. I could hire a dozen interchangeable HB-1 javaheads in a few hours. If I need someone who can work from an incomplete spec., do some analysis, or improvise a little, it gets much tougher. If I add language skills to the mix, I'm in fantasy land.

If I look for people with experience, I'll probably find a bunch of Y2K leftovers, carrying stacks of 132-column coding pads. Just what the doctor ordered!

A pure coder is not particularly useful. It's amazing how many people know the answers to the certification exams without having a clue about the world of IT outside their certification. Just try to buy something online -- see the clunky software in action. Who is this 404 person, and why is he so upset about a malformed SELECT statement?

Thanks to higher salaries and the HB-1s, we are increasing the quantity of IT people. Too bad we're doing nothing to improve the quality.

by dolbur37

I went to a job fair at a local university and witnessed the funniest thing. There was a recruiter yelling out to a crowd of college seniors, "Does anyone have Cobol experience....Does anyone have Cisco experience?" One boy went up and said, I've got some Cobol experience, blah, blah, blah. The lady then went out to ask him how many other certifications he had when he started stammering. The poor kid is maybe only 22, and this lady is asking him for multiple certifications at an entry level jobfair. On top of that, the opportunity was down in "beautiful" (haha) Decatur, Illinois. What a farse.....It was pretty funny at the time, and I thought'd share.

by dcavanaugh

Temps are not cheaper. In fact, you pay a premium over & above what a "permanent" employee costs. I have yet to meet a temp who wasn't (A) looking for a "real" job, and (B) willing to work for less (even including benefits) than we were paying their agency.

After all, the temps either work for someone who needs to provide benfits + make a profit, OR they have to factor in "bench time" between contracts. Hiring temps for work that is not temporary is a real waste!

Having said that, itoften makes sense to hire temps for "new development", since the project will someday conclude, and the resources can be deleted painlessly. Another justification is the paper chase. In most companies, it takes an act of God to authorize a new position, but hiring a temp is about as tough as getting your coffee cup refilled. The final justification is the "try-before-you-buy" scenario, where the temps are working on a project and management is looking to hire the best and brightest. The personnel screening process for IT leaves much to be desired, so why accept the risk of hiring a permanent "dud"? In some companies, getting rid of a person is more difficult than hiring!

Most managers try hard to avoid the need to fire people. In some companies, getting rid of a person is more difficult than hiring! In ALL companies the circumstances result in firing will surely result in much pain and frustration before the ultimate decision. Above all, firing a nonproductive person represents failure on the part of management, at least as much as it does the employee.

I think temps are hired mostly because of convenience on the front-end and "disposability" on the back-end, not cost savings.

This discussion is closed to new replies.