Discussion Locked

SYS-ADMINS! POLL! SERVICES NT4/2000

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Please forgive this rookie asking all You greyheaded eminences, but...

Should a commercially distributed serverbased application be configurable to start as a service in NT4/2000 Server?
(Without 3:d party utilities.)

If it isn?t? Is that poor components and programming or what?

Opinions please!

I will get more explicit if asked.

Rikard Malmborg
NIKAS SE
(site in scandinavian only)

...this have been posted at msnews.microsoft.com under:

microsoft.public.backoffice.server
microsoft.public.commerceserver.general
microsoft.public.win2000.advanced_server
microsoft.public.win2000.general
microsoft.public.windowsmedia.server

3 replies

by parrotheadny

Without question, Rikard. If a server based app cannot run as a service, then I assume it must run interactively. This is a problem because you will then need to leave your server logged on 24x7. If you typicallty log onto your servers with an admin account, (who doesn't?) you either leave yourself exposed to a significant security risk or you run the risk that someone will log-off the session and kill your app.

by richard ainz

Hi, and thanks!
I appreciate Your answer ParrotheadNY,
It made a point I didnt thought of and gives me more arguments.
I fill up with some more info below.
/Rikard

When You add a program as a service, You might want to do it because You
want that executable up and running always, even booting the server.
Many applications can be configured as service but some can not, due to
starting procedure or whatever.

This is our case, and since the application to run in service is, actually,
a server itself, my opinion is that it should be startable as service on the
main server.

If You need to create a batch-file or script or anything extra, the whole
point of putting it as service using NT4/2000 built in tools for this,
escapes.
It eludes me, anyway.

You loose in "usability" and the System Administrator in charge says, "I
dont know how to do this, is it necessary?"
And we loose customers.

So, getting back to basics, should, in this case a 3:d party server, be
configurable as service in NT4/2000 environment?

Whats Your opinion?

Thanks...

by parrotheadny

One solution to your problem might be found in the NT4 Resource Kit. There is a utility in the Resource Kit called SRVANY.EXE which enables you to run an executable or even a batch file as a service. I can't guarantee that it will work with your app. You'll have to test it but it might be a simple solution to your problem.

This discussion is closed to new replies.