Discussion Locked

TAX DAY, and 47 percent of all adult Americans pay NO Federal Income Taxes

0 helpful
220 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

220 replies

by santeewelding

What was said in another thread about penal and custodial.

[b]Oz, jck,[/b], even, [b]Tony[/b], announcing shitforbrains.

Surprised you didn't put in an appearance.

by maxwell edison

[i]..... over what was said in another thread about penal and custodial..... Oz, jck, even, Tony, announcing shitforbrains...... Surprised you didn't put in an appearance. [/i]

Never saw it. I have no idea what you're talking about.

P.S. I avoid Oz like the plague he is. I don't read his messages. He's proven unworthy of my time.

by flakeyjake

Actually the way I see it is the fact that lawyers should not be involved in the day to day running of any government in any way whatsoever. My opinion is that the majority of the worlds problems stems to the fact that a lawyer is only out for their-self. Besides, it is easier to be a lawyer than a scientist or engineer, which is in a short supply nowadays.

by maxwell edison

[i]I deprive myself of the current study in anthropology.[/i]

I can live with that.

Have a nice evening. Time for me to sign-off.

by oz_media

While referring to combat operations in Iraq: "I intend to remove all U.S. troops from Iraq by the end of 2011,"

"In his remarks today about the successful completion of Iraq?s second ever national election, President Barack Obama said that there are now less than 100,000 troops in Iraq and he assured the Iraqi people that the United States will fulfill their obligation and have U.S. combat troops out of Iraq by the end of August. Obama said, ?By the end of August, our combat mission will end.?

So he forsees a combat mission ending by August and all troops out of Iraq by the end of 2011.

WWII ended in 1945, yet many nations still have troops in Germany to this day.

by jck

I have vocalized to several representatives, past and present, my advocacy of the death penalty.

But for some reason, we have to pay $1Ms of dollars to keep mass murderers and baby rapers in prison for a lifetime.

by jck

I gave you answers as you requested, yet you gave nothing back other than an insult.

You running for political office yet? You'd fit in well with the not keeping promises thing.

Fact is, you have no comeback for what I said because it's all true.

Conservatives have spent almost $1T between Iraq and Afghanistan in the past several years, and we have NOTHING for it. Gas is higher, terrorism is still spreading, etc.

Yet, you will fault "progressives" (your PC term for socialists) for passing legislation which looks after the medical well-being of our nation.

I'm spot on. America will benefit. It just doesn't seem that way to you, since it doesn't put another dollar in your pocket.

You know, maybe you'd have more retirement money if you bought more gas-efficient vehicles?

Think about that. Maybe this blaming the government is due to a lack of actually evaluating what you're doing wrong too.

I'm not perfect, and neither are you.

by jck

First source - Reuters news report by Missy Ryan of Reuters in Baghdad, Iraq on Wed Nov 5, 2008 3:40pm EST:

[i]Obama opposed the U.S. war in Iraq from the beginning, and his promise to pull combat troops out of the country by mid-2010 was a cornerstone of his campaign.[/i]

That was reported the day after he was elected. So, that's fresh after the campaign trail.

Then, just this on January 28, 2010 from UNI:

[i] Washington, Jan 28 : While renewing his pledge to continue to fight al Qaeda, President Barack Obama has said the United States would withdraw all its troops from Iraq by the end of August, leaving that country to its people.

"As a candidate [last year], I promised that I would end this war, and that is what I am doing as the President," he said in his state of the Union Address last night. [/i]

And in fact, he did not promise a year. He campaigned on 16 months. Even the prime minister of Iraq knew that, as shown in this interview with German site SPEIGEL on July 19, 2008:

[i][b]Iraq Leader Maliki Supports Obama's Withdrawal Plans[/b]

In an interview with SPIEGEL, Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki said Barack Obama's 16 month timeframe for a withdrawal from Iraq is the right one.

Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki supports US presidential candidate Barack Obama's plan to withdraw US troops from Iraq within 16 months. When asked in and interview with SPIEGEL when he thinks US troops should leave Iraq, Maliki responded "as soon as possible, as far as we are concerned." He then continued: "US presidential candidate Barack Obama talks about 16 months. That, we think, would be the right timeframe for a withdrawal, with the possibility of slight changes."[/i]

So, Max. You are the idiot. Get your facts right before you go claiming you know what you're talking about.

Because as far as I can figure, 16 months from January 20th, 2009 would be May 20th, 2010. And, Obama readjusted the deadline to August after negotiations with the Iraqi government on what was agreeable.

You're an idiot. Obama is Ivy League educated.

And, I proved you to be stupid/wrong once again.

Oh BTW, I am a Christian. My God teaches forgiveness, understanding, compassion and love.

Maybe you should go to church more, if you are a Christian too, and get that hate and bitterness out of your heart.

And, my God isn't Barack Obama.

I'm just smart enough to realize just because you've played with money all your life doesn't make you qualified to run something or a born leader.

Have a nice day.

by tonythetiger

... will be just fine. Some of those who try to enter it, though, might not be. It's a simple world with simple rules... Be nice... and you can eat at my table. Be mean... at risk to life and limb.

by jck

[i]MY world...
... will be just fine. Some of those who try to enter it, though, might not be. It's a simple world with simple rules... Be nice... and you can eat at my table. Be mean... at risk to life and limb. [/i]

A) If you're *the* Alpha Male? Sure, you'll be fine.

B) Keep your friends close, and your enemies even closer. Know why? It's the guy who'll agree with you and smile at your face and buddy up to you...who will walk over you when you least expect it.

Given you watch your back all the time and don't trust anyone, you can enforce those rules.

But, don't make the same mistake others make. You can't be all things all the time to everyone and know everything.

Just remember: eventually, even the toughest male lion in the pride gets old and his arse gets kicked.

So, buy lots of machine guns and hand grenades and let the ATF know you're doing it. :^0

by tonythetiger

[i]Just remember: eventually, even the toughest male lion in the pride gets old and his arse gets kicked.[/i]

If they can take it, they deserve it.

[i]So, buy lots of machine guns and hand grenades and let the ATF know you're doing it. [/i]

I'm sure they know something... I DO have to show ID whenever I buy ammunition (which I'm happy to say is more available than it was just a few months ago).

by jck

I'll just say...I hope you didn't buy more than a certain amount.

And as for the alpha male thing:

You don't have to worry about me. I'm not out for anyone else's money.

Go shoot at thieves! :^0

OMG...I need to get my 30-30 out and make sure it's sighted-in so you don't try and come and take my house!!! :-0

by theprofessordan

This is all in the master plan for the bleeding heart socialist in the this country (the politicians formerly known as democrats). They can't get the slugs of the world to work so let's tax the crap out of those that have actually achieved something and worked hard to give it to those that don't want to work, granted there are some that are really trying and not able to achieve. Has anyone ever read Animal Farm? If you haven't, you should.

by ansugisalas

...just how did it happen, that a year of cleaning up the mess it took another guy eight years to make, made that whole thing to be the clean-up guys fault?

Just wondering.

Oh, and you guys' idea of socialist is our idea of a neo-liberal all-out privatizing corporate-owned scumball. Same person, different perspectives. You haven't ever seen socialism at work in the US, and you're never going to see it either.
Not that I'm in favor of socialism, just saying that that's not it. I prefer getting things done in an optimal way, not by way of some dogma or other, so both extremes are out.

by theprofessordan

"that a year of cleaning up the mess it took another guy eight years to make"

Are you kidding me? Yes it was George Bush that approved ridiculous home loans that people couldn't afford to pay after the adjustable mortgage adjusted. And if I recall correctly, Bush's predecessor, Bill Clinton, left a bit of a mess as well. This was a huge reason that Al Gore lost to Bush.

And for the record, I am not bashing Obama. I am not thrilled with ALL U.S. politicians. I do feel that there are things that the government needs to be involved in I just think that the government is starting to overstep their bounds. The reality is that this isn't George Bush's fault or Bill Clinton's fault or even Barack Obama's fault. I like most Americans want the government to back off.

by oz_media

Without extremes the US would come to a screechign halt. Left absolutely MUST oppose anythign right and vice versa. Anything teh left says, he right must say to teh extremme opposite. It reults in nonsense from both sides, a divided nation and no hope of middle, more comfortable and acceptable or sensible ground.
Maybe a few generations into the future, they'll wake up and realize that they have more strength by finding a reaosnable resolution to issues and not opposing for teh mere sake of opposition.

When both the numbers 1 and 10 are equally absurd, they see no number 5.

by oz_media

Was forced reading in grade 5, I remember it too. But you post seems a bit misguided, first it is slugs that wont work, but you recognize others whp are really trying to achieve it. OF course forgetting also that tehre are MILLIONS in America who do work full time and STILL can't afford health insurance because the industry was left to run rampant. There is no hope of an easy way out, as other nations have also found, but most citizens of other nations choose to blame the bums for their laziness, not the government for supporting those who deserve it and merely end up being shafted by those who don't.

All systems are screwed by someone, but it's not the fault of the system which actuallu does a lot of good, it's the fault of the abusers who scam the system.

In other words, I don't blame our government for supporting deserving people just because some people scam the system, my contempt is toward the losers who scam what is a worthy system instead.

Do I mind some of my tax dollars being used to help a fellow Canadian who needs a hand up? nope, not for ome second. I don't even think about it outside of TR. They will still tax me and waste it somewhere else if it wasn't helping others. Even as a working taxpayer, I see HUGE benefits, I pay a mere pittance in medical each month compared to most Americans and our care is just as good, if not better. We do live longer on the whole and I have never been turned down for care, never had to wait for tests or mecial procedures etc.

Then again, I don't live in under a socialist or even a democratic government, maybe that's it. :)

by theprofessordan

I just don't think that the way that this country is going is positive. The U.S. government does have some positive roles and I do appreciate them trying to help but they aren't helping. The reality is that the economy will fix itself if the government stays out of it.

by ansugisalas

Government in debt = his friends get richer by the second.
Obama got saddled with cleaning up the mess AND trying to get to do something else than damage control. But I guess that's worth getting rid of the monkey before it blew up something even more vital than the world economy:p

by ansugisalas

All your candidates are corporate-owned. Some of them just have minds of their own.
Now dubya... he wasn't one of those.
As for Obama, time will tell.
One things for certain though, republicans wailing about the economy are showing severely selective memory.

by jck

http://www.opensecrets.org/pres04/contrib.php?cycle=2004&cid=N00008072

Notice:

Of the 20-some major banks who Bush started the initiative of bailing out before he left...just by eyeballing it.

8 or so are on Bush's list.

4 or so are on Obama's list.

So who was more in bed with banking, Tony?

As far as I can see, most of Obama's top contributors were members of the academic community and the technology industry.

Almost all of Bush's had to do with banking, finance, lending, mortgages, etc.

I'd question Bush's intentions more than Obama's based on that.

by oz_media

7 YouTube clips:
Part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HylCsiH-s88
Part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3CvkhPlqYrc&feature=related
Part3: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E58sxakgqus&feature=related
Part4: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l0Y86_RpUZ8&feature=related
Part 5: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHi9LWKKKwI&feature=related
Part6: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8HKpOk_Et8I&feature=related
Part 7: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wSS0zckyDco&feature=related

Unfortunately the NatGeo Special shot by US soldiers and commanders in Iraq is not on YouTube yet, but if you manage to find the latest National Geographic "Inside Iraq", it's worth a watch, it is very well balanced, both very supportive and very condemning of both sides.

Here's a cip or two:http://channel.nationalgeographic.com/episode/inside-the-iraq-war-4377/Overview#tab-Videos/07540_00
But timelines and truths about propaganda in the US and Iraq are, for once, illustrated very clearly for once.

Watch the Fight for Oil links above, and note the actual time line between when they met in Venuzeual to be told that they could be cut off from their oil there and the US's quick and globally questioned turn to Iraq. Then note that both heads of government appointed by the US in Iraq and Afghanistan were former UNESCO employees. I am not makign accusations but the facts will speak for themselves.

The problem with China, they refuse to get politically involved when looking for oil contractsm they just offer money for product.

The problem with the US, they insist on getting politically involved when looking for oil contracts, they seek to control government in exchange for product. We even see it in Canada when they want to rape our nation of its resources. They will seek out rules that suit their needs, then balk on their half of the bargain. We also trade with China, without such restrictions and the Chinese actually pay their bills.

With China, now being second in NEED to the US, the fight is on and it seems that US money means less and less to the producers.

I am not saying the war is strictly over oil, but the timeline, the political relationships and personal relationships they have, certainly have expedited the issue. And AGAIN, the US just had to enforce political changes in a foreign nation, which was the number one turning point of insurgent violence in Iraq. Removin Saddam was broadly accepted even by his own government, removing the government started WWIII.

Before toppling the government, and after the initial invasion, there was a hope for peace. The change of government, ousting thousands of Shiites, caused so much unrest that it instantly began a civil war in Iraq where as soon as one dies, another two take up arms.

The US wanted it all and actually believed they could have it (I think many still do), resources and money, which requires control of foreign governments.

But we are finding out that beggars cannot also be choosers, well THEY are finding out anyway, the hard way.

by av .

His fabricated justification of the war in Iraq was all about oil and lucrative contracts for his corporate oil buddies. Sure, the Clinton administration talked about regime change in Iraq, but Bush made it happen and it was all a big lie.

Maybe thats why Bush can barely show his face nowadays.

He doesn't deserve all the blame though. Our Democratic Congress at the time, and most are still there, allowed the financial wizards on Wall St. to make all kinds of risky investments that eventually caused the collapse of our economy.

And after that, taxpayers had to bail the "too big to fail" companies out. That was the ultimate kick in the pants to us taxpayers.

Obama got handed the "bag". I think he's doing an admirable job, given what he has to face. I don't agree with everything he did, but our economy didn't collapse.

AV

by jck

was sworn in in January 2007.

The first 6 years of the Bush administration was a Republican majority in both houses, which was when all the rampant lending practice was happening unfettered.

I agree with you tho.

Obama may not be doing a perfect job, but at least we're not all waiting in line for a "chicken in every pot".

by ansugisalas

As far as I've heard they insisted on government stakes in the rescued companies, right?
That means that the bounceback can be pretty lucrative for the US govt economy, in fact, it's the only way to get a fair return on the rescue money. If the economy turns around, then that can make a big difference in the future.
Temporary partial nationalization is just a way (the only one) to get your money back.

by theprofessordan

To think that one man would have the power to do all of that. Wow, I am just shocked. What an evil genius.(if you aren't catching my sarcasm then I am not laying it on thick enough).

We have been round and round about this. Bush didn't do this. Clinton didn't do this. Bush Sr. didn't do this and Obama can't undo this.

by ansugisalas

Bush facilitated it, as did the republican majority.
If you take off the hand-brake of a car parked on a hill, then you can't blame gravity. It's the guys who released the brakes on loaning that caused this.
And yes. Re-regulating can prevent it from happening again, at least in that way.
The economy is fragile because it's synergistic; if something gets skewed all out of shape, then the rest will suffer too, it's a snowball effect. It's not an act of God. It's not Karma. It's just stupidity and trusting in robber-baron-economists like Friedman.

by ansugisalas

Not trying to be snide or butt into a personal argument, but soap-boxing is often experienced as a personal attack by a lot of people, in fact, every person not feeling exactly like you do. Then, if someone has worries, then the perceived attack is quite real, even if it was not your intent. Whether it's collateral damage or friendly fire, either way it's no good being defensive about it.

by tonythetiger

"taking offense". It's in the eye of the beholder, and their choice whether or not to "take offense".

That's not to say that the choice is right or wrong, but absent evidence of specific intent, the onus is on the beholder.

by av .

You paid into it. Thats what its there for.

Maybe you're too proud to do it, and thats your choice. I know you don't like entitlement programs, but you've paid into unemployment for your entire working life. If you need it, its there. Theres no shame if you don't abuse it and its certainly better than killing your retirement fund.

AV

by ansugisalas

...means in a literal reading to "be making an attack". And when soap-boxing, some people are often making wholesale attacks, so they shouldn't be surprised and start whinging when someone acknowledges their existence and intent by taking offense.

by ansugisalas

"Why are you being cranky?"
It was my two year old daughter.
I stopped and thought about it, and no, there was no good reason.
Saved my day, that.

by ansugisalas

Dubya hasn't made history books yet, nor, apparently has the communist regime of... who was it again? JFK? Jimmy Carter? Ronnie McDonald? Enlighten me.

Bush made it a policy even before 9/11 to put the federal government in debt. I guess it was a tribute to that freak Milton Friedman and his theory of "How to put a Gas Chamber in every home"... talk about turning the tables.

by theprofessordan

Presidents get too much credit when things go well and take too much crap when things go bad. Bush made his fair share of mistakes. I will be the first to say that going to Iraq was a mistake. He also allienated the rest of the world and pandered to his buddies when it came to things like drilling the Alaskan pipeline. But this countries issues are a result of bad business practices and people in power at financial institutions encouraging their companies to approve loans that were for lack of a better word bad. I was talking to a girl one day who worked as a hair dresser. Her husband was a construction worker, and not a foreman. They had bought a $250,000 home on an adjustable mortgage. Now unless the young girl was promoted or bought her own hair saloon or something drastically changed with her and her husband's income, when her mortgage company decided to adjust her mortgage rate, more than likely they wouldn't be able to pay their mortgage. This wasn't Bush's or Clinton's fault and to be honest as much as I admire Obama for trying, this is a problem the government can't change.

by ansugisalas

If high-risk loaning is illegal, it tends to happen less.
If interest adjustment is well-regulated, then the kind of marketing of low-interest-soon-to-be-astronomical loans won't happen.
Regulating loan interest manipulation is easy and useful, and no society needs loan-sharks, and if the interest rate is tied to the fed rate, then people have a chance of knowing what they're getting into, and can budget for it.

Bush wanted wholesale deregulation, the republicans wanted wholesale deregulation, Milton Friedman posthumously wanted wholesale deregulation. It's just not wise, it doesn't work, it's a recipe for disaster.
Look at Friedman's track record with Argentina: Before, it was a wealthy stable nation that generated wealth and stability synergistically in it's neighbours as well. After: Not stable. Not wealthy. Negative synergies. Long recovery ahead.
Friedman was misguided in the extreme, and you guys need to shake that off.

by oz_media

I have dug and searched and yet find no legislation was passed that forced banks to lend money, it's as stupid as suggesting people are forced to use Windows.

No one can force a bank to lend any money they don't wish to. The door was opened and they took advantage of it simply because of greed. They all knew it was high risk business, banks know finance (or at least we hope they do), yielding extremely high interest rates, but they also knew the tax payers would ultimately cover the losses.

It had nothing to do with political FORCE, it was financial greed of bank CEO's to seek opportunity, at the tax payers expense.

by jck

They had guidelines for federally backed mortgages. Not those they lended against their own assets.

Then, banks weren't "forced" to falsify the income levels of their applicants to greater amounts as tons of them were shown to have done as well.

They weren't forced to lend to everyone.

Banks in fact, much of the time, pushed loans out to people with reduced incomes who still didn't qualify by falsifying information about the borrower themselves, then selling the loan off quickly to get their money and screw someone else in the process.

So no, Clinton didn't force banks to falsify information.

Nor did Clinton require banks to lend to people who already held 3 other mortgages and whom were flipping houses for profit in a speculative market.

Banks hurt themselves by not sticking to the plan.

However, it is still ironic all those banks were practicing bad/unscrupulous business throughout the Bush administration without the FDIC, FSLIC, Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac looking into the widespread, rampant lending.

Guess even when lending increases over 200% in just one year, there's no possibility of anything wrong happening.

Especially when it is mostly Bush's top campaign donors doing it.

Right?

by tonythetiger

Providing context, Richman said government policy laid the foundation of this crisis more than 30 years ago when Congress passed the Community Reinvestment Act of 1977. This law forced banks to loan money to low-income borrowers as a way to ensure that financial institutions would "meet the credit needs of the local community."

Under the Clinton administration, federal regulators began using the act to combat "red-lining," a practice by which banks loaned money to some communities but not to others, based on economic status. "No loan is exempt, no bank is immune," warned then-Attorney General Janet Reno. "For those who thumb their nose at us, I promise vigorous enforcement."

The Clinton-Reno threat of "vigorous enforcement" pushed banks to make the now infamous loans that many blame for the current meltdown, Richman said. [u]"Banks, in order to not get in trouble with the regulators, had to make loans to people who shouldn't have been getting mortgage loans."[/u]

http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/36048

by oz_media

If ANYTHING, if you don't support the system, at least get your money back.

Not collecting what is rightly yours, that you have paid into (like it or not), is like cutting off your nose to spite your face.

by jck

...you imply the current regime's actions to be bringing "imminent" damage.

However, why don't you talk about the [b]factual[/b] damage that was done previously?

In the past administration, capitalistic business was allowed to profit and run rampant. What has it gotten our society?

Practical economic ruin.

Then, you criticize a similar botton-up system of assistance and improvement for the everyday American that has in our country's past brought us back from the greatest economic oollapse in our country's history.

Perhaps you should teach your son what we should have learned from Teddy Roosevelt when he tried to corral and prevent unfettered capitalism: that greed to hoard the goods and riches of our country to one's self or to a select group does no good to a country of varied peoples.

BTW, I'm not nearly as old as you and have been paying in for over 30 years now. Do you think I have any less stake than you?

by ansugisalas

can choose his words wisely :p
The instigator carries responsibility; the ability of some victims to bear the attack is not in defense of the attacker, and you know that.
Like this: If I hit you, and you shake it off, I'm still guilty of assault. Your good fortune in avoiding injury doesn't count in my defense in regards to the making of the attack. It may shed doubt about the deadly force of my attack and so may lead to a smaller sentence than if you'd been massively unfortunate and died from that tap on the chin, but that's just the way the cookie crumbles.

by oz_media

First of all, I did try not to laugh too hard, I mean "hotair" and "CNN", REEEEEEAAAALLY? That's what you now consider proof? lol :D

Secondly your links don't show, in ANY way, tha the banks were "forced" to offer loans. One link merely illulstrates how someone pulled the race discrimination card to support his validity for a loan, BUT that link does not illustrate how Clinton was responsible in any way shape or form, bot does it support your stand here.

So what you consider factual proof of yoru bizarre comment is merely horsecrap with no relevance to your claims at all. Get real.

by oz_media

Maybe read it a bit slower so that you actually understand what CRA regulation entails. There is no FORCE to offer unqualified applicants loans. They are merely regulated to meet CRA/HDCA criteria for low income or racial minority neighbourhoods. Such practice of blank discrimination, without proper consideration of the applicant's suitability for a loan, is called redlining.

It can also be easily seen as protection from modern day racism.

All the act does, is ensure there is no bold discrimination based solely on area of residence, race etc. The banks were merely urged to adhere to laws pertaining to equality.

It does NOT, in any way, state that banks are forced to offer loans to unqualified applicants.

They were previously blocking ANY loans at all, to ANY applicant in a geographic area (redlining) based solely on the racial or financial demographics of the area instead of based upon the individual's financial qualifications.

An applicant, that does not meet the standard criteria for obtaining a loan, can still be refused that loan without any FORCE placed upon the lending institution.

Your argument is like saying that because a company cannot refuse to hire a person based on their minority race, that employers are thus forced to hire any people of minority race regardless of their qualification for the job they are applying for. LUDICRIS!

Your baseless argument is pure garbage. Unsupported and completely false.

"http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining"

The act was also put into power in 1977, under Carter, not Clinton. Clinton just saw to it that the act was being adhered to.

Or are you suggesting that companies should be allowed to discriminate based solely on regional demographics?

Instead of repeating news bits, that you took well out of context and make you look quite stupid, try looking up legislations and finding out exactly what they were urged to comply with instead.

by nicknielsen

Or the legislation in question does not directly require such loans. You know that's how Oz will argue it, Tony.

The whole thing reminds of Tom Lehrer's intro to his Army song, words to the effect that the Army has not only banned discrimination on the basis of race, color, creed, gender, and national origin, but also on the basis of ability.

by tonythetiger

For example, your CHOICE of the word "instigator", without any evidence of ill-intent, implies someone who has a preconceived notion that everybody is out to get him, and is seeking an excuse to claim some sort of victimhood status, presumably as justification to try to force his views or conditions on another when merely practicing those views hasn't convinced them to see it his way.

by tonythetiger

It was a video from C-SPAN of Mr. Cuomo's own words.

"[u]They would not have qualified[/u] but for this affirmative action on the part of the bank, yes."

It's just like the rest of the leech mentality. "I have the right to take whatever risk I want (whether risk to health or risk to financial stability) and force everyone else to pay the consequences."

And no, it has nothing to do with race. There were ten times as many loans given to white people who normally would not have qualified, and there is no statistical anomaly in the racial makeup of those foreclosed on. Just more tripe from those who can't get ahead even when given a crutch, so they have to blame someone else for their failure.

by tonythetiger

It's just like there was no legislation requiring a national 55 MPH speed limit in the 70s either. But the feds told the states if they didn't change their law, they would find great difficulty in obtaining federal highway grants for their states.

It's the strong asserting its will on the less strong, and many are fine with it... so long as it's not their ox being gored, and sometimes they're OK with it even then... content to kiss the ass of whoever is in charge :)

by nicknielsen

From the flow of posts, it appears Tony was thinking I was you.

I'm not going to complain about that. B-)

by av .

This is pretty lucrative for the taxpayers

http://www.buffalonews.com/2010/03/30/1003596/governments-sale-of-citi-stock.html

But there's still the 800 lb. Gorilla in the room

http://www.businessweek.com/news/2010-04-22/u-s-said-to-weigh-aig-exit-through-two-years-of-share-sales.html

You don't always get your money back from government backing. If we can offset some of the "too big to fail" losses in any way, that would be the best we can expect.

I think the Dems are doing a good job with managing the bailouts, but really, the debt will be paid by future generations.

AV

by oz_media

There was a regiulation set in place in 1964, that regulation was updated by Carter in 1977 to focus on banks that were redlining neighbourhoods, literally drawing a boundary where they will not offer loands based on demographic survey's. However that law had been all but been ignored, Clinton said that he was going to make sure that banks were adhering to the standards set out that say banks canot redline a neighbourhood.

For THAT, you come up with saying the banks were FORCED to hand out loans to people who were otherwise unqualified for a loan.

Of course that was plastered all over the right wing media and was taken out of context to the point that people now parrot teh media without actually investigating what regulations the banks were told to adhere to. Absolute BS!

They were just told they couldn't redline and thus be refusing loans to otherwise qualified applicants and that such loans were protected by Fanny Mae and Feddie Mac.

It had nothing to do with being forced to offer shady loans at all, in fact it didn't even HINT at such. The banks which are just fat pockets out for more money, took advantage of the promise of recovery and offered loans ON THEIR OWN TERMS to unqualified applicants, that was 100% THEIR CHOICE, not force of any sort.

Just try looking for facts with support instead of news headlines and party propaganda.

by tonythetiger

up your ass, but that won't make it any less painful if someone decides to search for one.

The very compliance with the investigations, whether or not anything was found, would lose the bank money.

It's roughly equivalent to a cop pulling you over and saying "If you don't donate to the policeman's fund, I'm going to pull you over and run your license every time I see you driving. I might not find anything, but it's going to be awfully inconvenient."

I truly find it hard to believe that the worldly Oz is that naive to not understand that.

by ansugisalas

If you pick on kids with bigfisted dads, don't whine about taking a beating. :p
Anyway, I was just trying to enlighten max about how his cute little agitprop blew up in his face, and how he could prevent that kind of backlash in the future.

by oz_media

There's nothing I will say that I would expect to change your choice to buy into slanted media, it's how you've always lived your lives and always will. You are Americans and, without attempting to downplay that, it is a well known world fact that Americans love to live their politics their hard stance and their media.

BUT...all you'd have to do to look into what regulations they were told ot adhere to, is look up those very regulations and see exactly how they don't FORCE bbad loans, they FORCE banks to consider each and every application as individual, without using regional demographics to close all possibilties for worthy applicants. If they make loans that are bad, it's not their problem because FMFM had agreed to insure them against their financial losses. IN otehr words, choose who you want to make loans for, don't worry about the demographics and just use your own discretion. Of COURSE the banks jumped on the opportunity, it made them money and banks seek money. Of COURSE banks knew very well taht they were lending money to people they shouldn't, they had a choice not to, but they did of course to make money, again, that's what banks do.

Don't for one second fool yourself into believing that they were forced to offer loans to unqualified applicants. If they were guaranteed loan insurance before, they would have done so 10 years earlier. Being reassured they could make as much money as they wanted, without risk, just made it a sure thing for them. Banks are in the loan business for one reason and one reason only, to make money. the more they lend, the more they make. Of course they initially protected themselves against bad loans, who wouldn't? Of course they took advantage of the fact they were backed regardless, who wouldn't?

'Hey, it's not our fault, we used to block those people from getting loans, but now we have to accept their applications. We are protected no matter what happens.'

It doesn't mean they have to give them loans though. Choice, not Force.

by jck

courtesy of the IRS:

http://www.irs.gov/compliance/enforcement/article/0,,id=213770,00.html

Most have to do with rampant bank and mortgage fraud.

There's thousands of examples of this.

So, where was:

Freddie Mac?
Fannie Mae?
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation?
Securities and Exchange Commission? (where the mortgages became "bundled" and a commodity they allowed traded on their markets)
HUD?
FBI?

Anyone?

Plain and simple: The past administration did not make it a point to make or rigorously enforce banking and lending regulation.

Like I said, don't think it could have to do with who were the majority of the Bush campaign's top financial backers? Could it?

by jck

At the time of the housing market collapse (about 3 years ago), Clinton hadn't been in office for about...6 or 7 years?

How would he and Reno enforce squat?

And if those people could not have paid their mortgages, they would have been foreclosed on much earlier than 2007.

The housing collapse had to do banks rampantly lending money to ANYONE (not just low income) and not assuring there were sufficient means and that debt/credit wasn't already too high for even people with money.

Trust me, Tony. I watched my neighborhood get filled with houses in 4 years.

Then, I have seen it fold because of them letting all the spec builders come in and fill the lots and build crackerbox houses because they were selling so quick.

Banks were out for sheer profit, and because of their unfettered and irresponsible lending (and the government's lax oversight), we have the situation we do today.

by tonythetiger

The LAWS don't force... but those charged with upholding the law often DO.

The law, for example, does not say that the federal government can force a state to change the level at which a driver is considered drunk, but the federal government threatened states with loss of federal highway money if they didn't change their laws to reflect the new level.

by tonythetiger

[i]At the time of the housing market collapse (about 3 years ago), Clinton hadn't been in office for about...6 or 7 years?[/i]

the ORIGINATION date on those loan papers :)

(I'm just glad I decided to deal in cash... a bird in the hand...)

by oz_media

of how force is used on drinking and driving law enforcement.

Now, how EXACTLY, regarding the CRA/HCDA, does your argument apply? What in those specific documents, which they were told ot adhere to, "forces them" to make bad loans?

You can even pick out one specific srticle in the act itself if you like, I know from reading it that no such FORCE was ever imparted beyond adherring to regional profiling limitations. Yourself, I assume that you will NEVER have the patience to read such facts' you have always illustrated the "he said she said" game instead of researching the facts, as most others here do too.

As Nick commented: [i]Or the legislation in question does not directly require such loans. You know that's how Oz will argue it, Tony[/i]

Well seeing as that is EXACTLY your debate, of COURSE that is what I will reply with. You say they ARE forcing banks into bad loans. I am saying they are forcing banks to adhere to a regulation, that does NOT "force" then into making bad loans, it just restricts demographic profiling as a means of qualification.

Housing ReDevelopment Act of 1974, clearly states, right in its opening article"

"[i]No person in the United States shall on the ground of race, color,
national origin, religion, or sex be excluded from participation in, be
denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any
program or activity[/i]

Banks were told that they can not redline, therefore they were told they had to adhere to CRA regulations that restrict such practices, it does NOT force them to make bad loans. It forces them to accept all applications for proper consideration without restricting them solely by area of residence.
The banks just use it as a scapegoat for knowingly offering bad loans to unqualified applicants. FM & FM couldn't afford to back all the bad loans they were supposed to and the government assured them they would be covered in such a case (which I agree is an oversight on the part of government, not recognizing the banks would see it as a way to make money by offering sketchy loans). The banks had a field day making money by offering what they KNEW were bad loans that they didn't have to back themselves. They then blamed the shortfall of insurance payouts on FM&FM and, when they were asked why they had issued the bad loans, they said they were forced to do it, which they clearly were not.

The banks are the real crooks here.

What is redlining anyway(predatory lending)?

[i]Redlining is the practice of denying, or increasing the cost of, services such as banking, insurance, access to jobs, access to health care, or even supermarkets to residents in certain, often racially determined,areas. The term "redlining" was coined in the late 1960s by John McKnight, a Northwestern University sociologist and community activist.It describes the practice of marking a red line on a map to delineate the area where banks would not invest; later the term was applied to discrimination against a particular group of people (usually by race or sex) no matter the geography. During the heyday of redlining, the areas most frequently discriminated against were black inner city neighborhoods. Through at least the 1990s this practice meant that banks would often lend to lower income whites but not to middle or upper income blacks.[/i]

So they took a lengthy set of regulations they know had to be dug for and would never be read by most people, abbreviated it to mean what it didn't and used THAT, through the magic of headline grabbing media, to pass the blame to someone else.

A white paper on the practice of redlining dating back to 2004, that also ilustrates that banks would not lend to such people due them being less likely to have Private Mortgage Insurance, regardless of who they were and based solely on the region.

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6WMG-4B22X9V-1&_user=10&_coverDate=03%2F31%2F2004&_rdoc=1&_fmt=high&_orig=search&_sort=d&_docanchor=&view=c&_searchStrId=1308096124&_rerunOrigin=google&_acct=C000050221&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=10&md5=ae01f63e37bbbb1ce0a07266c0ba31a4

Of course your instant, knee jerk defence said that it wasnt racially based, which I never said was the case to begin with, but that racism was the common result of demographic profiling.

They were merely 'forced' to adhere to a regulation that restricted them from profiling which was most often seen as racial profiling. The regulation had been around for years, yet ignored, Carter just said he would see that the practice of redlining stopped and that he would force banks to adhere to laws, just as anyone should be.

About the CRA:
http://www.ffiec.gov/cra/

by nicknielsen

None of us is truly objective, Oz. Our world-views are based on our experiences, the core beliefs we have picked up through our lives, and our current situations. Whose definition of "slanted" are we using? Yours? Mine? Tony's?

Many Europeans of my acquaintance consider [u]all[/u] American media to be excessively conservative. Many Americans consider the media to be too liberal and Europeans to be Socialsts.

It all comes down to opinions, Oz, and in this case, the opinions of a non-resident non-citizen are as meaningless as .

by theprofessordan

I prescribe to the notion of KISS (keep it simple stupid). What is the biggest problem that this country is facing right now. Fiancial institutions are going belly up. We have seen a record number of banks close recently. Why is this happening? Because of things like adjustable and no-interest mortgages. We in this country want more than we can pay for and because of banks and financial institutions giving us the rope, we have hung ourselves. Regardless of what Bush and the Republicans wanted in regards to deregulation, Americans have done this to ourselves.

Now here is what REALLY scares me. If you study the great depression, one positive outcome of the great depression is that people that lived through the great depression died with a lot of money because what they went through taught them to save and to make sacrifices. In this current situation, we aren't reacting the same way. We are looking for bailouts and someone to force the mortgage companies to help people stay in their homes. I am not saying that it is a good thing for people to lose their homes, but sometimes in life you have to make changes and the government's approach is not a positive one that is going to lead us out. And to be honest, this conversation started talking about Socialism and that is where I am aggravated with. The economy will fix itself one way or another. All the government is doing is using this to take more power, which is the wrong thing to help.

by oz_media

We are discussing how banks were FORCED to adhere to an existing Act.

That act is NOT a matter or personal, political interpretation at all, look it up and read the bloody thing for yourself, instead of being lazy and going on with your completely irrelevant commentary.

Adhereing to The Community Reinvestment Act (1977) is directly considering the Housing and Community Development Act (1974).

A Federal Gpvernment Overview is offered here for the reading impaired.
http://www.federalreserve.gov/dcca/cra/

Which also clearly states: [i]"Neither the CRA nor its implementing regulation gives specific criteria for rating the performance of depository institutions. Rather, the law indicates that the evaluation process should accommodate an institution's individual circumstances. Nor does the law require institutions to make high-risk loans that jeopardize their safety. To the contrary, the law makes it clear that an institution's CRA activities should be undertaken in a safe and sound manner.:[/i]

You guys just can't be bothered to investigate and just go with what the media spews at you. If you are left you buy the left's spew, if yuo are on th eright you believe what the right spews at you. It's 100% pure political bias.

As I don't believe EITHER side without fact finding and reading the Acts and refulations put in place, I am definitely seeking the reality and not the media spin, I have nothing to gain or lose either way. Being from OUTSUDE and not having a political agenda actually makes me able to look for facts without bias. The absolute extreme opposite of what you 'claim'.

by puppybreath

being forced to follow CRA guidelines wasn't the issue. CRA was used as a reason for bogus lawsuits or the threat of lawsuits against certain banks.

In these lawsuits and threats, ACORN and other "community organizers" made bogus claims of Redlining (denying poor people loans because of their ethnic heritage). They protested and got the local media to support their "cause". This meant that the banks faced thousands of misinformed people closing their accounts. Local and Federal politicians also started to lobby to stop the banks from doing some future business, expansions and mergers.

If the bank had gone to court, they would have won, but the damage would have already been done to the bank?s reputation and any expansion plans would have been shelved for years costing them millions.

The banks handled it like so many other frivilous and nuisance lawsuits: they settled out of court because it was cheaper than fighting it. In these cases, it was easier and cheaper to give loans that they knew would never be repaid rather than go through the lengthy legal process.

So, they weren't technically "forced" to give the loans, but it was in their best interest long term to do so.

by oz_media

Okay th edo nothign approach. Sit on the hands and hope for the best. Unforunately, that doesn't look so good on the world stage and wouldn't fare too well for America in teh long run.

by tonythetiger

[i]Unforunately, that doesn't look so good on the world stage[/i]

Who is actually trying that that you can say it isn't working?

What country's government is "staying out of it"?

by oz_media

The US is a major importer countries worlwide. The US economy directly reflects on teh economy of others who [i]currently [/i]rely on US dollars for their goods. When the dollar goes down, other nations prices go up and THEIR economy is harmed too.

In one sense, it is GREAT that the US dollar is on par with the Canadian dollar right now, in 30 minutes I can hop across the line and buy cheao gas, smokes, booze etc. (yes gas is cheaper where we sell it than where we drill it).

But our gasoline costs are balanced by the amount of gas sold into the US, when the US dollar is stronger than ours, our oil companies make more money and our gas prices come down(example: when $1.00 US = $1.20 Canadian).

Since the dollar neared and now JUST slightly exceeded the US dollar, our gas prices have proprtionately crept back up. Today, gas was $1.14/L which is $4.29 Canadian per gallon (again now on par with the US dollar).

I can hit Point Roberts, WA in a half hour and fill up for 2.79 a gallon, once again, dollars at par.

So if all other nations who were hit by the economic downturn are making efforts and offering massive bailouts at the taxpayers expense, it would case a lot of dissent towarsd the US if there was nothing being done.

It's a pretty damn simple concept that doesn't need to be tested to be realized.

by oz_media

someone gets it, well done, puppybreath. Tony said Clinton "forced" banks to offer loans to people who couldn't pay it back. I corrected that by saying Clinton merely "forced" adherence to the CRA.

They were only forced to abide by fair practices and consider each application as valid, without redlining. I never argued the validity of the applications or lawsuits resulting from redlining; of course the race card was played many times. But that's also because there WERE people who should have qualified but weren't even allowed to apply due to demographic profiling.

ie: "If you live there, you must be a risk, we won't even consider your application."

In many cases I am sure they were right in refusing such loans, and in others they were not. So they were merely told to adhere to guidelines and use their OWN discretion on a per applicant basis to qualify loans. Don't discriminate regionally based on financial demographics.

Of course the thing that made it easier was that they were told FM&FM would cover any losses, which the banks instantly took advantage of and abused by offering loans to anyone and then saying they were forced to do so.

The result though, and as you have attested yourself, Tony's claim that Clinton "forced" banks to loan money to people who were unable to repay loans is completely and entirely FAlSE. In fact they were told to follow a set of guidelines that specifically stated how the banks should [i]use their normal cautions[/i] to offering loans, just as they would anyone else.

It is 100% the bank's fault, and of course the promise of FM&FM to not forsee the inadequate resulting actions of the banks that they could not insure.

Nobody was FORCED to do anything, except technically FM&FM who were then under contract to cover delinquent loans.

They (FM&FM) could have had forsight to ask for more specific criteria to QUALIFY the loans in the first place, beyond stopping simple redlining which could step on people's rights.[i](of course that would mean the government stepping in and actually controlling hwo got loans though, in which case Tony could have actually been correct, but that wasn't the case)[/i] By making it the bank's responsibility, then removing any financial responsibility and repercussions by offering to cover them; they ultimately gave the banks a free ride into haplessly lending money. They should have foresaw the bank's greed and assumed they would not act accordingly.

Either way you slice it, Clinton never forced banks to loan money to anyone, that's pure BS.

Tony's comment that started this entire segue:
[b][i]"Does Clinton forcing them to loan money to people who couldn't afford to pay it back count? "[/i][/b]
Posted: 04/21/2010 @ 03:13 PM (PDT)

To answer that one more time; No, it doesn't count because it never happened.

It's really no different than a parent telling a bank that if they loan his kid money, the parent will cover it (a cosigner of sorts), except with a LOT of delinquent kids to cover.

by tonythetiger

Where were you when Clinton threatened the banks into making the risky loans.

Ostensibly, Clinton was trying to get more money into low income neighborhoods... by threatening "redlining" investigations... but an unintended consequence was that once the banks lowered standards for inner-city applicants, they couldn't very well turn away poor applicants from rural areas without clearly violation of equal opportunity housing laws. The banks were stuck between a rock and a hard place, and begged Fannie and Freddie to lower the requirements on the mortgages they were willing to purchase. That was in 1999, over a year before Bush took office.

In 2003 Bush recommended putting Fannie under the supervision of the Treasury Department, to set reserve requirements and to ensure that the agency was properly managing its risk, but that was opposed by the Democratic controlled Congress...

From http://www.nytimes.com/2003/09/11/business/new-agency-proposed-to-oversee-freddie-mac-and-fannie-mae.html?pagewanted=all

[i]"These two entities -- Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac -- are not facing any kind of financial crisis,'' said Representative Barney Frank of Massachusetts, the ranking Democrat on the Financial Services Committee. "The more people exaggerate these problems, the more pressure there is on these companies, the less we will see in terms of affordable housing."[/i]

I guess the Republicans weren't exaggerating after all, were they?

by oz_media

I was on Earth, don't know what planet you or your Clinton were living on. By the way, we are talking about Bill Clinton, the president who was impeached for getting a BJ and saying he didn't.

Please, post links to the exact terms that he forced the banks to adhere to (as I have also done).
As he forced them to adhere to CRA regulations, you would need to post the exact verbage from that regulation that proves your invalid point, not just some hogwash a the media or some right wing weblog came up with.

Man, how can you possibly expect to be taken seriously when yoru support comes in the form of online blogs and BS from the media?

Don't you know by now that you can't trust them but you can look up and qualify their sources for yourself in order to find the truth?

Don't let them summarize and take out of context exactly what was said in an act, read the act for yourself.

That's why these things run politically rampant, people are just too lazy to do their own homework and they settle for whatever their preferred media outlet tells them.

I KNOW as a fact that you won't go through it, you never do, so any further commentary and posturing on your part is purely, unqualified political bias.

by tonythetiger

You can choose to claim that they meant other than what they said, but that's entirely YOUR chosen ignorance.

Good luck with that, really.

by ansugisalas

So, they were being *forced* to issue large amounts of subprime credit, with time-delay skyrocket rates, and package them into "derivatives" to be sold like crack-cocaine high and wide?!?
The derivatives are what cracked open the economy... the loans in and of themselves and the fannie and mac crap would just have been business as usual, snafu if you will.
This was beyond snafu, and that all happened under Bush, and during the republican controlled house.
Bush probably just tried to undercut Fannie Mae back then to drop some poor people out of the voting registries.

by santeewelding

I would prefer to see you exercise your analytical and linguistic prowess on something other than partitioning a platter of shilt.

Leave it to the scatologists here.

by oz_media

You will soon learn that Tony gets the most warped ideas from little snippets he is able to read. However he never looks into what is actually being said, in this case what he was forcing them to abide by. As a result he parrots US media and even when unquestionably proven wrong, he will argue until you finally give up.

In the many years I have proven such things completely out of context, he has ceded, even after being shown the proof in White House Transcripts etc., perhaps twice. His usual effort is to simply ignore the facts and just carry repeating nonsense in another part of the thread, hoping to convince someone that he knows what he is on about.

He's not stupid by any means, he just has an issue with reading and researching facts. He make up his mind based on what he hears on the news, taken comletely out of context or not. When offered in complete context, he simply refuses to acknowledge it.

It's sad and often rather pointless to debate beyond that point.

by tonythetiger

Reno didn't tell them TO violate the CRA. She told them that if more loans weren't made in these areas, she would see to it that every one of the applications was vigorously investigated. I can't imagine that you couldn't imagine what the banks would do to stave off these investigations. It seems that you are being intentionally obtuse.

by oz_media

This one certaionly isn't working out for you.

You made a firm statement that I questioned, you then argued it with mroe firm statements. When I prove those statements false, now I am being literal. Well if we are not supposed to be literal, why do we even bother with such discussions? You even went as far as to post links to media spins in order to try and prove your point.

Whether you feel it was Reno, Clinton, Obama or even Lincoln, makes no difference at all. They were NOT, at any time, never once, not at all, not now, not then, not before, EVER forced to offer loans to unqualified applicant, N.E.V.E.R.

Just did not happen, okay? You have absolutely no recourse, no possibility of correcting your false claim, no hint of truth in your links, no nothing. Your assertion is incorrect, no matter how you try to twist and turn to make it what it wasn't. Give up and move on with your life.

by oz_media

Clinton FORCED banks to abide by CRA regulations. That is a FACT.

But...those regulations do not force banks to make loans to unqualified applicants, THAT is also a fact.

Thus your use of the qoute out of context and ASSUMING yuo knew what that force was, is simply "YOUR chosen ignorance."

by santeewelding

Find consolation in that you did -- at length and in detail, as I see it -- successfully delineate and separate the hows and the whys of redlining, vis a vis "government", the banks, and the sub-primers.

May it please you to know, further, I have read every word here that you have written about the matter. I am also old enough to have lived through the times and to have paid attention. I still do.

If that is what you mean by my "fetish" about shilt, then, so be it.