Discussion Locked

Switching sides from being contracted to being employed by the same company

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What to do? How do you create a win/win situation for both the vendor and the vendor's customer? Legally, there is no non-compete clause between us, but I still want to do the right thing.

Here's the story: I have contracted with a company who has assigned a highly skilled IT staffperson to our company on a full-time basis for at least the last 12 months. Now this person wants to change sides and work full-time for us. It would be foolish to turn this person down, but there is an equally important matter of continuing and maintaining a good business relationship with this company. We certainly need and can afford the new position, since we are essentially paying a higher price for this person anyway.

It's a "win/win" situation -- We win because we get the same service at a much reduced cost ... and although the vendor looses a staffperson, they win by gaining an inside support champion for future support and project bids.

I want to consider all the risks and benefits, both short and long term.

What does a IT Manager do? Any thoughts and/or real-life experiences would be much appreciated.
Thanks. "TORN"

2 replies

by oldefar

You have contracted with a company who has assigned you a highly skilled IT person for at least 12 months. This is the starting point.

You need to let the company know you would like to bring the individual on as a full time employee. The non-hire clause gives them the right to say no, and you should not be talking with this individual about becoming an employee unless you get approval from his current employer.

Any discussion puts that individual at a long term disadvantage. His current employer can block employment with you, or at least seek damages for contract violations. Are you willing to pay these? He will feel his career has been blocked by his current employer if it refuses to release him. This will likely have a negative impact on his performance with them.

Meanwhile, if you have already talked with this potential hire, you have lost trust with the firm you contracted with.

Your initial win/win just became a lose/lose situation.

Keep in mind that body shops have overhead involved with placing people. A certain percentage is on the bench at any given time, and their salary and the salary of management and sales comes out of the revenue from those they have placed. A long term full time placement represents a significant chunk of revenue, and you want to take that away. Their techs who are most likely to be offered a full time position by the contracting firm are the ones who are easiest to place and who generate the most revenue. This is a long term revenue issue for them.

Your next steps are fairly clear - damage control. Step one, be upfront with the firm you have your contract with. Step two, be upfront with this potential hire. Step three, consider working with the contract firm to reward the employee if they don't release him. Perhaps a bonus, with you kicking in a share since you helped create the problem, and the contract firm kicking in a share since it helps them keep a good revenue source happy.

I have been on all sides of this issue. I have made the mistake of talking with a potential hirer only to have such a move blocked and watched a good relationship go sour because of it. I have watched a top performer go down the tubes because of feeling he was taken advantage of. And I have felt my career was blocked by my employer on a couple of occaisions with both internal and external opportunities, and finally quit. That they later hired me as an external resource at many times my previous salary, when they could have kept me with a relatively small reward for performance, indicates their poor understanding of human nature.

by timwalsh

It is a fact of life in the commercial world that companies try to "steal" valuable workers from their competitors. It isn't often that you see this happen between companies that want to continue business relationships with each other.

Who started the talk of changing employers, you, or the tech? If it was you, there is no way that you will be able to maintain a friendly business relationship as you will have in fact enticed away (or "stolen") what they may consider a star employee. You would also in effect be "stealing" business in that you would no longer be contracting the type of work performed by this tech with the vendor. Thus they would lose profits. I can't imagine the vendor's management being happy about that unless there is other work that you contract with them that is far more profitable.

If the tech started the talks, you may be more successful in maintaining a working relationship. But the vendor still won't be happy. If the tech's support is currently the only business currently being conducted, again you would be effectively "stealing" profits from the vendor.

Why do you think the vendor would be gaining an inside advocate? The tech obviously wants to jump ship for some reason. You discount the possibility the tech may hold some sort of grudge against the company. You also discount the possibility that even if you you contract further work with this vendor in the future, the vendor might consider it too dangerous to send their star employees to do the work. You might get stuck with support techs the vendor might WANT to lose.

When does the current contract end? Don't even think about making any commitment until the current support contract expires or you will find yourself neck-deep in legal troubles.

There may be no non-compete clause between the two companies, but is there a non-compete clause in the tech's work agreement/contract with the company he works for.

In my mind, you have two choices:
1. Tell the tech that although you would loveto have him on your team, but you really don't want to cut your vendor's throat by doing so.
2. Hire the tech and forget about getting any quality support from this vendor in the future. While they will still put on a happy face and take your money, they are not likely to send any more "star" performers your way for fear of you "stealing" them also.

Good luck, whichever way you end up going.

This discussion is closed to new replies.