Question Locked

T-1 vs. Fiber Optics for Wireless Network

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

My community is reviewing a proposal from AT&T for a 10mbit fiber line that would feed our 802.11 wireless network. We currently use a T-1 feed that slows quickly once we have too many users signed on. I have been unable to find a published explanation of the throughput differences between a 1.5mb T-1 line and a 10mb fiber line. Even the AT&T engineer can't explain the difference. It's more than just the difference between 1.5 and 10, isn't it?

If someone has knowledge of a "white paper" on this I would appreciate a direction to it. I will have to explain these differences to my community board in order to get funding for the increase in the AT%T costs.

Jack

7 replies

by Former member

Clarifications

by ssfpridav

The T1 has 1.5Mbps of bandwidth. That means that at any given second the T1 can transmit & receive 1.5Mb of information. The 10Mbps fiber line has about 7 times the bandwidth. It can transmit or receive 10Mb in the same second that the T1 could only handle 1.5Mb. For an easy analogy think of traffic on a roadway: A 2-lane divided highway can carry some traffic but it can get congested easily. A 14-lane highway can carry significantly more traffic before becomming congested. Your T1 is analogous to the 2-lane highway. If too many people use it, it gets congested and nobody goes very fast. Replacing it with a circuit that can provide 7 times as much bandwidth will give you lots of bandwidth and it takes a lot more to congest it.

(Technically the 10Mb line has only 6.66 times as much bandwidth as a 1.5Mb T1 but it makes it easier to talk about if you round up to 7.)

by Former member

So it's a two dimensional difference. I was hoping it was three dimensional. By three dimensional I mean that there are 6.66 times as many lanes(or some increase in the number of lanes) all of which were going 6.66 times faster. But I don't think you are saying this.

If it's as you say, then this means we will get six+ times the performance with the same number of users or six+ times as many users with the same performance. Right?

Jack

by lnguyen_x

I was told by Verizon Business that a fiber line is shared much like DSL or Cable, so you may not get the 10 MB speed. I am currently using TW Telecom's 10 MB fiber and let me tell you, it's horrible. Our speed is never consistent from day to day. The only that explains this is the shared line by other businesses and no, the sales person did not respond to my inquiry. :)

by raiz714

The speed of your fiber network is dependent on what type of equipment they use. Single mode fiber is estimated to handle up to 500GIG speeds but there is currently no equipment that can transmit that fast. I have put together a network of over 1000 devices including CCTV's on 2 fibers and i can see all my cameras in streaming real time at the same time. We have a 10 gig network here

by robo_dev

While more bandwidth never hurts, I would expect that the WLAN part of the network is the weak link.

There are two challenges with WiFi:

It is a shared medium, so if it's 802.11b, for example, you're allocating a total of approximately 4.5 MBs of throughput amongst whoever is connected, which means that it only takes a few users to kill the throughput for the others. And forget what you read about 802.11g giving you 54mbs of speed, that's 'market speak'..actual throughput is typically 15-18 mbs, which must be shared amongst whoever connects.

The other issue is that multiple WiFi access points are often deployed incorrectly in terms of channel selection and coverage area. Multiple devices need to be setup with non-overlapping channels, and antenna selection and positioning is critical to ensure that coverage is adequate. Remember that WiFi connections automatically slow down when the connection gets worse.

This discussion is closed to new replies.