7 replies
Switch:
PRO: Better network performance if there are many simultaneous conversations, i.e. multiple servers. If the bulk of the traffic is generated by a single server, a switch may give only a slight performance increase.
PRO: Security. Workstation connections running a network analyzer will not be able to see traffic from others.
CON: More expensive than a comparable hub (in terms of number of ports, management capabilities,etc.)
Fast hub (repeater):
The inverse of the above, i.e. lower performance in a multi-server network, lower security for a lower price tag.
As a general rule, the larger the network, the more likely you will benefit from a switch and the easier it will be for you to justify the cost.
by den_espe
by mightyidle
Switches move data across the network without collisions. Each node attached to a switch has an open 10- or 100-Mbs channel. Hubs share a single channel among all ports and this can, when large amounts of data are being transmitted, cause a large number of collisions and choke off throughput.
Switches generally cost a bit more than hubs, but in a reasonably large network the cost is easily justified.
To summarize, if you have a very small network and have a limited budget for equipment, then a hub is the way to go. If you network has any size to it and performance is an issue, then you need a switch.
by den_espe
by jackieb
Hub: Inexpensive. All packets received are transmitted out all ports, meaning that the speed of the port (10 or 100 mbit) is the total aggregate speed of the hub (the maximum throughput of ALL ports combined) Useful in a very small environment, or to connect users to a backbone if the users are not doing high traffic things.
Switch: Probably double or better on cost. All traffic adressed to a specific address is 'switched' to the port with a path to that address. All broadcast packets are passed to all ports, but the total throughput for EACH port is very close to the rated speed of the port (10 or 100 mbit). Switches are better for server connections and those 'power' users who tend to transfer lots of information over the network. Switches are also used to create a 'backbone' for your network.
Picture a network with switches providing connectivity for all your servers, where a switch port feeds a hub providing connectivity for users, and the switches are interconected forming your backbone.
JackieB
by den_espe
by den_espe
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Networks posts
Sort by Trending