Discussion Locked

Switch or Hub: That is the question

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have a 60 client network. All clients are 9x connecting to NT4 servers. I also have an AS400. My problem is this: We have a new server and through running NetBoy to analyse load and traffic on the network, I have realised an average load of 2000%.This is obviously a problem, so I need to look at topology. The new server has two NIC's and a third redundant NIC. The AS400 has one NIC but we're seriously looking at installing another. The servers will all be connected to switch ports and the clients connected to hubs determined by workgroup. Printers are the problem as all printers are used by AS400 application and Windows applications(eg. Excel, Word). Where would be best to connect them to? Switch or hub? Workgroup hub or specific printers hub? Are there any network design tools to help with this? (I've forgotten all I learnt at Uni about OSI etc). Please help! Thanks.

4 replies

by tbradley

How big is your budget? The optimum solution for you sounds like a 4 switch stack connected with Matrix modules, like the 3com 3300 series.

If you don't have the budget, the next best would be to subdivide your network into logical workgroups, and use vlans on your switch to keep them segregated.

The main server and the AS/400 obviously need to be on the switch, with the workgroup hubs connected. You mentioned server(s), so if any
are exclusive to workgroups, move them to that workgroups hub also, leaving the common ones on the switch.

You're probably having severe collision problems, and the vlans will help alleviate this problem. The 2 Nics in the server could also be generating excess traffic rather than providing more bandwidth.

by walterzalewski

I'd recommend setting the printers on the workgroup hubs if they will not be used (or at least not often) from other workgroups. If the printer will be used heavily across different workgroups, then consider putting it on the switch. I'd also recommend replacing the hubs with switches, with the prices of switches going down. Hope that helps and good luck.

This discussion is closed to new replies.