Discussion Locked

Teacher claims spyware mader her show porn to 7th grade class, facing jail

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

read this interesting article on computerworld. A 7th grade teacher claims spyware pulled up porn sites while she was showing a website to her class. She's facing 40 years.

There's some good arguments

for her: including judge falling asleep during trial, school has no filtering software, NO ONE checked the seized PC for spyware or adware;

against her: why didn't she simply shut off screen and PC and tell her IT dept?

http://www.computerworld.com/blogs/node/4346

16 replies

by tonythetiger

the teacher, not being an IT person, not immediately turning off the computer.

What's the first thing you should do if a pan of food catches fire on the stove?

What's the first thing most people do?

by dr dij

When the teacher told me of the link-rot on my page, I browsed to it to be sure. It wasn't someone stark naked, doing it; instead someone in a photo you'd see anywhere, middle aged, kind of cute gal, in normal setting of normal room with lots of normal stuff around except she was smiling and topless. Like maybe my gal friend will occasionally be, at home.

Ok, I admit, as a guy, my first impulse was to keep looking :)

Does seem odd that penalty is so harsh for seeing the natural human body. View porn (possibly by accident) and get 40 years. Kill someone and get 7, 5 after early release for overcrowding or good behavior.

And it does sound like the judge in this case had made up her mind. Tho it was likely a jury trial? The judge still has leeway to determine intent I'd think, and maybe figure out the person was startled... I'll bet this one gets appealed.

by charliespencer

I've often wondered why movies featuring people having sex are considered less acceptable than movies with people doing extreme physical harm to one another. I especially wonder about the hypocrisy of these attitudes in a supposedly Judeo-Christian country like the U.S. Would you rather your kid got caught having sex at the drive-in, or going from car to car with a chain saw?

by pc-guru

its very possible that it was spyware or an AD popup but damn what website you would show a class would do that? unless the teacher was looking at porn another time
and got a spyware infection...

by nicknielsen

This happened to me in my classroom. I clicked on a link on an auto electronics page (we were designing the ultimate car audio/video system as a senior project) and BAM. There she was in all her naked glory, and she was just so excited to be there, she wanted us to see all her friends, too. My all-male class's reaction, of course, was "Cool!"

My immediate reaction was [u]not[/u] to kill the monitor, but to try to kill the process[es]. My second reaction was to disconnect the network cable. Then I thought to kill the monitor. To add insult to injury, the principal walked through the classroom door just as I clicked the link.

As I was able to reproduce the results on his PC after school, he was very understanding. I also don't think any kind of blocking or filtering would have stopped it. At the time, the school district was using full internet filtering, including domain blocking and heuristic filters.

As for the alleged computer crime investigator's claim that [i]"You have to physically click on it to get to those sites,"[/i] that's one truly ignorant investigator. I can probably write a script (or find one on the web) that will run on page load and visit any site you want without the user ever clicking on a single link. And I'm a hardware guy.

by the ref

I once wanted to search for either "code analyzers" or "code analysis". Being Australian we spell it "code analysers", so I thought about the search and typed in "code anal".

Gave myself a really unpleasant surprise!

by slappymcnasty

is the name of matchbox car from the early 70s that I collect.
One day while sitting at my desk working on a SQL Server install, I typed the search term into google on my desktop and clicked what I thought was a good link. While the site was coming up, I turned back to the server to do more stuff. 5 minutes maybe 10 minutes later I turn back to my PC to see the screen displaying a close up of a specific female orifice.
My knowledge from 15 years of using PCs flew from my head, I couldn't remember how to close a window with a mouse or a keyboard. in a panic I simply pulled the plug on the CPU.

At other times in my career I have mistyped URLs at work at went to politically incorrect places. marshallfieldS.com was an online store marshallfield.com was not. More recently at home I mistyped drudgereport.com and started getting slaughtered with pop ups (I had forgot to turn my firewall back on).

If I was on the jury, I would tell these stories.

by nicknielsen

used to be a porn site. I've always wondered how many people wishing to visit the President's official web site (whitehouse.gov) typed in the wrong URL and got sidetracked...

by deepsand

PC World: Technology Advice You Can Trust

Teacher Faces Prison for Pop-Up Infested PC
Crazy, but true: Woman convicted of exposing minors to porn, could serve 40 years.
Steve Bass
Wednesday, February 07, 2007 12:00 AM PST

Have you ever faced a pop-up that wouldn't go away? You try clicking it closed and another pops up in less than a nanosecond. You reboot the system, annoyed that your anti-spyware program let something slip through.

That's a hassle, sure--but chances are, your experience won't land you in jail.
A Teacher's Worst Nightmare

Julie Amero, a substitute teacher in Norwich, Connecticut, has been convicted of impairing the morals of a child and risking injury to a minor by exposing as many as ten seventh-grade students to porn sites.

It's a short story: On October, 19, 2004, Amero was a substitute teacher for a seventh-grade language class at Kelly Middle School. A few students were crowded around a PC; some were giggling. She investigated and saw the kids looking at a barrage of graphic, hard-core pornographic pop-ups.

The prosecution contended that she had used the computer to visit porn sites.

The defense said that wasn't true and argued that the machine was infested with spyware and malware, and that opening the browser caused the computer to go into an endless loop of pop-ups leading to porn sites.

Amero maintains her innocence. She refused offers of a plea bargain and now faces an astounding 40 years in prison (her sentencing is on March 2).
Just the Facts

I'll admit all my don't haves right away: I don't have access to court records; I don't have first-hand evidence of what occurred; and I haven't examined the computer's hard drive myself.

What I do have is a working knowledge of spyware and plenty of experience cleaning infected PCs.

I also have a copy of the report written by computer forensic specialist W. Herbert Horner, the expert witness who testified in Amero's defense. You can read it, too; it's on the NetQos site.
Proof, Speculation, and a Not-Very-Good Defense

Horner made an image of the computer's hard drive. He saw that there was no firewall and that the antivirus program was outdated. He also found 42 active "spyware/adware tracking cookie/programs." Most important, Horner said that 27 of the spyware apps were accessed before Amero had access to the computer.

To me, the implication is clear that Amero hadn't used the PC for browse for porn, as the prosecution claimed.

The defense wanted Horner to have Internet access at the trial in order to re-create what happened to Amero in the classroom. The prosecution objected, claiming they hadn't had ?full disclosure? of Horner's examination.

In my opinion, had the defense attorney been on his toes, and had the jury seen the demonstration, Amero would have been found innocent.
Guilty: The School or the Teacher?

The question is, Who should be held responsible? After reading articles in the Norwich Bulletin, the area's local newspaper, and a chat with someone familiar with the case, I've come to some conclusions. (And if you've ever helped a computer novice deal with a PC loaded with spyware, I think you know who I'm siding with.)

First, it would be a good idea to take a look at newspaper articles covering the trial. Read the January 5, 2007 article, the next on January 7, and the January 11 editorial supporting the conviction.

Now, back to our story. To begin with, the prosecutor pointed his finger at Amero because she didn't turn off the computer right away.

If I faced the same situation, I'd probably panic, just as Amero did--shield the kids from seeing the monitor and move them away from the computer. Then I'd reach over to an unfamiliar system, fumble around looking for the Off switch, and turn off the monitor, or computer, or both.

I imagine Amero was also flustered because she was told by the class's regular teacher, quite adamantly, not to turn off the computer. That's a lame excuse, I agree, because questioning authority is sometimes the right thing to do.

But I've learned from my source that Amero is a rank novice. About the most she can do is check e-mail on AOL using her husband's home computer. That says lots, no?

For instance, when faced with the classroom PC's pop-ups, her reaction was to click the red "x" in the corner of each box--which, as anyone who's faced spyware knows, often results in another pop-up.

More important, though, if the school had done its part in protecting its students, it would have up-to-date anti-spyware and antivirus programs installed on every PC.

On January 24 the Norwich Bulletin reported that the school district's technology administrator, Information Services Director Bob Hartz, said, "from August to October 2004, the district's filtering system didn't regularly add newly discovered pornographic sites to its restricted Web sites database." Oddly enough, they upgraded the software just after Amero's incident.

In my opinion, Amero is the victim here.

The blogsphere has been following the story carefully, though the mainstream media hasn't picked it up yet. My guess is when it does, the bits will hit the fan.
Malware: How It Happens

Have you ever clicked on a browser message that looks legit and offers to, say, block spam or remove spyware? According to Sunbelt Software's spyware expert Alex Eckelberry, if you click on an innocent looking dialog, you could inadvertently install malware on your machine and end up with a PC that's infested with annoying pop-up ads that appear whenever you open your browser. Watch this YouTube video to see exactly how it happens.

To protect yourself from spyware, you need protection and advice--like you can get from PC World's Spyware & Security Info Center. But you may just want to cut to the chase. In that case, read "Spyware Fighters," "Disarm Net Threats," and "First Look: SiteAdvisor Plus vs. Norton Confidential."
Steve Bass writes PC World's monthly "Hassle-Free PC" column and is the author of PC Annoyances, 2nd Edition: How to Fix the Most Annoying Things About Your Personal Computer, available from O'Reilly. He also writes PC World's daily Tips & Tweaks blog. Sign up to have Steve's newsletter e-mailed to you each week. Comments or questions? Send Steve e-mail.

by deepsand

[b]WARNING: DO NOT CLICK on any LINKS contained within this report, unless you know what you are doing![/b]

The Strange Case of Ms. Julie Amero: Commentary by Mr. Herb Horner

W. Herbert Horner has worked in computers since 1966. He was Systems Software Engineer for General Dynamics, Operating Systems Internalist for Sperry Univac, and he has diagnosed and corrected mainframe operating systems for the U.S. Armed Forces, NSA, IRS, and various commercial interests.

He now operates his own consulting firm, Contemporary Computer Consultants, writes custom software for medical, municipal, business, and forensic applications. He also does network design, implementation, and administration. He also is a computer forensic examiner who was called as a defense expert witness in the Julie Amero case.

In an effort to dispel rumor and produce a more accurate understanding of the Amero case in the public, we have offered him a chance to offer his commentary. Tomorrow we hope to have commentary from Detective Mark Lounsbury, who testified for the prosecution at Ms. Amero's trial.
The Forensic Examination of the computer assigned to Julie Amero

We obtained a copy of the PC hard drive from Officer Lounsbury who was most cooperative and at our office we created several copies, preserving the original.

During the copy process we received several "Security Alerts!" from our antivirus program. We analyzed the activity log and noted that there were spyware/adware programs installed on the hard drive. We ran two other adware/spyware detection programs and more spyware/adware tracking cookie/programs were discovered. Out of the 42, 27 were accessed or modified days if not a month before October 19, 2004. We also noted that there was no firewall and there was an outdated antivirus program on the PC. The PC was being tracked before October 19, 2004 by adware and spyware.

(Continued...)

We examined all internet related folders and files before October 19, 2004, during October 19, 2004 and after October 19, 2004. Most significantly, we noted freeze.com, screensaver.com, eharmony.com and zedo.com were being accessed regularly.

On October 19, 2004, around 8:00 A.M., Mr. Napp, the class' regular teacher logged on to the PC because Julie Amero being a substitute teacher did not have her own id and password. It makes sense that Mr. Napp told Julie not to logoff or shut the computer off, for if she did she and the students would not have access to the computer. The initial user continued use of the PC and accessed Tickle.com, cookie.monster.com, addynamics.com, and adrevolver.com all between 8:06:14 - 8:08:03 AM. During the next few moments Julie retrieved her email through AOL.

http://www.hair-styles.org was accessed at 8:14:24 A.M., based upon the hair style images uploaded to the PC we were led to believe that there were students using the computer to search out hair styles. The user went to http://www.crayola.com at 8:35:27 A.M. The user continued accessing the original hair site and was directed to http://new-hair-styles.com. This site had pornographic links, pop-ups were then initiated by http://pagead2.googlesyndication.com. There were additional pop-ups by realmedia.com, cnentrport.net, and by 9:20:00 A.M., several java, aspx's and html scripts were uploaded. A click on the curlyhairstyles.htm icon on the http://www.new-hair-styles.com site led to the execution of the curlyhairstyle script along with others that contained pornographic links and pop-ups. Once the aforementioned started, it would be very difficult even for an experienced user to extricate themselves from this situation of porn pop-ups and loops.

All of the jpg's that we looked at in the internet cache folders were of the 5, 6 and 15 kB size, very small images indeed. Normally, when a person goes to a pornographic website they are interested in the larger pictures of greater resolution and those jpgs would be at least 35 kB and larger. We found no evidence of where this kind of surfing was exercised on October 19, 2004.
Testimony and Trial

We asked the prosecution to arrange for the defense to have unfettered access to the internet so that we could reenact the events of October 19, 2004. It was not granted. I went to court with two laptops and a box full of reference material prepared to very clearly illustrate what happened to Julie Amero. But, the prosecution objected because they were not given "full disclosure" of my examination. I was allowed to illustrate two screens, that of the www.hair-styles.org , and www.new-hair-styles.com sites.
Conclusion

This was one of the most frustrating experiences of my career, knowing full well that the person is innocent and not being allowed to provide logical proof.

If there is an appeal and the defense is allowed to show the entire results of the forensic examination in front of experienced computer people, including a computer literate judge and prosecutor, Julie Amero will walk out the court room as a free person.

Let this experience stand as a warning to all that use computers in an environment where minors are present. The aforementioned situation can happen to anyone without fail and without notice if there is not adequate firewall, antispyware, antiadware and antivirus protection. That was not provided by the school administration where Julie Amero taught.

Technorati Tags: Julie+Amero Connecticut+Schoolteacher Spyware Connecticut+Justice+System Law Network+Security

Monday, January 22, 2007 Digg The Strange Case of Ms. Julie Amero: Commentary by Mr. Herb Hornerdigg ? Bookmark The Strange Case of Ms. Julie Amero: Commentary by Mr. Herb Horner on del.icio.usdel.icio.us ? Add The Strange Case of Ms. Julie Amero: Commentary by Mr. Herb Horner to your Technorati Favoritestechnorati
TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.netqos.com/MT/mt-tb.cgi/127

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Strange Case of Ms. Julie Amero: Commentary by Mr. Herb Horner:

? Amaro case proves popups can be far more than just an annoyance from Jeff Budzinski's Weblog
During the last week or two there has been a lot of news about the Julie Amero case (see Google News... [Read More]

Tracked on January 24, 2007 08:22 PM
Comments

Thank you for arranging for this, Mr. Boyko.

I suggest everyone read Mr. Horner's concluding paragraph a second time. Add to Mr. Horner's recommendation that the operating system have all available security updates installed as well.

Regards,

Corrine

Posted by: Corrine | January 22, 2007 07:52 PM

Those of us that have been using the Internet for several years knows that this can happen. I once neglected installing a popup blocker and spyware blocker on a PC my daughter used and this same thing happened to us. If these government people are not competant in a technical area they have no business prosecuting someone based on detailed knowledge of this area.

Posted by: Gerald Gibson Jr | January 25, 2007 09:04 PM

[This post has been edited --ed.]

Shortly after reading the article I decide to check on http://new-hair-styles.com/
It looked like a regular page until I click on the Image with the text "new-hair-styles.com" and on the main image of the website, and to my surprise instead of taking me back to the Home page as expected. It took me to:
[a .ru porn site]
I wish there was some other way to help Julie Amero.

Posted by: Hugo | January 26, 2007 07:19 AM

I am a substitute teacher, and in the school district where I work, substitutes are not allowed any use of school computers-period. Now I understand more fully why this is so! I have no idea how well-protected are the computers where I work, but even though I have accessed the internet (using a teacher's account with permisson), I have, thankfully, dodged the bullet so far. After reading this article, I intend to NEVER use school computers in the course of my work ever again.

Posted by: Rebecca Randolph | January 31, 2007 01:31 PM

It sounds like the Prosecution knew that they didn't have a leg to stand on if anyone with any computer experience was called to testify, and then hid behind "legal technicalities" when they saw Mr. Horner.

I've been recently hired by a local school district ("recent" in education means you've only been working 3 years) for the purpose of providing IT support for ROP computer labs in the high schools. I have a computer engineering degree and 20 years s/w & h/w testing experience, so I knew a little bit about computers.

The first thing that appalled me was the classrooms had expired antivirus software, and no one--not even the district's own IT department--understood about spyware! I had to do several special training sessions and explain to key people in charge that having an antivirus s/w won't catch spyware.

It took a lot of manhours to remove the viruses and spyware that already embedded itself into the computers, not the easiest thing sometimes.

Most school districts have a web filter (i.e. Websense) to block desired content. But if your IT is not on the ball keeping the database up to date, it is easy to bypass if someone wants to.

Instead of pointing fingers to teachers (what I call the path of least resistance) here's another possible suspect, from personal experience: I teach the last class on Saturdays and the first class on Mondays, yet I have come in on some Mondays to find porn printed on the class printer--timestamped Saturday night! Only the school custodians and plant employees have keys and be around during that time. (Unless you count intelligent mice and roaches with lockpicks!)

Law is not logical like computer code, but keep fighting the good fight, Herb!

by shaun.g

If there is any truth in this.. it needs to be validated and the judge disbarred!

by deepsand

Perhaps even the defense attorney!

It seem that [i]everyone[/i] involved here fell asleep at the switch.

by deepsand

PC World
Steve Bass's Tips & Tweaks

Take Action: Julie Amero Porn Case

Steve Bass

February 21st, 2007

If you're not familiar with Julie Amero's legal problems, you can catch up by reading "Teacher Faces Prison for Pop-Up Infested PC":
Tips & Tweaks column

This week I have more for you on the case.

I've been privy to conversations with a dozen high-level security experts, forensic examiners, and a top-notch attorney.

Unfortunately, there's lots I can't repeat. What I can say is the consensus is that Amero is getting a bad rap. For a sample of what intelligent, tech-savvy folks are saying, I've got two excellent articles for you. The first is Randy Abrams's "Can a Legal System Unversed in Technology Result in a Fair Trial?":
Randy Abrams blog http://eset.com/threat-center/blog/?p=42

Next is Mark Rasch's "Mouse-Trapped":
Mark Rasch seven-part article http://www.securityfocus.com/columnists/434

After my first Amero column posted, many of you asked how you could help. You've got plenty of options, but first I thought I'd share some interesting e-mails I've gotten.

A Juror Speaks Out

One of the jurors in the case sent me an e-mail explaining why he thinks Amero is guilty. The juror said he subscribed to my newsletter, then proceeded to talk about his rationale. He asked me not to reveal his name, but I've verified that he was on the jury that convicted Amero.

Here's what he wrote in his e-mail to me. I've lightly edited it to remove a few typos and make it a little easier to read. (I've inserted my comments in brackets):

"I was on the jury and yes we did find her guilty.

"But everything seems to be misquoted by the papers and reporters involved. The bottom line was that it didn't make a difference who or how the porn sites showed up on the computer."

[According to the trial transcript, Amero testified that she made every attempt to keep the children from seeing the images. In fact, a number of children testified that she had attempted to block them from seeing the screen. Also, another substitute teacher testified that Julie had asked for help in the teachers lounge.]

"The fact that a teacher in a public school system did absolutely nothing to keep it away from the children is what was wrong. Yes, we were told that she was given no permissions to turn off the computer. She also said she was not allowed to use any other school equipment.

"If a 40-year-old school teacher does not have the sense to turn off or is not smart enough to figure it out, would you or any other person wanting her teaching your child or grandchild?"

[At the trial Amero testified that she didn't, in fact, know how to turn a computer on or off.]

"If you and your wife were watching an xxx rated movie the you put into the dvd player, powered it up and hit play, and then went into the other room for a snack, and your child or grandchild entered the room, would you expect your wife to stop the dvd or just let it play because she didn't start it. No, you would be upset as all get out.

"Even giving Julie the benefit of doubt, not knowing enough about a computer to be able to turn it off. Some paper and tape would have covered the screen or a coat or sweater. It was October after all.

"Finally she was pronounced guilty because she made no effort to hide or stop the porno, not just because she loaded the porno onto the machine. Going to the history pages it was obvious that the paged were clicked on they were not the result of pop-ups.

[Actually, the defense expert at the trial testified that the sites visited were from pop-ups.]

"Each web page visited showed where links were clicked on and followed to other pages. Pop ups go to sites without change ink colors, as in used links.

[That's incorrect. Pop-ups show as a changed type color, just like a normal site visit.]

Personal note to the juror: I made a mistake using your partial e-mail address in my blog, even though you said it was okay to do so. I should have advised you not to do it--or ignored your permission--and just used "anonymous." As a result, many people found out who you are and you've received "over 250 e-mails most of them telling [you] how bad, stupid, or evil" you are. I don't think you are any of these. (I don't agree with your decision as a juror. Despite that, or perhaps in spite of it, I have to respect the judicial system.)

Either way, I owe you a tremendous apology for exposing you to the uncivil and contemptuous e-mail you received. --Steve

Norwich Detective Weighs In

As if that weren't enough, I also heard from Detective Mark Lounsbury, the crime prevention officer with the Norwich Police Department. Here's his e-mail, exactly as I received it.

"Dear Mr. Bass, Unfortunately the truth in this matter is yet to be told to all those who were not located in the courtroom during the trial. Those in the courtroom saw and heard the truth. Once sentencing is done the truth CAN BE presented to the world IF they want it. I'm thinking the world doesn't want to hear the truth. IGNORANCE IS BLISS. The lies are exciting, bringing up STRONG emotions. OMG, that poor person, victimized by the Evil Government and its minions.

"It continues to amaze me how people can base their opinion on what is fed to them. Did anyone ask the Expert for the evidence he recovered which would support his claims? The "curlyhairstye script", those pornographic googlesyndication.com generated pop ups? BUNK also known as errors of commission. Would you like to know the truth? Once sentencing is over I'd be more than happy to let you see the source code, scripts, etc.

"I've received allot of calls and emails regarding this. All from people interested only in TELLING me their opinions or TELLING me they're going to get me. Not once has anyone called or written me to ASK me a question. They apparently have what they want. I work hard every day for the victims of crime. I search for the truth not for me but for them. If what the newspaper reported about my testimony was my actual testimony, taken in context, don't you think there would have been some consequences, a rebuttal, something.

"Feel free to write if you wish.

Mark Lounsbury"

I had tons of questions and fired them back in an e-mail. Unfortunately, this was his response:

"Dear Mr. Bass, Once the sentencing phase for this case is done I can answer all your questions. I have all the information you seek. My opinion is not important but I am fleshing out a theory concerning site blocking software which was in place and how to circumvent it. I can provide you w/ the source code showing all the .htm and javascripting for each web page, images from those pages, date/time of creation, MD5 hashes, etc. I will contact you after sentencing. Thank you,

Mark Lounsbury"

How You Can Help

You can check Amero's blog and consider helping by way of the Julie Amero Defense Fund, which is linked to the site. Here's the blog:
Julie Amero http://julieamer.blogspot.com/

You can also use the power of e-mail. The State's Attorney responsible for supervision of David Smith, the prosecutor in the Amero case, is Michael L. Regan (at michael.l.regan@po.state.ct.us). You might want to write to him and strongly urge that he help Smith file a motion to vacate the conviction. An e-mail to the Chief State's Attorneys of Connecticut Kevin T. Kane (at conndcj@po.state.ct.us) and Connecticut Governor M. Jodi Rell (at Governor.Rell@po.state.ct.us) can't hurt, either.

If you write, try not to go on a rant. I know it's tempting, but if you use your computing expertise--and a civil argument--you'll likely get better results.

Spread the Word

This time I'm bugging you for a good cause and asking you to forward this week's newsletter to all your tech-savvy, socially active friends so they can help out too. Oh, and be sure to include the subscription link (what, you thought I'd forget to ask?):
Newsletter subscription page http://www.pcworld.com/resource/newsletters/index.asp?sub_source=NL_XB

Steve Bass writes the "Hassle-Free PC" column in PC World's print edition and is the author of "PC Annoyances, 2nd Edition: How to Fix the Most Annoying Things About Your Personal Computer," available from O'Reilly:
Online catalog http://www.oreilly.com/catalog/pcannoy2/index.html

Send your comments on the case to Steve at:
tipsandtweaks@pcworld.com

See the archive of Steve's previous columns.
http://www.pcworld.com/columnist/id,43;n,stevebassstipsamptweaks/columnist.html?tk=nl_sbxcol

Check out Steve's blog on PCWorld.com.
http://blogs.pcworld.com/tipsandtweaks/?tk=nl_sbxblg

by deepsand

[b][/b]
[b]If you find yourself the victim of pop-up ads on a computer, with children in the vicinity, you could face decades in prison.[/b]

I wish that I was exaggerating or being sensationalistic, but for Julie Amero this is far too real.

[b]Meet Julie Amero, substitute teacher[/b]

There's a good chance that you've already heard something about Julie. She's perhaps better known as the Connecticut substitute schoolteacher who's been convicted of "child endangerment." She now faces a sentence of up to 40 years in prison because porn pop-ups appeared on a school computer.

For background on the case, you can read articles from the New York Times
http://windowssecrets.com/links/uhjut5obbkokd/123a72h/?url=www.nytimes.com%2F2007%2F02%2F14%2Fnyregion%2F14teacher.html%3Fei%3D5090%26en%3D9e18a05a5f2e2de3%26ex%3D1329109200%26adxnnl%3D1%26partner%3Drssuserland%26emc%3Drss%26adxnnlx%3D1171481393-PZ2abm9Sp2napgnyEloHcg,
MSNBC
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/17134607/, or
SecurityFocus http://windowssecrets.com/links/uhjut5obbkokd/dd9302h/?url=www.securityfocus.com%2Fcolumnists%2F434.
(Full disclosure: WSN editorial director Brian Livingston is quoted in the New York Times piece supporting Julie. The article at the MSNBC site is also a good read, but I don't recommend the accompanying video, which starts out with a falsehood and goes downhill from there.)

Let me begin by saying that I'm biased when it comes to Julie's innocence. I'm doing my best to spread the word about her case, and have offered my technical skills to support her defense. I have access to some technical experts who are reviewing the trial transcripts and computer forensic evidence. I can't point to a public reference to support all of my positions yet, so you'll just have to take my word, for the time being.

There are many points I could make about what's wrong with her case. But I'll stick with my core competency and just point out some of the technical flaws.

[/b]Flawed technology condemns an educator[/b]

The key issues were set in motion before Julie ever arrived to substitute-teach on the day in October 2004 that the pop-ups occurred. The school district had allowed its Web-filtering software support contract to expire, preventing the software from receiving updates. The computer in question was running Windows 98, and the browser in use was IE 6.

According to evidence analysis performed by Alex Shipp, an independent malware researcher, the antivirus software was a trial version of Cheyenne Antivirus (CA). That product had been discontinued by Computer Associates on Mar. 17, 2004. It appears that CA issued a last courtesy update on June 30. Julie taught the class on Oct. 19. The computer had no antispyware software.

In other words, this computer had almost no protection and an unsecurable operating system. This is the machine Julie was given to use.

On the day in question, the regular teacher was there before class to log Julie into the computer. Substitutes didn't have their own accounts, and were ordered not to log out or shut down the computer. Julie left briefly and, when she returned, the regular teacher was gone. She found students, some of whom didn't even belong in the upcoming class, Web surfing on the teacher's computer.

Experts now analyzing the hard-drive image have confirmed that the computer had been infected with adware days before Julie's arrival. Unfortunately, in this case, that means that when a student tried to visit a hairstyle Web site, he or she was instead redirected to a different site that had adult products advertised. When Julie tried to close the site down, this started a pop-up cascade.

One thing I should mention about Julie: She's a total "computerphobe." She can perform basic computing functions, but that's about it.

So what did she do when she couldn't get rid of the pop-ups? She turned the screen away from the students. It was at the front of the room, where the students would have had to be essentially at the teacher's desk in order to see. She did her best to get rid of the images without making it obvious to the students that something was wrong. If a student approached, she reportedly chased them away.

During a break, Julie went for technical help to get rid of the pop-ups, which reappeared as fast as she tried to close them, but she received no help. No one would return to the classroom with her. She was told not to worry about it. However, she was worried about it, and it turns out she had reason to worry ? she was later arrested for "child endangerment."

[b]Legal system fails pop-up victim[/b]

When law enforcement became involved, sanity should have prevailed. Instead, the technical flubs continued, and the case sped downhill. A detective was assigned to take a forensic image of the computer and perform a technical analysis.

Let me briefly tell you what I know about taking a proper forensic image of a computer that will be involved in a criminal case. Keep in mind that I'm not a forensics expert; these standards are just common knowledge in the computer security field.

If you're going to image a drive for evidence, you have to use special write-blocking hardware that helps take a sector-by-sector image of the entire hard drive, including the "empty" space. The image is then hashed so that any tampering will be evident, and you always work from copies.

Typically, only software tools with support from existing case law are used. Otherwise, questions can arise over the soundness of the tools and techniques. The imaging tools that have case law behind them are EnCase http://windowssecrets.com/links/uhjut5obbkokd/b62bc3h/?url=www.guidancesoftware.com%2Fproducts%2Fef_index.asp
and the Unix dd utility.

The detective in this case took an "image" of the hard drive with Norton Ghost. Norton Ghost is a tool used to back up a computer's hard drive in order to restore it to a known state after people have modified the configuration. It is often used on training or lab machines. There is nothing wrong with Ghost for what it does, but it is not a forensic tool.

So what did the detective use to examine the "image"? He used a program called ComputerCOP Pro. It appears that the program displays a version of the Internet Explorer history, which shows the URLs that were visited. At trial, this ended up translating to the prosecutor telling the jury that this means that Julie "physically clicked" those links. In fact, pop-ups show up in the history the same way as a link you click on.

In truth, the software also cannot tell you who was in front of the computer, who typed in a URL, or who saw the pictures displayed. It's clear that someone who lacks the technical background to properly interpret the results, and is not willing to put in the time to figure it out, can jump to some very wrong conclusions. The detective never even looked for spyware on the computer.

This is the kind of technical evidence on which Julie was convicted.

[b]An innocent teacher awaits sentencing[/b]

Julie is now awaiting sentencing, which is scheduled for Mar. 2. I could discuss jail-time possibilities, but many of us are still refusing to accept any possibility other than someone coming to their senses and throwing the verdict out.

To that end, the experts I mentioned are frantically preparing their report on the technical information. The hope is that the prosecution or court will recognize that there has been a basic mistake in the facts presented at trial before a sentence is handed down.

Despite my bias that I told you about, do you have reasonable doubt about Julie's guilt? For more information, see the julieamer blog
http://windowssecrets.com/links/uhjut5obbkokd/6bc337h/?url=julieamer.blogspot.com
at Blogspot, which is largely maintained by Julie's husband. There's a PayPal button at the top of that blog so people can contribute to help pay Julie's defense costs, which are reported to be over $20,000 so far.

This discussion is closed to new replies.