Discussion Locked

Take the test - The ISI Civic Literacy Test

0 helpful
127 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

ISI: Intercollegiate Studies Institute

Take the test, and compare your results to the average citizen AND to those who've held public office.

First, take the test:

http://www.americancivicliteracy.org/

Then compare your score:

http://www.americancivicliteracy.org/2008/additional_finding.html

No looking up the answers.

And don't look at anyone's reply before you take the quiz, because some people might comment on some of the questions.

And then, if you dare, share your results with us. (Even if you don't think you did that great, please share.)

Prediction: My esteemed TR peers will do better than the general public, at large.

Please, no ridicule of anyone brave enough to share their score.

127 replies

by maxwell edison

.....81.82 percent. I answered 27 correct out of 33 asked.

I missed (and the wrong answer I gave):

4 (C)
13 (C)
14 (C)
27 (D)
29 (A)
33 (A)

However, compared to the average citizen - and elected office holder - I suppose I did pretty well.

by jamesrl

I'm sure you do - I got 84.85.

We both missed 33 - I think they worded it ackwardly.

James

by maxwell edison

My score was respectable, and if you look at my incorrect answers, well........ some of the questions are awkward, and I never read much of Socrates, Plato or Aristotle. And I didn?t miss any Constitutional questions.

by charliespencer

I notice it is one of the questions with the lowest success rate. I agree about the wording; I spent more time on it than any three others.

by thechas

Max,

This is bizarre or at least just plain weird. You and I had the same scores and missed nearly all the same questions.

I did not save and cannot report my specific answers to the same questions.

As to the general population, I would say the average score is higher than I would have expected. However, a large number of the uninformed in the US also do not have an Internet connection, and those that do avoid anything of substance.

I strongly suspect that a detailed review of the majority who failed the test would find that few of them watch news broadcasts, or read the newspaper. Even fewer would search out news and political information on the Internet.

Of course, this is in line with myriad other studies that have shown that the majority of US natural citizens would not pass the tests given to immigrants before they can become a citizen.

While many would blame the education system and the media industry, I believe the real culprit is apathy. The average US citizen only cares about the Constitution and Civics when they believe their civil rights are being violated.

It's too bad that we cannot have knowledge standards for becoming a voter, politician, or parent.

Chas

by Member 25348569

I answered 27 out of 33 correctly ? 81.82 %

However, I hardly consider it disappointing.

:D

Question #4
Question #6
Question #7
Question #11
Question #18
Question #29

were answered incorrectly.

by maxwell edison

For a Brit, you did great. I don't think I would fare nearly as well on a similar British Civic Literacy test.

Question 29 was stupid:

[i]a resident can benefit from it without directly paying for it[/i]

Well, a citizen indirectly pays for it.

And I wasn't crazy about 33 either:

[i]If taxes equal government spending, then ..... D. tax per person equals government spending per person[/i]

I actually changed my answer from that correct one to [i]government debt is zero[/i] - after I thought that some [i]per persons[/i] don't pay tax at all. Moreover, the premise of the question is stupid - taxes DO NOT equal spending. The amount of tax revenue could equal the amount of money spent - and if this is always the case, then my answer could be considered correct.

P.S. Like I said, I'm impressed with how well you scored, but not a bit surprised.

by charliespencer

Maybe if it was phrased as 'average tax per person equals average spending per person'. Like you, I responded with 'debt equals zero'.

Good exercise though. Thanks for posting it.

by santeewelding

Same two you mentioned, and for much the same reasons. Only, I never saw "resident" until I went back to check. I had "citizen" on the brain.

Wasn't fond of the "profit" question and the available answers, either. But like most of the one-sentence questions and one or two-word answers, difficulties were artifacts of compression.

Oh. And do you recall the question relating the Bill of Rights to the anti-federalists, dear man?

by captbilly1eye

Answered 31 out of 33 correctly ? 93.94 %

My wrong answers:
Question #9 - C.
Question #33 - A.

I wish I did as well on my last cert test.
;-)

by road-dog

You answered 29 out of 33 correctly ? 87.88 %
Question #7 - D.
Question #8 - C.
Question #27 - A.
Question #30 - C.

I wasn't a big fan of question 30, Spending one's way out of recession.

by sleepin'dawg

Missed #8. My choice was D. It's an interesting quiz, not so much indicative of intelligence as it is of knowledge. I doubt Americans are any worse or better than any other nation when tested upon the civic literacy as applied to their own nations. The teaching of history has been relegated to the back burner in far too many institutions these days and it would not surprise me in the least that seniors would score higher on average than the youth of today.

BTW the only reason I scored as well as I did is due to the fact that at one time I minored in history and I took two full credits in American history. I doubt I would do as well on Canadian history which I skipped, since at the time, I considered Canadian history boring and prosaic and less exciting than American history. Also much of Canadian history was covered by the study of English, French and American history. Canada as a subject for historical study just didn't appeal to a teenager back in those days.

Don't get me wrong, I was by no means being unpatriotic, it was just that I had to constantly struggle against boredom, and chose to follow the easiest and quickest route, for myself, to get through the process. I ended up with a degree in engineering physics, but I had also dabbled in the arts and commerce faculties and even considered giving medicine and law a shot.

I'm addicted to reading and the acquisition of any and all knowledge; I'm just not particularly impressed by, or fond of, formalized education. I believe in that old adage, "Those who can do; those who can't teach." In my whole time of enduring the educational process, there were, at best, half-a-dozen teachers, or professors, who impressed me with their capabilities as teachers and their abilities in their sppecialties. A case in point: Economics. Can anyone show me any system of economics that has succeeded, or better yet, that hasn't ultimately failed. Show me any economist, anywhere, who foresaw, or could have stopped, the cuurrent international fiscal boondoggle

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by maxwell edison

.....Bill of Rights to the anti-federalists? Yes, I saw that. And you'll notice I correctly answered that question as well.

James Madison and George Mason (federalist and anti-federalist respectively) also seemed to know what they were doing. Did I ever suggest otherwise?

by charliespencer

MIssed

Question #8 - C. appoint additional Supreme Court justices who shared his views
Question #14 - B. stressed the sinfulness of all humanity
Question #27 - A. the price system utilizes more local knowledge of means and ends
Question #33 - D. tax per person equals government spending per person

by maxwell edison

.....eight.

In order to get around the lifetime appointment obstacle, and to avoid the necessity to impeach them, FDR wanted to expand the court to twelve (12) justices, instead of the nine (9), thereby changing the balance of the court. He was shot down like a duck over Nebraska.

by charliespencer

As much as we scratch and claw around here, I find the quality of correspondents on most other forums to be depressingly poor. Most of them quickly deteriorate into name calling or worse, with few attempts to bolster their arguments with even biased supporting data. Some appear to run on 50% tin foil, 50% Kool-Aid.

by road-dog

It kills when inhaled

It can be found on 70 percent of the Earth's surface.

It must be banned!

by road-dog

I've picked up what I know along the way.

What surprises me (and embarrasses me somewhat) is how well outsiders know so much. I would look like a drooling idiot if I had a pop quiz on British government.

I did Like Tony Blair, though.

Also The British Parliament debates are much more colorful than our Congressional sessions. Our pols seem to be intent on being too genteel. Too much politeness comes off as disingenuous.

by jmgarvin

Not too bad considering I missed some of the esoteric history questions but did fine on the civics questions. The fact that our elected officials scored less than 50% is pretty damn depressing.

by maxwell edison

They should have scored 80 percent or better - giving the benefit of the doubt for the questions that might have been ambiguous.

by the scummy one

They were elected, however no list for what positions. However, I still think they should have outscored my 66%
Also, it stated that some of the elected officials did very well, while others did poor. This would be expected.
I was surprised that the basic populace outscored the elected officials though.

by maxwell edison

.....the population as a whole AND the elected officials.

I continue to be impressed at the level of knowledge held by my TR peers. There are some smart cookies who hang around this site, and Michael, you're one of them.

P.S. Sorry, but I missed your earlier message referencing the same quiz. The only reason I posted this was because it appeared on Yahoo!'s home page, and it grabbed my interest.

by ontheropes

I got 24 right too, better than I expected to get. I closed out the page after finding my score so can't post the ones I got wrong.

by michael jay

note to self;
do not inhale
Ingest, I always try to get 2 to 3 bottles, it comes in bottles in this country, into my system each day.

Taken that way the bad effects can be avoided.

by Former member

my score is the lowest one. :(

'You answered 17 out of 33 correctly ? 51.52 %'

very good topic!

by santeewelding

I've missed you!

So good that you have not been made to go down to your knees for a bullet in the back of your head.

Have you been occupied with the real?

by Former member

looked up three on-line translators, but I still no idea what you mean: 'made to go down to your knees for a bullet in the back of your head.'

yes, i was busy at real. Last Saturday, I just attended a test about business English. Hope I can pass it. :)

by the scummy one

Since you are not a resident American. I would say you scored well (above 44% for an average of American elected officials and 49% average American tested). This means that you either guessed better, or know more than many of us :0

by Former member

Frankly speaking, I guess a lot! haha
It seems this time I am quite lucky. :)

by maxwell edison

.....the people - the normal citizens - cede power to these idiots. Why, oh why, does a person cede power over him/her self to these people?

KEEP POWER YOURSELF!!!!!!!!

Are people really that insecure that they can't?

by road-dog

Our entire media complex is geared to elicit responses from us in exchange for entertainment.

Commercials are geared to make us feel inadequate and envious in order to get us to buy pimple cream and jewelry. Those "he went to Jared" commercials make me want to puke.

We are bombarded with ads that tell us we aren't complete until we are as good as airbrushed and chiseled models, and that we can be with such and such a product..

News is geared to presenting us with horror. What is good isn't newsworthy. Therefore we watch to stay abreast of how our toothbrushes are deathtraps. After the commercial break....

It's taking it's toll, we are the most prosperous nation on earth with the highest standard of living whilst the anti-depressant drug manufacturers are making a killing.

We look to our politicians for answers. Again and again we are told pols will solve problems and that we can't make it on our own. Meanwhile we are told that the evil rich must be made to pay their fair share. More inadequacy and envy.

A politician is a product sold as an elixir that will make real our covetousness and give us the illusion of security.

by santeewelding

"Bullet" does have something to do with business.

Stick around. Your business English will hopefully improve faster than a bullet.

by Former member

I never and don't expect my business English would be improved from here, I mean TR, but I am very sure that my acquaintance about your politics and history does improve well. I mean it. Really!

by tig2

The more you read here and the more you are willing to
ask questions of us, the better your English in its entirety
will get.

The slang will probably continue to be the most difficult
point. Our cultures are different, therefore our idiom will
be different. But even that, over time, will change.

As an American, I find that when I am in conversation with
British friends, I use the idiom most common to them in
addition to spelling by their rules. When speaking with
another American, I use American idiom and spelling
rules. When speaking in a mixed environment, I use
American idiom and spelling and try to not use slang.

Every time I see you post, I see you grow. This is a good
thing.

by Former member

Don't worry, I am wearing flak jacket. haha

by Former member

I also have right to stay hidden to dodge bullets, I mean lurking, or enjoy other good, useful and funny topics.

And I think sometimes language barriers could be a good thing, because I often don't know where bullet is. haha!

by Former member

I just quite enjoy the way you talk about politics, life, job and other things. Too different from us. Sometimes I feel shocked. I often look through some reports on your mainstream media, but obviously, I like here than there.

by .martin.

and all this from a non-American!!!

hmmm... will have to study harder next time! :D

questions I got RIGHT were: 2, 11, 15, 16, 18, 19, 23, 25, 27, 28, 30

My purpose in life: make Americans look STUPID!!! (no offense...)

by ontheropes

Did you read the OP and forget already?

Personally, I hate tests of all kinds, feel I've taken too many or something. I also do not like that others give people a hard time when they don't score as well. I took my test before coffee. Maybe I'd have done better at another time.

I've nothing to prove here, it's just a test. I can still hold up my head regardless of my score.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Missed questions 29 and 33.
33 is pretty ridiculous. Both the 'correct' answer and the answer I gave are correct. B-)

edit: #29 I answered E (silly of me, really)
# 33 I answered A

by Former member

heroine!

The position you are in my heart is more grand. haha

by Former member

How often you guys say this sentence: I love you? HAHA

When I did this quiz, I think one thing is pretty funny: the way I know Sputnik is from Friends, which Ross act it to his son. haha

entertainment and politics

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Entertainment and politics. American industry and media would make them one and the same.

Beware that phrase, 'I love you'. It has the wildest range of meaning that any (American) English phrase can have, I think.
No wait. You already know that.

typo

by Former member

I love you.

I think last time that I said 'I like you' was a little progress. Now it is juge. lol

by ontheropes

That whole agape love thing again? I hate it when people from differing cultures get along with each other. Where's muh gun? I can straighten this out. :p

by charliespencer

It's disgusting. It's like a Lifetime movie, or an 'ABC After School Special'. They're getting cooties all over the site...

by ontheropes

Cooties everywhere. Where's muh gun? That's how us good 'Mericans straighten out this kind of crap. No loving each other at TR! It's probably against the Terms of Service too. Where is that moderator?

by jamesrl

My only American history courses skipped over the great depression, a subject I think they assume we covered adequately in Canadian history.

Thats my excuse :)

James

by jamesrl

I just squeeked past in reality, and I would accede to you the title of expert on the US Constitution without any debate.

I'm just happy to score well, considering the fact I have only had one high school class in American history, and one university class in comparative political systems, that spent alot of time comparing the Canadian/British Parliamentary system with the US system.

I was more teasing you than gloating. In truth there were a few questions I should have gotten correct if I had taken more time and care, thats not a boast but an admission that I was a little sloppy - my own darn fault.

James

by charliespencer

That sounds absolutely fascinating. When I get over 60 and can start auditing classes at the local university for free, I hope I remember to look for something like that.

by jamesrl

...but not love, not BigHair love...

That was a good class. Ones I would avoid if I was taking it for interest sake - Public Administration. All about how governments work and how bureaucracies develop. Maybe it was my prof but it was deadly boring.

Probably the most interesting was a philosophy course called "The Philosophy of economic history" It focussed on the writers and thinkers who wrote about economics - from ancient times (Greece) to Marx, and encompassing Smith, Locke, Rousseau etc. I doubt you would find that exact course, but maybe something similar.

James

by ontheropes

This religion thing comes in handy. I've got your response ready for all of the posts I've made so far today. :D

by delbertpgh

Some bits were very easy; others, not at all. I luckily managed to get none wrong. I was not sure about Lincoln/Douglas, and guessed.

My wife's a history professor. We both care about politics and history. For us, pillow talk can be about long-distance trade in the early renaissance and the development of banking. Or fiscal policy since Reagan. No sh*t.

Some people would find us weird.

by charliespencer

Smithsonian magazine had an article on the debates two months ago. The debate format was the first speaker had 60 minutes uninterrupted, the second had 90 minutes, and the first speaker got 30 minutes more at the end. Repeat five more times over the summer. 3 hours at a time and they packed them in. I think it says something about modern attentions spans and (lack of) ability to follow an argument. What most people forget is that Lincoln lost that election.

by michael jay

I like my DHMO straight and at room temperature.

However I am not against putting DHMO in its solid form in my scotch.

by tink!

I only scored 60.61%

Although I swear it said 24 out of 33. :p
(mathematics, of course, state otherwise...bah!)

I did worse than I expected. Ah well.

What interests me is that elected politicians score below citizens on average, yet politicians are citizens to begin with. So we're electing in citizens that know less than the average person? LOL.

by the scummy one

On the second link it states that some elected officials did very well, while others couldnt even answer the question correctly about who was our enemy in WWII.

Also, there was mention that some of those elected were only elected once, and no mention of what positions -- or who elected them, and no confirmation that they were actually elected anything.

Maybe they were elected 'dumba$$ of the year' in the office, maybe they were just messing around screwing with the stats. Who knows.
However, at a mere 66% (I thought I should have done better :( ) I cannot comment too much other than to say, yes, it was a disappointment to see the stats.

by tig2

I only missed one. Question 28. Frankly, I didn't like any
of
the options. But then, I don't agree with the concept of a
"progressive tax". I find the idea of any tax to be less than
"progressive".

I wonder if this means that I am smarter than a 5th
grader...

Edit- forgot to post score

by dadspad

26 out of 33, but the ones I missed were, mostly, different. They reflected my lack of knowledge in history.

by notsochiguy

After taking the test (I got 31/33...missed the FDR/Judges question and the Lincoln/Douglas question), I clicked the link to look at the statistical breakdowns.

I used to joke about giving politicians an IQ/Proficiency test when they were going up for office (makes as much sense as looking at their medical and financial records if you ask me). Now, I'm 100% convinced it should be mandated.

Just when I thought my confidence in our politicians couldn't sink much further, I find something that sets the bar even lower.

Wow.

by ganyssa

but I confess to guessing on one or two of the questions that I got right. Still, a reasonable 90.91%

I was wrong about Puritans, apparently cannot steer a country out of recession, and concur with the general malaise regarding question 33, which I apparently did not understand.

by charliespencer

but I haven't found a good concise link yet. I also wonder how elections are scheduled when a vote of no confidence ends a term before it's scheduled time, how a leader is chosen when no candidate or party wins a majority in an election, and why no other democratic country seems to require two years / half a term to choose a new leader.

by jamesrl

Up until the current PM created fixed election dates last term, the Prime Minister could call the election at any time they chose - or in the case of a minority government, when they chose, or if parliament votes against them in a "confidence" bill. The bills that are deemed confidence bills are those that have to do with direct spending of the government in question. Budgets are always confidence bills, for example.

You might think that gives the government a lot of power, and it does. Traditionally an election is called every 4-5 years, and 5 full years is the maximum. Voters tend to punish governments who call early, or minority parties who force an election for no justifiable reason.
This past election, the Conservatives did call it before they had to, and before the period laid out in the legislation they passed. They thought they had conditions for victory. They were only partially successful, they increased their seats but no majority.

The Prime Minister is the leader of the party with the most seats. On rare occasions with minorities, the leaders of the two smaller parties will form a coalition and petition the Governor General (Queen's representative) that they be allowed to form the government. This happened once in my lifetime, in Ontario during the 80s. Generally the party with the most seats is the governing party.

Our party leaders are chosen by party members. Each party has a consitution which dictates how that is done. Most parties have a clause that says if the party loses the election, there will be a confidence motion at the party's next national convention.

The Governor General is pretty much a figurehead, but the PM goes to them to call an election, form a government, and swear in a cabinet. Once in history the GG had to actually make a decision about who should govern.

James

by charliespencer

I wasn't expecting anything from you, just expressing my lack of knowledge. I appreciate your taking the time to put a synopsis together. Thanks.