Discussion Locked

Switches, hubs, and things.

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I heard it is better for a buisiness network environment to have everything on switches rather than hubs. MY network is running at 10 MBps I would like to get it running at 100 MBps or close to it.

Thank youse,
Doug Carter

9 replies

by barry hensley

Switches are much more effecient at controlling LAN traffic because they pass traffic ONLY to the switch port belonging to the destination host rather than broadcasting every packet to every port like a hub. When one host on your network is communicating with another host on the same network, a switch will isolate that traffic so that other hosts do not see it at all.

With the cost of switching coming down so rapidly, I would highly recommend retrofitting your network with 10/100 switches. These devices will autodetect the speed of the NIC in each host and adjust accordingly. You can support BOTH 10Mbps and 100Mbps devices on the same switch at the same time.

I recommend purchasing manageable, stackable switches, all from the same manufacturer. Install the manufacturer's management software and you will be able to control and monitor traffic at each port on every switch.

by mckaytech

The primary advantages to switches are that each workstation gets full bandwidth to/from the switch and that data transfer can run both directions at once (full-duplex). Theoretically, the perfomance boost from going from 10Meg hubs to 100Meg switches is about 20-fold.

In my experience, an upgrade from hubs to switches is the single most cost-effective network upgrade you can do.

paul

by mikejbyrne

You have to realise the distinct difference between switches and hubs.

Switched work at layer 2 of the OSI model (you get layer 3 switches aswell), and forward packets based on port destination. The principal is that each individual workstation attached to a port of a switch has the entire bandwidth of the line from the pc to the switch, not other traffic or collisions etc, thus increasing speed dramatically. A hub just simply recieved traffic through the port and sends it out on all ports (broadcast) until it finds the correct destination (unlike switches which forward based on mac address).

All these factors taken into consideration basically says that yes switched are faster and better than hubs but if all you want is a little increased speed without all the trouble i would go with a 10/100 autodetec hub. You have to ensure all your NICS are upgraded to 100 mb aswell else your wasting your time.

Mike

by jolly roger

You've gotten some great advice already. I would stress that you get quality NICs (10/100 with full-duplex capability) to get the maximum benefit from your new switch(es). Then give some thought to whether your network might benefit from one or more server-specific NICs in your server(s). Intel NICs are typically capable of load-balancing and port-aggregation and have their own processor so the server's processor is free to do other (more important) work.

This discussion is closed to new replies.